Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Or, how about you formally apologize here for your post in which you stated that anyone who buys an Escape is "out of their mind"?
Then I would take your "challenge" seriously.
Anyone get any real info on why this isn't close to the 18-24 advertised? Dealer said "everything checked out (codes)." Anyone know details on the O-ring problem with the injectors /fuel lines?
There...counter that one!!! Zooming past ya!!
bob
Have had my truck for 3 months, over 5000 miles, and only this past weekend really needed the 4WD-- snow and ice roads, unplowed, unsalted and unhanded, with steep hills (other people were sliding around a lot). However, after only about 15 minutes of slow driving in these conditions with the 4wd locked, I really noticed a burning smell, which is sweet like burning transmission fluid. While in 2WD, this smell is not apparent. The truck is at the dealer now as they inspect it.
I love the Tribute, and have not found anything else I would have bought instead, but is this another recall or design problem? Has anyone else had such a problem?
There have been five Safety Recalls on the 2001 Tribute/Escape models, affecting from 1,800 (first recall - throttle cable) to over 58,000 vehicles (most recent recall - windshield wipers.)
Is five Safety Recalls within the first six months of full production typical? Examination of the NHTSA database shows there are 11 instances of 5 or more recalls within a six month period on a given model year over the last 5 years of manufacture. The affected vehicles are:
1995: Chevy Caprice, Chevy/GMC pickups, Dodge/Plymouth Neon, Ford Explorer, F700; 1996: Ford Explorer, Windstar, Chevy/GMC pickups, Dodge/Plymouth (Grand) Caravan/Voyager; 1998: Ford Windstar; 2000: Ford Focus; 2001: Ford/Mazda Escape/Tribute (with Dodge Stratus coming on strong.)
In contrast, Toyota 4Runner and RAV4 have had 2 recalls each in their entire history. Nissan Pathfinder has had 2 since its last redesign in 1996 (12 in its entire 15 yr history.) Nissan XTerra has 1 recall. Honda CRV has zero recalls. Subaru Forester has zero recalls.
Of course, Safety Recall data is only one factor contributing to overall quality, and should be weighed accordingly.
Hope this helps.
The Sante Fe ride is more car like. That is what I wanted. The crash test data for both autos is not out. The Sante Fe rides much higher and is heavier than a Sonata. Ford's rollover record released today is not impressive either. Who knows how the Escape Tribute will fare.
But let me clear up a couple of things that seem to have gotten lost in all the mccain smack. My original comment was "are you out of your mind" but it delt with the fact that AT PRESENT the quality issues would overshadow the good points on the Escape. This discussion is filled with very serious concerns about things that are not minor first year build problems. They are problems that clearly indicate a lack of quality control likely resulting from a rush to market of this auto. Clearly, quality was not job one. BUT, I do think that EVENTUALLY (future tense) the Escape/Tribute will be a pretty good auto, say in 9 months to a year. With all the quality control issues so far one should wonder what else may be lurking. I think that the early track record would make people very leary. When I find posts that obviously are ignoring concerns I don't understand it. When I saw a post chastising owners of the Escape for posting their complaints and doing so very vocally, in essence saying tone down your complaining because I love the Escape, I don't understand it.
Fule smells, lemon law returns, bursting fuel lines...these are NOT minor problems and they still are not getting solved according to posters on this discusion.
The Sante Fe may not be perfect and I am under no delusions thinking that it is. But there have been no significant issues with it. As for the coverage, 10 years is 10 years and where else are you going to get your service if not from the dealer. (plus 5 yrs roadside and 5 yrs bumper 2 bumper)By the way BMW and Mercedes do the same kind of thing with their service. You have to have the records certified by BMW. If you want to take a new car to a corner mechanic go ahead.
If Ford has halted the rush and is actually addressing the quality then buying one makes more sense. But if those issues have not been solved...you take a pretty big risk.
Zoom on....
The ES handles like a dream, and goes on snow and ice as if it were magnetized :-)
The quality of my green ES is quite good for the price, and I love the openness the sunroof provides. I have read the previous posts for many months, and I really think that the pleased owners as I am, have not been posting. I have yet to find any problems with my ES, other than the mileage being lower than expected (arount 18-20MPG). I would recommend this to anyone in the market. The only complaint is one which is inherent to all suv's, that the bumpers are not impact absorbing bumpers as on cars and on the Subaru. I think all of the problems with the Tribute have indeed been corrected...hopefully. Anyway, I for one am pleased as can be. It is more than I anticipated it would be!
You don't make sense - tone down your complaining because I love my Escape? What kind of a comment is that?
I bought my Escape because I like the looks, performance and value. No it isn't a BMW X5 and I agree with you I'm not putting 70K down on one. To me it is a poor man's Lexus RX300. The dimensions are all very close, but the Escape is 10K less. I tried the Hyundai and at 6'8" I just didn't fit. Even the saleslady at the autoshow said it wasn't big enough. It was clearly designed by Koreans for Koreans meaning by short people for short people. Besides, even if I did fit do you really think I was going to buy an SUV from a company that has never built an SUV before and has an even worse reputation for quality than Ford? Are there any long term Hyundai owners out there that have good things to say about their Hyundai's?
Recalls happen. The important thing is that the manufacturer recognizes the problem (instead of hiding it in an employee locker) and then does something about it. Ford/Mazda have done a very good job of owning up to their mistakes.
With that said, I agree that we have to wonder when they are going to stop finding them. The shear number of problems (even those that are not published recalls) is absurd. Completely absurd! The design of the vehicle seems to be pretty solid, but with this many quality issues brought to light in such a short time, you cannot ignore them.
For the sake of everyone who owns either vehicle, lets just hope both of them get a good rating, and for owners to conitnue driving safely.
Of course Ford/Mazda will have a bigger sales volume than Hyundai, but consider the RATIO of units produced and defective units sold, SF would have significantly lower ratios (BTW that is not factual). Also having a higher volume of order doesn't excuse them from rushing production and sacrificing the quality of the vehicle. Consumers who have done their research, knows that Escape has 20+ HP more than SF so it is no surprise that you would do better on that uphill race yours.
And for people who chastise others to post messages about the problems that they have with their Tribute/Escape, if you haven't noticed yet... the title of this forum is 'Mazda Tribute/ Ford Escape problems'
so if you're tired of reading about them, do ur self a favor and skip this forum. Or better still, balance it out by posting how happy you are with your truck. But I think people are already doing that.
When I was doing my research (Sep - Dec 00), I tried very hard to look for forums where I could find satisfied buyers so I could get an assurance that those problems were isolated and 'typical' first year model problems, I found one in yahoo, but to my disappointment, the bad outnumbered the good.
That being said, maybe we should start a new room for this topic.
Also, when I did my research I also looked at other forums. There were only two recalls that people complained about the most - windshield wipers and the fuel smell. I scrutinized the recalls and realized that for the most part they only affect a few compared to the thousands produced. The biggest recall was the wiper blade problem. If you were to research other makes of trucks you would see that many don't get recalled until hundreds of thousands of vehicles are made. To me this says that those manufacturers aren't listening to their customers. At least Ford is admitting to their problems.
Thanks for keeping me honest. I'll try to be more attentive in the future...
Also, regarding the waiting period for an Escape - don't hold your breath for the 10 week wait quoted - I've been told 3 to 6 months! During my search (I went to over a dozen dealerships in search of one) IF any dealers had them on site, they were either bone stock or fully loaded. I bought mine off the lot (fully loaded - the dealer had two) at MSRP. That's the price you pay for wanting something really popular I guess. Anyway, so far, so good. The wife loves it and it's fun to drive. I'll post updates as we put more miles on it.
The next day ptmccain proceeds to call me a moron and it just went downhill from there. But in a way it was kind of entertaining. His vicious defense of the Escape no matter what was hard to understand (since he dosen't even own one). So I played along, again entertaining reading.
But no matter what, there are still enough problems that are not fixed and people who are mad as heck at Ford/Mazda that it should not be ignored as a factor in considering purchase of this auto.
By the way, I think our new poster lovemyescape maybe someone else in disguise. Just a guess.
Oh, BTW...I am soooo impressed that you traded a BMW on a Hyundai...you sure do know your sports cars. You had a 4ws Honda Prelude....too bad the MX6 GT 4ws beat it huh...the Prelude was manual and the MX6 electronic. Guess who holds the Guiness WORLD record for sports car sales....??? MAZDA Guess who was forced to add weight to their car to build competition because they dominated IMSA....RX7. Now guess which UTE has the best braking 60-0 AND also can do 0-60 respectfully...Tribute/Escape.
Please define "truck"....look it up in Webster's dictionary...
What ALL these new UTE'S are doing is appealing to those who don't want a truck, like a sporty car but want the convenience of an SUV. The first was the RX 300 Lexus. It was the ONLY one to blend car ride, platform with the "function" of an SUV.
I can end this by simply stating that I don't want a war of words but answers and solutions to FORD/MAZDA Escape/Tribute PROBLEMS....not Hyundai.
Fact is I love my Tribute and for the last time mine produced in late Oct. '00 has ZERO recalls pending and one that was a dealer check prior to delivery which was the wiper issue and that checked out fine. Can't we get back on topic for those of us who own MAZDA/FORD Tribute/Escape and not cause each other grief. I can flame just like you....but I prefer FACTS and I "try" to help on Tribute/Escape boards....I didn't find this site on the net....I was asked months ago by many on Yahoo to post here. This is not a whose is bigger and bad but fixes to this first year production vehicle that OBVIOUSLY has its flaws.
bob
well of course they do, their cars for many years were all sub compacts, almost all sub compacts, be it Ford Fiesta or Hyundai Excell, have dismal death rates because anything that hits them is bigger and weighs more.
"who came to THIS board and challenged and ran over the edge on the Santa Fe"
Yes I challenged ptmccain, more as a joke than anything. mcain has been on my case ever since my first post, it was directed at no one but him and he did not bite on it.
"Please define "truck"...."
The Tribute Escape is built in Claycomo Mo. Ford's TRUCK facility. built on the TRUCK line, by people who have spent their lives building Ford TRUCKS. I grew up in the area, I know many of these people. It is built on a truck style platform.
"I can flame just like you....but I prefer FACTS"
I responded to your message, asking for a reply to Zooming by ya. What facts are you refering to? You posted no facts that I recall in your message, just a quip about racing up the mountain.
That's funny. I thought the Tribute/Escape was being built on the old Contour/Mystique line. You must know your people at Claycomo very well. I also wouldn't call a unibody vehicle with fully independent suspension a "truck style platform."
Used People First for financing. Got 7.05 which everyone around here was in shock about it being so low. Bank here [Oklahoma] was 8.5. I think some of the complaints about the recalls are to get you to buy something else. [their brand]
Is 3-6 months and sticker price after a year in release really worth it? Is the Escape so revolutionary that it demands this sort of pricing and wait? Hardly. Houses are built in a shorter time. Heck, some children are conceived and birthed in the same amount of time that some people are waiting for this vehicle.
TC
8-P
(tongue in cheek)
and precise steering. There are just 2 things that bother me.
Has anyone noticed a thumping when the left side of the car
hits a bump, typically at low speeds?
The other thing is the user's manual says that you can
turn fog lights on either with parking lights or low beam on
and in my case they only work with low beam turned on.
bob
"I agree to disagree in a civil manner should I take issue with the statements of another Town Hall participant or any Edmunds.com, Inc. Editor or content contributor. I understand that civility and respect underlie the success of an on-line community such as Town Hall."
Discussion and even debate is encouraged amongst our members. Please attack the issues, not each other.
Thank you for your cooperation in making Town Hall a comfortable place for all to participate.
Sincerely,
Dana S. Livingston
Community, Manager
Town Hall
Edmunds.com
dlivingston@edmunds.com
19.4 mpg doing mostly highway (and I feel I have a light foot on the petal; rarely go over 65 mph).
Anyway my question is on the 5W-20 oil they spec for the V6 engine. I've only been able to get Motorcraft 5W-20 at Walmart. No one else seems to make it, and I really want a synthetic (like Mobil1 which I've used for 10 years).
Mobil1 says they have no plans to make a 5W-20. Castrol said they were coming out with a 5W-20 this year. Does anyone know of source or mfr for a synthetic 5W-20, or even other 5W-20 regular oils ?
I bought my Tribute from Menlo Mazda in Oct 00.
Right from the first week, I could detect fuel
odor. After taking it back couple of times,
one mechanic acknowledged the problem and contacted Mazda customer support. Here is his
report in work order:
"Check Fuel leak. Use engine analyzer to detect fuel vapor smell. Verify leaks from intake manifold. Call hotline and talk to Les.She told me
to pull out intake manifold and inspect intake O-ring. It was not fitted right (uneven). Check for parts availibility. Intake manifold in on national back order. Mazda hotline told me to reseal the O-ring for now and order parts.
[After two months]
Removed intake manifold assembly clean the gule. Install new i.m. assembly and transfer throttle body and ISC valve. Torque intake bolt to 12nm. Even Torque. Check for fuel smell. OK!"
---
My observation for last 24 hours is: It has fixed the problem! Finally!!
I.I.
discloses costs of new quality initiatives
A quote from the text: " Another challenge Ford Motor Company faces is shaking the recall bug that has pestered Ford for the past couple of years. Last year Ford Motor Company issued more recalls and thus broke it's record setting 1999 numbers. However, many of the recalls were on new model introductions and Ford admits that it may have brought some to market somewhat early to meet the strong consumer demand. That now seems to be changing with reports in from various Ford plants around the country that the new message coming from the top down is quality first".
It seems to me that this quality first policy should have been the norm from the get go. It's a little late for current owners of Tributes/Escapes and Ford vehicles in general.
{65} after 20 minutes or so, it chugs, bogs down & simply loses power. It feels as if you disconnected a couple plug wires. It's still at Planet Ford in Dayton, Ohio. Been there a week now. At first they used their diagnostic & it showed nothing. Then it sat there for 4 days until I finally got the service manager to drive it home after work. It seems during a regular work day, there's simply nobody with enough time to waste 20 minutes on a mere test drive. Anyhow, the service manager confirmed that he experienced the loss of power. That was 2 days ago & I'm still walking! My father is a retired GM worker. He warned me about Ford. Maybe I should have listened.
I'm about to purchase an Escape, but am debating between the cloth interior on the XLT and the leather. I'd prefer cloth, but it seems rather industrial and potentially uncomfortable. I'd like to here from owners who have purchased the cloth and how they like it.