Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Good luck
-Jon
http://www.kjjeep.com
tidester, host
Still a happy camper with the Wrangler.
Thanks Jeff
And there's a Special Report on Diesel Developments that may be of interest.
Steve, Host
Diesel isn't too difficult to find here in Columbus, Ohio. It just takes a little "re-programming" to look for it. I hope most commerical stations begin to offer the USLD fuel, or maybe even 80/20 blend with biodiesel.
I'm personally looking forward to the diesel Liberty, and I have been entertaining thoughts of picking up a used one as a second vehicle in 3 or 4 years. By then, we may have that low-sulfur diesel and the really nice diesels from Europe may have replaced the current crop. In that case, I may go for a new diesel Liberty. Well, I have plenty of time to think it over.
My mom has a 2003 Sport and I was really surprised by how much I liked it. Nice styling, plenty of room, good ride, etc.
I could never deal with the MPG in a DD though. but I would definitely consider the diesel version.
As for the ETA, I've heard July, but don't hold me to that. I figure it will be August or September.
The Lib's seats seemed narrow and short on thigh support (in the Limited). Like you were sitting on top of them instead of in them. Any thougts? Are the Sport seats better?
Foot room also seemed lacking in each seat. In the rear, toe room was a problem. In the front, the space was very narrow in the footwell. And the floor isn't very flat anywhere.
On the plus side, low end torque seemed much better than the Toyota. How is the high end? On my test drive I couldn't get much past 45 mph.
The Liberty's ride was more sporty, but more bouncy than the 4Runner, which is probably expected (kind of like a small car compared to a bigger car) although the Liberty is only a few hundred pounds lighter. Is the ride and comfort satisfactory on longer trips?
For off-road, I expect both vehicles to do well. The 4Runner has a little more ground clearance, but the Liberty has a shorter wheel base.
It's a tough decision. The Toyota is bigger and better equipped. The Liberty is more fun to drive. Both are now offering nice incentives. The Liberty would be about $5,000 less cost (for me) and lower insurance, although it depreciates much faster. I appreciate others' thoughts.
Thoughts:
Seats - I too found them short compared to my 90's model accord, but still comfortable. Took me a while to get used to them, but I have taken several highway trips, some as long as 12 hours and found it to be very comfortable (Limited model). I have also seen shorter seats in other new models. Suspect "games" are being played with interior measurements - shorter seats means more leg, knee room etc. I sat in a Sport model, and found the seats very thin and uncomfortable. Not sure how they feel on a long road trip.
Jeep ride is somewhat truck-like, but to me it feels smooth and comfortable. Some trucks aren't. I would think the Toyota could be more comfortable with a longer wheelbase.
Room - Liberty seems more compact to me, but I don't have any problems riding to work or on road trips, either in front or rear seats. Some Jeeps are narrow by tradition, if you ever go off-road and see some of the road width's you'll see why. Easy to see some off road heritage there. If the extra width is important to you, go with the Toyota. I came from an accord, which felt as if it had much more interior width, but I don't miss it.
Power seems fine to me, but you really should try both vehicles on an interstate - I'd steer clear of any dealership that won't let you.
I bought the G package, with all the bells and whistles (heated leather seats, radio controls on steering wheel, sentry and theft alarms, smoked glass, power heated mirrors, power steering, abs brakes, Selectrack 4wd, speed controlled locking doors, towing and off-road package, outside temperature, compass, gas mileage, distance to empty and so on). If the Toyota has much more, it must really be loaded!
Off road, I took my Liberty up a narrow road from a friends cabin in the Tennessee mountains. Road width was only a few inches wider than the Liberty, with drop-offs several hundred feet down. The liberty climbed a very steep, angled, muddy road with little to no effort at all, in 4 wheel drive.
My only concern was reliability when I bought it. More than a year later, it's still trouble free, quiet and fun to drive. I just finished a thorough underside inspection this past weekend. I especially checked every metal to metal joint on the engine, transmission, transfer case, and front and rear differential pinions. Not a leak, in fact not even any weeping at the joints.
Bone dry. This after 6 months of almost daily driving over Interstate under construction that is broken, pothole filled and very rough in stretches 10 miles long. So I'm pleased so far.
Engines - I prefer cast iron engine blocks in vehicles that can go off road with a low range transfer case, as they can get to some places that will cause your vehicle to really take a pounding.
Fortunately, you get that with the Liberty and the V8 model Toyota. If you don't ever plan to off road, I doubt it would matter.
Touch choice - Toyota looks like a great vehicle. I think if you get the V8 equipped Toyota, you'll have more torque than the Jeep. I'm guessing since I haven't driven one. Looks like it comes down to price and preference.
&;
Sounds like you might like the Toyota a little better already. I'd go for the Toyota if you like it better, even at 5 grand more. The only thing about the Toyota I wasn't sure of when I saw the first pictures was the cladding on the non Limited models. I like the Limited models much better in both the Jeep and the Toyota.
Seats - I think you are right in the seating size versus legroom theory. I'm coming from a '95 Ford Ranger STX and it has more room and bigger seats.
Room - the Liberty looks and feels pretty small, but others have complimented it on its roominess. It is certainly much taller than most small/mid size SUV's. With the back seats upright, there isn't much room behind them.
The 4Runner has more electonic gizmos, like traction control, stability control, hill decent control and hill start assist - all standard. Some of those have value to me and some don't. I wasn't planning on buying a loaded Liberty. I just can't figure out why Jeep doesn't put ABS and Cruise on their base models. Even the Limited doesn't have ABS standard. The dealer tells me that ABS generally comes packaged only on the higher equipped models.
Engines - I was planning on the V6 4Runner with 245 HP and 283 ft/lb. of torque. I know it is a new aluninum engine, but Toyota has an excellent track record so I'm pretty comfortable there. I will do some off roading (live in Colorado) and the size and shorter wheel base of the Jeep would be beneficial in that regard.
Toyota has realized their design error on that cladding. They have stopped doing the gray wheel and bumper cladding. Now they all look like the Limited style on the outside.
You're right that I'm leaning toward the Toyota. Reliability was going to be my deciding factor. I'm glad your Liberty is problem free. Thanks again the your thoughts. This is one quiet board!
If this thing can do this kind of work and survive only like a Jeep can, imagine how well it will handle normal every day driving.
Another bonus is the warranty. At the time it was a free 7 year/100,000 mile powertrain but now it is a 7 year/70,000 mile powertrain.
My advice is Get the Jeep and never look back.
Tom
-Bob
Steve, Host
-Jon
Also, has anyone added the overhead console (at a dealer or after-market dealer). How much did it cost, how difficult is it to install.
Thanks for any help(or suggesting another website with this info)
I've had the same wind noise on my Liberty. I just assumed that was normal. If you want some real noise try it with the rear windows down about halfway and the front windows up.
Rod
At 1:30 in the afternoon, three sisters were in the libery (the 19 year-old driving) on a perfectly straight, flat highway in the fast lane (speed limit 100kmph/62MPH). They just crossed a small creek, (and the road has a gentle rise and drop over the bridge) when it suddenly veered over to the right shoulder for about 130 feet, then off the road and rolled. The 2 older girls survived, but the youngest one was pinned in the Liberty and died on the scene.
What's unusual, is that the RCMP have a specialist examining the vehicle, and in 20 years of reading the Vancouver Sun with fatal accidents every week, the only time I recall them mentioning a mechanical investigation is for brake failures on dump-trucks. I've never seen mention of an investigation of a passenger vehicle. So it sounds like the RCMP suspect a problem with the Liberty itself.
Has anyone encountered anything weird with the steering/suspension?
Cheers
Pat
thanks
Unfortunately, it doesn't contain much detail.
tidester, host
As a Jeep Liberty owner, and a cop, I can tell you that in any traffic fatality, the vehicle is always looked at as the possible cause of the accident. In my experience with vehicle accidents, especially SUV's, 99% of accidents are due to driver error. It's always possible that something went wrong with the Liberty, but it's more likely that the driver went off the road, over-corrected, and lost control. I saw the exact same thing happen in a Wrangler a few years back, and all four in the Jeep were killed. The inexperienced driver went slightly off the road, over corrected, came back into traffic, and hit an oncoming Orka truck at 65mph. The Wrangler actually stayed in pretty good shape, but they weren't wearing seatbelts and the top was off. it was an ugly scene to say the least.
Anyway, the gist of this message is that atleast here in the U.S. (Colorado), the vehicle is ALWAYS looked at as the possible culprit. Not sure how our brothers up north do it.
I have owned a number of Jeeps since 1983, and this one is the best , hands down.
Does anyone know what type of oil filter wrench is needed to remove the oil filter?
I tried using the old style straight arm with loop at the end but there is no clearance to loosen or tighten the filter.
My Jeep has the off road group which includes the skid plates. I don't know if this makes a difference regarding not being able to reach the filter easily.
Any and all suggestions will be appreciated.
1. requires drilling (rust potential?)
2. rubber guards stuck to hood (do they say on? ruin the paint on my hood? are they necessary?)
3. inability to keep hood clean w/o removing it
4. does it really keep bugs off windshield?
5. does it make noise at high speeds?
6. will it really decrease my mileage?
Can anybody help me out there????
The vinyl hood protector however is easily removed for cleaning. If you keep a thick coat of wax under it, you will not have any scratches. This is what I would suggest.
But the question was "has anyone ever purchased one?" We don't want to discourage dealers from participating on the boards but let's not use them for drumming up business - it's against the rules.
tidester, host