Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!





Tribeca Safety Issues

balderman1balderman1 Posts: 5
edited March 9 in Subaru
On August 8, I was rear-ended by a Cadillac.The caddy was almost totalled and I was pushed into a car ahead of me, but not very hard. My first concern was my new mesh grill which I had just put on two days earlier (at a cost of $712.00). There was no damage to the front of the car. On the rear the bumper cover was knocked off, the spare tire was on the ground and punctured, the left muffler was pushed into the left rear tire which was cut in two places. Just received repair estimate of $2,980.00. I was very pleased with the structural integrity of the frame
«1

Comments

  • rshollandrsholland Posts: 19,712
    Ouch! Sorry to heat that you've been hit, but happy to hear that the damage wasn't too severe.

    Bob
  • pschreckpschreck Posts: 524
    Oh man. I feel for you. I hope everything is made right and am glad you didn't recieve any injuries. Good luck.
  • morey000morey000 Posts: 355
    all in all, not too bad. If your first concern after an accident is your new mesh grill, then you did pretty well.

    With 43,000 people a year dying in auto accidents in the US- it's good to be in a vehicle that's on the safer side of average.
  • My wife was one of those 43,000. In 1989 a lady came across the freeway (Interstate 20 in Abilene Texas) and hit us head on. My wife was killed, the other lady was killed and I was in and out of hospitals for almost three years. I was in a 10 day old Suburban and she was in a Lincoln Town Car. Cut it in two. I am probably more cognizant of impact statistics than most people.
  • morey000morey000 Posts: 355
    I'm so sorry to hear about your loss.

    Perhaps you're familar then with www.iihs.org
    A great web site of auto statistics, and every now and then they put out a fatality ratings report. It's amazing how some vehicles have 5 to 10 times the fatalities (per million owner years) as others. Very interesting reading! The 'beca is too new to be in the lists- as they take 3 years worth of data.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Posts: 72,587
    I'm glad you were OK and the 'beca held up well. At some point people have to stop hitting you! :sick:

    -juice
  • megreyhairmegreyhair Posts: 154
    I had a minor accident as well.. Some guy rear-ended me.. He nose dove underneth the bumper. His grill is smashed and the left headlight is pointing in the sky. I now have 'hex' shaped dent, the size of a 3/8 nut in the bumper and some scratches on both the painted and unpainted part of the bumper. Also some of the syroform is compressed.....
  • ateixeiraateixeira Posts: 72,587
    Make sure you have a professional evaluate the damage. Once the foam is crushed, it has to be replaced. It's designed to break apart as it absorbs energey, so it may be useless now.

    -juice
  • Morey: Can you tell me where to find the data you refer to.
    i.e. which vehicles have the most fatalities.
    I looked on the iihs site but could not find this specific report.
    thanks
  • try this link:

    http://www.iihs.org/news/2005/iihs_sr_031505.pdf

    it's under their news releases, but you need to select 2005 and scroll down to March 15th. They update this report every few years. It's pretty interesting.

    It's for passenger vehicles made 1999-2002, but still very telling. Some results are surprising, others not so surprising.

    The Subaru results are not stellar but about middle of the pack. I was surprised to see that the 4Runner and Rav4 did so well- but perhaps the fact that they were so underpowered had a lot to do with it. Time will tell whether the new Rav4 with 269hp will fare as well.

    Also- in looking at the list of 4WD SUV's it's interesting to see the group that did a bit better overall, had most of their fatalities due to multi vehicle accidents, whereas the group that faired a bit worse were primarily single vehicle accidents. Clearly roll-over had a lot to do with these, but ya' gotta' wonder why they actually had a lower rate of Multi Vehicle accidents than the lower group.

    perhaps vehicle with a higher center of gravity are more likely to roll over (no surprise) but are perhaps more visible and likely to be hit by another car? Or if they feel more tippy, are less likely to be driven aggressively?

    really interesting stuff for someone who has a passion for empirical data.
  • Thanks for the link.
    I agree with you about empirical data; for instance, in my opinion large suv and pickup drivers tend to drive agressively and fast. However, the data may prove me wrong if as you noticed in the data, they are really not in as many multi car accidents as I would think they ought to be.
  • PF_FlyerPF_Flyer Pennsylvania Furnace, PAPosts: 5,967
    Let's use this one as the base for discussing B( safety issues.

    MODERATOR
    Need help navigating? pf_flyer@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
    Share your vehicle reviews

  • tupintupin Posts: 71
    Sorry...Had this in the wrong forum...
    Saw this on another site...thought I'd post it here....I know the Tribeca has a good crash rating...nice to see that proved though:

    I was responding to a MVA head on. This accident involved a Subaru Tribeca and a newer style Dodge Intrepid. Now both vehicles where traveling at approximatley 58mph. The driver of the Dodge Intrepid was killed in the accident. The driver of the Tribeca was injuried but will survive and make a full recovery with only a broken leg. But after looking the vehicles over, I was extremely impressed at how the vehicle survived and protected the driver. Yes the tribeca was a mangled mess but it was designed in such a way that the front end crumpled in many spots. The motor actually broke away and it was underneath the passenger floor. I mean it's hard to say in words how impressive it was but subaru technology is absolutely amazing!! I'm very happy to say that I own a subaru. I will try to get pictures of it for you guys to see.
  • PF_FlyerPF_Flyer Pennsylvania Furnace, PAPosts: 5,967
    Thanks tupin! Usuauly get a better response by posting in existing discussions.

    Looking forward to seeing those photos. I have a friend who is an accident reconstruction specialist and it amazing the amount of damage that cars can do to one another!

    http://www.carspace.com/pf_flyer

    MODERATOR
    Need help navigating? pf_flyer@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
    Share your vehicle reviews

  • ateixeiraateixeira Posts: 72,587
    Well, to be fair it's had many years of advances in technology over the older LH cars.

    -juice
  • My mother was complaining to me that on her way back from Maine, there was freezing rain, and bad roads. She complained that her traction control switched off by itself, and almost sent her into the ditch. I told her it was probably her mistake, and she hit the button... But she likes to play stubborn... So what do you fine folks think? I think it was her fault... :confuse: :confuse:
  • tupintupin Posts: 71
    I went to a snow covered parking lot and tried to see how the stability control worked...with a lot of spinning the stability control off light will flash on from time to time. I'm not sure what that indicates....however I can't see how it would go off permanently. If the system was off...how did it nearly send her into the ditch?

    Most people feel safer in a Subaru in those conditions. Did the light stay on permanently? Was she reaching for any other switches in that area? Hard to really say but if it never switched off before and hasn't since....makes one wonder.
  • morey000morey000 Posts: 355
    Let's see now. She was driving on bad roads in freezing rain and then complaining that it was the car's fault that she almost drove into a ditch

    Methinks that we should drive as if we don't have VTC, Traction Control, Antilock Brakes, stability control, etc etc. Those things are there to help us out if we need them in an emergency. Is it some kind of strange American phenomenon to always want to blame someone (or something) else when we make mistakes? She must have very high expectations of the Tribeca if she's expecting it to handle flawlessly in all situations.

    While I guess it's certainly possible that the traction control got switched off- I take issue that she 'expects' the car to have traction control and drives as if she'll never lose traction.
  • aka1aka1 Posts: 110
    Trying to switch on the front windshield de icer, and accidentally got the VDC switch instead?
  • If the VDC switch is poorly situated and allows for easy unintentional switching then she may have a serious safety issue of importance to all of us. Lets see how this plays out before pass judgment
  • tupintupin Posts: 71
    Well, if you did hit a button accidently and then suddenly a big illuminated warning showed up on your dash....that might be a clue what that button did.
  • Not really. For most drivers there is far to much going on inside and outside the car in the best of circumstances to necessarily notice another light that means little or nothing to you; this is particularly true if you are trying to stay alive in bad weather. If the switch can be accidently turned off then it is a poor design. Lets just move it to where it takes a conscious decision and a deliberate action to complete the task. Problem solved.

    Best
  • roy19roy19 Posts: 3
    Help, I ended up here. First love your forum.
    I'm looking for info. on making the front dvd work when in drive. I've searched but not found anythind with a true answer.Any help or direction. my e mail; is roygbiv63@yahoo.com
    I'll try to go on that thurs nt chat as well. Thanks.
    b-9tribeca
  • morey000morey000 Posts: 355
    I've never seen anything posted on how to do this in any of the Tribeca forums. Or even any way to bypass that 'agree' screen.
  • kmartinkmartin Posts: 427
    Check the NASIOC .com boards...there are few experimenting with the idea at this time.

    -Karen in AZ-
  • leh33leh33 Posts: 1
    My 2006 tribeca with 42K miles on it is clunking up front. I brought it in and the mechanic told me the stabilizer bars are shot. He says they are on back order with Subaru and that is a sign that a recall may be needed. There shouldn't be this much demand for that part with a car so new.

    Anyone else have this problem? I'm out of warranty and he said it would cost $180.
  • occkingoccking Posts: 346
    The ride on my Tribeca is getting worse and worse. Clunking up front, rough ride all around.
    I am bring vehicle in for 30k "physical" in a week or so & I hope they can do something. I have also heard problem could be with struts as well? Don't know much about what goes on under the vehicle all I know is that the ride, unless on a perfectly smooth surface is bad!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Posts: 72,587
    I don't buy that. I can't imagine why a dealer would keep sway bars in stock. They're always special order.

    You stock things that are normal wear and tear, like oil filters, windshield wipers, etc. Why would anyone stock sway bars? :confuse:

    In fact, we're talking about a solid rod of metal, here. It's more likely the sway bar end links or bushings failed, not the sway bars themselves. Unless you hit something pretty darn hard.

    Here's an example of what one looks like (the smaller items are bushings):

    image
  • occkingoccking Posts: 346
    Would the end links or bushings, if worn or defective, be the cause of a rough, noisy ride?
«1
This discussion has been closed.