Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Mercedes SL55
Mercedes CL600
Mercedes E55
Ferrari 360 Modena
Aston-Martin Vanquish
Audi RS6
Porsche 911 C4S Cabriolet
oh well...it was fun to imagine.
M
In the September issue of Road & Track's review of the Maybach to which you refer, there is also a boxed tidbit on the potential Mercedes Benz customer.
It said the typical Mercedes Benz buyer had an annual income of two to three times the purchase price of the car or $250,000 and for the Maybach an annual income of $1 million or more.
According to the IRS, Over 144,000 returns for 1997 showed adjusted gross incomes over $1 Million, so there is a “huge” market for the limited production Maybach.
On top of not being able to afford a Maybach unless I was intent on mid-term financial suicide, my objection to cars like the Maybach and Rolls is that they're too damn big to be fun to drive around, and unless you are *truly* rich you'll be close to a nervous break-down whenever you drive in city traffic. I know that also bugged me when I owned the XJR, the constant paranoia about something happening to it (which is inevitable) - the new car has been a very liberating experience in that respect given Bay Area traffic and lack of civility. I can't even begin to comprehend how I'd feel if I was sitting within $350k of bills on wheels...
bwia,
I'm sure there is a pretty good size market for the car. They sold 13 in the U.S. in June, I wonder what July's sales total was? I'd be curious to know what other cars are in a Maybach onwer's garage.
M
Whatever the number of Bentleys and Rolls Royces sold annually is, don't expect Maybach's entry into the market to expand the market by all that much. Maybe the market grows to between 1.2x and 2x what it was.
I saw the car in person at the auto show plus I saw that one car going into the Lincoln tunnel. Its' styling is not up to snuff with its other immense attributes but it's certainly a good looking car. Like the S-class it hides its considerable bulk real well. I can't imagine you not liking the car in person.
What do you all think about the Maserati Quattroporte? Autospies.com has some very good pics of it this week.
M
According to Automotive news MB plans to build 1,500 Maybachs a year, and expects 70 to 80 percent of all Maybachs will be sold to current Mercedes-Benz owners who want more than a top-level S class.
I don't know what percentage they expect to sell in the U.S. but let's assume 50% of production or 750 cars. The latest IRS statistics show that 193,798 tax returns with adjusted gross incomes of over $1 million were filed in 2001. In California alone there were 30,843 taxpayers with incomes of over $1 million.
So, to reach their target sales level they only need to sell one Maybach per each 258 people with incomes over $1 million. I am not a sales guy but this does not appear to be an unreasonable target.
We are getting to know one another too well my friend, as I was just going to ask you what your opinion of it is. So what do you think?
By the way - I do like the Phaeton - quite a bit actually - but I still don't see it making it.
No Lexus stops tommorrow - I'm disappointed in you. I still want you behind the wheel of an LS430 and an objective opinion of it.
As to the Maserati, the design all in all is sound, with some Maserati cues (which historically have not been the prettiest Italian cars, I think), but somewhat droopy looking in the front. I think the lower part, scoops and such, of the car front let the design down, they seem kit-car-like add-ons, even though lights and grill and hood are quite nice.
The Phaeton has received terrible reviews in the German press. It's supposed to drive very ponderously and feel heavier than it is. The quality of the cabin is supposed to be awesome, however. It seems getting the first luxury sedan out of the door is always going to be an experiment at first - Audi in its time also took its time getting the feel of the A8 right.
And while the Phaeton, in my opinion, is also nice looking, a poster on the Phaeton board said it was over 5000 lbs!! Very hefty for this class.
It looks like a pair of mating spiders to me, memorialized in a wankel rotary engine rotor.
The car itself is very odd looking too - two tones paint job and all - Lincoln front end - sort of comic book like. I'd expect Jack Nicholson to step out of one as the Joker.
Note the classic Maybach Motorenbau was not exclusively into luxury cars, those were more of a side business. Ironically, Maybach himself was a high-powered diesel fan and thus loved trucks. Maybach was also the engine supplier for the feared German panzers in WW2.
ljflx,
Nope, no Lexus shopping and not by my doing, honest. I know Lex dealers treat you like royalty, but around here unless you strike them as fitting in a certain demograph when you walk through the door, they're pretty rude and snobbish, there is no way I could put up with them long enough for them allow me to drive an LS430.
Yes! Italian styling is the best. Ferrari and Alfa being at the top of the list. Europeans in general, excluding the French, make the best looking cars on the plant, imo. Between Ferrari, Mercedes, Audi, Porsche, Lamborghini, Alfa-Romeo, Maserati, Jaguar, and Bentley there is just a glut of gorgeous machines.
The VW Phaeton is a lost cause I think. I think It's a brilliant luxury cruiser, but it's wearing the wrong badge (for numerous reasons) and simply won't have the dealer setup worthy of such a car, if and when it goes on sale here. Now the Euro press has knocked the car mainly for being overweight and not sporty enough, as it weighs a good 600lbs more than A8L. But like pablo_l touched on the car has a stunning interior and should impress a few Americans enough to buy it, but it won't be anywhere near VW's sales goals. VW, per AutoWeek is saying it will go on sale in Oct. We'lll see.
The Maserati Quattroporte I'll have to see in person, but it does look at lot better in the autospies pictures than it did in those first-release shots.
M
The Audi A8 impressed the most editors, while the 745Li was at the opposite end with the S430 and XJ8 in the middle.
They're calling the S-Class "old-faithful" now....amazing how time flies.
M
However they were talking about CY02 sales, maybe things have improved.
http://www.autobild.de/suche/artikel.php?artikel_id=1986&A_SE- SS=667dbe625caa0f297a306233a544933f
it is mentioned that that VW sold 1,063 Phaetons in June 2002 in Germany alone, turning it into the best selling luxury sedan (at least that month). Mercedes was next with 786 S-class cars sold in Germany that month.
The articles on the Phaetons success or lack thereof seem to be contradictory depending on the source. The reports on its driving aren't, in Germany the V6 engine verison is seen as the best and most balanced, which makes the article -in which the usual US predilection for V8s without consideration for the rest of the package becomes obvious- somewhat formulaic...
Mercedes in particular shocked a few people by dropping the 6-cylinder S-Class from the U.S. lineup, as the old S320 made up 40 percent of S-Class sales during some years of the previous S-Class' run from 1992-1999.
I could see a lot of people choosing a car like these over a LS430, the only car that would cover their price point. Of course the Japanese car would have a power advantage, but that would be about it.
The price of having the right image is high in the U.S. market as these are seen as "premium" cars and thus no sixes or even small eights are deemed worthy. Now if you want to talk diesels, they'll be bringing them as soon as they can!
M
Didn't you know "all generalizations are false"?
Edmunds comparator is a great reference tool:
Lexus LS430 betters S430, A8 and Jag XJ:
turning circle,
cargo capacity,
gas mileage,
horsepower,
torque,
braking...
oh and about $20K over S and A8
and most importantly to folks that actually want to be able to drive these puppies EVERYday...
And my favorite, JDPower Customer Service, Quality and Reliability ratings:
far and away leadership reliability, availability, and undisputed best dealership customer service.
While Lexus strives for perfection, the rest of the pack just strives to make cars that work.
M
Go do the comparo and see if the info isn't right.
You are welcome to characteristically carry on with out any serious response.
However, when posts get light on facts, fill with inuendo and forget the 'in my humble opinion', I'll post data to clarify issues. And Edmunds is such a great source!
After all, we wouldn't want newbies and lurkers here to think anything of these cars but exactly what the facts demonstrate, right?
Secondly, the survey issue has been exhausted in here and in the News and Views section, and you're one of those people who'll believe anything that JDP says without a second thought, thats why I stated your posts are not worthy of a serious response. You think JDP is the bible and that everybody who owns a Benz is subjected to such awful conditions/cust service trying to get their junk serviced. I don't think or agree with any of that, so lets just disagree and be done with it. Oh, if you think me not responding is my character, you're wrong on that count too. I just don't respond to obvious nonsense like your posts, anymore.
M
Of course, Mercedes also lowers the price of the S430 for US market purposes.
I just find it interesting, since when it comes to their SUV offerings it seems somehow magically they arrived unanimously at the conclusion that you must offer both 6 and 8 pot configurations.
Finally, I have always find it somewhat amusing that, in a country limited to 65mph that are enforced by a highway police force with less sense of humor than the German [non-permissible content removed] (my Californian perspective speaking), somehow car consumers cry out for the models with the additional power, and the love affair with bigger displacement for its own sake continues. Must be in the genes or something... :-)
Before I get told I should give Japanese cars a chance: when I moved to the US, initially I got an Infiniti because I wanted the most troublefree ownership experience, and truly wanted the appliance-like utility that Japense brands seem to bring along, popular-wisdom-wise. Bad luck: it was the worst car I have had reliability like, its rear bumper paint job lasted less than my Fiat Uno's many years ago, and it's the only car to ever leave me stranded by a highway other than a Citroen (the latter having the good excuse it was over 10 years old and very poorly maintained). My least favorite car ever was that Infiniti - other than the fact I didn't lose much money when getting rid of it again after less than 2 years, and that the service experience was always very good (though I got to enjoy it more often than I'd like) I can't say much good about it. I replaced it with a mildly used Jag XJS convertible with a horrid reputation for reliability, and it was the most reliable car I have ever had - never had one single issue. That comes to sho how much one should be ruled by consensus when making an individual choice.
Individual experience is individual experience.
The statistics for Infiniti, which these days is right behind Lexus, are very good, far better than MB, Jag and Audi.
What you point out is that unfortunately you were one of the relatively small number of folks that have bad experiences with Infiniti.
Similarly, you were fortunately one of the relatively few that had a great experience with a Jag.
Nothing like being a double outlier. (ier not iar)
This is a very respectful and respected discussion about, well, about luxury marques. There is no room in here for petty sniping and backbiting.
There is no reason to get into any kind of a turf war. We are not here to prove a marque better or worse than another. We are here to enjoy them all.
Contribute respectfully if you wish to participate. If you want to get into a pissing contest, you are in the wrong place.
As with everything, people should buy what they enjoy. There are no bad cars anywhere near this price category, there are just different value propositions that appeal to different people. And it is wired in part of my car credo that there isn't a single car brand that is "better than" whoever else - it is all merely a function of someone buying into the value propositions the brand accentuates with their cars.
Vive la difference, as I'd say if I was French (and possibly dyslexic)...
On a side note, does anyone know if the new XJ8 will be offered in a long wheel base version?
Bryan
They still make a very good 6cyl S class, and a diesel one too, and sell them in big numbers elsewhere. MB's marketing dunces just don't see fit to offer it here. I believe such vehicles would sell
M
http://car.kak.net/modules.php?op=modload&name=news&file=- article&sid=1142
M