Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
VW Golf TDI
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Here in So. Calif. it is still rather warm and I had the air conditioner on during the test drive. So, when I look under the car and saw a small liquid puddle I thought it was water run off from the air conditioner. That is until I touched it. Upon closer examination I thought it was an oil leak because the liquid was light brown, similiar to 10-30W, not the redish color found in most gas engines cars.
I had them put the car on the rack and stood there with the mechanic as he peeled the plastic shell away from the pan. At this point, I still thought it was an oil leak coming from the oil pan. However, the mechanic told me (with a thick German accent), that the fluid was transmission fluid and it was coming from the pan; it just turns out that the pan was for the transmission fluid.
He didn't think it was serious, and thought that a seal ruptured somehow. Fair enough, it may very well be that simple but I didn't want to chance it. So I backed away from the deal.
While saddened yes, I just wanted to post this in case others find a similiar problem. I hope this was just a fluke. I really liked the car and would have had it in my garage today if it were not for this incident. Good luck.
DynoMIKE
GR
Here's the story.
A litle slow and noisy in first gear. Faster and quieter thereafter. It is remarkably silent and accelerates easily at highway speeds. The car is of very high quality, delivers about 48 mpg overall and is, well, interesting. If you want a sports car, trot over to the Corvette or Prelude dealer. A Golf TDI is an entertaining, different, and cheap ride. No smoke, no smell, just not a dragster.
Driven sensibly, it has plenty of power and you'll forget when you last put fuel in it. Don't pay more than $16,300 (East Coast). Enjoy.
To bad for VW - I can't find one. And I know better than to try and deal with a dealer with the only GL within 400 miles.
Perhaps in a year or two the Brazilian built Golfs will arrive with high quality - I pity the first victims that snap up the initial production.
On one of my on and off looks at the VW dealership lots a nice salesman popped out and "sold me a TDI Golf". I'd been researching the diesels especially the TDI and after owning three of the early beetles I was convinced it was the way to go. With the youngsters now old enuf to have their own auto it was time to get back to having my own toy. And a "toy" it is. I've even been accused of 'road rage' by the wife. Who me?
With only over 2 months of ownership and 6000 miles of driving I'm convinced the salesman did me a favor.
This 'toy' is a Y2K, indigo blue automatic. Mileage has ranged from 42mpg to 49 mpg (I think the fillup stopped too soon on the low end mpg). But with a 60/40 ratio of highway/city driving the average is 45 mpg which is the advertised highway mpg for an auto.
Well, this is VW number four and the best so far. If they keep making them this way, I may be going for number five (but MANY miles from now).
BTW, my only negative feedback was when I put my headlights on and didn't have any.......two bad bulbs. A QUICK fixit at the dealership had them on again.
Used the vw.com site to find dealers in an ever expanding ring until I found one with one in stock 70 miles from here.
Test drove it and loved it even more than the road feel of the jetta tdi I'd already tried. Told them I'd drive it home for the carorder.com price and after whining for a bit they agreed.
The over the road feel/performance is so superior to the echo and focus zx3 I had been considering it not even fair to name them in the same group (which they are not in, even when the others are fully loaded).
Now we'll see if VW really has its quality act as together as it feels when I'm all new toy rosy eyed.
Second My drivers side seat heater only worked for a couple of days when I first got it. I brought it into the dealer and they started replacing components of the seat heating system ruling out one component after another (elapsed time 2 days on the bus) then only to have the dealer tell me it was the element in the seat that was faulty. So they order the part while I continued driving the car. Finally their parts dept. calls me and tells me It's in so I made arangements with the service dept. to drop the car off for the day. They said it would be ready that day, Ya Right! A week and a half later after sending the seat away to be rebuilt by an upholstry shop I pick up my car again.(very Bitter by this point). I'm Driving away (this being a cool evening here in Canada) I try my Seat heater only to find out it still doesn't work. Rage Sets In!!!!
Any body else out there problems? Let me Know!
P.S. I drive a '90 CRX - don't be confused by my handle.
I've owned 4 Hondas and they are nice, but I'm not so stupid as to think they're the best thing since sliced bread. Now I'm enjoying a perfectly reliable VW Passat that drives much better than any Honda I've owned.
Learn to be more open-minded - it'll do you good. At least be mature enough not to run around spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt.
I feel sorry for people who have to cut other's down (or their cars) to feel better. My father's family is a VW and Chevy family, but his brother is a Honda and Ford family. I can honestly say we've both had our share of difficulties with our cars and trucks.
A final note about the troublesome-heated-seats-Golf. The way I see it the dealer should have handled that one better. Not only is this person probably disinclined to buy another VW but I doubt if they will go back to that dealer for any auto purchase. I have a VW dealer locally that is the same way, so I will drive the extra 50 miles where there are three VW dealers in close proximity and they compete to take care of their customers. I guess I would have demanded to speak to someone 'in charge' and probably I'd be driving a loaner car in the interim, on the grounds that if they didn't I would have to go elsewhere for my next auto purchase. Anyway...
Also...To my amazement the second dealer I called (just a few miles away) had a Golf GL TDI. So I went out for a test drive and I must say that I loved it! Sadly, I'm not quite ready to buy. Still saving my pennies.
In Europe, diesel is more highly (bad english) refined than in the USA to reduce emmissions. I am sure in the future the States will also have cleaner diesel.
SO please.....don't worry about not being able to get diesel for your golf, beetle or jetta. It will never be more difficult to find than it is now.
My 2 kroner,
NorwayDoug
I appreciate the insights. In my searches on the web I have stumbled across similar information. In fact, one particularly intriguing topic was "biodiesel fuel". Apparently a mixture of diesel fuel and vegetable oil.
However my questions still remain. Especially regarding current legislation. Apparently, as I understand it, the states of New York and California have already effectively banned the import and sale of diesel automobiles. It would seem they do not see the future of diesel automobiles as being so bright.
So, as I said before, my concern is that other states my follow the example. I'm hoping to find more information about this possibility.
Thanks again,
Jeff
While it appears you intentions are very good, in treating yourself to all the nice options they make, perhaps this will be a listen to you in evaluating better what you actually need in an ideal economy hatchback and what you possibly could be sold to you.
I am curious if you had a removable face plate to your aftermarket stereo, and was it removed from the car when it was parked???? Was the upgrade to the VW stereo offered NOT good enough for your listening???? Do you think that heated winter seats and the cost of them rival a good winter driving coat and an adequate heater in the vehicle??? Surely, these items have nothing to do with safely, and everything to do with excess. That does NOT sound like the theme of owning a VW TDI but rather a Lexus or something.
While your intentions to treat yourself are admirable, people who have been through a few decades of cars as well as snow would perhaps have chosen their options much more conservatively. For example, an engine block heater would seem to be a much more worthwhile option than heated seats. They prolong the life of the vehicle, get your warm faster, and are relatively easy to replace.
Hopfully you will be wiser next time around and still be able to enjoy your new vehicle.
I started looking for a new car to replace the old one. After some serious searching I decided that I would be interested in purchasing a Golf. The one decision I had to make was if to go for the gas or the diesel. So I put together a car on VW's web site. What I came up with was the GL with the TDI in bright green with beige interior and the 6-disc changer.
I started making phone calls to dealers around me and found that the only Golf within 150 miles was a green TDI with beige interior with the 6-disc changer on a dealers lot within 30 miles. I went up immediately and test drove the car.
I cannot believe that this is a diesel engine. Peppy, quiet at high revolutions, and plenty of power for the weight. At 80 mph the engine just went silent. I turned down the radio and could not hear a thing.
Needless to say I purchased the car the day I drove it. It was just too weird to find exactly what I wanted and have to drive to even look at another one. It has been a long time since I have had this much fun with a car. Fate is funny that way.
I'm glad you are enoying your car. Just be more considerate of those who are searching high and low, and still come up empty handed. We get jealous easily.
Well, I have driven the car for almost week and the only problem I have found is that the back passenger headrest will not come out of the seat back which prevents me from laying down the seat fully. Has anyone else seen this before?
Best of luck of all of you out there who are looking for a Golf TDI. Keep up the faith, you will find one and it will be good.
takeru
"Well my car got broken into very easily and I'll tell you how they did it. All they simply had to do was pop the cover off of where a key lock should have been on the front passenger door latch and open seseame."
Obviously new owners of Golfs won't be prying at their doors to see how easy it is to break into, but has anyone else heard of this complaint? Does this seem possible. The reason I am asking is that I have recently put in an order for a y2k golf. Thanks for your help!
"Well my car got broken into very easily and I'll tell you how they did it. All they simply had to do was pop the cover off of where a key lock should have been on the front passenger door latch and open seseame."
Obviously new owners of Golfs won't be prying at their doors to see how easy it is to break into, but has anyone else heard of this complaint? Does this seem possible. The reason I am asking is that I have recently put in an order for a y2k golf. Thanks for your help!
then after stumbling upon the Ted's TDI Forum decided to pursue the TDI.
At first I dreaded going to dealerships. There was rarely a Golf on the lot, and if there was it was loaded up with luxury items; salesmen were pretty uninterested when you told them what you were looking for. I was fortunate that I didn't have to buy right away...
Anyway I finally found a mellow dealership in Portland OR called ArmstrongBuickVolkswagen. They were strictly low pressure and one of the salesmen
, Kevin Posey, was a TDI enthusiast. He was very knowledgeable and very straightforward. There happened to be a silver GL TDI "in transit" and I put a deposit down. About 3 weeks later the car arrived and it is tremendous.
That's my 2 cents. I appreciate Edmunds as a good resource in the car buying process.
Thanks for your reply
Truthfully, I admire the Golf TDI and would seriously contemplate the purchase of one if I could be reassured that the stories I've read and heard (anecdotal, I know, but troubling all the same) represent only a small minority of unhappy owners. I'm worried about buying a TDI only to have reliability problems which will become all the worse due to a lack of good service and support from VW of America and local dealerships.
I love the car itself, the incredible efficiency and torque of the motor, and so forth, yet I wonder if it'd be silly to jump off the Honda bandwagon after so many years of really terrific reliability. And, I'm wondering if the reaction to my post came because people absolutely love their TDIs or because VW owners are defensive because they secretly think Honda makes a better product. To get down to brass tacks, Hondas do seem more reliable (see Consumer Reports, etc. - also see Road & Track's Used Car Classic article about the CRX: according to their data it was phenominally reliable), yet cars like the Golf and Passat TDI just seem more fun and somehow more lovable.
I'd love to hear reports from the field. I know about Fred's TDI page but I'm a little afraid to believe what I read there, intriguing as it is, because I wonder how objective such true enthusiasts can be. (But why are they enthused?, you ask. I know, I know.) At any rate, if you have good advice, I'll be listening.
also see
Road & Track's Used Car Classic article about the
CRX: according to their data it was phenominally
reliable), yet cars like the Golf and Passat TDI
just seem more fun and somehow more lovable
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I don't see HOW the Golf TDI could be more fun than my '91 CRX. That is my exact problem right now, actually: what to replace "old (fun and) faithful with as it nears 10 years and 150,000 miles.
My verdict on the Golf is that it might approach the handling of my CRX with about $2000 worth of tires and suspension mods for a base GL. (I sure as heck am NOT going to pay $23k for a GLX and then spend another $2k on suspension. For the price, and the intended market, VW really blew it on the GLX suspension. Small wonder they are going to "upgrade it in 2001!!)
I'm anxiously awaiting the arrival of the Toyota MR2 Spyder in the spring. A great handling, fun car for $21k...sign me up. On the other hand, for that money I could buy a Prelude right now. Oh, choices, choices...FWIW, my wife still wants me to buy a used 911.
Bruce.
your co-host in Smart Shopper
Back to topic:
That TDI torque is great and with a chip you can get 180 lb-ft !!! This is also at a little higher RPM (by ~500RPM). It's an awesome engine, no doubt about it.
Still, like you, I have become spoiled by Honda reliability. It's not that my (wife's) VW have been bad, but the CRX has been phenomenal: 140,000 on the original exhaust, shocks, CV joints.
Bruce
asking $20k, 2500 miles with CD player
black on black interior, sunroof and splash guards
The new Passat (same chassis as my wife's Audi A4) with a TDI engine would be a great car. As nice as my old Passat is, it is an old design.
Until such time as VWOA decides whether it will sell the TDI in the new Passat. I am limited to the GOLF, JETTA, and Beetle.
What I am most interested in hearing from GOLF/JETTA/Beetle TDI owners is how well VW did with noise and vibration. I understand that this delayed the introduction of these cars while they worked it out.
The next thing I am interested in hearing is everything about the automatic transmision. As much as I love my Passat TDI, I have found myself wishing for an automatic. I guess I am getting shifless in my middle age, but the availability of a TDI automatic is good news to me.
If anyone had told me ten years ago that I would own a diesel car, I would have told them that they were crazy. After living with one for the last three years, I do not want to be without one now!
I am concerned by the decisons of CA and NY to ban diesels. While I realize that diesels do have higher particulate emissions than gasoline vehicles they are lower in every other respect and more efficient to boot. Let's hope that national emission standards modeled after CA and NY do not become a reality.
(Cheap to operate, yes, at least if you drive an average number of miles or more.)
Thanks for all the interesting reading - which brings to mind a point; can a TDI powered Golf tow a utility trailer ~1k loaded about once a month for 40 miles at 65 mph max? I'm used to driving a small pickup but am considering a new Golf. My hauling needs are infrequent and lightweight and with a growing family I may be better off getting a Golf TDI and a small utility for the occasional dirt bike hauling or dump run.
I don't want to jeopardize the longevity or reliability of the drive train so - what do you think? Anyone ever towed anything similar with a VW TDI?
Thanks alot,
a Workingman (aka Marc) ;^)
Golf GL 24/31 mpg 2723 lb
Civic DX/LX/CX 32/37 mpg 2359 lb
Saturn SC1/SL1 28/40 mpg 2367 lb
these numbers don't prove much, because the Golf's engine is more powerful than the base Civic's and Saturn's, but check out these numbers...
Golf GL 24/31 mpg 115hp, 122 lb-ft
Nissan Altima 24/31 mpg 155hp, 156 lb-ft
Toyota Celica 26/40 mpg 140hp, 125 lb-ft
The numbers here show how the Celica has more horsepower and better fuel economy, but it is lighter than the Golf. The Altima on the other hand, is more powerful, has the same gas mileage, and is 200 lbs heavier than the Golf. This leads me to believe that there is another factor (besides weight) that causes the Golf to drink more gas. Price of the vehicle is okay with me, and if the mileage numbers were a bit better, I would get the golf in a heartbeat. But could the Golf's engine be less refined than some other engines, thereby causing it to drink more gas? Anyone, please offer insight! Thanks.
Patrick.
42/49 mpg - 5sp. 90hP, 155 Ft-Lbs torque.
34/45 mpg - auto 90hP 155 Ft-Lbs
As far as performance IMO it outperforms the 2.0 gas engine in ALL respects.
Just past 5000 miles on my 2000 Golf GL TDI ($16,000 + tax/license). No problems at all and averaged 47 mpg (while playing speed racer) with higher mpg each tankful. Zero problems / complaints.
I'm in love.
I had an awesome 89 CRX hf for 10 years and as fun and cheap as it was it is no comparison to a TDI. Checked out focus and civics before deciding - no contest once you feel the difference behind the wheel.
The TDI drives like a V6 and the fit/finish is impecable (interior and controls are Audi-like).
I look forward to any chance to get out and drive in my TDI.
www.tdiclub.com is full of combative realists that can answer any question you may have - once you get a TDI you are stuck on them forever. Sounds cultish, yes it is.
Of course, I could ask a dealer, or read the manual (which, if I buy, I will do), but this might even prove entertaining. So what do you have to say?
Have a bad thing to report, though. When driving it for the first time at night, coudn't see the speed or the engine RPM. Seems the illumination for the speedo and tach pointers isn't working. [non-permissible content removed] happens even to the best of them. As far as driving goes, our other vehicle is a Voyager. You can imagine the difference! It does take a bit for the turbo to kick in, though. But again, it's brand new. I'll keep you all posted on how it works in traffic.
By the way, dealer tells me timing belt needs changing at 92 KM (55000 Miles) and costs under $300 Canadian (about $0.50 USF). The housing is external and can even be seen without removing the shroud. Oil changes are 8000 KM (5000 mi). I always change oil at 5000 KM anyway, good habit and cheap warranty. Glow plugs are $15.00 and installation costs the same for 1 or 4. If needed ever, would not be for about 200K KM (120K mi)
To think that this is the only year they're coming from Wolfsburg is a bummer..I'm inline to get a car, but not just yet..damn
what is the difference between 1.9tdi and 2.0 gas engine ?