Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
After reading the 350+ posts on this discussion I don't see how you could not have reservations about the Escape/Tribute.
Also as far as best mid-sized SUV the new Toyota Highlander may be the best overall when it finally gets here.
Tell everyone. You have a mission!
; )
I admit that I was considering the Excuse, but after talking to two of my college roommates who are ISE engineers with both Honda and Ford, I relented.
The Excuse is being mocked at Honda as the perfect example of what not to do when introducing a new vehicle. What nto to do when checking a line-run, what not to do when fitting a plant for new unit production. At Ford, the Excuse is being called just that "The Excuse." No one can figure out how the vehicle got so screwed up and so problematic.
5 recalls, and 4 TSB on a new car are not "normal bugs."
I was neither told not to buy the Ford, nor to buy the new CR-V next year. My roommates simply said that given the problems plaguing this vehicle, corrective actions would not be effective until next summer. In other words, sure the bugs are goign to be figured out, but almost a FULL YEAR after launch.
If you read, Ford delayed the new Explorer for over a month because they did an assembly line test-run and found almost 50% of the vehicle n the new line were defective.
If you are a executive at Ford and you have your compnay mission list, where does quality fall? Certainly not at #1.
By the way, Ford is on record as saying last summer that they expected the Tribute/Excuse to be a major hit, yet they still ran out of moonroofs and ABS parts....Uh, hello, another red-flag.
All this negative recall publicity has had little to no affect on the sale of Escapes/Tributes.
The Santa Fe, its Hyundia don't forget. And, speaking from my brothers experience with his Sonata. Parts are hard to get when they go bad and take a looooonnnggg time to get here from South Korea. He once had a loaner for 3 weeks! Yeah sure the warranty is great but at what price. Also, read the fine print. I think you need to use the dealer service and recommended service intervals in order to keep the warranty going for 10 years.
The construction and design are for different use/purpose and the Vehicles they are mounted on are very different (Escape is 1000 lbs lighter, wider track, lower center of gravity). Wilderness HT's found on the Escape are designed for primarily highway use (HT = Highway Terrain) vs off road, mixed use of the AT tire (AT = All Terrain) on Explorer. No new Firestone tire should have the defects found on the recalled tires.
The tires are designed for highway use and are not meant for great off road or heavy snow/ice traction. The best reason for replacing the tires is wanting better traction, not because of recall.
As for "dinky" wheels on CR-V, Honda has built their entire business on producing vehicles that, on the surface, seem underwhelming. But their products are based on sound engineering & designs, proper R & D, and just basically giving consumers what they need. "Dinky" or otherwise, if it works, that's all that matters. Can Ford say that about most of their products? Actually, speaking of "dinky" and "gimpy motors", I wonder what Ford thinks of their own Focus?
R is for Run-about
*
V is for Vehicle
I don't think Honda ever intended the CR-V to be a Rubicon Roughrider, but I've heard the 2002 CR-V will probably have 16 inch wheels.
I was actually just trying to satirize this topic, which seems to be on the decline. Honda is great; I wanted an Odyssey but got the Tribute because the mini van aesthetic was unacceptable to my SO.
What I'd like to see here is more discussion of the real problems that are cropping up with these vehicles, because figuring out problems and solutions is kind of fun.
Although it is not the size tire that is currently being used on the Escape/Tribute, it's not that reassuring, particularly since there's now another consumer's group saying that *all* of Firestone's SUV/truck tires use the same *basic*, inherent tread design and construction techniques as the tires that have failed by treads separating and caused injuries and/or deaths.
I know I'd be a lot happier with something other than Firestones on my Tribute.
Source: http://mirror.bridgestone-firestone.com/homeimgs/000912b_c.htm
Now onto more Escape stuff...
Ford sells a ton of cars but that is due to marketing, strong brand loyality, many dealers, etc. It is not based just on the actual Quality of a product. There are many products that have very high quality but fail because of poor marketing/distribution. And there are many poor quality products that survive only because of strong marketing/distribution.
So when someone was critical of the Focus for some of its shortcomings firing back with "the Focus is the best selling compact car in the world" really does not address the fact that someone posted a concern about the car. It just means they sold a lot of Focus cars, it says little about their quality or how good/bad a car may be.
I know that the rib and escape share some if not all of the same parts but as far as I am concerned I have a Mazda.
When checking out the Mazda Tribute, I went to http://nhtsa.gov/ (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.)
They give ALL the details on the Tribute recall issues and any other vehicle on the market. What an eye opener for me. Of course when I asked the dealer about the recall issues, they said that they "didn't know anything about them", ay right. Guess the Mazda finance manager at the dealership was right when she told me that "She would never buy a new issue model that has not been tested". Makes me wonder what the dealerships Aren't telling us? I am SO glad that I waited before buying the Tribute.
My local Toyota dealer is expecting the new Highlander in within the next 2 weeks. I can hardly wait and hope that they have done all the pre-testing to avoid recall issues like the Mazda Tribute.
For gas mileage - when I first got my Trib a few months ago, the gas mileage sucked. The first long distance trip I took to a friends place an hour an half away took half a tank EACH way. Over Christmas I visited again, and it took less than a quarter tank each way. I'm not one of those who track mileage, but this seems pretty close to what I expected when I bought the truck. I now have about 3,000 miles and have been told that it will keep improving to about 5,000 miles.
For recalls - take a look at the recalls on the NHTSA site. Most are more line stopages rather then recalls - they affected only a few hundred vehicles in most cases, or at most a couple of thousand. The only significant recall I'm aware of is for wipers. Wipers are important and the recall should not have happened, but its not like there were six recalls which affected the entire Tribute fleet. Keep it in perspective.
For the fuel smell - luckily not a problem for me, but on the Yahoo Tribute site, BOBMAZDA has posted a fix which appears to be quick and easy. I'm not sure if it has filtered through all dealerships, so if it is a problem for you, take a look, print it out and take it with you.
I have a Trib and I am very happy. Not saying it is the best vehicle made and not saying its for everyone. Just make sure you know the facts and aren't buying based on public opinion - either good or bad.
Sure Escapes are selling like hot cakes (and no doubt will continue to sell well). But as has already been pointed out, that doesn't make the Escape the best SUV any more than the Big Mac is the best burger for the money. Marketing and a large distribution network mean far more than product quality in America. There are plenty of people out there willing to settle for mediocrity....and therefore, that's exactly what they get.
-Frank P.
Ross
The comparison of Macdonalds and Ford is ludicrous, as I know of no one who puts the same decision making process in purchasing a $3.00 hamburger to a $10,000 to $45,000 automotive purchase.
Thanks!
As far as bad weather driving is concerned. I live in Michigan and the weather has not been very good here lately. The Escape does very well on the snow and ice. Almost gives me an overconfident feeling like that person that goes buzzing by on the highway then ten minutes later I pass them in the ditch waving for me to stop and help. I have switched from the AUTO mode to the ON mode of 4x4 and I can notice the extra pull around corners the ON mode gives. Make sure you read the owners manual as it basically says only to use the ON mode when snow or ice are on the road. It says never to use it on pavement as transaxle damage could occur. Also I don't know how true it is, but it sure sounds like a common sense thing to me, but the dealer told me when I picked up the car not to switch the AUTO to ON unless the car and tranny was all warmed up to operating temperature. That might also be in the owners manual but don't remember and it just sticks in my mind that the dealer told me that. Cold weather starts are fine. I can't help but get that foreign car feeling when you turn the ignition because the engine just turns so easy. Makes that quick and light CHOO CHOO CHOO CHOO noise rather than the heavy SHOO SHOO SHOO SHOO noise my F-150 gives when the started is engaged. It warms up really quick also. In comparison to our 96 Pont. Grand Am and F-150 it is warm in probably half the time. Seems I could almost start it and then sit and watch the needle rise when warming. I went on a two hour trip at zero temp and interior stayed warm when about 3/4 way up to full on temp and on #2 of 4 on the fan level. #2 level is quiet and temp always stayed comfortable. By the way I love the car drive and the truck (just plow over a snow bank) feeling.
Just hit the whopping 600 mile mark driving on all snowy and icy roads. Two thumbs up for the Escape. As I said before I will let you know if get any problems (cricket chirp, cricket chirp) no problems to report for today. Time will tell. Happy driving and ENJOY!!!!!
Ludicrous? I wish! I think you'll find that comparison is far closer to reality than it should be. Sadly, there are far too many people out there who buy purely on impulse, regardless of whether it's a $3 burger or a $20k+ auto. I don't have the source handy but a large percentage of American car buyers purchase their vehicle before they leave the 1st dealer (that's why so many sales people use the hard-sell approach). I'm pretty sure that the folks who check out this and other forums are in the small minority of informed car buyers.
-Frank P.
Most people decide they need a car for whatever reason and head to the dealership. Likely the same brand they currently own will be the dealer they go see. And they leave with a car that they likely cannot afford and will soon be in the position where they owe far more than their car is worth because they trade in every 2 years and keep the same payments.
People do buy big ticket items on impulse. Maybe not quite like a hamburger but believe me when I say marketing people know this. The auto companies bank on this.
-Frank P.
And, if that makes you sad enough, then just take a moment to imagine the wondrous smell of fuel that'll fill your cabin and burn your olfactory glands so badly, you don't realize your being poisoned.
I think the lemmings comment posted earlier this week is so accurate and so appropriate when it comes to the Excuse/Tribute.
If you were to buy a house and upon inspection, you were told that three were 5 majors things wrong with that house and 4 other things that weren't so good... Would you still buy the house?
As Ford said at the LA Auto Show "Clearly quality has been an issue with our new vehicles of late. We are trying to get that cleared up."
In the paper today a large Ford dealer is advertising XLS 4WD V6 Escapes for 18,999! I knew the prices would fall it was only a matter of time. Competition is going to get even hotter and I feel prices will fall even more on the Escape/Tribute. The new Jeep Liberty, New Saturn SUv, New Suzuki Z-7 will be on the market very soon.
Obviously someone is screwing up someplace.
The fewer people who buy an Escape the better -- that way I'll get mine sooner.
It's a freakin' car. A $24K car at that. Get a life.
The fact is, a happy Tribscape owner and an unhappy Tribscape owner count exactly the same - one piece of anecdotal evidence. Period. The only difference is that the unhappy ones are more likely to make their voices heard. Most people who do auto research on the Internet learn this very quickly. The rest, I suppose, are out looking for Corollas.
As for Yasmine, bless her, I never said which badge she wore.
I pick up my new Hyundai Sante Fe tomorrow. I found the one I wanted and guess what, I didn't have to wait 10 weeks. So here is the challenge mccain, I will promise to post any and all problems I have with my new auto. IF you will do the same whenever you get your Escape (next Summer sometime maybe).
Maybe we will both be blessed and neither of us will have problems.