Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Honda Odyssey vs Dodge/Chrysler minivans
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
I would often compare our results, of let's say several thousand of one particular model, against CR's data and almost always see discrepancies, sometimes very wide. The fact that CR's data is only based on subscribership is alone a statistical bias as the reporting population, by virtue of the fact that they are more consumer oriented, is outside the "average" car owner. And as you mentioned, the term "major problem" on CR's form leaves it entirely up to the subscriber to determine what is major and what is not. In this manner alone the ambiguousness of the completely open-ended questionnaire violates Standard Statistical Form, even for one that's unsolicited.
Regards,
Dusty
I have subscribed to Consumer Reports since the late '60s. I always take their evaluations with a suspect eye. The earlier posting about the validity of their reader responses has to be considered.
Too much time and effort has been expended here trying to argue about whose math is more accurate. I like to read about comparisons of vehicles by owners. The only reasonably reliable information is that which is posted by owners stating specific problems or satisfaction. I would most value the posting of someone who has owned a late model DCX AND Honda minivan and who has no agenda.
It does take some effort to find these boards but they are a valuable asset if we take the time to state accurate FACTS.
"Now here's what really makes me wonder why the DCX crowd isn't on here all upset. Here's how DCX and Honda owners think about there cars. So it's like overall satisfaction. Performance DGC 2/5 Ody 5/5 Comfort DGC 2/5 Ody 5/5 Features and Instrument DGC 2/5 Ody 5/5 Style DGC 3/5 Ody 4/5 Overall Appeal DGC-2/5 Ody 5/5. So why aren't the people complaining here??"
The same J D Power ratings rated Initial Quality and the results are; Mechanical Quality DGC 4 Odyssey 4 (tie), Feature and Accessory Quality DGC 5 Odyssey 3, Body and Interior Quality DGC 3, Odyssey 2, Overall Quality DGC 4 Odyssey 2.
Do you really think a Odyssey owner would rate his or her van lower after having paid a premium price for it over DCX vans. Socalwad excepted because he's convinced he got the best price on his first Odyssey after buying 3 or 4? DCX vans.
I have only purchased 1 Dodge caravan(2001) I did it purely for the price, had 2 as company cars(1990,1993), and one given to me (1986) when we were too poor to buy anything(about 8 years ago). I bought the van I wanted, don't care if you think I paid too much. The most important thing is that whomever buys is happy with thier purchase. That will make you keep the car longer and save yourself much headache in the future. I think driving them both and then looking at the features you want/need and can afford is a excellant way to find a car you can live with.
I really did like the Ody's comfort, safety features, VCM, VSC, offset crash test ratings, Lockable in floor storage, side shades for the twins, ride, 9 inch DVD screen, looks, braking, and overall smile factor of getting this van for my wife and kids. So I guess you should guess again. Or maybe not.
You hit the head on the nail here!!!! Ody buyers certainly wouldn't knock their Minivans after a premium price. If you paid $30k-$40k for a MINIVAN, you'd be giving it rave reviews no matter what problems you have with it.
The "Problems" areas on here is amazing when you look at the number of postings vs numbers sold for each minivan. You have at least 2:1 more DCX vans sold, but a fraction of the postings on here. For most people, a minivan is strictly an appliance, point A-B tool (especially a DCX).....not worth getting too excited about unless you paid a lot more for your's or have a problem. If you browse thru DCX Problems, many are like "I have 130k miles on my 1996 Caravan and my thingy is acting up". Very few late models problems for DCX. Even the latest CR buyer guide rates them identically even.
Well there he is Mr. look at these forums.How ya doing today??
For most people, a minivan is strictly an appliance, point A-B tool (especially a DCX).....not worth getting too excited about unless you paid a lot more for your's or have a problem.
Well you seem pretty excited sometimes!! Did ya pay too much or do ya have a problem??
If you browse thru DCX Problems, many are like "I have 130k miles on my 1996 Caravan and my thingy is acting up".
Well ya still have the forum if all else looks bleak I would think that will never change! I only know about 20 DCX members on here(small gene pool) and not a one of them would dare post there!! Some guy had a check engine light on in the Honda forum and like 10 differant people posted. On the DCX board ya have to wait until someone shows up. Heck just the other day I was the first person to respond to a guy with suspention noise after 3 days. I hope it was the sway bar bushings(common 50K issue on the DCX vans) and not the whole rack and pinion like on the 2005 DCX owner that replyed
Very few late models problems for DCX. Even the latest CR buyer guide rates them identically even.
Look now we like CR and will quote it!! EVEN!!
You hit the head on the nail here!!!! Ody buyers certainly wouldn't knock their Minivans after a premium price. If you paid $30k-$40k for a MINIVAN, you'd be giving it rave reviews no matter what problems you have with it.
No you guessed wrong again. How about 2005 cars would ya think the appeal scores on the BMW 5 series would be high, how about the Mercedes E-Class?? Guess what they both scored lower than the Ody. Mostly 3's. You can get a EX for around 26K a LX for 23K, the average car price is 30K(mine was 29.5K EXL with RES). It's really not very expensive for what ya get!! It's definitely not the car for the masses, but you could always buy a really old car and drive it until the wheels fall off. My dad does! 500 deductable and only liability. Now thats the way to save money! That guy got 270K(bought it with 95K in 1984 drove until it rusted to the ground) out of a 1979 mercury Zephyr wagon. I perfer to have something nice for about 10 years. To each their own. So if ya wanna save money dennis buying a new car wasn't the answer. You coulda got a used Ford Expedition with a tow package for about 10K less.
J D Power Appeal Ratings Advantage Odyssey (see post 4935).
Consumers Report both average, tie (see post 4898).
VSC ? same rollover rating for DCX without VSC.
VCM ? Some (not all) Ody owners are not happy with mileage.
Full Curtain side Airbags, Advantage Odyssey.
Trade in value, Depending on your savings rate, Advantage Odyssey.
Price paid, Advantage DCX
Crash test ratings DCX and Honda Odyssey (tied) 5 stars for both vans, Driver ,Passenger, Front and Rear. 4 star rollover ratings for both.
http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/testing/ncap/
Looks like both of these vans are pretty equal except for price!
J D Power Appeal Ratings Advantage Odyssey (see post 4935).
Consumers Report both average, tie (see post 4898).
VSC ? same rollover rating for DCX without VSC.
VCM ? Some (not all) Ody owners are not happy with mileage.
Full Curtain side Airbags, Advantage Odyssey.
Trade in value, Depending on your savings rate, Advantage Odyssey.
Price paid, Advantage DCX
Crash test ratings DCX and Honda Odyssey (tied) 5 stars for both vans, Driver ,Passenger, Front and Rear. 4 star rollover ratings for both.
http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/testing/ncap/
Looks like both of these vans are pretty equal except for price!
Well lets be grateful he didn't need his engine or tranny replaced, like I've seen a few Honda owners talking about!!!
How about 2005 cars would ya think the appeal scores on the BMW 5 series would be high, how about the Mercedes E-Class??
Maybe, just maybe people who are spending upwards of $60k for a vehicle have much higher expectations than Minivan buyers?
You can get a EX for around 26K a LX for 23K, the average car price is 30K
True!! if you fly to North Dakota to purchase it, or send out a million emails looking for those prices. Begging some dealers to knock off a grand, then turn around and charge you a grand for mudflaps and paint protector. Even your own little fluff piece last week noted Odys selling for sticker.
I'm waiting for the new X5 to come out next year...preferring German styling, handling and engineering over anything else.
Oct 31 2006 rating DGC 9.0 Ody 8.5 looks like a fall from grace to me!
Maybe now you see the potential for unreliability of CR's methodology? The problem for ANYONE willing to prove reliability based on CR's sloppy methodology is that it's a two-edge sword. The variabilities are too great and their methods are too flat. Remember, too, that you and another were criticizing my criticism quite vigorously and, with certain qualification, by default defending CR. So if you believe in CR's methods over anything else, then maybe you are forced to accept the latest results.
But as far as I go, you can ease your mind. Although I never believed that the Honda was as good as CR indicated, I still think CR's methodology is no better than a sixth grade math assignment. Trying to predict the future performance and reliability of manufactured goods based on past performance of items in the hands of users with the full range of owner behavior is inherently flawed to begin with.
I think thats pretty close to true. I accept without any reservations. The Ody is a first year model and DCX has been improving since the late 90's. That's why I bought in2001 I saw them getting better.
Do you know how they do rollover testing?? Well here ya go they find the center of gravity and see how high it is then compare it to the tire width!! It is not a dynamic test!!
VSC is a very good safety feature please don't try and disregard it without using useful information.
VCM ? Some (not all) Ody owners are not happy with mileage.
Test track show a average of 13% better gas mileage.
Crash test ratings DCX and Honda Odyssey (tied) 5 stars for both vans, Driver ,Passenger, Front and Rear. 4 star rollover ratings for both.
Whats the offset for the DCX they have it listed as marginial. While the Ody is Good and a best bet.
Looks like both of these vans are pretty equal except for price!
Only if you close your eyes and don't drive them both!!
How many times can you use the arguement both ways if you pay more you will only say good things!! Then you say if you pay more you expect more so you'll say bad things!! You are quite confusing to say the least :confuse:
True!! if you fly to North Dakota to purchase it, or send out a million emails looking for those prices. Begging some dealers to knock off a grand, then turn around and charge you a grand for mudflaps and paint protector. Even your own little fluff piece last week noted Odys selling for sticker.
I dealt with 3 dealers and sent 4 emails. Wow it was so hard. Oh I almost spent as much time posting this then getting my Odyssey for 200 over invoice. BTW after that I had people bugging me with the I got a deal for you. Rock Honda, Riverside Honda, Honda world, Fladeboe(where I took my test drive) I was like throw my number out. Oh where do I live Southern California. Huh I've never been to North Dakota>
Test track show a average of 13% better gas mileage.( Better than what?)
Crash test ratings DCX and Honda Odyssey (tied) 5 stars for both vans, Driver ,Passenger, Front and Rear. 4 star rollover ratings for both.
Whats the offset for the DCX they have it listed as marginial. While the Ody is Good and a best bet.
Are you reading the same Test as I am? I did not mention the driver door coming open on the Ody http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/testing/ncap/
Key Word being "I"!!!!!!!!! There are many postings from people on Honda Prices Paid searching the world (or at least out of state or their living area) trying to find a deal!!!! All for just a MINIVAN.
BTW - DOES ANYONE ELSE ON HERE HAVE THE VERY ANNOYING "INSIDE LINE/TOYOTA" AD COVERING THE MESSAGE AREA, MAKING IT VERY DIFFICULT TO READ POSTINGS???? EDMUNDS??????????
My dealer had an ample selection of Odyssey models and colors and just the one I wanted. I am certain the DCX dealers have loads of vans mainly due to poor sales and large inventory. Read the October sales figure being released this morning to see just how bad things are for Detroit. Something is going on when the American car makers ran "Employee Pricing for All" sales for months this summer. DCX wouldn't even let old Lee Iaccoca enjoy retirement.
Most of the comments on here are very biased. Since I just spent a bundle on an Odyssey do you think I am going to come on here and slam that model? I am going to tell everyone how great the Odyssey is thus making me out to be the genius I know I am . Car buying is almost as personal as your political views. Yes, I would post like crazy if my Odyssey turns to junk but short of that I want to look brilliant.
NHTSA has Odyssey, Grand Caravan, and Sienna all 5 Stars except 4 stars for rollover rating for all 3 and Sienna only 4 stars for driver.
IIHS has Odyssey and Sienna "Good" for frontal crash but ODYSSEY only MARGINAL for rear and Sienna POOR....BUT has Grand Caravan as Acceptable for frontal and rear.
WHY the discrepancy between NHTSA and IIHS for Grand Caravan? :confuse:
It also covers part of the message area when one typing to reply to a post.
Must be some type of punishment for all the statistics and Consumer Reports
posts that have been going on in here.
It's a offset test. It was developed for a typicial car coing over the center divider. How many people hit striaght in a flat barrier?? Just another type test if you go to crashtest.com they have like all sorts of tests at different speed by differt countries.
From socalawd :Whats the offset for the DCX they have it listed as marginial. While the Ody is Good and a best bet.
The truth, My quote is from NHTSA which tested 06 minivans.http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/cars/testing/ncap/Index2.cfm
Socalawd's Quote is from IIHS which last tested a DCX van in 2001
Semper Fi
This discussion hasn't just departed from its usually high-quality level; it's gotten completely off-track; for that reason, a number of posts have been removed.
I think everyone here is aware that opinions are biased, that even the most scrupulous research has a built-in margin of error, and that interpretations of both are likely to vary widely. In other words, it's helpful to consider one's own needs and take everything one reads with a grain of salt. If you'd like to continue discussing the validity of CR's research methodology, you can do so here:
Consumer Reports: Testing and Review Methods.
This discussion welcomes all of your opinions, but that welcome is limited to opinions about vehicles... not each other. Here are a couple of guidelines:
If you can't think of a way to respectfully refute someone else's opinion, don't reply at all. Go on to the next post.
Be respectful in your attitude and language. If you choose to speak in a tone that you wouldn't dream of using during a job interview or dinner at Grandma's house, your choice is probably inappropriate and harmful to productive discussion.
Comments about the appropriateness of another's post are off-topic and perpetuate an unpleasant situation. If you happen to spot a post that you feel is harmful to the discussion, please let me know via email, rather than pointing it out on the boards.
Keep it on-topic. Lurkers vastly outnumber posters in any given forum, and this Forum belongs as much to them as it does to active posters. They don't come here to find out what the members think of each other -- they come to find out about your experiences with your vehicles. Trying to decide which car to buy is nerve-wracking enough -- give them a break by not requiring them to wade through 50 posts to find one that pertains to the subject listed at the top of the screen.
Thanks,
ClaireS, Host
Coupes & Convertibles | Vans & Minivans
MODERATOR
Need help getting around? claires@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
Tell everyone about your buying experience: Write a Dealer Review
It seems to be an intermittent problem and it's been reported. I agree that it's pretty irritating :sick:
MODERATOR
Need help getting around? claires@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
Tell everyone about your buying experience: Write a Dealer Review
I think I've read a few times now that 2005 Caravans were sold out early. Bet Honda wishes it could say the same. Someone a few weeks ago made a comment about Honda not being concerned about selling more vans than Chrysler etc....but isn't it funny how much Honda covets the "No. 1 selling car in America" with it's Accords and Civics but not it's Odys?
The "something going on" has more to do with $3.00/gal gasoline than EP.
Well I checked four dealerships out here( None are sold out)and they have almost 50 Caravans left. Cerritos Dodge has 35 2005's in stock come out and buy one!! maybe I have to go to North Dakota to find a dealer thats sold out of 2005's. In september Dodge caravan(all styles) sold 12,390. Honda Odyssey sold 12,347. Something is going on here!! People are spending there money wisely!!
One month does not a sales year make...or something like that, also, you may not be including T&Cs which I believe are selling almost same volume as Dodges now that Plymouth is history?
Maybe what's going on is "selective" reporting of stats?
I guess people are wising up here....
Here's the latest: Chrysler Group Reports Sales
Looks like 25,412 Minivan were sold in October, up from previous month but down from year ago.
"Sales of the Dodge Grand Caravan held steady in the period."
Why did the DGC hold steady if the T&C rose by almost 87% for the first half of the year? I may be missing something, but DCX Employee Pricing was on ALL DCXs, right?
One month does not a sales year make
Your own words, not mine.
None of these Honda dealers would put a person on a waiting list without a $ 500 NON-refundable deposit. When asked why, the Honda salesman replied that if it were refundable, someone may order one at every Honda dealer and then take the first one that came in LEAVING the other Honda dealers with an un-wanted vehicle."
When you realize the Odyssey is a totally new design with state of the art features and dealers can't charge above MRSP (like the 1999-2003s?) and they're not gaining much market share??? Whereas the Dodge is a more mature design?
None of these Honda dealers would put a person on a waiting list without a $ 500 NON-refundable deposit. When asked why, the Honda salesman replied that if it were refundable, someone may order one at every Honda dealer and then take the first one that came in LEAVING the other Honda dealers with an un-wanted vehicle."
Ok I checked Inventory Willey Honda has 0 2005 Honda Odyssey's. Kan Garff has 2 2005's and Larry Miller has 0 2005 Odyssey's. But they have plenty of 2006's. Now Doug smith had 0 2005 Grand Caravan's Menlove has 3 2005 Grand Caravan, and Hinkley has 1 a silver SXT 2005 Grand caravans. I talked to a sales guy at Menlove 1-800-447-2098 and he said all 3 are there!! So at these dealers in SLC(I got them by just putting Dodge/invertory and Honda/inventory these are the first 3 that came up) it's Dodge 4 Grand caravan leftovers and Honda 2 (all model Odyssey's)leftovers. I know I should look for T&C and SWB caravans so this is only a partial info post. I know that dennis and dan would have sniffed the one out as a false claim. Since they only worry about the truth! :P
I will probably buy the Toyota Sienna LE at Mark Miller Toyota when I get my next vehicle. Mark Miller has the best inventory of Sienna and does not load them all up with overpriced Toyota options as does Menlove Toyota and Larry H. Miller Toyota. Most Toyota owners are much more pleasant than most of the Honda owners...altho I have met nice salesmen at Willey Honda, Ken Garff Honda, Ken Garff West Valley Dodge/Chrysler/Jeep, and Doug Smith Chrysler/Jeep/Dodge.
Doug Smith caters to buyers of USED Grand Caravans and sold 3 or 4 USED 2005 GC for every NEW 2005 GC. :confuse:
I would NOT buy either a Dodge or Toyota from Menlove Dodge/Toyota nor any vehicle from one of the dozens of Larry H. Miller dealerships....even though Larry H. Miller himself is a very nice guy. :sick:
In fairness, I drove a Sienna XLE in June. I came back to that same dealer in September and it was still there. By its Texas state inspection sticker it had been at the dealer since March. Guess what? It is still there along with another XLE but that one has been there since February!
I like my Odyssey. As I said before I have owned a Vanagon, Nissan Van, Trans Sport, Grand Caravan, Windstar, Sihouette and now the 06 Odyssey. The VW, Nissan and Dodge were junk. The rest were very reliable.
I do not think people are stupid for buying another brand different from mine. We all make choices based on our personal taste. I am certain the DCX folks are just crazy about their machines. My like for the Odyssey could change upon a major problem cropping up. All I can say in conclusion is that if any one of you DCX troops would like to do a side by side quality comparison you have a deal!
Can't we all just get along?
I thought they all charged above MSRP. :confuse: At least that what I always hear you pushing when you compare costs.
and they're not gaining much market share???
And they aren't discounting like crazy. Looks like the T&C has slowed down. Not +87% but +31% for the year to date oh no. Also the Dodge brand is down -4% year to date. Do we really want market share?? No I think they like the good margins!!
Whereas the Dodge is a more mature design?
Your right a little old for my tastes!!
No editiorial comment.
We're talking two very different companys. Honda (and Toyota) both slowly grow their sales. Their production methods allow them to do this which ensures maximium profits. Was the Accord/Camry the top sellers when they were first introduced? No way. After 10-15 years it's a competely different story.
Inventory is carefully controlled by Honda. They don't even normally offer incentives to move out the last because they space their production. They're quite effective at it, even on the high volume models you'll see very little year-end incentives. There's $3,000 rebate on the T&C right now and quite a few to pick from. I've been shopping for a new truck ($5500 rebate plus I can get employee price isn't bad...) and there are at least 3-5 2005 vans at the Dodge dealers I've been searching inventory on. There's not even any marketing support for the Honda dealers to push the Odys so I'd have to say the '05 inventory is pretty much gone.
But the point is, Honda will sell more for a greater profit while DC will produce whatever number covers their fixed overhead and then push incentives to move them. It's a problem all the domestics are stuck with, called excess capacity.
Who cares what van you drive? You do. It is not my business nor anyone else on here. Most people come here looking for first hand owner information to help them make an informed choice. Sniping at each other does not help anyone.