Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!





Honda Accord vs Nissan Altima

1910121415

Comments

  • thegraduatethegraduate Posts: 9,731
    Well, MSU is the meteorology part of my job (I'll have the broadcasting part from UAB), but it is a very good school, and quite different from being in the middle of Birmingham!

    I wish you the best in teaching HS Band; it's a tough job!

    TheGraduate
    PGHS '05 ;)
  • wyngatorwyngator Posts: 29
    I want to trade in my Navigator and am looking at sedans. I took a test drive with the Altima 2.5 (looking to go from 8 cylinders to 4 for better fuel efficiency). I intend to test drive an Accord today. I love the LOOK of the Nissan, but am willing to test drive the accord because I used to own an accord and they make great cars.

    My question to this group is maint. and repair? I know from previous ownership that the Accord runs like a clock. Never was it in the shop for anything major. Just oil changes and tires .... the normal stuff. I am wondering about the Altima. We have a 2001 Infiniti (basically Nissan) that has 188,000 miles and runs great. But, that vehicle was made in Japan. Now a days .... I don't know if the Nissans are really made in Japan.

    All I know is my 2003 Navigator has cost my tons on $$ on maitenance. I had a warranty that took me to 75,000 miles so the repairs before then were more of a nuisance than a cost problem. But, after the 75,000 miles I have put over $5,000
    into the Lincoln and it only has 96,0000 miles. Way to much in my opinion.

    So, I want my next car to be QUALITY. Any opinions on this subject?

    Thanks,
    Laurie :shades:
  • wyngatorwyngator Posts: 29
    Okay, I gave a test drive to the Honda Accord '08 EXL. Honestly, I was a bit disappointed. My first surprise was to see only a 3 star rating on side rear impact while the '08 Civic had 5 stars in all categories.

    Next disappointment was that the Navigation system did not have a back up camera like so many other new vehicles that I have taken for a test drive. Also, not even a back up audible sensor. Another surprise.

    The one plus I saw was the 100,000 miles of maintenance free service. Only needs to do oil changes, air filter, and tires. That looked good, but I guess I am ruling the Accord out based on how I felt drving it. I wasn't "wow"ed.

    I next went and test drove the Acura TL, but that is for a different forum.
    I do give that a thumbs up :)

    Now, I am going back to the Nissan dealership to test drive the Altima again. I am refining my search ....

    Laurie :shades:
  • jd10013jd10013 Posts: 779
    well, I'll try to answer some questions for you. first off, no, nissan doesn't import many cars from japan anymore. If I had to guess, I'd say the number of nissan imports from japan to the US is zero. most of the altima production is in the tennessee plant, with the rest being made in the mississippi plant.

    maintance and repair? well, thats a tough one. I've owned three of them (still have 2) and have never had a days problem with any of them, though the altima is only a little over a year old and about 11k on it. none of my nissans have ever left me stranded, has failed to start, or been on the back of a tow truck/wrecker. 2 of the 3 nissans have NEVER been repaired for anything, and the first one never required more than 7-8 hundred in repairs in its 12yr 224k mile lifetime (still running when I got rid of it)

    as for maintanence, very minimal. oil changes, tires flushes, and tune ups. all normal. But, the cvt in the new altima will cost considerably more to service (60k) than a normal auto trans would.

    but, some people have had problems with nissan vehicles, and their overall quality ratings have dropped some in recent years. I would confidently buy another (and probably will in a couple years) nissan, but I would deffinitly get the extended warranty.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Posts: 9,731
    I have a close friend considering both of these cars, but has opted for the Altima. She felt the Accord actually drove better between the two, but she was instantly comfortable in the Altima (2.5S with Convenience Package) and couldn't get used to the massive Accord. She is coming from a 2001 Mustang and just can't adjust to something THAT big.

    She's 5'2" and very small. I won't guess how much she weighs because I've been taught better than that! :)
  • madpistolmadpistol Posts: 126
    That's the exact reason I chose the Altima. The Accord drives better, but the Altima is very easy to use, even on the first test drive (and it's still more fun to drive than the Accord, even though the Accord has a better ride overall.)
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    Attention Nissan lovers. I about to purchase a 2008 2.5SL Altima. My mechanic loves them and my older brother likes the Accord. I fancy the Nissan. But I can purchase a Honda Accord for about two thousand dollars less. *Whistles and bells on both, but Honda has stability control and Altima 4cylinder does not. Do you really feel the Nissan is worth the extra dough? I love the car and keep my cars forever. I am also concerned that Altimas are no longer made in Japan but are made in Tennessee. I would really appreciate your input. And I don't want to have buyers remorse. I have noticed that the Altima has a smoother more luxurious ride,you sit higher up,and it's sporty. The Accord is tight and you feel the bumps more but still a beautiful machine also. Thank you all! :confuse:
  • madpistolmadpistol Posts: 126
    I seriously doubt you can get the Accord for $2k less than a similarly equipped Altima. However, if you can, power to you... Anyway, the Altima has CVT, manual shift mode, no torque steer, more nimble handling, and it gets its advertised fuel economy. The Accord doesn't. However, the Accord does include VSC, which is definitely a plus for safety, and it is bigger. I chose the Altima. I got a great deal on my 2.5SL. You should seriously compare OTD prices of both the Altima 2.5SL and the Accord EX-L 4-cyl. If you're not comparing the out the door prices of both cars, you have no clue what kind of deal you're getting.

    The ONLY number you should be looking at is the final "Out The Door" price that includes all fees, taxes, extended warranty, etc. If money is no object, though, I think the Altima is the better car.
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    Please see my message of July 5th. :surprise:
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    I did get my OTD prices. EXL without Nav versus SL with Connection but no Nav. SLs with Connection are rare right now because of the July 1st law barring handheld cellphones, you know people want Bluetooth. Me, I don't even own a cellphone, but I love that stereo! The OTD price I negotiated for Altima 2008 is $27,200.00 The OTD price for EXL is $25,300.00.
    Altima's will only be more expensive in the fall with no rebate, so I figure it is now or never, plus I got a decent offer on my ancient car from a private person. Money is always an object. Still I really liked driving that Altima. I guess I want a reason to justify why I am spending more money.... mean why is this car more expensive? Is it really that hot an item? And I worried if it will stand the test of time.. have over 200,000 on my current Camry and the Civic I had before got 243,000 miles before I sold it for $1500 to make the downpayment on the Camry! Btw, the reason my brother wanted me to get the Accord was because of the VSC, but I drive very conservatively. As a matter of fact, my brother said not to bother test driving a V6 as "it would be wasted on me." :blush: Thank you!
  • mazda6dudemazda6dude Posts: 283
    I traded in my 2007 Nissan Altima Hybrid for a 2008 Honda Accord LX automatic. Its been a few months now. Hands down, there is no comparison. I found the accord to be a better car in all phases. Handling, Comfortability, Ride, Resale Value, and more Standard Features. If you compare the Altima 2.5S to Accord LX automatic. This is apples to apples since both are base automatics, the Accord had more power, standard features, space and better resale. The mainteance minder system in the Accord is priceless. Altima doesn't have it. Bought my LX for $20K OTD with Tire Hazard Warranty + rotations and balances for 5 years unlimited mileage.
  • gooddeal2gooddeal2 Posts: 749
    If you compare the Altima 2.5S to Accord LX automatic. This is apples to apples since both are base automatics, the Accord had more power...

    IMO, I think the Accord has less power than the Altima. I like the tight steering on the Accord better b/c it's closer to my '08 G35 in term of handling. However, if you like a softer ride and less bump, the Altima is a better choice.

    Resale value is not much an issue if you keep your car 7 years or longer.
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    I just want to clarify that I am talking about the Accord EXL and the Altima 2.5SL with Bose/Bluetooth. Both are 4cylinder luxury models but no navigation. It is funny I too feel the Altima is more peppy, but the Accord apparently has more horsepower. 190 I think.
    You know, I like that Altima a lot and may take one more test drive before I make my decision. I did the math this morning. The Altima will cost me $2090.00 more out the door than the Honda, or I can get a Honda with Nav for $500 bucks less than this Nissan! Not to mention that .09% financing with Honda. I shopped quite a bit... and it has been tough to find what I want in the Altima but I got the best quotes from both dealerships... and I researched many! My mechanic says the price difference is all about inventory, and it is true Nissan's with Connection are rare! Is $27,300.00 too much to pay for the Nissan SL with Conn?
    On the other hand I do not want to talk myself out of getting the car that feels to fit me (Nissan) because of money alone. It is not only that it is a smoother ride. I think because I put so many miles on my Civic (242,000) and almost $200,000 on the Camry, those car rides are kind of well...boring...dare I say....like an old shoe?
    Oh my God did I really say that!? :surprise: THe Nissan feels different and more new and exciting. :shades: Thoughts please?
  • madpistolmadpistol Posts: 126
    WOAH!!! that price for an Altima 2.5 SL w/ connection is awful! I paid $24,600 for my 2.5 SL w/ connection pkg. You're getting ripped off. See if there's another dealer around that can give you a better deal because the Altima is a great car if you can get it for a good price.

    If you got a good deal on the Altima 2.5 SL w/ connection pkg, it would be less expensive than a similarly equipped Accord EX-L 4-cyl.
  • madpistolmadpistol Posts: 126
    The Accord LX actually has LESS power than the Altima 2.5S. At the same time, even though the Accord EX 4-cyl has more horsepower, the 2.5L in the Altima still has a lot more torque, so the Altima is still the quicker car.

    I will admit that the Accord has a smoother and more refined ride, but the Altima will be more fun to drive, and it's significantly lighter. It's your pick as to which one you want.
  • busirisbusiris Posts: 3,490
    WOAH!!! that price for an Altima 2.5 SL w/ connection is awful! I paid $24,600 for my 2.5 SL w/ connection pkg. You're getting ripped off. See if there's another dealer around that can give you a better deal because the Altima is a great car if you can get it for a good price.

    If you got a good deal on the Altima 2.5 SL w/ connection pkg, it would be less expensive than a similarly equipped Accord EX-L 4-cyl.


    Something is definitely wrong here...I haven't yet seen what I would call a comparable Altima/Accord pricing comparason in which the Accord was priced cheaper. Further investigation would definitely be in order before buying...
  • bvdj84bvdj84 Posts: 1,721
    Well, I have always been as crucial as to just pull on the door handles to see exactly how well they are made when looking at cars. It is small little details like that, that makes the overall car quality. That is alot to remember for a company, it comes from overall look, gaps, paint, to the feel and texture of everything. It is the smaller details that add up to an overall feel of the car, all those details add up to how a car feels, and holds up with every mile. This does not necessarily mean spending more money, but rather choosing the right parts, and seeing that they work together well.

    So that is something to think about when you look at your next new car, pull the door handles, shut the doors, close the trunk, look at the engine. These details make a difference for me, it tells me that they cared about everything, all the way down to the door switches.
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    Where did you buy your Altima and how long ago? In Calif you will not find a 2.5SLAltima with Connection for $25,000 OTD. Not any more. If you or anyone else can, I will be glad to admit I am wrong. Just point me in the right direction. I've contacted numerous dealerships over the last two months. SL with Connection is rare right now because of Calif new law banning hand held cells and because they are getting ready with the 2009s. Maybe you can get dark colors but black is not for me. Please if you know of something out there let me know. I am tired.<a href=" :sick:
    I did get the Honda quote in internet writing and by phone by a reputable dealer.
    But I love the Altima. Thank you mp.
  • altimrsaltimrs Posts: 15
    Sorry I think I am responding to madpistol. But you are right about those door handles. They are both great cars but that Nissan is a dream. I mean...I feel happy when I drive it. With the Accord it is more like a going to work feeling. Maybe because I commuted so many years in a Civic with 242,000 miles on it!
  • madpistolmadpistol Posts: 126
    I see. It's different on the west coast apparently. I live in Alabama, and I got one dealer to quote $24,565 and one quoted $24,600. Both were OTD prices on nearly identical 2.5 SL's w/ connection pkg. Funny enough, the lower priced one had more on it, but it was all cosmetic stuff; the cars were essentially the same

    . I'm sorry to hear about the new cell phone law in California. The 2.5 SL's w/ connection pkg is fairly rare by itself, but seeing as bluetooth could be a huge asset now, it would make them pretty difficult to find. I bet this is the last generation of cars that bluetooth is a high-grade option. Next generation, it will more than likely be mainstream technology due to demand for it. I would also be willing to wager that there will be more 2009 Altima SL's due to the inclusion of bluetooth. Nissan/Honda/Toyota needs to capitalize on these markets due to demand for technology like this.
Sign In or Register to comment.