Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!





Honda Element Maintenance and Repair

pleiadespleiades Posts: 38
I've been shopping the Element and CRV, trying to decide...
I was just reading the CRV problems and solutions...is the Element more trouble free?
the CRV owners are complaining about a pull to the right, cruise control, etc...
«13456712

Comments

  • cwalticwalti Posts: 185
    We bought an '05 Element EX 4WD automatic last September. I drove it off the lot for $23,200 in Orange Co, Calif. Absolute trouble free and a joy by any measure. I personnally would have preferred the Element, but...

    Chris.
  • cwalticwalti Posts: 185
    We bought an '05 CR-V (sorry screwed up in the previous post...)EX 4WD automatic last September. I drove it off the lot for $23,200 in Orange Co, Calif. Absolute trouble free and a joy by any measure. I personnally would have preferred the Element, but...

    Chris.
  • tidestertidester Posts: 10,110
    BTW - after posting, you may edit your post for 30 minutes.

    tidester, host
  • pleiadespleiades Posts: 38
    Curious (since that is my dilemma now) why the CRV if you preferred the Element?
  • 1racefan1racefan Posts: 932
    These are the 2 that it came down to when my wife and I purchased our '06 Element EX, 4wd auto 2 months ago. Going into the dealership, I favored the more traditional looks of the CRV, she favored the Element. We ended up driving the Element, and a 4wd, EX CRV auto.

    I liked the fact that the CRV interior was more "refined" than that of the Element - my wife liked the "bare bones" look of the Element more. In hindsight, I am happy that we ended up going with the Element, as there is a ton of room in it with the seats folded up against the side (and with them completely removed)....much more cargo room than in the CRV with the seats folded down.

    One thing we did like more about the CRV was the position of the sunroof (in the front of the car where it belongs) vs the rear sunroof of the Element - although we have had the rear sunroof completely out of the Element a couple of times, and it does generate a good breeze throughout the vehicle.

    When we drove both vehicles back to back, we both got the feeling that the Element was more nimble than the CRV. Even though it looks more top heavy than the CRV, it seemed to feel more stable. The Element does have less ground clearance than the CRV (it sits lower), which would probably help it handle a little better. You need to feel the steering of the Element...it is very precise and tight - no deadspots at all. My wife also said she had better rear visibility out of the Element than the CRV - which is a big selling point for her (and this is her daily driver).

    One other thing to note is that the CRV utilizes a 5 speed automatic vs the 4 speed automatic in the Element. After driving both of them at highway speeds, I personally did not notice the 4 speed auto in the Element being any noticably louder than the 5 speed in the CRV. And speaking of noise...this is very subjective, but we did not notice any more road noise in the Element than we did in the CRV.

    As far as gas mileage for the Element goes, I can't comment on that. My wife only puts about 150 miles per week on it while driving it to work. We have a different vehicle that we use for long trips.

    You really should look at, and drive both. However, I would say that if you frequently carry backseat passengers, the CRV would probably be the route to go. If that is not an issue for you, I now personally prefer the Element.

    P.S. - we LOVE the audio controls on the steering wheel in the Element. I don't think these were available on the CRV.
  • pleiadespleiades Posts: 38
    What a great review! You could write for CR!
    Visibility would be an issue for me too, and cargo but passengers... not. Funny, CR mentioned road noise and freeway handling as not being great but every Element owner I have spoken to has said they don't find any difference from other cars. I was concerned because I'm told they won't let you testdrive on the freeway (didn't want to find out it was uncomfortable after (if) I bought the car). I like the idea of the venting sunroof, I sunburn easily so I don't need the expose, but my old bug had a sunroof that was great for letting heat out when parked in the sun for a while.
    The interior looks very plain and the dash board looked like an odd shape to me, but too many of my friends have SUVs with dash boards that look like the cockpit of an airplane (overdressed with gauges), I just see that as wasted money (though I'm sure it's poplular with some). I'll go drive some Monday...(CRV's and Elements). Thanks for the info!
  • bigfurbigfur Posts: 649
    I have heard the Element has a problem with rear brakes from the factory wearing out faster than the front? Anyone run into this problem?
  • jesbecausejesbecause Posts: 2
    I have an 05 and since i've had it , I have always heard a grinding noise from the right rear wheel. Taken it back to 2 different dealers and could not replicate the problem . One said it might be dust or pebble caught in between . I pull on the emergency brake to try to quiet the noise , sometimes it works and sometimes it don't . Please post if recall or some sort of fix . Next step i'm going to change pads
  • tomsr1tomsr1 Posts: 130
    I had a 2002 CRV and it always had a clicking
    noise from rear brakes. At 36000 miles the drivers seat was wearing out and the steering
    wheel was worn badly.This car did not look like it would hold up cosmetically so I traded
    it for a 2004 Toyota Highlander.It is much better quality.
  • elementmanelementman Posts: 11
    I have a little over 6,000 miles on an '06 Element EX-P AWD Auto purchased in Nov '05. I had some trepidations moving down from a Ford Explorer, and owning 4WD Trucks or SUV's for the past 30 years, but am glad to report complete satisfaction in owning and driving the Element. Since this is a problems page, here is what I've experienced. 1) Dealership trying to upsell me on an oil change at 3000mi, even though the manual plainly states 10,000mi. I complained to Honda America, and they reiterated 5,000 to 10,000 depending on road conditions. 2) I've noticed a click when turning the wheel hard over, but only at the max wheel over and seems OK. I'll keep an eye on it. 3) One time the door bound (binded?) when opening. Seemed too close at the front edge and caught the fender panel. POP! I'm lucky it didn't bend anything. Happened 3 or 4 times at that spot, but never again. I must have been sitting funny and had body twist. When I take it into the dealer I'll have the door adjusted. 4) Battery went dead once after 2 or 3 hours of XM radio (while I washed the car). I bought one of those jumper units from Costco for $49.00 (in case it happens during a wilderness campout) and now listen worry-free. 5) there is no 5. 6000 miles and pretty much trouble free. I'm loving my Element. Fun to drive, plenty of power (for what it is), lots of room!! I just moved my son from college condo. Loaded two bedrooms of furn in the Element and pulled 4x8 trailer in 3 trips to storage. Same goes for camping. You feel the weight, and it slows you on the hills, but it still gets you there!! Fun car. Happy purchaser. Do not miss the Explorer (every time I fill up at $30 instead of $50). Steady 21.5 to 22.5 MPG. City or highway.
  • pleiadespleiades Posts: 38
    there is no lock or any protection over the "fuel fill cover" or "fuel fill cap". Ther have been several items in the news about people siphoning gas....Help?
  • 1racefan1racefan Posts: 932
    I think there is an optional locking gas cap available. The way I look at life is that there are so many things crime wise that "could happen", that you can't worry about them all.
  • pleiadespleiades Posts: 38
    "Worry"?
    On the other had I'd be a fool to leave my front door open when I go to work or not attempt to protect my property or car where such protection is reasonable and sucessful.

    Thank you for the advice about the locking cap.

    When I write to the forum I'm seeking advice about automobiles, not "life" advice.
  • bigfurbigfur Posts: 649
    Can buy an aftermarket locking gas cap alot of places.
  • steverstever YooperlandPosts: 39,993
    I think the concern with an aftermarket gas cap is whether it will seal correctly; otherwise it could cause the check engine light to go off.

    Steve, Host

    Moderator
    Need help navigating? stever@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.

  • 1racefan1racefan Posts: 932
    Just to clarify - I was stating an opinion, not providing life advice (as I really don't care what people do/don't do).

    Just merely stating that there is a locking cap available, but I personally have not priced it or deemed a neccessity in my particular case. I think over the past year I have heard of 2 cases of stolen gas on the news. Out of a city of 200,000 plus people, I think I will take a chance.
  • cwalticwalti Posts: 185
    You do not need locking gas caps anymore either. It is for the paranoid and the gullible. Today's gas tanks have screens in them that prevent jerks from stuffing watermellon pieces in your tank or slipping an 'Oklahoma Credit Card' down the fuel spout. Also tanks on most new cars are sitting so low to the ground that it would be difficult to make that 'OCC'siphon work anyway...
  • cwalticwalti Posts: 185
    Oh it was a very simple decision.
    The wife said the Element was too ugly to have in the driveway and she wanted a Pilot. We already have an Odyssey and do not need another large vehicle. The closest I could get to an Element was the CR-V. It is a very good vehicle but I like the out-off-the-box functionality of the Element. My wife likes the same old box... And since I know where I sleep tonight I forced myself to have the insight and compromise for small but conventional...
  • cwalticwalti Posts: 185
    Do you wanna trade wifes? I think we got them mixed up a while back... :-)
  • Oh God, more insults.
    Ok, so they can't steal my gas anyway, good to hear (just because you're paranoid, doesn't mean they're not after you). Actually saw it on TV news, camera in a parking lot, watched guys stealing gas...OK? (not that the news people are not above a little sensationalism (OK, a lot of sensationalism) but, this one was true)
    What on earth is an Oklahoma credit card?
    As for the tank being low to the ground, as long as the container it was being siphoned into was lower, it would work. Basic science class.
    Asked at Honda service today, "How much for a locking gas cap?"
    Service guy "$79.00, for the cap and installation."
    Me "what installation?" gesture twisting cap three times clockwise....
    SG "That's what it says, $79.00, cap and installation"
    Me "how much for the cap and I'll uhh, install it myself"........"someone on the message board says they bought one from Honda for $29.99...."
    SG blank stare, no answer......

    Me "Never mind, I'll look on the internet".....

    Thanks, you just saved me a lot of money....
«13456712
Sign In or Register to comment.