It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Luxury Full-Sized SUV comparison
Looking at the Navigator, Escalade, QX56 and the LX470.
From what I've seen, here are the issues:
Navigator- poor interior components/styling, power fold-flat 3rd row, low HP
QX56- love it or leave it styling, poor reliability
Escalade: great interior, plenty of power, crappy removable seats
LX470- poor towing, outdated design, poor towing, great reliability
I don't think there's a perfect choice here. I would choose the Infinity if the reliability was better. I've seen pretty favorable reviews for the redesigned Expedition- I wonder why the Navigator was rated so low?