Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!





High End Luxury Cars

18288298318338341156

Comments

  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    "The car is GOOD, but not 3-Series Great..."

    Yeah. Someone here posted that the IS has better straight line motion than the 3 Series.

    Hey, sooner or later, ya gotta turn the wheels!
  • sysweisyswei Posts: 1,804
    the car WILL NOT outsell the 3

    I would agree, provided that one ends "anytime soon" to the end of the sentence.

    The 3 does what it does very well. Moreover, it is entrenched in its position, and in people's minds. A competitor merely matching the 3 in capabilities isn't going to outsell it.

    But IF someone can produce something just a bit better, in overall handling/performance and/or reliabililty and/or styling, then over a 5-10 year timeframe, the 3 can be surpassed in unit sales, imho.
  • blkhemiblkhemi Posts: 1,717
    Very possible. However, the wigs in Bavaria will halt all new plans to drive the 3 if anything gets within it's comfort zone. Well, Lexus scratched the surface with 306hp. BMW will counterfire with 310-hp twin-turbo I6 with 325lb-ft of torque, this will definetely take the car under 5 seconds. BUT: What does that mean for the M? We know it will be V8, but what power? Over 400, but nowhere close to it's big brothers M5/6's 500hp in fear of killing those cars.

    The 3 has survived all this time by delivering what it's customers want. The car was long the pinnacle of poor reliablilty, yet they bought the cars continually in droves. The car's redo in '00 erased most problems and thus have infused reassurance with it's customer base, and this is why the 3 only has a 4 day lot time.....
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    which can produce something "just a bit better" than the 3 Series in its price category, will be BMW with the next version of the 3 Series.
    Nobody else will do it. BMW owns the ELLPS segment.
    You can take that to the bank.
  • drfilldrfill Posts: 2,484
    Hemi, when did I say the IS would "kill" the 3-series?

    If you would read my last post, it clearly stated that the IS is BMW's greatest challenge yet. That's all.

    I have tempered enthusiasm for the IS. I still want to see the convertible due next Summer, and the manual tranny for the 350.

    The Next G35 is not to be overlooked either!

    When the IS is fully realized, and the G35 reinvented, they should both be putting out 75k units, which will be similar to competing units from BMW. The other 15 variants will give the 3 higher total numbers, doh.

    If you are going to TRY and quote me, at least copy and paste, to avoid such errors in the future. :sick:

    Thank You.

    DrFill
  • sysweisyswei Posts: 1,804
    You know what they say, "Never say never". And if the Germans are thinking that, they are complacent and complacency will only make it easier for someone else to take the top spot.

    BMW may own the segment now, but they may not always.
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    BMW is far from complacent. They are always improving their vehicles' driving dynamics, which is why the others won't catch them.
    Most 3 Series reviewers state the current 3 Series is better than ever. The car continue to evolve.
    They just have to keep Bangle away from those tail lights. :(
  • sysweisyswei Posts: 1,804
    They are always improving their vehicles' driving dynamics, which is why the others won't catch them.

    All auto companies are always improving their products. But the rate of improvement can vary, and there is NO assurance that BMW's rate of improvement will always equal or exceed the competition's.

    Before Lexus introduced the RX, didn't it look like the ML dominated its segment?

    Didn't MB probably think at one time (like 1988) that it had nothing to fear in the S segment?

    Didn't Cadillac at one time dominate some of its segments?

    BMW and the 3 are not invincible. Maybe the 3 will be at the top of the heap 10 years from now. Or maybe not.
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    I hope I'm still here to find out.
    If I'm wrong, I will admit it right here, 10 years from now.
    Should be right around that time Tagman trades in his Lotus. :)
  • designmandesignman Posts: 2,129
    They just have to keep Bangle away from those tail lights. :(

    Whatever happened to your praising Bangle for boldly going where no one has gone?

    I haven’t criticized BMW styling in a while. I’m thinking about stoking up a few of my rants.
  • deweydewey Posts: 5,243
    Most 3 Series reviewers state the current 3 Series is better than ever. The car continue to evolve

    My fellow BMW fan I respect your opinions but the real question is what will the 3 evolve into?

    In order to discover where it is going you will have to look at where BMW's R & D $$$ are going. The link below is a good indicator where not only the BMW 3 series is going but where the entire BMW productline is going:

    http://www.worldcarfans.com/news.cfm/newsid/2060804.010/country/gcf/bmw/bmw-late- - - - st-driver-assistance-r-d-developments

    Their R & D is focused on "Driver Assistance Technologies"?

    Ain't that a hoot!

    The Ultimate Driving Machine is becoming the Ultimate Rider's Machine with minimal involvement from the driver.
    If this is the future of the BMW 3 then I can assure you the future 3 will not be in my garage.
  • deweydewey Posts: 5,243
    Personally I think Bangle looks much better in wagon form than sedan form.

    Based on my unbiased opinion the 5 series Touring wagon is the best looking wagon on this planet. And ofcourse the second best looking wagon is the 3 series Touring.

    Only Bangle can make a wagon look this sexy.
  • tagmantagman Malibu, CaliforniaPosts: 8,441
    My fellow BMW fan I respect your opinions but the real question is what will the 3 evolve into?

    Excellent question, isn't it? And what will the Lexus IS evolve into? More power? Better handling?

    Oh, I'm sure no one here thinks that the IS can be any threat to the mighty BMW, and so far I would agree that it isn't much of one, but my crystal ball tells me that the future will be different, and Lexus will step on BMW territory.

    When the LS first came out, who would have thought that it could possibly impact the almighty S-Class the way it did and does?

    I am absolutely a Eurocar fan, but I have tremendous respect for the marketing capabilities of Lexus in this country. The Lexus/Mercedes lesson is one for the history books . . . we either learn from it or we don't.

    TagMan
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    Go back and read all my posts on the new 3 Series.
    I have written many times that I find his work on the 3 Series tail lights hideous.
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    Well, I must agree with you-if BMW corrupts its mission with more driver assist technology-(its adaptive steering has widely been proclaimed to be "a disaster")-such as MB has done with the new S Class where I hear the car can practically drive itself, I would no longer be interested.
    This is fine for Lexus and MB, but would be a total shame if BMW caves.
  • dhamiltondhamilton Posts: 873
    mentioned this before on here, but I "think" the biggest competition for the 3 in the future is going to come from Audi. The next body style [09, or 2010 I think] is supposed to come with improved weight distribution and the usual Audi brilliance.
    Competition is a good thing me thinks.... :P
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    "Only Bangle can make a wagon look this sexy."

    I don't know about that. I believe the Audi A6 Avant looks pretty sexy!
  • hpowdershpowders Posts: 4,269
    If anyone can do it, I would have to concede, Audi might.
    Not that they will.
    Unless Porsche decides to enter the ELLPS arena.
    Other folks around here listed reasons why they won't.
  • Some people tend to disagree on the sucess of the R-Class, I just happen to think it depends on where one lives. But I think those people did not see that i also mentioned the Chrysler Pacifica which is more successful than the R-Class because it costs about $30-40,000 less. And though the pacifica is cheaper it still has the same basic features, heated rear seats, 3 rows, 6 seats, & a flat folding 3rd row. They both offer the same nice alternative to the minivan. So let me rephrase what i said before. Would Lexus consider venturing into that market with a new crossover, or does the RX already take that spot?
  • guestguest Posts: 774
    Mercedes and Chrysler are answering a question nobody is asking.

    How far do you take the station wagon (Without calling it a station wagon)?

    I would put more R&D into a super minivan, which Americans seem more partial to, than a super station wagon, which Americans think of a relics that are remembered for wood paneling and seats that face backwards.

    The RX doesn't need to change, or adjust to any other vehicle, particularly the R-Class.

    What Lexus should do is make a bigger RX, like the HPX concept. The next Infiniti FX will only get bigger, and the SRX is already that size.

    Truck chassis are in decline, and Lexus has a nice bullet still in their holster! :shades:

    I'd say Lexus knows what their doing with the RX. Anyone care to disagree?

    DrFill
Sign In or Register to comment.