Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Jeep Wrangler Wave and Meet the Owners



  • mac24mac24 Posts: 3,910
    Listen to the folks that make these forums what they are. Go back to the way it was!!!!!

    Unfortunately I really don't see that happening. This whole change of direction to become like most other automotive forums has come from the top down. It certainly hasn't been driven from the bottom up.

    Someone at a high level has decreed that this is the way to increase profitability, by increasing the number of hits Edmunds gets. More hits equal a higher advertising rate, which equals a greater income from the advertisers.

    Unfortunately (again), it doesn't matter what we, the long timers and regulars, feel about the changes. In fact it doesn't really matter if we go away. Our number will pale into insignificance compared to the number of new hits that will be generated.

    The new system will generate many more extremely specific thread titles. Whether or not those threads contain any pertinent information is irrelevant. What does matter is that someone using a search engine (Google etc.) will now find that Edmunds regularly appears close to the top of the results for their very specific search, as search engines will prioritize thread titles over content within them.

    So, more search engine hits equate to more site hits. More site hits mean more income. It doesn't matter whether those people coming here find the answer they want, it's just the fact that they came that's important. Under the new site model it's important that as many people as possible come here asking questions and looking for answers, anything else is a bonus.
  • div2div2 Posts: 2,580
    Unfortunately (again), it doesn't matter what we, the long timers and regulars, feel about the changes. In fact it doesn't really matter if we go away.

    And if the newbies wind up finding little or no accurate/useful information, so what? It's the amount of hits that will determine the success of the new format.
  • tsjaytsjay Posts: 4,591
    Can we old members just go on as usual in here, instead of in our old hangout, Jeep Wrangler? Maybe new folks will find us and ask some questions in here.

    If nothing else, we can at least stay together and communicate amongst ourselves. I would hate to lose track of the good friends that I have in here.

  • I'm in.

  • if they are going for more web hits, they need some help in the search engine optimization department.
  • I agree but I don't think it will change. Money will win out over community. Mac said it all and we may be stuck with the reality of a poor decision for all the wrong reasons. John
  • mac24mac24 Posts: 3,910
    And if the newbies wind up finding little or no accurate/useful information, so what? It's the amount of hits that will determine the success of the new format.

    Exactly my point.........and because of the way that search engines work, it should be an initial success in terms of increasing the number of hits.
  • mac24mac24 Posts: 3,910
    The problem is that instead of a 'Problems & Solutions' board, there will be hundreds of individual topic titles with questions on very narrowly defined problems. Who is going to be answering them all?

    The beauty of the new system (for Edmunds) is that not only will new visitors be coming here because Google has found a thread title encapsulating the very question they want answered, they will be encouraged to start new threads, thereby drawing more people here.......and so it will repeat.

    Again, who will be answering these questions?
  • mac24mac24 Posts: 3,910
    I imagine we can, as long as it doesn't get too popular.

    Apparently, that was the problem with 'Jeep Wrangler', too many posts.
  • erickplerickpl Posts: 2,735
    I'll be here. I don't know about being able to answer all the questions (or even a small fraction of them). But I love reading posts from everybody.

    Like many of you, I hang out on other automotive forums as well and if I need VERY specific help, I'll go to those forums, to other sources that I've used successfully in the past. I suspect if Edmunds is trying to recreate a specific automotive-type forum for ALL the vehicles they cover, I suspect they're gonna need a LOT more money and a LOT more servers.

    There ARE options for a friendly community-based Jeep forum, right Tom? :)

  • nolid5nolid5 Posts: 148
    Long time lurker checking in - My "Jeep" piggy bank is getting full just waiting for the JK to get the bugs out. I spotted a cool video on YouTube with the new '07s on the Rubicon. I also agree with the concensus of the new forums, but if we all stick here it should be like nothing changed (except the number of posts for awhile)
  • Stever@EdmundsStever@Edmunds YooperlandPosts: 38,931
    Heads up - somehow we managed to have two Wrangler "meets" going. We'll combine this one with the *Wave* and Meet discussion and keep all of y'all together that way.
  • Stever@EdmundsStever@Edmunds YooperlandPosts: 38,931
    We'll combine the Meet the Members posts in here shortly; meanwhile the recent tire thread now has its own discussion. Please talk about your 31's and 32's in there (ok, 33's too, and toss in a few rims too!).

    Jeep Wrangler Tires
  • mac24mac24 Posts: 3,910
    I hardly felt the bump as you hitched the coaches together. ;)
  • Stever@EdmundsStever@Edmunds YooperlandPosts: 38,931
    That's because Tides disconnected the front sway bar and I aired the tires down. Keep it under your hat but another friend came along and gave us a nudge with his Hummer H1. :shades:

    For those looking for the recent active tire thread, we put it over in Jeep Wrangler Tires.
  • keatskeats Posts: 412
    Yep, I've always thought of this forum as more of a hang-out forum and talk about how we love our Jeeps (my previous Grand Cherokee rant aside...).
  • jimlw2jimlw2 Posts: 122
    Everytime I hear news reporting about the Southern California wildfires, I worry about Mtngal...Has she checked in here? I hope I'm wrong and that wildfire isn't causing her grief or any of the other SoCA folks that frequent our forum. Let us know how you're doing if you can.
  • 99tj99tj Posts: 187
    Tom's absolutely right. Let's just stick to this "meet the members" area and keep helping each other out. Hopefully the newbies will hunt us down.

  • brazucabrazuca Posts: 95
    Hello far I got all my questions answered and I'm trying to keep following this forum....I'll stay here and follow you guys.... ;)
  • Welcome. I have been to Kentucky many , many times. A beautiful state with friendly people. Went to college in West Virginia (in the 60's). I am in Windsor,Connecticut and just wanted to welcome you to Jeepland. It took you awhile but you did it. Go Easy, John
Sign In or Register to comment.