Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
I know you might have explained this earlier so sorry if you have to repeat yourself.
i won't say i "love" the car, because even though i'm really into automobiles, i don't "love" any of them. well, maybe a bimmer...
but this car is the best i've had, and i really like it. i washed it this weekend and when i caught a glimpse of it walkig back inside i got a little chill.
so not all jettas are bad, just the ones everyone hears about.
I knew that I had a problem at 3k with a dry dipstick. The dealership suggested that I contact VWOA and request help to trade in my new car and get me into a different new one. I was told at 10k that $2000 would have done it. VWOA ignored my request.
The dealership and VWOA told me that 1 quart every 1,500 miles was normal and that it would go away at 15,000 miles when the engine breaks in. Neither is true.
All I wanted was $2000 in help to get me into a different car. No help was offered, so I sued them under the lemon law and they paid:
my lawyer: almost $2000
me: $3750
their lawyer: ?
Under the PA lemon law....they had to pay my legal fee's win or loose!
Wanna laugh....go see www.lemonlaw.com
What color do you think the VW is on the webpage!
Part of the agreement was that if the car did burn oil, they had to fix it. I proved to them that it did burn oil....21 quarts / 42,000 miles....so they put new rings in also! Again, $2000 could have fixed this whole thing at 10k.
It took 18 months to sue....but I won, I think?
Good luck guys! I got mine....go get yours!
Yup YupOldBull
Gosh...maybe you should scoll up to #1653 and then you would see, that I was just answering the question from mr. shiftright. Or don't you understand that either?
Yup
based on your post, you want reliability and a smooth shifter. and you think the Civic is beautiful.
again, keep it, or get a four door Civic or Accord. you can get the Accord EX in a 5 speed with a four cylinder. Not a bad four at all either.
Second, MSEALS, what about a WRX wagon?, they are pretty close in price, 4 doors, and reliable so far.
My service manager also heard it, and VW told him that they are getting complaints about it, but that Monsoon says that that is how they adjusted the amp. for the Jetta.
Apparently they screwed up, and VW says they're looking into a way they can solve the problem.
If anyone else has this problem, complain to VW on their web site, or at your dealer. The more complaints they get, the faster they'll find a solution
At what point does VW say, "yep, thats to much"?
That's the problem....offically, and listed in the warranty info., it is 1 quart per 2000 miles.
That is the problem, in that, they write the spec's in their favor. Big deal....lots of lattitude!
My contention is that if you have one of the Jetta's with known bad rings,(like I had), they should replace them. Ever hear of a recall? Or of a silent MFG. recall? But they are in business like everyone else.....profit driven! They will bump and stall you, like they did with me! What a dance!
If you don't have a Jetta with bad rings....in my estimation, you don't have a beef, and shouldn't have severe oil consumption.
Yup YupOldBull
Mark
anyway, all i was saying was if you dig your Civic as much as you indicate in your post, a Jetta is not going to be your cup of tea. HELLO, I own one, so I am not dissing the Jetta. I love mine. But, I find that most people that like their Hondas, are dissappointed with VW's. They get kind of freaked out if the VW needs some service. Not to mention, if you love the way the Civic looks, and it is reliable, and cheap, why take a chance on the VW? The Civic and Jetta are complete opposites. Just keep that in mind. And the Jetta is not even close to the BMW. That said, my recommendation would be to get the VW over the BMW anyway.
kirstie_h
Roving Host
Edmunds.com
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Need help navigating? kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
Share your vehicle reviews
I am also considering a new Jetta and was interested in your comments to Mark regarding Hondas v. VWs. I too have a Honda (1993 Accord LX w/ 192,000 miles) that I love. I am not one for upkeep, so other than an occasional, and I do mean occasional, oil change, I have done nothing in terms of maintenance. With almost 200K miles, it has had its share of repairs, but nothing you wouldn't expect with that kind of wear and tear. Although I am considering a new Accord, I am ready for a change and love the look of the new Jettas. With that said, I was curious about your comment that Honda owners would freak if the VW needs to go in the shop. What is your experience in terms of reliability with the Jetta? And why do you feel that Honda owners would not be happy with a VW? Any advice would be appreciated by you or others. Thanks.
i was reading all the posting here about jetta for almost a year,i have read all the good things and all the bad things about jetta,talked to the people who are driving jetta and after all my research i bought a 2002 Jetta GLS 1.8 Trurbo with leather seats and i had 3 different models of honda before getting this jetta and i never had any problem with any of them.for those of you who are driving honda,i have a advice for you,STICK TO YOUR CARS,because jetta is not your cup of tea.one who always has driven honda or toyota can never be happy with jetta because he/she will be driving that car just the way he/she was driving honda, and thats a problem.
i am a pressman and i have worked with different printing machines,i had spend almost 8 years working on japanese printing machines until i got a job in a company which have only german printing machines,i was pulling my hair when i begin to work on my german machine, nothing was easy,every move seemed to me making no sense,my machine is state of the art fully computerized and my company spend almost twice the amount(which is in millions of dollars)to get it as compare to a same kind of a jananese press and one day i found a german pressman who helped me to understand my machine,First lesson was ,"forget whatever you know about japanese presses", take the manual and read it,if you learn something new, write it down and remember it, keep you eyes and ears open for any new noise and it needs more maintenance than any other japanese press,follow the manual thats your bible,there are few things which have different specfication than the japanese presses,remember it and yes...keep an eyes on the level of oil (which i never did on japanese presses),grease the machine properly and use the grease recommanded for the machine........and so on....after that my press started moving with me, my production is twice as compare to the other guys running the same machine in morning shift,when they can't print any job during their shift,i print that in my shift, the only difference between me and other guys is that i tried to understand my machine....and i love my machine,its my bread & butter....same way all those who know their jetta, they love that car because they know it and they have less problems than other ,i never checked my honda's oil but i have jetta for almost 2 months now and i am developing a habbit to check the oil every time i fill up my gas tank.
for those who say that bmw has less problem, they should check the reality,bmw has problems,bmw has lemons too but its the company's policy that they keep every thing under wrap nicely.
as far as the comparison of performance with honda accord & jetta,my opinion is that honda is seriously under power, it has lack of torque but than you get better mileage on gas while jetta has excellant balance of power but its expensive in gas consumption and it need premium gas too.but i like the handling and performance of my jetta and i can spend few extra dollars on gas.
as far as maintence i can compare,honda is not cheap when it comes to maintenance,i am in toronto canada and i have paid $450.00 for 24/48 month service for my accord 1998and also it needs to change the tramsmition oil and break oil change for every 2 years and it need service after every 4 months as compare to jetta which has longer service period of 6 month/8000kms.so i think jetta and honda accord has same price when it comes to maintence and one more thing,price for break service is expence for honda accord as it has only front disc only that price is almost same as break service for 4 disc breaks but on the other hand jetta needs more break service because of the powerful engine it has.
at the end i want to mention that i didn't want to insult anyone who is driving honda or is in love with his/her honda, i used to be in love with my honda too but again i used to go to kinder garden too.
Now, I have also had a 99 Gen IV Jetta GLS VR6, and now I have a 2002 Jetta GLS Turbo. Both were automatics, leather, sunroof. I have had the opposite luck with cars. My Hondas were troublesome, and my VW's have been the only cars I have owned that HAVE NOT given me any real problems. My 99 Jetta had a "silent" recall on the tires and something to do with the headliner. Other than that and a burned out tail light bulb replaced under warranty, the car was perfect for 20k miles of DC driving. I half expected my 2002 to be be worse, since everyone thinks that Jettas are so bad, and thought my maybe my luck would run out. But, the 2002 is great too. It developed some rattles about a month in - the dealer fixed them pronto. No other problems.
My advice is, if reliablity is your NUMBER ONE priority, skip the Jetta. Even if the Jetta is perfect, you will constantly be waiting for it to mess up. Meaning, if reliablity issues are the issues that you lose sleep over, and you already have doubts about the Jetta in that department, why put yourself through the mental anguish? On the other hand, if you are like me, and you buy the best car you can afford, at the time, that makes you feel good because of performance, safety, and style, then get the Jetta. The Jetta is a different car than any Honda. And I can't really tell you why.....it is weird. The way they are smooth, yet "punchy", the way the interior lights up at night is STILL intoxicating to me sometimes, and just the way the car moves down the road. Solid. The way the seats fit me perfect, even though they aren't power seats. And all 8 airbags, standard ABS, traction control, etc that comes standard. I just feel great driving VW's. Hopefully you will too.
trips to a dealership. Bwlow is my story. I hope
the information can be useful to those of you
who are annoyed by rattles.
I brought my car (2002 Jetta 1.8T) to the dealership in
Hicksville, NY for the first 6 month
service and asked them also to fix my car's
rattles. They promised me to fix the rattles.
but when I picked up my car in the evening, I found the rattle
at the driver's door was still there.
The next day I complained to the service department,the receptionist told me to bring back the car the next Monday on 3/4 and said that they would give me a loaner on that day. So I brought back the car on 3/4 the morning. A
technician (Tom) rode with me,
and he immediately told me that he know where the
rattle was. He then applied silicon spray
to inside/outside the weather strip around
the door. Then we drove again and could not hear
any rattle anymore! The whole thing took only
about 15 minutes so I do not need to take a
loaner (a Cavalier, who wants to drive it???)
any more, And I happily drove back my car without
the torture of rattles!
BTW, previously I've tried to use WD-40 and
Gumme Phlege to rid out of the rattles, but they did not work in my case. It is Silicon Spray that worked!
driver should "STICK TO YOUR CARS". It's at least
not true in my case. I bought a 2000 Honda Accord EX new, but wanted to sell it within a month. Why?
- Its seat was uncomfortable to me, it could not
be adjusted upright enough.
- It's too slow (Anyone can remind me
what VTEC stands for? (vanishing torque...?)
- It's too boring.
- The fuel economy was far worse than advertised
(often I got only 15 mpg in city driving).
I eventually sold the Accord within one year
of ownership, and bought a 2002 Jetta 1.8T manual. The Jetta is exactly the opposite
of the Honda that has the above mentioned
shortcomings. I love my Jetta. The car is problem-free so far (6 month old) except some rattles.
But now the rattles have been fixed under
warranty.
My 2 cents.
I thank you all for you opinions and experiences. The truth is, I am a car guy, I have been since I was a little kid, I am now going to be 30 this month. I drove my first stick at 12 and haven't looked back. I love my Civic for what it is, an economical and actually pretty fast. The factory rating of 0-60 is 7.2 sec. while I still average 31 MPG. Yes, that comes with no torque, but oddly enough, the speedometer just rises without the feeling of being thrown in your seat. The biggest complaint I have had is the tires, they plain sucked. I replaced them with some Yokohama's and then I noticed that the brake rotors are starting to warp. This is very common with Civic's from what I hear. I am planning on replacing them with aftermarket rotors and pads in the spring. Oh yeah, and the car rattles in the winter until it warms up in the cabin. So yes, all cars have problems, and if you go to the Civic Problem forum you will hear tons of them. But, that is a poor view of a cars reliablity isn't it? I mean, aren't the problem forums to point out problems of cars and find resolutions. That means either someone should be posting a problem, or a solution to a problem. That is why I ask people how they like there car, not what problems have you had. This is my first Honda, and I have been happy with the purchase. It seems to have kept its resale value while not costing me an arm and a leg to maintain or drive for that matter. Insurance is about $60 more every six months than a jetta, I pay $724 every 6 months. The truth is I wanted a jetta back in 2000, but I didn't think I could afford it and it had just come out. I have always been leary of first year cars, even though I leased a 99 Grand Cherokee, boy was I lucky on that one. But hey, that is a perfect example. That truck was suppose to be horrible, problems up the wazzu, but I never had a single one. I did replace 2 tires and had a healthy break job to turn all 4 rotors and new pads which cost me about $260, but that was at around 60k miles, it was my ex-wifes fault. So were the two bald tires up front, apparently she has never heard of rotating tires. Anyway, the Grand Cherokee was flawless while I had it and that was suppose to be a 3 year lease, I ended up turning it early when I got divorced last year. I figured since the Jetta is in its 3rd or 4th year of production that most of the kinks should have been found and fixed. Like I said, little things don't bother me, especially if they are still under that 4yr/50,000 mile warranty. Oh, yeah, I also had to get a wheel bearing fixed on my Civic, it was under warranty, but I hear they are really weak on Honda's anyway. All in all, I am going to test drive a Jetta and see what I think. I want to get the GLS 1.8t 5sp, I have to have a stick, especially since I don't see much traffic. Oh yeah, and whoever said Honda's weren't cheap on repairs or maintainance is right. They want something like $240 for the 15k mile checkup and they don't do anything but an oil change. On the 30k mile maintainance, they want $480 and they are suppose to adjust the valves if they need it and top off fluids and change the oil. Big deal, I get my oil changed very regularly and my car runs like a top. The engine redline is 8000 and my normally driving is at about 3000 so I never stress the engine. Honda makes their cars to be wound up because the torque is always at the top due to VTEC. Believe me, my car is not torqueless, it has more than enough, it is just you have to be above 5000 rpm's to see it. And at that speed, you have to skip a gear or two because you are already at the speed limit. I have shifted from 3rd to 5th getting on the freeway because I was already doing 75 in 3rd getting on the freeway. I am getting older now and I want a car that is more mature, more grown up and I think that is the Jetta. My Civic is great, but it gives off a boy racer image more than I want it to. And that is a shame because it really is a great car, especially for the money. If I can get about $13,400 for my car it will be well worth buying it two years ago when I paid $17k. KBB and Edmunds say it is worth that on a private party sale so wish me luck. This spring I plan on driving a Jetta GLS 1.8t with 5 sp.
However, when I did all of my calculating before buying the car to make sure I could afford it, I didn't consider numerous costly repairs: I have had 2 windows that simply fell while I was driving - $365 each to have repaired by the dealer. (By the way, I found out the cost of the part is only $85!!!) Anyway, the cheap cup holder broke about 2 months after I had the car, one rear seat belt got stuck (pulled tightly against the seat so that the leather is messed up now - I never even used that seat belt), the headliner recall, the fuel pump (or whatever they called it - basically I think it was the equivalent) $875, the alarm goes off on it's own if I don't start the car quickly enough, the driver side door lock doesn't lock unless you press unlock, lock, unlock, and then lock again, the cruise control won't work sometimes, the glove box hinge broke, and my most recent problem happened just a few days ago - the brake lights stopped working. yes, i checked the fuses (not that I could tell which one was for the brake lights - I had to check them all). I am not hard on my cars - I live in South Florida so it's all flat land and granted, I get stuck on I-95 a lot and it's stop-and-go (remarkably no clutch problems) but other than that there is really no added stress on the way I drive my car. This is a car that will cost you money - if you're okay with that go ahead and buy one - or an extended warranty. I took only the 2 year warranty that was offered then.
By the way - does anyone have any ideas on my brake lights? I hate to take it to the dealer again. I really just want to get rid of it - looking at the Toyota Matrix. Wish me luck.
Even though wiper controls are not the most imp't part of the car, I am VERY DISAPPOINTED that a car which has not been off the lot for even 1 week has an electrical problem which will take another week to fix.
Any suggestions on what to do? Are there VW regional reps to whom I can complain?
Thanks in advance.
thanks,
lilbigrig
The rubber around the edges is perfect and I've been told by a friend that it could be from the weak seals around the rear lights.
Wondering if anyone has had any experience with this?
Thanks, Mycal
Many people on www.vwvortex.com own one.
riley
but what if i just want to check the code, not clear it or change anything. on my dodge all i have to do is cycle the ingnition key a few times and any tripped codes will show in the odometer display or cause the check engine light to flash in a type of morse code. how bout something like that?
I have a Golf TDI, and have driven my friend's WRX. I'll tell you my impressions:
WRX:
Pro: Fast car 'nuff said.
Cons:
Sloppy shifter (even though it's a solid linkage, sloppy because of the soft rubber bushings)
Lacks the refinement of a "Japanese" car.
Like the Jetta/Golf, it's got some glove box & interior rattles.
Wasteful cupholder in the dash design.
Horrible stereo, even with the upgraded system (speakers/amp/sub). But it does come with a 6-disc in-dash CD changer.
Engine is asleep until it hits 3000 rpm, when the turbo is spooled up.
V6 gas mileage
Transmission problems (most likely attributed to driving style)
Conclusion: You buy this car only for raw speed and handling. Compared to the Jetta, it lacks the creature comforts and refinement to live with everyday. This would be my "second", weekend driving car.
Jetta 1.8T
Pros:
Smooth and powerful VW corporate 1.8T motor.
Lots of creature comforts
Very refined
Good suspension (even without a rear independent suspension)
Nice cable shifter, smooth & precise (my WRX friend loves my shifter compared to his car)
German Engineered (VW decided for higher quality materials, such as the "Soft Touch" plastic, which feels nice to touch)
Excellent aftermarket (a chip will bring the car to the 200 bhp range for about $400)
Turbo lag? What turbo lag? Makes 174 lb-ft from 2000 through 5000 rpm (thanks to a smallish turbo)
Good stock stereo system
Some Synchro problems (attributed to driving style)
Cons:
A little too much body roll ruins the confidence of the suspension tuning.
Dash rattles
Not quite the Japanese dash ergonomics
Velour seats are a LINT magnet.
Obviously not nearly as fast, nor handles as well as the WRX.
Monsoon system (optional) is mis-wired (see www.vwvortex.com for details), severly limiting its performance.
Conclusion:
Trading raw power and handling in exchange for some refinement, which makes a nicer to live with daily driver.
lilbigrig
Before the days of OBDII (about 1994-1996), you can easily check the codes yourself with no special tools.
Because of the emissions requirements, we have OBDII, which requires a special scanner. It allows us to read and reset the OBDII computer.
The New Beetle has this suspension as standard equipment.
thanks for the reply, guess i'll have to bite the bullet and take her to a tech.
The WRX is a blast, 0-60mph around 5.6 seconds! Living in Wisconsin, there have been many a day when I wish I had the four wheel drive of a Subaru when needed, and also the fun-ablility of a turbo with that speed for that price.
After test driving a WRX, climbing back into my jetta, I noticed how sloppy the handling on the jetta was, comparatively. Read the article in one of the popular car magazines in which they test the WRX against an Audi S4 and a BMW. Both are around $15,000 more, but rank lower on many tests.
Get the WRX, and keep me posted on how much you love it. I will envy you. JB
I wonder whether anyone has a similar problem before and any suggestion is highly appreciated. Thanks!