Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!





Subaru Forester (up to 2005)

14243454748860

Comments

  • dawatdawat Posts: 5
    - "We wanted something that handled more like a car, had all wheel drive, and could carry more than a sedan. That's what we got. Simple."
    Seems like the Highlander would be the perfect car, no? After all, it's a Camry in heels with a foot of extra space tacked on the end. And I seriously doubt the Forester carries more than a sedan WITH the seats up.
    I didn't look at an Escape because I'm trying to Escape... crappy Ford cars, I didn't look at a Rav or CRV mainly because I heard so many people on this board gloating about how much bigger a Forester is. I DO need space but I also wanted something that would carry passengers, dogs, lumber, whatever but still be safe and drive well. Oh, yeah and not break like a crappy Ford (or Forester in this case) I wish I had driven it and I knew that was the one thing the people here would point to but it was really hard getting a "hello" out of the subaru dealer much less keys to one of their cars.
    I didn't really want to flame Foresters or Subaru or their owners. I just wanted people who do research here to get a balanced perspective. Read the opinions on this board and then go out, drive the car, sit in it, jiggle things around, kick the tires and be HONEST with yourself about what the vehicle can and can't do.
  • jeijei Posts: 143
    Sorry the dealer ignored you (WHO was that?) and the rear cupholder broke. Two years ago I bought a '99 Forester "S", even though the back seat is tight & flat - because of the driving experience -I mostly commute alone.) On the same day, we tested a RAV4 (too light/small/cute; dumb rear door with no bumper), an Outback (roomy, pleasant) and the then-new Forester - which produced big silly grins on our faces! For all the cost of a new car, I wanted some delight. Still true at almost 60k miles with few problems. When the kids are home, they do grumble about the back seat if they're stuck back there.

    HOWEVER - if the Highlander had been on the market, I would have also test driven it, and most likely, seriously considered it. Definitely more roomy, and really another size/price point in the market. I will test drive the HL for the fun of it even though it's fairly pricey and I'm not in the market.

    So good luck in your research & purchase. I appreciate your honesty. If you do try a Forester (at another dealer!), let us know how the driving compares to the Highlander.

    John
  • drew_drew_ Posts: 3,382
    LOL, only Steve and I are co-hosting the SUVs message board. No Joe here! ;-)

    Carry on...:-)

    Drew
    Host
    Vans, SUVs, and Aftermarket and Accessories message boards
  • kate5000kate5000 Posts: 1,264
    It's too bad that ignorant inattentive salesmen at that dealership turned you away. The back seat room is small in the Forester, no question about it. As far as front seats are concerned, opinions differ. There was a person of 6'7" on this forum (with an appropriate moniker "big_guy"), and he said the Forester and Escape were the only SUVs where his head was not brushing the ceiling. Try Nissan Pathfinder, for example. It looks much bigger, but interior is pretty small. Even I feel cramped there, and I'm only 5'3" (on a good day :-).

    I did not get a chance to test-drive the Highlander yet. It looks nice (like Forester on steroids). We think of Highlander as possibly a good choice for my husband's next car, but I reserve all the opinions until we actually test it.

    I should say that driving dynamics of the Forester are so good and it's so numble that after I owned it for 6 mo, every other SUV feels really clumsy. Since most of the time I commute alone in the car, back seat room is not an issue. Yet it holds a teenager plus baby pretty well when needed.

    Try driving both the Highlander and the Forester, and let us know how they compare.
  • tomsotertomsoter Posts: 2
    Just got 99 S automatic with 17k. Subaru doesn't provide seatbelt extenders and universal type won't work. Anyone know of extender from other import (like Toyota, Nissan,etc that provides extenders) that works?
    I remember reading on this & other sites about the funny sulfur smell. What is it and can it be fixed?
    Do ABS normally travel closer to floor than regular brakes? Mine go to about 1 inch above floor.
  • canadianclcanadiancl Posts: 1,078
    brake pedal travel for ABS should not be more than for non-ABS.
  • I really do not see how the Highlander and Forester compare. Our 2001 S+ with every option was around $23,000. For a 4 wheel drive 4 cylinder Highlander the MSRP is $25,395 without adding options. Adding a few options to that, and no huge sunroof, I got the price to $26,569. That doesn't include an LSD system, side impact air bags, huge sunroof, 6 disc in dash CD changer, heated front seats and mirrors, aluminum alloy wheels and its short 10HP and weighs more than the Forester. Even paying a little over invoice, option for options the Highlander is a good $3-4,000 more than the Forester. If 1 inch more headroom and 1 inch more rear seat room is worth that price, then buy the Highlander.

    My only point is that option for option, SUV for SUV the Forester beats the competition hands down. The Subaru dealership I bought my car from has called me repeatedly to make sure the car is okay and I still like it. They rolled out the red carpet for me when I brought it in for the first oil change. They even called me on my birthday last year to wish me a happy birthday. Not all Subaru dealerships are the same. When it comes to dealerships remember, Your mileage may vary.

    Also, the over inflated EPA estimate for the Highlander 4 cylinder is 24mpg highway, while the Foresters is 27mpg. Even 3 to 5 mpg over the life of a car matters to me. Just my 2 cents worth on comparing these 2 cars.
  • p0926p0926 Posts: 4,423
    dawat- The Highlander is sure to be a popular vehicle but it's in a different class from the Forester. It's really a mid-size SUV designed to compete with Explorers, Blazers and the like. Also, I just checked Edmunds prices for the Highlander and the selling price appears to be at least $5,000 more than a comparably equipped Forester.

    The Forester will certainly hold more than a sedan, even with the seats up (remember the cargo area goes all the way to the roof).

    Sorry to hear about your experience at the dealership but fail to see how that soured you on the vehicle itself. There are plenty of other dealerships out there that I'm sure will be more than happy to sell to you.

    Bottom-line. If the Highlander better fits your individual needs and if you have the cash to pay for it, then you should certainly buy it. (After test driving it of course)

    -Frank P.
  • joseph50joseph50 Posts: 235
    Before I purchased a 2001 S in January, I was mindful of reviews commenting on the Forester's "soft" brakes, and I found this indeed to be true on mine. But, in the course of driving (and thoroughly enjoying)the vehicle, the impression registered that the relative softness is actually conducive to using the ABS correctly in an emergency-stop situation. If the brakes were tight or hard, the initial and immediate felt resistance might cause me to back off the pedal instead of continuing to apply constantly increasing pressure.
    Just a thought from a someone happy to see 30 mpg on my last fill-up when my previous Tauras' best was 27 mpg over the the same trip.
  • pnptmpnptm Posts: 5
    I picked up a Blue S 5 spd Monday night, and just wanted to say thanks again to all the helpful responses to my questions posted here while I shopped........juice, Frank, and others.....I'll be checking in from time to time and hopefully can help others (and dawat, agree the cupholders are poor- but we all need something to complain about!!)
  • ateixeiraateixeira Posts: 72,587
    sport33: congrats. I'm sure your mileage is much better than before. Any more specifics on the rattle? They are not common in that area.

    Tom: the pedal can be adjusted, but you may need new pads. The previous owners may have ridden the brakes. The break-in smell should be gone by 17k, though. Wash the undercarriage to get any salt mix from winter off.

    Congrats pnptm. Glad we could help. Hang around and share impressions in a few weeks?

    I think ít's a high complement that the Forester is being compared to the Highlander. We're talking about a $30k plus SUV, easy. Equip one like a $23k Forester S Premium and you're probably a good $10 grand over the Forester, yet we are arguing over which is better.

    Thanks!

    -juice
  • jackleungjackleung Posts: 79
    Remember the electrical outlet problem I had mention before? Turn out is my poor quality phone charger coz the short the circuit and burn the fuse. So, the electrical outlet in the front panel is ok to use any electrical accessories (of course, resaonably load) with it.
  • p0926p0926 Posts: 4,423
    pnptm- Congratulations! Wait a minute...my Blue Ridge Pearl Forester is becoming less and less rare every day it seems. Ah...the price of fame!

    Jack- Glad to hear it was your phone charger causing the problems. That makes much more sense.

    -Frank P.
  • jackleungjackleung Posts: 79
    Ahh... I love a Blue Ridge Pearl one too. Too bad they don't have it on S+ model... :~(

    Rgds,
    Jack
  • araymondaraymond Posts: 3
    Juice, Ken - anyone: What's your sense of the going market price these days for the Forester I I/ automatic. Edmunds is showing: invoice $19,223, MSRP $21,095 & TV $19,649. That sound right? We're in Conneticut. - Anne
  • kenskens Posts: 5,869
    Anne,

    I don't know about the NE, but around here in the San Francisco Bay Area, Foresters will go for $200-$300 over dealer invoice.

    One way to check "market" prices is to go to carsdirect.com and look up their prices.

    Ken
  • hi, I'm in Ct also-I just bought a 2001 forester S+ for $150 over invoice, but my first quote(online -of course!) was for 250 over.
    I haggled with the online dealer(claiming another site quoted me less) which is how I ended up with 150.

    I ended up getting my subaru at colonial subaru in danbury- which was a good experience, I recommend.
    I think these guys have a big overstock of the foresters.

    Hope it helps
    ~L
  • mac08854mac08854 Posts: 6
    Hi everyone -- I've had my 2001 5sp Forester S since January 26. The car now has 2041 miles. Last weekend (St. Patrick's day), I began to experience major problems with the car.

    On the end of a trip, as I was about to park, the engine light turned on and the car began to idle roughly. I reached my destination, turned off the car, and let it sit (I went about watching the Corrs play in Rockefeller Center). When I returned to the car and started it, the engine still idled VERY roughly. However, the car still seemed to be able to drive okay, but that did not last long. Less than 2 miles later, I would step on the gas and would get little or no response from the engine. In order to get moving forward, I had to pop the clutch. But, as I would depress the gas, the engine would rev to 3000 RPM and then the power would drop rapidly. I could not let the engine idle in neutral because the car would stall due to the rough idle (it was like the engine was wheezing).

    Luckily, the dealership (Hillside Automall in Hillside, NJ), was on my way home and not too far from Hoboken where the car was parked. The car literally limped there (I *should* have called Subaru Roadside Assistance). A mechanic at the dealership took a look at my car with the diagnostic computer and got the code "301", interpreting that as misfires in Pistons 1 and 3. This was at about 1950 miles.

    He blamed the problem on bad gasoline (I used regular, like I always use and as the owner's manual states) which clogged the injectors. He poured a canister of dry gas chemical into the tank and revved the engine, which seemed to clear up the problem. He said that if I continue to have problems, bring the car back. I was able to drive the car home, and it seemed to be fine. The tank was filled about 1/8 with the old regular gas, so I proceeded to fill the tank with mid grade gas from a station on the way home.

    On Tuesday night, I began to notice a slight rough idle, a slight power loss, and the engine light turned on again. Sensing a return of the problem, I made an appointment for Thursday morning at Hillside for service. But, just my luck, it drives fine Thursday morning and the engine light turns off. The dealership looks at it, says there's nothing wrong with the car -- but I insist they do something about it and they order new injectors for the car. They continue to tell me the car is fine to drive home, which I did, and it did handle fine. The car now had 2011 miles.

    HOWEVER, on Thursday night, less than 12 hours after I left the dealer with the "good-to-go", the problem returned with a vengeance pulling into my driveway (2041 miles). I had the car towed Friday morning (this morning) by Subaru to Hillside, as I deemed the car way too unsafe to try to drive to the dealer. The response of Road Side Assistance and the actual tow truck driver itself was quite fast (45 minutes, compared to a 5 hour experience I had once with AAA), and the towing experience was actually really pleasant (good conversation with the mechanic while driving to the dealer). I wish that my experience with the dealer was only so pleasant.

    They were extremely resistant to giving me a loaner car, and it took my insisting to speak to a manager and arguing I should NOT be having any of these problems with a car that is not even 60 days old and hasn't even had its first oil change. I was NOT going to pay for a rental. I got the loaner rental for free: a lovely Geo Metro (well, it WAS free).

    I am now waiting for a response from the dealership, what they find, and what they fix. Luckily, everything is covered under warantee (that first 90 days). I am praying that I did not receive a lemon -- I waited for this car (it was ordered) for nearly three months, longer than I've even HAD the car. I do not believe it was bad gas, as my Dad had filled our van with regular gas from the same station the same day I filled my Forester, a week before St. Patrick's day. I am very disapointed in the mechanical problems I am having, after reading so much about reliability -- especially since I've only put 2000 and-some-change miles on the car.

    I must admit, I still do love the car and how it drives as well as its feature content. I also must commend Subaru for the excellent response with their roadside assistance and the mechanic/tow company they chose in Edison (DeFalco's towing?). However, this has done some serious tarnishing on my view of the Forester as well as the decent purchasing experience I had with the dealership (Hillside Automall).

    Needless to say, I will be writing Hillside management and the operations center in Cherry Hill, NJ.

    I will post the resolution of my mechanical problems hopefully later this week.

    --Mac

    PS. I recall someone in this group had a similar problem in an automatic where she would lose power while depressing the gas. Did they ever post a resolution of the problem and the root cause?
  • bassistbassist Posts: 15
    Mac,

    It sounds like you are having the very same problem I had with my '01 Forester. No power on gas, very rough idle, backfiring, etc. I posted about it a few weeks ago (#775). The dealer replaced a bad fuel injector and a faulty fuel air sensor (actually the 2nd time the oxygen sensor has been replaced). Since then my Forester has been running fine.

    Sounds like I had better luck with my dealer service than you however (Carr Subaru in Portland, OR). They were pretty sympathetic and gave me a rental car with no hassle.

    I have a lot less confidence in my Forester. I'm seriously thinking about getting rid of it but I'm not so sure about what I would replace it with.

    cam
  • sport33sport33 Posts: 19
    Ateixeira, re post 881. The noise has a soft "tumbling" quality, however I have since gone back to the dealer and have heard the sound to a greater or lesser extent on other, new Foresters. It's a hypercritical complaint, I have to find something wrong with the vehicle!

    I am sorry to hear others are experiencing trouble with their soobies. I have owned many new cars/trucks in my lifetime, and let me assure you there is no such thing as a perfect car. My other fun car for now is a BMW 330ci and it is by no means totally "ultimate". For the money, I have not come across a better value, or level of finish than the Forester not to mention the fun factor of a 5 speed... rally, rally!
This discussion has been closed.