Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
I'd suggest checking the Finance, Warranty, and Insurance board for more discussion of extended warranties.
--Robert
I'm willing to bet that those who are disussing the pros and cons of both have never actually driven both. And it really doesn't matter what the spec sheet says - it matters what the experience is getting behind the wheel and driving down the highway. After doing that in both, as I said, there will be no more argument.
Stick with comparing the Intrigue to the Grand Prix, Regal, Impala or Intrepid. They're what Edmund suggests comparing it to, and I agree. We're talking apples and oranges.
You asked why I bought an Acura over an Accord, it was the CL not the TL, and I negotiated mine for a mere 2 grand more than the Accord. To me the extra options/features were worth the 2 large ones (30k was my limit). And yes I could have lived with another 20-25k car. Point is that, the national meridian price for cars is 24-26k, so at 27k I would not find that too extravagant by any stretch.
[Sidenote: the TL/CL has NO dual climate control, but Onstar is new this year]
Pricing has always been one of my big bug-a-boos about the Intrigue [now & back then], when fully loaded it tops out at almost $31k. And WoW, that is in the luxury car price terrority, there are a lot of 30k cars with more features and reliability etc. etc. Granted most everyone in NOT paying full price, but there are some people who simple do not haggle on car prices.
One other thing I do not like some car pricing structure where you have 10-12k differences between the low-end/base model and a fully loaded model. It tends to dilute or muddy the model's true worth ie. Nissan Altima at 18-31k JMHO.
mapsco ::: <<< Stick with comparing the Intrigue to the Grand Prix, Regal, Impala or Intrepid. They're what Edmund suggests comparing it to, and I agree. We're talking apples and oranges. >>>.
It may seem like apples and oranges to you, but if they are both "fruit", "same size" and about the same "cost", then they should be comparables. What you are eluding is that one should only compare the different types of apples; Green, Red-Delicious, Jonathan. Now apples to a watermelons, when the comparison does not make sense.
I guess it must mean compare only American to American.
It is ludicrous to only compare just those vehicles suggested, just because Edmunds (or any other established source) deems these vehicles are comparables [again remove the blinders]. Comparisons; if one has like vehicles ie. approximate same body and engine sizes, number of doors, and comparable prices then, that is where any good comparisons should start from. Case in point, it then would off-base to compare a Chevy Cavalier to an Intrigue, or any 40-50k luxury car to an Intrigue.
In making any sound decision(s) [personal or business], one must be objective in reviewing "ALL" the available data and information "NOT" just some of it. If people choose not be to confused with the facts, then that is their personal choice.
If you want stiffer springs, check the tags on your current ones and compare to a printout from dealer. This will show you the one's you have relative to what's available. My front's happen to be 22133029-FJT and rears are 10421038-HSI-0840-TKS. On the printout for 99, this shows my fronts as being the 2nd stiffest (or softest) on load rate out of three sets listed. On the rear, the TKS is listed 6th out of 8 displayed (1 being the highest load rate). Incidently, my numbers don't match the list for the rears, but since the TKS does, I figured that's the load rate I have.
That being said, I've determined (from experimenting) my springs are good for my ride preference. You can get springs for about $34 each at GMpartsdirect.com or one of those sites. Will cost double at the dealer. I'm gonna keep the springs I have.
My ride is good with the Sensatrac struts but a little firmer. I'm hoping they will loosen up a bit over time. I'm told they will but not much. Oh well, that's what I get for being the guinea pig. I'm very happy with the Yokohamas.
jgriff : It makes sense to compare an Accord to an Intrigue. To compare a TL which cost thousands more does not make much sense. I know it's hard to understand, but it has nothing to do with the car's origin. The Accord is MUCH better anyway.
Take the Nissan Altima or even Toyota Camry their prices range from 18-20 to 32k yeah a fully loaded Camry is just shy of 32k. Point being that one might argue for a mere 2 grand you might as well step into a Lexus 300, again if that is NOT a budget breaker.
It can be the same type of argument, as jumping from a fully loaded Alero to an base Intrigue.
Once of Saturn's greatest appeal to some people, is knowing they paid the same price as all the other people. Now if Saturn would streamline their broad range of configuration within a singular model, I think it would help to lesser the confusion amongst many consumers.
Anyone is free to make set up any comparo whatsoever over on the Comparisons Board.
This is a single-vehicle dedicated discussion - let's keep that in mind.
Thanks.
Pat
Sedans Host
The days of carrying 4000 CDs are effectively over. I'm not going to debate the Intrigue's lack of an in-dash player vs. the TL/CL. What I am suggesting is that if you want to take advantage of what's out there now instead of arguing over what car is better because it uses or doesn't use late 80's "high tech", take a look at this:
SavingsLots.com
That's a darn good price for this unit. Compare it to Crutchfield and their supposed discount:
Crutchfield.com
The Pioneer CD player oscarz2 and I purchased sounds FANTASTIC!!! People swear I changed the speakers; highs are crystal clear and lows deep and throbbing, which tells you how good the factory speakers are in the GL/GLS. Check out the list of features including the 200 watts, independent bass/treble control for the front AND rear, 24 station presets (great if you go bewteen cities--set the stations then switch once the signal fades) then ask if you would put an in-dash CD player in ANY car.
Did I mention it's XM Satellite ready?
oldsman : What is the model # of that K&N? Which car is suppose to be for?
Like you, I compared the Intrigue to a comparably equipped Accord before buying, and I saved about $2K. But in jgriff's world I paid $2K more for my Intrigue than the Accord would have cost.
I have had several problems with the car including: replacing window motors, replacing the fan motor for the a/c, the 3rd brakelight went out which required that the entire spoiler be replaced, the brakes pulsated unusually and had to be replaced and a motor seal had to be replaced. However, I am not unhappy with the car. Of course I do not like problems, but the car has many positive qualities that make it very enjoyable.
The removal has cleaned the rear up a bit, although it is obviously a minor change. I used dental floss and 3M Release Agent sparingly. The removal went quite smoothly.
I imagine the addition of the Rocket badge to an Intrigue would give it an attractive custom look. There's actually a bit of heritage in not having the Olds name on the car as the original Aurora didn't feature it for the first few years.
I feel that the steering is heavy and while on the gmservice.com website I found an article referring to magnesteer and its operation and differences with conventional racks.
In this bulletin it says that some models that use magnesteer have three programmable levels of assist. Factory, more firm and less firm and that the module only be reprogramed on customer complaint.
My request to you if you will, is to browse through your fancy manuel to see if there is any reference to this and if it applies to our cars.
Thanks in advance
00 GL, 38 k.
I had mine in about 7 times. They would not even look at the sensors because there was no trouble code and they could not duplicate.
This is why i turned my car in early. They could have cared less.
Take it to a dealership that is proactive.
I'd be enjoying an Aurora right now too if the clowns at GM hadn't made the Aurora interior smaller than the Intrigue (they did lengthen the seat track slightly in later build 2001 and later Auroras but not enough).
My Oldsmobile name actually looks pretty good on my Intrigue only because the dealership's name uses a very nice script on the left of the license plate. So when looking at the car from the rear, it looks symetrical. That's the only reason I had them leave it on there.
BTW, anybody know where I can get Star Trek license plate holders?
Looked a lot cleaner.
In the aurora my knee was touching the dashboard and the console. Mostly the console. The aurora is designed like a cockpit so there is less spread out room for my legs.
The backseat had less legroom than the intrigue.
The bottom cushion was down low and because I could not pull the front seat up like I could in the intrigue, there was noticeably less legroom back there.
In the headroom department the intrigue wins by a mile. The intrigue has an open green house feeling with incredible visibility.
The winshield header is away from my forehead which gives great upward visibility and makes it easy to see overhead stoplights.
The aurora has a low windshield header and rearview mirror. This blocks forward visibility and makes one lean forward to see stoplights.
Both one2one and I looked at the aurora but each decided that it was a step backwards not forwards. Why pay more fo a car that has less room?
The manufacturer's specs don't tell the whole story when it comes to interior room.
My current car is an impala.
I am 6'8" by the way.
I am also tall, better than 6'4", thus leg room is quite important.
1st E-MAIL TO DELPHI
I have a 99 Olds Intrigue/3.5L. I guess it has Magnasteer. However, power-steering performance is poor (not enough assist). Dealer says GM is aware of this problem but "no fix". My question is: can it be replaced easily with magnasteerII and if so, would it give more assist?
Thanks.
2nd E-MAIL TO DELPHI
I originally took my 99 GLS/3.5 to the dealer
for a complaint with my steering because of a minor shudder/vibration when turning at low speeds (such as backing out of a driveway or turning when barely moving). I also complained that the steering felt heavier than before. When I picked up my car, the paperwork stated, "no fix from GM at this time". When I asked the service advisor if they acknowledge my complaint and confirmed the symptoms, she said yes. Basically, that's why I inquired about Magnasteer II. I guess it's a moot point based on what the engineer stated. The shudder/vibration has since decreased (I'm assuming the much colder temperature outside is a factor) but the steering is still too heavy in my opinion. Much more so at higher speeds and I realize that is how it's designed but I've driven other 99 Intrigues that have lighter steering than mine so that's what led to the complaint. I'm just searching for a way to boost the power-assist at any speed, especially higher speeds. Any remedies? Thanks.
1st RESPONSE FROM DELPHI
"I'm not aware of any problems that exist on the Intrigue regarding not enough assist. In order to provide any insight on how to improve it, I would need to know more information about the problem. For example: 1)What speed/speeds does this occur? 2)Is it a lack of Assist (efforts spike up when steering wheel is moved rapidly or in the corner during a parking maneuver) or is the complaint just high effort? 3)Does the steering appear to stiffen with vehicle speed? Regardless of the issue, changing from Magnasteer to Magnasteer II is not a simple task on a vehicle that is not already equipped. It would require a new controller, steering column, and wiring harness. In addition, from the little information we have, I doubt that Magnasteer II would help this
situation. Magnasteer II systems are usually tuned to stiffen the System more, and it sounds as if the steering efforts are already too high."
Delphi Saginaw Steering Systems
Communications Staff
3900 Holland Road
2nd RESPONSE FROM DELPHI
"Sorry for the delayed response, but I was waiting for some information on the Intrigue controller. Based on this gentleman's explanation, it doesn't sound like there is anything wrong with the system, except that it is tuned too heavy for his preference. Some
Magnasteer controllers have an option which allows the dealer to increase or decrease steering efforts for situations such as this. I
have been informed that the Intrigue controller does NOT have this capability. It is possible that he has a gear which is on the high end of the range for steering effort, or a pump which is on the low end of the range for flow. In such a case, changing the component would help the situation. I wouldn't recommend changing these, however, without an indication from the dealer that the steering efforts in this vehicle are heavier than normal. If the efforts are typical for the way this car has been tuned, then changing parts will not have a significant effect, and could actually make the steering a little heavier yet. I'm sorry I don't have any solutions for you. There's not much more I can offer. His best course of action is to work with the dealer if this is truly at the complaint level."
Delphi Saginaw Steering Systems
Communications Staff
3900 Holland Road
Just a footnote: The shudder/vibration went away on its own a while back. Maybe the dealer did something and didn't tell me. Since tweaking my suspension and changing tires, my steering is more comfortable (mainly attributable to understeer) but that's just me. I would still take a little more assist if I could get it.
oscarz : Interesting.
It was only a low speeds and often while backing.
Mine did it but they could never duplicate it.
I remember one time i was doing a three point turn. i pulled into a drive way, threw it into reverse and turned the wheel left and the whole car groaned. It was so loud that pedestrians stopped in their tracks.
Add it to the list of the things that were never fixed on my car.
I'm 6'8" too. I discounted the Chrysler LHS/300M for the same reasons (though I tried really, really hard to find a way to fit :-)
;-)
rjs200240, that is ONE HANDSOME AURORA and I love the personalized license plate. I've never actually sat in an Aurora so I dunno how I'd fit. I'm 6'4" but most of my height is from the torso up so headroom is VERY important to me. Doesn't sound like I'd fit in an Aurora. Sounds like a lot of us Intriguers are tall guys.
amuhaluk, I have that starting problem too, exactly like you describe. Apparently it's one of those "features" of the car... wink wink, like the dimming headlights. Drives me crazy but, as you well know the dealership "can't duplicate." It's so intermittent and unpredictable though, so I haven't done anything about it.
Sounds like quite a few of us are Star Trek fans too. Now how would THAT be on the back of an Intrigue? (A Starfleet insignia). Hmmm....
My Malibu sometimes starts from the second attempt. I notice that it never happens with my wife, and happens with me only when I am in hurry, and the car was not driven for long time - at least the whole night, or longer.
We discussed the problem on Malibu board, and one participant (sorry, do not remember who) wrote that he knows the reason.
The key out to be left in the "On" position for a second or two before starting engine, for fuel pump to build pressure. The gas drains back to tank from fuel lines while sitting long enough, and it takes some time to pump it back.
Looks reasonable explanation for me, at least with my car.
Of course, this is Malibu, not Intrigue. However, I have impression, that GM W-body cars have the same basic design of the fuel system...
FRONTS- 88945802 (Road Response Silver)$57
22400000 (Reactek)$98
REARS- 88945803 (Road Response Silver)$34
22400001 (Reactek)$66
My dealer list shows same part #s but prices are not shown.
Am I correct in assuming that 22400000 & 22400001 (Reactek) are the sportier, i.e., stiffer struts, because they're more expensive?
Also, for some reason whenever I run a search for struts and shocks on GMpartsdirect (whether by model info or by VIN) the only response I get is "No parts were found matching your search". Naturally, when I enter the part numbers you provided, they show up as struts at the prices you passed on. How did you run your search? I really appreciate your help. Thank you.
Oddly enough, my OEM struts (which sit in my garage) are labeled D7 on the fronts and CK on the rears. Both say "DELPHI" and "specifically made for Intrigue" on them, so I don't know how they relate to the Road Response or Reactek if at all.
To add more confusion, A 99 Regal LS brings up 3 part #s for front and 4 for rear (2 of which are the same "Road Response Silver" listed for Intrigue). Start changing the year of the vehicles and you will need to hire a detective to figure out those riddles.
This is what drove me to the Sensatracs. I had no way of gauging where I stood with my OEMs in the stiffness/valving category. And based on all I could find, I believed the Sensatracs would provide the comfiest ride with the softest valving. 2 people (one a staffer at Tenneco-the makers of Sensatracs) said Sensatracs are softer than Reflexs. After I got the Sensatracs, I called Tenneco again and said they felt firmer than my OEMs. They said OEMs usually have the softest ride. I said !@#$!%^@#^@$$^&#%^&@# (to myself of course). I guess that was the important question I should have asked beforehand but I didn't think it even possible at the time.
There is a happy ending though. I'm very satisfied with the way my car feels now. The Sensatracs provide an excellent combination of comfort with control/stability. Either they have broken in some over the last week, or I'm just used to them now. Either way, I like them and will recommend them. Keep in mind, I have no sway bars on, Yokohama Avid Touring tires are brand new at 32 psi, SLP rear STB, Next-Level front STB, and my comfort is probably the next persons discomfort.
I spoke with someone at the dealer via email and he confirmed the final 500 were going to be made, that I could order one if desired but they had no plans to get one.
I don't think my Intrigue's occasional starting problem is fuel pump related. It mostly happens when it's warm and it's been driven a short while before. I almost never have a problem with first morning startups.
Let's not forget the Bridgestone Potenza RE950s for replacement tires. I love mine and they have great ratings on tirerack.com as well.