Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Hyundai Sonata vs. Honda Accord vs. Toyota Camry vs. Ford Fusion
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Just a thought.
Makes sense. However if they do follow the lead of Mazda, as in the 6, the base I4 would not come standard with SACs. That would be perfect for fleets and Joe consumer alike.
I guess realistically it really doesn't matter to me. I'd like to see ABS and SACs standard on everything but either way I'm going to pay for them when I buy. My 6 does not have SACs because it was hard enough finding a V6 with an MTX let alone one with SAC's back in early 2004. I bit the bullet and took what I could get for my S-Plan. The Ford salesman I deal with already committed to allowing me to Factory order my Mustang at the end of this year and still get X-Plan pricing because I was concerned that those are still really hard to find with an MTX, and nearly impossible to find with SABs. You can bet the ABS and SAB boxes will be checked on that order sheet. Together, and with traction control added in, those "necessary" options will cost me about $600. Well worth it IMO.
They are are making great strides with the Sonata, Elantra and other new vehicles. This is just their first salvo, stand by for their counter and followon attacks attacks already in prgress!!!
I dropped my wife's Honda Pilot off at the Honda dealership for servicing and parked my 2006 Hyundai Sonata right in front of the big service window (OK I did it on purpose). Recently waxed, tinted windows etc. I saw five or six salesmen huddles around obviously discussing it. I don't know what they were saying they looked worried and they certainly weren't laughing at it!! LOL!!
You guys are stuck on Gargonzola and it is clearly Brie time baby! Honda and Toyota step aside!!! I love to see the giants fall!!
The Sonata is a great car, but it too is unappealing. Wouldn't take much to turn it into a looker.
This is very true. I personally think that all four of the cars here are handsome, if not breathtaking. No midsize sedan should be polarizing in its style (if it wants to sell high volumes). I feel that the Fusion went out on a limb with some of its exterior details, and most of those paid off (the best looking Ford sedan in YEARS). Hyundai, Accord, and Camry are all fairly bland IMO. The Sonata took the 03 Accord's rear and stuck it on the Sonata (especially taillights). The Camry makes me sleepy to look at! The Accord has a much nicer looking rear with the 06 redesign, and adds a touch of class with the LED taillights (offered on the more upscale cars like Azera).
While I'm talking tail lights, I was very dissappointed to see that Ford still hasn't made a seperate blinker from the brakelight/taillight. The one bulb shares all three functions. Just seems like a cheap out to me, and I personally feel that having a seperate brakelight and blinker is safer (Just my opinion, not necessarily yours).
Have a good MLK day tomorrow!
thegrad
Wow - really? Looks is one of the top criteria for me in a car. Sure I want performance, safety, reliability etc but I want that package looking good. I don't think the Sonata is all that stylish, but neither is the Accord. Honda needs to do a restyle quickly or their Accord sales will continue to slide. And I'm not talking about just redoing the tail lights.
Yea you shouldn't have to worry about impressing anybody with a car purchase. But that doesn't mean you gotta go down the boring road all the time. Life is short. Live it up!
I do think Hyundai would benefit from pulling a DatsunToNissan move. They build a decent car now but their negative reputation in many circles precedes them.
Nissan changed to Datsun because the name Nissan was so recognized with the Japanese war machine, our arch enemy, not long before. After memories had faded more they went back to Nissan.
No they should stick with Hyundai and do exactly what they are doing inprove styling and quality. It is too soon now, but in the future they need to have a luxury plate name Lexus, Infiniti, Acura etc.
I'll try to remember how much more mature this discussion is when I post next time...thanks for keeping me in check.
Everybody seems to use the "IMO" for some reason. I bet ole Mrs. Bishop is rolling in her grave! It's funny how you remember advice like that from way back in High School!
Stockmanjoe
I recognized it back in 1999(aren't we in, like, 2006, man), only after driving my Sephia with 70,000 mile Yokohama radials and Konig Diva wheels. That car was really fun to drive with the improved handling the Yokohama's afforded me. I paid a whopping $7995 for the Sephia in 5-speed form in May of 1999. What car did I dump for the 1999 Kia Sephia sedan? It was none other than a 1997 Ford Escort sedan. Not a bad car but uninspired. The Sephia was fun to drive.
With my '01 Kia Sportage I gained 4WD, which has helped me get out of more than one tight icy spot in both Missouri and Idaho winters. The SUV has consistently shown me that it is a tough little truck that will give and keep giving and keep giving.
Why people can't think beyond Audi, Toyota, Honda, Chrysler and BMW is beyond me. The future is all South Korean for automobiles. I am glad that I didn't listen to other people. That would have been a huge mistake.
2021 Kia Soul LX 6-speed stick
The reality is that adding IMO or, waay better, IMHO, to a post that is opinion makes it far more palatable to a reader who might not agree with said opinion. To leave that disclaimer off makes it appear that the poster believes him or herself to be posting pure "facts". And when that happens, those who might disagree with the posted non-disclaimed opinion get quite annoyed at the seeming arrogance of the declaration and all heck breaks loose ...
So let's not worry about Mrs. Bishop's admonition and keep faith with the usual message board etiquette here.
And that would include getting back to the comparison at hand ...
The Accord does not look like a Beamer in my opinion. Honda and BMW used to have similar styling themes in the 80's and 90's but not anymore. Your right on the Sonata though it does some Audi flavor to its style.
You should have read my post more carefully I put the sentence about the Sonata being boring looking in quotes because I was replying to another post that said the Sonata was boring looking. In response to the post that said the Sonata was boring looking I said the Sonata looked good in "black color".
Ok lets pick apart your post one by one:
Didn't CR rank the 6 a couple years ago best in class in crash test results?
Styling:Nothing has changed since 2002: Uh the Camry and accord looks better than the 6? The Altima came out a year before of the 6 and you are going to say how the 6's styling hasn't changed since 2002? BTW, the 6 was new for the 2003 model year in the US.
in quickly changing market: what quickly changing market? The Altima was new for 2002 model year as was the Camry and the Accord was new for the 2003 model year as was the 6. Just recently the a new Passat, new Fusion and new Sonata have come out as 06 models.
HP: The 6 has a 2.3 liter 4 cyl engine that makes 160 HP and you think its weak? 220 HP is no slouch either in the V6.
Finally, I am not trying to go at you directly in my response to your post but I was just answering some of your issues that you picked out that the 6 has in its class that its competing in. I;m with you 100% on the issue of interior room though.
"Mazda's 6 is a great car with great handling, it just isn't what everyone looks for when shopping for a family car."
I agree with you there.
Your right Honda should push up the release of the 08 Accord. The new Camry is coming out in a couple months. Yeah sure the Camry may not look all that stylish but its one of the best selling cars in America. I should also add in a new Altima maybe on the market before the next generation Accord comes out as well.
The Altima SHOULD be out before the next generation Accord, especially since the current one debuted as a 2002 model. Perhaps they spent too much on the interior upgrades for the 2005+ models? The 02-04 Altimas were PITIFUL inside IMO.
The current Camry, although a yawn, is better looking on the outside than the 2007 model. The inside is a different story, however. Very nice 07 Camry interiors all-around.
For those who wrote about Sonatas in rental fleets, I am renting one right now from BWI Avis. It is a V-6 GLS. I have to admit it is much more comfortable than the Grand Prix I was expecting to pick up.
Just like buyers do!
**The above is a completely baseless statement, and intended for humor purposes only. This joke was too easy not to pass up, though not that funny.
(Gets serious)
My sincere apologies to the Ford crowd.
thegrad
I am aware of the pricing considerations but the test seemed just a little unfair and misleading to me.
Now, my turn. "IMO" may be polite, but "IMHO" is ridiculous. Look up the word "humble" in the dictionary. If everyone is supposed to be equal on this forum, why should anyone be "humble" in responding to another's opinion? It is an unnecessary word, often used paradoxically to imply superiority on the part of the writer.
Anyway, that's what I think, IMHO. :>)
We liked it. When we started it, we literally had to roll down the windows to hear if it turned over!
Was like this until the day we traded it for a Scion tC, in Sept of 04.
We had issues, like turn signal stalk cracked in half at 85,000 miles. 25 dollars to fix it.
Alternatro failed at 103,000, water pump at 105,000, radiator leak at 113,000 miles(adn other nickel dime stuff "robbed us" of 2K, which was supposed to go to the house for work, that still is not done, unfortuantely...had other issues last year, and spent our tax returns on :mad: ).
We traded it in at 118,000. Still had issues.
2)Our 04 Sonata GLS-V6, Loaded minus ABS, cloth seats(not as good as the leather ones).( the 01 tiburon had 103,000 on it, and tranny was thisclose to death. Spouse was lucky to get 2 Hyundai lot with it. We got stuck buying the 04 Sonata. We took a few grand hit, tacked onto the Sonata, from tiburon, Luckily, the sonata was on a major sale.... I wanted to have achoice in what I buy, not be desperate, and stuck w/no choice) :mad: !
Manual 8 way seat adjuster( note: when I tested the I-4/2006 Sonata, it did nto have the 8 way, just 6, in GLS... the salesman tried to tell me'Sonata never had 8 way in GLS", until I SHOWED HIM! he practically choked!).
Anyhow... the 04 is cool in that it has the manushifter, which helps for passing, or slowing down the car faster, to brake(saves on wear n tear on brake pads).
But,NVH is worse than our 99.
Can hear the engine when ya start the car, every time. No need to roll down the windows to double-check , to see if it turned over, or not(like in the 99).
More NVH all around.
Can't lock the glovebox(minor issue, but the old GLS ya could, but then, it was the top model in 99, now the LX is top model). The mirros are Not folding/break away, like our 99's were.
Door lock does not illuminate green (around the lock) to light it up, at night, so ya don't scratch your door, like our 99 did.
They give ya less for more now?
:confuse:
The 06 was slightly quieter than my 170HP, 2.7 L v6 2004(the I-4), but still not on par of the 99(since they broough out the XG330, then XG350, now Azera....they do not want this model to be as quiet a it once was, so if ya got a few grand more to spend, ya may wanna go get the Azera, and make more $$$ for Hyundai's pocket?)/
Anyhow, it was ok, but that center stack is ugly.
The new 2006.5 Optima has a nicer interior.
Looks like a Buick, in an ok type of way.
Anyhow, people, it is late, and I gotta go.
I think I posted this stuff before, but, not sure.
Fusion was ok. I have tested the Malibu, G6 sedan, Fusion,
Sonata. To me, minus maybe one is safer, or a fewmore MPG, whatever, they are almost all the saem to me these days: Family sedans, that are decent, and do not cost a ton, especially when on sale.
Me? I am getting old, and want a Sports Tourer car:
Maybe the 09-10 Eclipse?
I only need 2 seats anyway these days!
Exactly. Altho a nice all around package, nothing excites me about the Sonata.
kind of tacky and fake. I'd put Honda first, Sonata, then Fusion, and Camry in terms of styling, period.
I hardly even notice my car's road noise. When you are listening to the radio when you drive you don;t notice any road noise.
Reasons to buy for the largest segment of the market:
reliability and economy ( it's why the 4c's are so popular)
styling ( this is very very subjective, but most Camry owners wouldnt be caught dead in a 300 )
price ( Camry is the price leader but it can't get too far out of line )
performance ( as long as it's anywhere near the pack it's OK )
my vote is
Fusion, Honda, Jetta, G6, Sonata, Altima, Camry just to add a twist to the discussion..
As far as Fords new entry into this market, Fusion, Milan. I am a huge car buff. Have been since I was 12. I get out on the internet and read review after review of all types of cars/trucks/SUV's. I have been subscribing to Motor Trend for over 20 years, along with Car and Driver for over 15 now. I am not claiming this makes me an expert. However, I have to tell you. I have yet to read one really terrible article about the Fusion or Milan. Ford can be bashed all day long, I find this to almost be a norm with some groups. Ford has done its homework on these vehicles. Take a look around the net, read the reviews. There will always be those who hate Ford, as those who hate Honda, Hyundai ect...
Some people just need to take the visors off and see the Fusion for what it really is, "One bitching mid-size that can go toe to toe with any import".
All extremes aside, I had the opportunity to drive an SEL V6 recently, and was VERY impressed with the tight steering, compliant suspension, and seat comfort.
~alpha
When the vehicle comes out it will make all the others start scrambling all over again.
As a 4 time camry owner I'm biased admittedly. I have been mildly impressed by the current model Camry '02-'06 because it's just OK in style and performance. The current Camry generation is a lot better performance-wise than my Camrys the latest of which was a 2000.
I'm speaking heree mainly about the 4c versions which are the bread and butter of the line. It's not the best of the 4c group ( Accord, Sonata and Camry ) by a long shot and it may be third but the differences arent that great. Styling & Features IMO ehh. It probably deserves it's position of 3rd/4th. The V6, except the 3.3L in the SE, also a lukewarm .. ehh.
But you cant beat them for giving a driver the feel of driving a near-luxury vehicle at a blue collar price. That's what wins hearts and what Hyundai is seeming to emulate very well.
Now come March...
The 3.5L V6, pull-the-skin-off-your-face, Avalon/Lexus powerplant with 6-speed tranny and stupid V6 FE ratings will have every competitor scrambling to catch up just to be equal to the CAMRY??!! Who'd a thunk it?
Throw in a 40 mpg FE V6 for which there likely will be waiting lists for months, now you have an excitement and sizzle that the Camry has never had. A waiting list for a Camry??!! Get outta here.
The 4c LE trim will have all the safety features standard plus VSC/Trac as the first likely option, all at the same price as the previous models, including a 6-disc changer. A 2006 model with these features would sticker for ~$23000. I'm guesstimating the new '07 LE will be in the the $22K, or lower, range. Add more features and drop the price. That sell vehicles.
Then put this all in the best looking package, IMO, the Camry has ever been in. It will again have the others scrambling for the next redesign.
Come March then the leaders in the key buying criteria are>> the envelopes please..
Reliability:.. Camry/Accord.... then Fusion/Sonata
Economy:.... Camry, 1st, 2nd and 3rd places
Safety & Features:.. Camry/Sonata, Accord
Styling:.... very very subjective, my vote is Camry, Fusion
Performance:.. Camry
Pricing:.... Sonata. In a different universe
Handling:.. Camry/Accord, Fusion or Accord/Camry, Fusion but TBD
Bang for your buck... It's your personal decision but there certainly is a lot more value across the product line now than there was last month.
Performance? Accord runs with the Camry. Especially the V6 manual trans (oh wait, Camry doesn't offer ANY stick shifts... BOO)
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
HSD 4c 39-41 combined.. off the chart
4c 29-30 combined.. 1st for the 4c
V6 26-28 Combined.. 1st for the V6's
Handling:
This is just about the new '07 which is why I put '..TBD.' They will have to run the SE V6 and see what happens. Now the '06 Camry is ..ehh.. 4th maybe.