Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
This is your post webby1 "BMW 3-Series vs Acura TL 2004" May 5, 2004 8:40pm!
Thanks bodble2 for the explanation. Mine doesnt vibrate also.
You might also try driving the 6-speed TL. The 6-speed has a stiffer suspension, Brembo brakes and (optional) high performance tires. I believe the handling of the TL 6-speed is the best of any FWD sedan out there. Better than Audi and VW, and competitive with the RWD Infiniti G35, IMO.
However, make no mistake, even the new TL does not match the handling of the 200 lb lighter, RWD 330i. The 50/50 balance of that car and BMW suspension technology produces the best handling small sedan, period.
The ONLY advantage the G35 has over the TL is the handling of RWD vs. FWD. And it is not a big difference. The G35 is NOT a BMW 330i, no matter what Infiniti marketing promotes. I actually thought the steering in the TL was crisper, although it can be affected by torque steer.
The Acura TL navigation system - 8" screen, voice activated - is the best available in any car, IMO. Add the voice recognition for other controls - audio, HVAC - that comea with the Nav system and the advantage is even greater.
Acura offers a few other features - Bluetooth phone, XM radio / DVD audio system, lighted steering wheel controls for everything, etc. that the G35 didn't offer. The G35 interior just looked downscale to me.
The Acura TL engine is smoother. The G35 has a torque advantage, but it is at the expense of a rougher engine. I have a 1995 Maxima with the 3.0 liter version of the 3.5 liter V6 used in the G35 and felt that my 10 year old Maxima engine with 153k miles wasn't as rough as the G35.
I believe most car mags tout the G35 as more of a driver's car than the TL, mostly because of its RWD and better steering and handling. However, if you want a nice blend of luxury, sportiness and new cutting-edge gadgets at a reaonable price, the TL is a VERY GOOD choice, particularly if reliability is also your top concern.
As for the G35's "better steering and handling", I honestly didn't find that to be the case. I do prefer RWD in principle and the TL does exhibit occasional torque steer under hard acceleration, but in my test drives, I found the handling and steering of the G35 to be at best on par with the TL. Clearly, all RWD's are not created equal. The 330i, 530i and 545i I drove after the G35 were several rungs up, especially in terms of steering feel and feedback.
I have not driven the G35 AWD. I don't believe it came with a 6-speed in the past, perhaps that's changed.
In a word, no.
And it is extremely comfortable at the same time. And it has a great nav, although it's not voice activated, but it comes with a remote for the passenger to use or the driver has handy controls on the steering wheel. Amazing handling.
INFINITI G35 Year: 2004
NHTSA Complaint Number: 10093125
2004 with approx. 7,200 miles. Rattling noise heard in 1st and 2nd gear. Dealer said it needed new tranny. REPLACED TRANNY.
Picked up car and while driving home, could not get it into 5th or 6th gear. Back to dealer.
Was told that tranny was bad and HAD TO BE REPLACED again. Picked up car and within a week heard a knocking noise in 5th gear,
Vibration in stick shift and a clanking noise when applying the brakes for the first time after car sitting for a bit.
Later found out that dealer lied about installing the 2nd transmission. Dealer refuses to tell me or give me paper work
Stating what was done on car the 2nd time they had. Infiniti consumer affairs and regional manager have not proven to be out
For consumers interest. In fact, they call lying about the 2ND TRANNY A "MISTAKE". Sounds like fraud to me, especially when
I was told several times that they don't repair trannys ...they only replace them. They also gave me a work order/paperwork
Stating that new tranny was installed twice.
Infiniti g35 year: 2004
NHTSA complaint number: 10098647
Transmission makes chattering noise as the engine shuts down (only able to hear when the transmission is warmed up and only able to hear it from outside or with the door open.). TRANSMISSION WAS REPLACED but the chattering noise still exists. I was told that THE PROBLEM EXISTS INTERNALLY IN ALL 6 SPEED TRANNYs' and the problem can not be attended to unless more people complain.
The new TL has 0 record for transmission failure 1 year since it was introduced. (at least no complaint on NHTSA record)
So which drink that needs some lemons? G35 anyone?:)
My previous driver was a '98 A4 2.8 quattro w/sport package and 5 speed. I went with the auto TL because the wife hates manual transmissions and I read about (and noticed) the torque steer on the 6 speed during a test drive.
The car is gorgeous. I picked it up a couple of weeks ago and have still not found ANYTHING wrong with it, with the exception that last night the outside air temp suddenly went blank. I'll see if it is still that way -- perhaps my first problem. Other than that, no problems - no rattles, no cosmetic blemishes of any type, everything functional, etc.
Of course (can you believe this) some axxhole in a Toyota SUV dinged my rear left passenger door - we had seen the guy putting his kid in the rear of his SUV and I didn't realize the door had hit mine until I got home. I have the paintless dent guy coming next week to fix it.
The audio is great and everybody loves the camel interior (it is a bit richer and different than most interiors). My Sony Ericsson phone links perfectly with the bluetooth and everybody in the car can contribute to the conversation!
The engine is smooth and runs great. The navi is wonderful and the audio commands really impress people - dial the phone, set the temperature, and answer the nave system - all by voice -- and no, it does NOT need any training to a specific voice! (very impressive).
The car is quieter thank my Audi and again, have not seen/heard any rattles.
Average mpg in mixed driving has been about 19, which is a bit lower than I expected. Perhaps after break-in it will improve. I did zero the trip computer on the freeway and the steady-state cruising at 65mpg mileage was reported at about 31.
One slight complaint is in the handling deparment. The steering is nice and firm, as is the ride, but what I've noticed after driving the car longer than you normally do on a test drive is that going relatively quickly through long sweeping turns feels noticeably less stable than in the Audi. In a 60 mph sweeping freeway ramp turn, when you hit small bumps the car wants to roll side to side a bit, and this affects the steering stability, feeling like it wants to wallow left to right with the rolling of the car. The Audi did not do that at all - it was rock solid. I had previously driven a G35 and felt it was even worse than the TL, however. I guess the A4 spoiled me a bit.
I can also tell that the overall solidity of the TL is lower than the A4, which is a very heavy car for its size. The trunk sounds a bit tinny when shut, and I miss the gas shock mechanism -- the TL still has supports than intrude into the trunk, although there are nice covers to protect the luggage (look at one and you'll see what I mean).
Still, overall the TL is a very impressive package for the price and I'm very pleased so far. I just wanted to let people know that problems are posted quickly, but that there are probably a large majority that have few to none. The initial quality of my car is better than any new car we've received to date!
tlong - what is the gas shock mechanism that you are refering to?
I also made the transition from an '98 A4 but a 1.8 version and have been in the TL since Feb and echo all of your comments. I miss my fold down rear seat and I would give the edge to the A4 slightly in terms of handling/agility but the TL is an outstanding vehicle considering everything.
I think the TL is a awesome product and I hope it will be as trouble free as my 86 Honda CRX-SI was until I donated it with 204,000 miles three years ago. Time will tell, and so will I.
You got a red one right? How did it 'hold up' so far? Hope you got good sunshine to reflect that bright pearl. Did you get camel or parchment? Did you get mug gurads and if so does it look OK on red?
I can't even believe I am considering a 9-3 over a TL, but in all my test drives I don't think I ever felt the nimbleness in the TL that I experienced in the Saab. I know the TL has a whole bunch of other qualities going for it such as a more refined ride, a hot engine, a super-nice interior, an awesome sound system, better reliability and a higher resale value.
I guess I'm asking some of you TL owners who have had their cars for awhile if you feel the fun in your ride is still there or if you just crank up that incredible DVD-Audio system and sit catatonic as you drive to work? If you had to do it over again, would you still buy the TL?
manthony:
I have often struggled with "fun to drive" and emotional desires and other more practical factors such as reliability, fit and finish quality, amenities etc. I am currently going through that dilemma in trying to decide on a replacement SUV.
However, I have no regrets for purchasing a 2004 TL 6-speed in May, whcih now has 10,000 miles on the odometer. I would NOT have purchased a pre-2004 TL at ANY price. It was an exceptionally fine car that had the emotional appeal of vanilla ice cream. With the 2004 re-design, the look and feel of the car went up 2-3 notches, but I still would NOT have bought an automatic version. Thanks to Acura's decision to make an extremely precise 6-speed manual available, and combine it with a stiffer suspension, high performance tires, and Brembo brakes, I finally had a car that appealed to both sides of my brain. That was a necessity, becasue I was also trading our third "fun" car - a Honda S2000 - for the TL.
I don't know if you are comparing manual transmission models of the Saab 9-3 to the TL. But, if you aren't, then IMO you have no basis by which to assess "fun to drive" ratings of either. It's been a few years since I drove a Saab 9-3 and, as I recall, the are relatively nimble, but lacked the tightness of suspension I prefer and the precise gearbox. The TL isn't perfect, but as far as FWD cars go, it is at the top of my list. The BMW 330i would take the overall handling prize, but even it's "performance package" 6-speed is slightly rubbery compared tothe TL.
In summary, you can have your cake and eat it too if you get a TL 6-speed. If you want an automatic anything, I can't help you with an unbiased opinion, because I am not. And I live/work in DC and am closer to 50 than 40, so I don't think I'll be changing anytime soon.
Good luck with your decision. You won't be making a mistake either way.
I really like the looks of the new 9-3. Even after buying my TL I still do a double-take when I see a new Saab drive by. I had my eye on a new Red 8-3 Aero. While my wife dislikes the interior of the Saab, I do like the "cockpit" styling.
I was close to getting the Saab because of a bad sales experience I was having here in Columbus, Ohio. The Acura dealer was asking waaaaay above sticker based on the lease price I was being quoted. (He refused to show me how he could justify his outrageous payments.) So I was back at the Saab dealer ready to buy when I went to another dealer (Lindsay Acura in Columbus) who was willing to deal forthrightly and not waste my time like the other dealer in town seems to do as a way of doing business.
Anyway, when I looked at the features of the TL: horsepower, awesome stereo, satellite radio, Bluetooth, Honda reliability and overall looks, I was sold once I found the right dealer.
I have an automatic and I think it is a ton of fun. I am one of those people who feels that you don't have to have a stick to have a sports car. (Although if I were buying a Porsche I would only get a stick.) The handling is tremendous and I have used the power and handling to get myself to the limit more than a couple of times.
I think the decision rests in what's important to you. I like a luxury car with all of the creature comforts and bells and whistles. So the TL suits me well. With that said, the Saab is very nice as well.
In the end it is a cost-benefit decision you will have to make. In this case I think it comes down to vehicle content (as mentioned above) and vehicle dynamics ("fun-to-drive factor).
Good luck!!
habitat1: It's clear that after 6 months you are still having fun and that's great. And, I can understand how the fun factor would increase with the 6MT, but I am on the farside of 50 and these old legs just don't want to push on that clutch pedal anymore. So, I am comparing the A/T versions of both cars and, still, the driving characteristics of the 9-3 are markedly different from, and, in my mind, more fun than the TL.
shs111: As far as dealer attitudes go, I'm sensing a little more arrogance on the part of the Acura dealers these days because they know they have a high-demand line of products (except, perhaps, the new RL . . TBD). But, in my case, I don't think the dealer differences will come into play as I think I can live with either.
So, bottom line question remains: Do I make the smart purchase (TL) or the emotional one (9-3)? I'll let you know on Friday how things turn out.
One thing I haven't mentioned is that Saab has foolishly upped the MSRP on the 9-3 this year to the point where an Arc equipped similarly to a TL w/ Nav is almost $4K more than the TL. I can get the GM Supplier discount, however, and am waiting to see if there are any December incentives which would bring it down to a comparable price. If not, then TL here I come for sure.
Once again my salesman fell short of good service. I asked him to get me a price on the floor mats and body side molding before I signed the paperwork and he said he would check on the wholesale price on them for me. When it came time to sign all the paperwork, there was nothing about the floor mats or side molding. I asked the person that had all the paperwork about the price on the accessories, and he knew nothing about it. He quoted me a price of around $375 for the side molding and I told him I just wanted the price of the molding and that I would install it my self. He then quoted me a price around $265, I said keep it. I then went to the parts counter and got the side molding for $140 and the all season mats for $105.60 and the salesman didn't get the credit for it.
Igiban, when are you finally going to pull the trigger. I'm looking forward to hearing your experience.
I'll let you know how my red TL is when I get it. It's been hard to get a hold of one.
only thing is the car still kinda veers to the right.....is that torque steer ? It is even present when cruising or when I'm not even really stepping on the accelerator....
will bring it in, and get the first oil change also....
Kinda pain to have to scroll thru it...
And this leads to another question. If you're not going to use the nav for an extended time, is it adviseable to take the disk out? Can the disk be potentially damaged (from heat, vibration?) from sitting in the cartridge in the trunk?
Jeff
My question is does the DVD player play burned music? Also are there certain dvd's that you need to buy. I have been in cars that only play certain kinds of burned cd's and I was wondering if the acura has the same type of issues with the dvd player.
I was also wondering if anyone has experienced any problems with the bluetooth not working with certain kind of cell phones - specifically the Motorola v710. The following link is an article which mention that this phone and the TL's bluetooth may not work correctly together. http://www.nuclearelephant.com/papers/v710.html
Thanks,
Cru
Graet spy phone, camera, video, voice recorder.
My question is does the DVD player play burned music? Also are there certain dvd's that you need to buy. I have been in cars that only play certain kinds of burned cd's and I was wondering if the acura has the same type of issues with the dvd player.
I was also wondering if anyone has experienced any problems with the bluetooth not working with certain kind of cell phones - specifically the Motorola v710. The following link is an article which mention that this phone and the TL's bluetooth may not work correctly together. http://www.nuclearelephant.com/papers/v710.html
Thanks,
Cru
Jeff
I have exactly the reverse of your problem; mine tends to veer to the left. The problem has improved significantly since having the tires replaced/rotated, but is still there to some extent. Specifically, the car will fall off rapidly to the left when cruising in the left lane but drive straight or pull slightly to the left when in the right lane (unless the roadway has a really steep drop-off to the right). The problem seems more severe on some concrete roadways, which have a more pronounced "bite" than smooth asphalt. Also, the steering loads up more when turning right than when turning left (i.e., turning resistance is proportionately greater to the right than to the left, other things being equal). I understand that this problem has also been reported for recent Accords. The Bridgestone tires are suspect, but I think other factors might be at work also. My TL goes back into the shop in December for further investigation. Apart from this, the car is great. Please post whether or not you get resolution.