Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
MINI Cooper
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
I was thinking about getting rid of the xA and Echo (which I got back from my mother, swapped her the Cavalier). I like the xA a lot, but the MINI is the "real thing." The Echo has an auto, which my wife will need if she starts driving, and a bigger trunk than any of the three cars (MINI, xA, Echo) but I want to gradually reduce the number of cars I have.
And I certainly wouldn't be the worried in the slightest about letting the 2005 production "stabilize". The changes are very evolutionary and minor - it is not like there is a new engine, new body style, or any other huge change. I'd be happy buying the first 2005 off the line. It is the first year(s) of a completely new model or a complete re-design you have to worry about.
- Mark
- Mark
I started with all the options that looked good, trimmed down to all the options that I wanted, then trimmed further to the options I am willing to pay for.
Basically, just DSC and multifunction steering wheel with speed control, plus the price increase. No added dealer markup.
In any case, I'm wondering, what is it that this car has that makes us still like it? After all, from the posts I've read here at least, this car appears to be underpowered, overpriced, expensive to maintain and repair, handles extremely well but doesn't spare the driver from any of road bumps and cracks. You can only have it serviced at authorized Mini dealerships, and all engine grades require premium fuel.
Also, if we were to compare the Mini to, say, the Toyota Corolla, here's what I found in terms of engine performance:
Corolla: 1.8L DOHC, 130 hp @ 6000 RPM,
125 lb torque @ 4200 RPM
Weight (LE): 2615 lbs
Fuel: Regular octane, (29 city / 38 highway)
Mini: 1.6L SOHC, 116 hp @ 6000 RPM,
110 lb torque @ 4500 RPM
Weight (Cooper): 2557 lbs.
Fuel: Premium octane, (25 city / 32 highway)
As you can see, the Corolla not only outperforms the Mini, but is also more fuel-efficient at the same time. Now some people here might say that I'm comparing apples to oranges, because the Cooper and the Corolla are two different cars, but I tend to think otherwise. Both are small cars, and although the street Corolla isn't the same one found in ralleys, I think the chances of getting your $25,000 Mini in a ralley anytime soon are pretty close to nil.
Mind you, I'm not knocking the Mini; I still love that car, and am trying to understand why people like it so much when there are more logical choices around. Maybe it's because the styling is so different? Maybe the other Mini fans would be able to explain this. Over to you guys.
'11 GMC Sierra 1500; '08 Charger R/T Daytona; '67 Coronet R/T; '13 Fiat 500c; '20 S90 T6; '22 MB Sprinter 2500 4x4 diesel; '97 Suzuki R Wagon; '96 Opel Astra; '08 Maser QP; '11 Mini Cooper S
Have you taken a test drive? From your post I would think not.
Go drive one. That should answer all your questions and you should leave the dealer with a clear understanding of whether or not a MINI is for you.
You can look at it two ways:
1) The Mini is way over-priced for an exceptionally small, slightly underpowered, virtually no cargo space, and very poor riding two-door hatch.
2) The Mini is way underpriced for an exceptionally good handling, very sporty, very well-built BMW.
Both viewpoints are valid.
Honestly, drive the Corolla and a Mini back-to-back. If the Corolla seems like the better car, then there is little reason to suffer driving a Mini.
Or go the middle ground: a Mazda 3. This is the best car today in straddling between a fun-to-drive and sporty car, but one with some comfort and practicality.
- Mark
The cheap BMW was the 318ti. If the 1 or 2 series come, then that will be the next cheap BMW other than used.
What do you mean by saying that a Mini isn't a car, but a "motoring experience"?
I don't know if I'm ready to say that the Mini is a "very sporty, very well-built BMW". Just because BMW bought them and spent resources on making it better, doesn't mean that it IS a BMW--that's kind of like saying the Toyota Camry is a Lexus ES 330. A Toyota Camry, even the XLE version, simply isn't a Lexus. If you want a Lexus, shell out the extra $10,000. Same goes with a Mini.
And, if you merely want to drag race, then buy a bike.
'11 GMC Sierra 1500; '08 Charger R/T Daytona; '67 Coronet R/T; '13 Fiat 500c; '20 S90 T6; '22 MB Sprinter 2500 4x4 diesel; '97 Suzuki R Wagon; '96 Opel Astra; '08 Maser QP; '11 Mini Cooper S
The folks that I know bought their MINIs for emotional reasons more so than financial, environmental, safety, performance etc,etc.
I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy the attention I get in the MINI but I really ENJOY driving the MINI. By enjoy, I mean GRINNING ALL THE TIME I'm behind the wheel. Always looking for an excuse to drive it. Its been a looooong time since a car provoked that kind of behavior from me.
Its quick, extremely responsive, flat cornering, feels totally stable, easy to move about in traffic, great brakes. It's kinda like driving a street legal go-cart. Almost everyone notices it and then they respond with a big smile or a thumbs up or both. Almost every time I park, someone has questions. It just makes me feel good! You really need to go drive one!!
People don't get enthusiastic about Corollas. They are appliances.
People get enthusiastic about MINI's because they are meant for people who like to drive...which is rare these days.
At the same time a MINI is more "practical" than, say, a Miata. Stiffer body, fewer rattles, takes four (two of them desperate) people in a pinch.
Sure you can load a MINI up with options to the point where you scratch your head. BUT, MINI's don't come "loaded" on the lot. Generally you can order just what you want. This is nice. There is no premium charge for ordering; you don't give up a "sale special price" when you order. In fact, usually ordering one is actually cheaper.
A MINI looks expensive, but it's actually not:
My typical bargain basement sporty ride is a Focus or Neon. These depreciate terribly. They come with few niceties if you want a real bargain - other wise they are mid-teens. The MINI is upper teens, if you want to be careful with the options, yet it holds its value incredibly well which more than makes up for the initial premium paid.
The MINI I have ordered is around $18,500. What other neat car can you get for that price? Not an RSX. Not a PT Cruiser (except for an underpowered, soft handling Base model). Not even a Mazda 3...
On top of a reasonable entry level price, on the MINI all facory maintenance is included for 3/36,000 or for an extra $500 for 4/50,000. The car is bumper to bumper warrantied for 4/50,000. There is very little risk of ownership (no ugly repair or maintenance surprises) during a typical ownership period and very high resale value. I will be buying mine, but many people lease them, with good lease rates from BMW, and presumably there is even "market risk" with a lease.
As I see it, the "Corolla" argument makes more sense if you talk about practicality, and not the Fun to Drive factor: the Corolla has a bigger rear seat, and a LOT bigger trunk. But, the Corolla won't handle like a go kart, and doesn't have factory performance options ranging from cheap to replace stock tires (cheap even in a plus zero 195/60-15 upgrade to Bridgestone 950's) to very high performance tires; from good stock suspension to outstanding sport suspension; from gas sipping commuter engine, to rallye worthy supercharged engine to the Cooper Works package.
Unlike the Neon and Focus that still offer "tossable" cars with sprightly engines, you don't have to fool around upgrading this suspension bit or that on a MINI - shocks a little stiffer, or a bigger swaybar, or lowering springs. The stock tires/standard suspension and center of gravity on the MINI results in a go kart with comfort. When I test drove the MINI, I realized this was what I was missing in 44,000 miles of VW Golf ownership - that "glued to the road," doesn't roll feeling. That was with stock suspension! For $500 more, upgraded roll bars, springs give a "super" go kart.
Where else can you "custom fit" a car to your personal driving tastes like this, for such a low price, from the factory, with a warranty? Where else can you get the city/highway mileage of the MINI and still have a 124mph tested top speed? (No, it won't get there that fast, and I wouldn't want to drive that fast, but it's nice to know you can do a high speed pass with vehicle stability intact.)
BMW advertises low price, entry level cars from time to time, but try to find a dealer that has them. Besides, BMW's come with a high "arrogance" factor. MINI's are humble and fun...talk quietly and generate high lateral G's in the curves. That's nice.
To me, it's the difference between a car that's an appliance, and a car that has character and history...between a car that will be gone in five years (the Scions and Mazda3's) and a car that can roll forward, won't be oversold, will still be "special" to own.
Is that worth the small number of dealerships and patience it takes to order? Is that worth possibly being tomorrow's overlooked Beetle or PT Cruiser when the honeymoon is over? Yeah, because the MINI has it's nostalgia element, but at the same time, it's built on a world-class "premium minicar" platform ... something popular in Europe, and that I'd like to see take hold over here. It's an upscale small car, and unlike upscale Golfs, for example, it isn't diluted by a bunch of cheap models. Every MINI has the usual power package; my 2001 Golf had crank windows and manual mirrors.
Go to the miniusa website. There is a lot of "under the hood" and history information there. I'd say BMW has really gotten into the spirit of the car...while BMW engineering has also made its way into the car.
One day I'll test drive a Mini... and will probably want one.
Question though: Owners here have commented that the ride is harsh. How harsh is it really? Is it as harsh as the Corolla, or on par with it? Obviously it'll be harsh if you're going from a Lexus to a Mini, but owners that are used to smaller cars might not see a big difference? I test drove a Civic, and found the drive to be very harsh. Maybe owners can comment on this one. Thanks!
I've owned several BMWs including an M3. The Mini is most definitely a BMW. It has the same rock-solid feel, the same attention to driving dynamics, the same great suspension and solid brakes. It's FWD with all the compromises that entials and it's a not nearly as fast as the higher-performance 3-series and 5-series, but it mostly definitely drives like a BMW and drives NOTHING like a Corolla or any other Japanese small car.
Build quality is a match to the bigger BMWs as well, although obviously compromises have been made to materials and fit/finish to make a car that sells for 40%-70% less. Granted, the Mini has had reliability issues, but that's very BMW as well - almost any new BMW model has teething problems. And it is astounding how many fewer problems are being reported with the 2004s.
And the ES330 most definitely IS a guzzied-up Camry. Different trims, different options, but underneath the skin, it's a Camry and drives like one. (Not that Camry's are bad cars.) If you could somehow drive both a ES and a Camry without being able to see which car you're driving, I doubt you could tell the difference.
- Mark
It really doesn't sound like a car for you. There are lots and lots of better all-around compromises in small cars.
- Mark
Mini number one is a base Mini with the standard 15" wheel and tire package. Normal suspension and it rides as well or better than most smallish cars. Docile and not to bumpy even on our concrete Texas roads and still has a good bit of sporty grip. Mini #2 is a bit different. Cooper S, stiffer suspension and the high performance 17" run flats (known for rough ride due to sidewall stiffness) and some after market suspension mods. It also has sport seats. I wouldn't call it harsh because the sport seats offer a bit of help but let's just say that I am aware of everything that goes under the wheels that's bigger than say, a lady bug! Most anyone else would call it harsh. I'll be nice and call it firm.
So you really have a choice. Get a base Cooper with 15" wheels and the ride is good and then gets progressively stiffer as you go up in wheel size and/or add the sport suspension. A suggestion is to get the Sport Seats on a base Cooper if you add the bigger wheels. (not a problem if you order the sport package as they are part of it).
I drove a Mini Copper S with the JC Works package which is probably the harshest ride available from the dealer and LOVED it! I am that person that owns the crappy little econo box and drives it back and forth to work until it dies. I will replace it with a Mini Copper S but leave the JC Works package off due to the huge price increase. If you buy a Corolla, which my father-in-law did, and then drive it for say 15 years then you will try to sell it and find that it is worth less than the soil that it would displace if you bury it in the backyard. Honestly, my Protege is worth something like $400 dollars. It's a great little car but most people want something else. I think the Mini will have that something else after 15 years of driving it. I also feel like it would be worth saving and fixing up for one of the kids when they are ready to drive and maybe I'll want a new one.
I'll spend a couple of months with the military in Iraq or Afghanistan to get some good tax free cash and then buy the Mini. I hope to sell the Mazda for something but like I stated earlier, it's a boring car with no "smile factor". It's an "A to B" vehicle and I did get more than every penney out of it that I put into it. I would recommend the Protege or now 3 to anyone who is looking for good reliable transportation and they are cheaper but it's not all about that when you set your sights on the Mini.
Drive one and see what you think. I agree that the sport seats are a requirement and you can only get lumbar support with the leather package which I now need due to the back surgery. Moonroof should be part of any Mini even for people like me who have so little pigment in our skin that we burn under a 60 Watt light bulb. It just makes it feel bigger.
Rambling on now so it's time to go.
Take care and test drive the Mini just for kicks. You'll smile on your drive home if nothing else.
Later
Phil
But in 2015, how much will a 2004 Mini Cooper with 195K miles be worth? Oh, I'd say about $400.
- Mark
They had an advertisement in the paper today for a base Mini with the Sport package and no money down for $269/mo. It was a 36 month lease with 10K miles/year. Real tempting but I will wait. Not a lease person.
Later
Phil
- Mark
My dealer didn't have the "black eye purple" for me to look at. This new 2005 color is replacing Indi Blue. My heart is set on either red or yellow, but I wouldn't mind at least seeing the new color before placing my order. Has anyone seen it, and is it anything like Indi Blue?
Can I order the dimming rearview mirror on its own? I recall it came in a "package" that I didn't want. If I can't get it, I take it the rearview mirror does the little flipping thing for night driving? (Those SUV headlights drive me nuts.)
This sounds stupid, but the first Mini I ever saw was Mr. Bean's! Ever since then, I have wanted a yellow one. Then, when the Cooper hit a couple years ago, the first one I saw on the street was yellow! Does anybody here think it is stupid to pick out a color based on "resale" value? I'm wondering if yellow is a less-popular color?
Where do you buy the fuzzy dice?
And in case you can't tell from my post, I am an auto novice, and this will be the first new car I have ever purchased (I'm 45). Again, thanks for the great posts. Grey
Mini2 is about the best resource for viewing lots of pictures of other people's cars to get an idea of what you like/dislike, especially with the varying interior treatments. But obviously, this won't help you out on a new color.
On color, get what you want. Granted, colors like silver are always popular, and certainly picking a real oddball color should be done carefully if you think you are going to sell in a few years, but in general, I say, "Buy for yourself, not the next owner."
A bigger consideration in color is upkeep. Darker colors are much harder to keep clean, harder to hide swirls, fade quicker (especially if the car is left out in the sun), and make the car hot inside. Red is particularly susceptible to fading - something to do with the red absorbing the wavelengths that cause fading. Unless you like washing your car often, I'd go for a lighter color, especially if you live in a hot/sunny climate. If you're considering the white wheels, you're really looking at a labor of love there.
miniusa.com is the place to go to see how the options are bundled, although they may not have 2005 info up yet. In general, you can order nearly everything ala carte rather than in bundles, although the bundles are cheaper.
Fuzzy dice? If you're serious, just about any auto parts store can help you out there.
Good luck waiting. It isn't any fun.
- Mark
Yeah, the miniusa.com 2004 configurator shows the auto-dimming rear-view mirror comes with rain-sensing wipers, for $150.
For 2005, there's a new package (ZCV), which includes: 319 Universal Garage Door Opener (also currently available as an individual option), 431 Auto Dimming rear view mirror, and 521 Rain Sensor and Auto Headlights. I don't have prices for 2005 stuff yet.
You'll find a dealer bulletin on 2005 changes at motoringfile.com.
More on colors: for 2005 there are two other new blues: hyper blue, and cool blue. You might want to take a look at those too; pictures of both are at motoringfile.com.
When I'm considering colors I try to get high contrast, good exterior/interior combination, and try to maximize the number of colors. For example, I like the warm biege cordoba interior (silver trim), with red or blue exterior. With a blue exterior, a white top, the red and orange taillights, and biege, silver and black inside, the car becomes quite colorful and interesting. I think the silver and biege work really well together inside, a little bit like a Ferrari. And, the biege and black seats look great (see Edmund's review for a good look--it doesn't look right at all in the configurator). It's fun just finding all the good combinations! (Yes, I'll get help soon...)
Both systems control throttle and apply brakes to regain traction. DSC additionally works to keep the car on track. In a Mini this means countermanding your right foot in snow or rain, thereby preventing understeer.
DSC is good for BMWs, which can spin out if the driver is careless.
BTW, I don't like any of the packages either, but many individual options look good. You sure you don't want the Chrono option, which gives oil pressure/temp? And the universal garage door opener? 3-spoke steering wheel? There's a 2005 options list floating around somewhere.
Would you like to say a little about how the ordering process has gone so far? I mean deposits and when to expect a production number, that kind of stuff...
Congrats on your order!
Ordering is easy. $1,000 refundable deposit, a check is fine (and they'll hold it for a week if you need to move funds around, as I did), you get a one page spec sheet and receipt for your check.
A month later I got a call saying their allotment was increased so my car was ready to confirm earlier than expected.
I gave them the update last week (they had package and option numbers) and it will actually go into production in a month.
Thanks for the info on the process, sounds painless.
-Mike
I'll let you know how the trade in aspect works out for me. The only silver lining in this cloud is the fact that East Bay MINI is part of the large Hendrick's group and can probably move my tradein to one of their other lots.
What say you fans and gurus?
And the MCS is not a very good gas mileage car. It does very poorly for its size and many owners (myself included) are not even getting the 24 mpg city figure ... more like 21-23. I'd recommend you look at the Mazda 3 which returns much better mileage on regular gas.
- Mark
BTW, the difference between 87 and 93 octane prices in my area adds up to about $2 per week more for me.
I'll be eager to hear how things go for you!
By the way, it looks like 2005 base prices are reported to be the same as last year.
BTW, John Roberts MINI in Dallas are stiff-necked boobs.
About JR MINI, The day that I took delivery of my MCS I was told that they were becoming an AutoNation dealer. It's possible that they have changed a bunch under the new owner's rules. I haven't had a reason to return so I wouldn't have noticed. Sorry you weren't treated well.
In general, sales staff are one of the worst sources of technical information. Everything they say is tainted by their desire to make a sale - if they preceive that a customer is sensitive to the requirement for premium fuel, nine times out of ten, they'll say it is Okay to use other fuels regardless of whether they have any information to that affect - anything to move the sale along.
- Mark
Are the back seats in a Mini acceptable for a kid or two; can it hold several grocery bags or a pile of drycleaning? I am sick of driving a mom-mobile and would **love** something small and zippy, but I do need at least a marginal amount of practicality. And if it comes in hunter green with white bonnet stripes, so much the better!
Of course there is enough room in the back seat for small children or a few grocery bags.