By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
If anyone out there would like to see pix of Vicarouza's install (#1787), raise your cursor!! Seriously, it would be great if you could post. Did you have to rework the dash's structural elements in order to get the depth, or was the depth already adequate to accept the P-907? How drastic was the install? Strictly a shop effort, or can a semi-capable DIY'er handle it?
To all: I noticed that two east coast dealers (per their web sites) are selling 2003 Corollas with premium JBL 3-in-1 ETS systems (approx. 300W). These appear to be the same type available on Sierras, Avalons, and Camrys. Looks like at least a couple of dealers out there are taking it upon themselves to offer attractive upgrades. I'll check out the So.Cal papers for similar offers. Based on the descriptions of said systems at the car makes' respective sites, the JBL sounds formidable, although I personally would still opt for aftermarket; it's more fun when you have to do the research. ;^)
The 95 has two DIN units. One Kenwood cassette/tuner and one single CD and using the factory speakers.
Having a DVD would be nice for those long trips.
The installation in the 95 was a day job. I had to get a repair manual to get the dash taken apart. This was done in 99.
The 89 was done at a stereo place. It was done in 97.
Either you fit comfortably in this car, or you don't. For those who do, this is a really good choice in this part of the marketplace. CU continues to also recommend the Civic, and prefers it by a small margin - I prefer the extra refinement and small performance edge that the Corolla has, as well as the slightly larger trunk. It's actually a classic case of the differences between Toyota and Honda in each area of the market - in almost every case, the Toyotas are a bit more refined and softer in character, and the Hondas a little more hard-edged. I've gone back and forth over the years, depending on what I was looking for most at the moment.
Anyway, CU clearly thinks the car is a big improvement over its predecessor, as do I.
anyone test them both and what are your opinions?
~alpha
What struck me and my 16 year old daughter was the difference in the interior. The dash on the S really is the first econo box without that clunky disjointed look. The Corolla's dash doesn't have a bunch of cubby holes in random places. All the compartments have a lid. The dash has unbroken lines that seem to have been designed as a unit.
I haven't received my CU yet but I'm surprised that they say the Corolla's seat is uncomfortable. My daughter's car has a knob that adjusts the bottom of the seat to provide a nice seating position for practically anyone.
According to my daughter, two factors were crucial in her choice of an S. One, every kid in school has a Honda Civic and while she loves it's looks, the interior is the most important because that is what she looks at.
The biggest area of contention is that the dead pedal, the flat area to the left where your foot rests, is too close to the seat. And some body types consider the pedals too close or the steering wheel too far away.
I'm 6' with a 32" inseam, and fit fine, but anyone with longer legs, regardless of height, is going to have a problem. We love the car in every respect, but this is a limitation that CU correctly called attention to.
If I keep my '03 center dash cubby lids open all the time, I am afraid that they will get broken off accidentally somehow.
I analyzed the dead pedal today to see if a more recessed one can be mounted; if it were available aftermarket. A inch or so lower would make a big difference. The bottom portion of the dead pedal is thick but the upper portion is pretty close to minimum material left. So it looks like we are stuck with this somewhat raised dead pedal.
~alpha
Car models ranking highest in their segment are:
Compact Car - Toyota Corolla and Toyota Prius (tie)
Entry Midsize Car - Chevrolet Malibu
Premium Midsize Car - Buick Century
Full-Size Car - Buick LeSabre
Entry Luxury Car - Ford Thunderbird
Mid Luxury Car - Lexus GS 300/GS 430
Premium Luxury Car - Lexus LS 430
Sporty Car - Mazda Miata
Premium Sports Car - Chevrolet Corvette
Light-truck models ranking highest in their segment are:
Compact Pickup - Toyota Tacoma
Full-Size Pickup - Toyota Tundra
Entry SUV - Toyota RAV4
Midsize SUV - Toyota Highlander
Full-Size SUV - Ford Expedition
Luxury SUV - Lexus LX 470
Compact Van - Toyota Sienna
Since J.D. is financed by the auto industry, they don't publish the worst cars. Wouldn't that be interesting.
To add to Corolla's honors, Consumer Reports in it's most recent issue rates the Corolla's frequency of repair record as much better than average (it's highest award). The Corolla's nemesis, the Civic, was only average.
BTW my entire unit was installed by a really good installer I've known here (at Circuit City). The Navigation DVD unit was neatly and discreetly mounted under the rear parcel shelf between the 2 rear speakers. The "brains" of the P-907 in-dash monitor is mounted under the driver's seat and the Navigation speaker and satellite antenna is attached to the left hand corner of the dashboard just below the edge of the windshield
rattle as well. :-( It started at 200 miles
on the odometer. It's seems to be coming
from up near the windshield. Mostly on
the drivers side but there is a slight creak
on the passenger side also. I think I'm just
going to take it in when I get my oil changed
in a couple of weeks. Please let us know if they
were able to fix your rattle. I'm a little concerned about them having to mess with the dash.
It almost sounds like it could be that plastic
weatherguard at the top of the hood, but it
seems to be in tight when i press on it. It's
a shame cause everything else about the car
is great, but rattles are really annoying.
vicarousa: Your best bet is to try one of
the sites that the moderator suggests
over in the Edmunds town hall, corolla
owners club..they suggest the following:
"You cannot upload photos directly from your computer into a message within a discussion. Your photo must reside elsewhere. Some have used free photo hosting sites (www.imagestation, www.fototime.com, www.clubphoto.com) to load their photos into a private folder and then post them within a message."
If your Internet provider gives you web space,
you could also put up a page there. If you
are still unsure how to proceed, let me know. :-)
it didn't have any effect.
I have seen a number of references to this
problem on different websites (Carpoint,
Edmunds, etc) but I never saw any follow-up
posts about how Toyota dealers responded,
whether the problem was corrected.
If any of the readers of this board
have had dashboard rattle defects
corrected, please post and let us know.
Thanks !
My wife and I drove home with a 2003 Corolla last week. As soon as I drove it off the lot, I started getting the same sort or rattles that 'corollarocks' and 'bxkid' describe (no rattles on the test drive, but started as soon as I left the dealership). I let it go for a day, thinking it would go away, but it got worse.
So I made an appointment to get it into the Service Center at the dealership where we got it. Halfway through the day working on it, the mechanic called and said they would have to keep it a few more days (had this car a week, 350 miles on it), so they were going to give me a loaner. Apparently they couldn't find the problem.
A few hours later I got a message from him and he said it was fixed. I asked him what the problem was and he said that they replaced the crash panel insulation. Had it back a week now and not one little creek or tick.
Hope this helps. Good Luck!
(complaints per hundred vehicles)
2002 2001
Toyota 107 115
Honda 113 133
GM 130 146
DaimlerChrysler 141 154
Ford 143 162
Volkswagen 152 159
Nissan 152 145
Kia 212 267
Since JD Powers in paid by the auto industry, they don't publish the bottom dwellers. But you get an idea of the bottom by Kia that was cited for the most improved.
This is initial quality. Consumer Reports frequency of repair record is long term reliability. There Toyota really shines compared with the competition.
I was VERY satisfied with my car till
the rattle struck. :-) I'm gonna give
the dealer a call on Monday then.
I wonder if Toyota has a database that
the dealers can access with problems/solutions
to these kinds of initial defects.
Ours was built at NUMMI in early March, and has had no such noises develop; we are at 2300 miles and 10 weeks. I did notice that the foam that sits between the dashboard assembly and the firewall looks a bit irregular as you follow it around the base of the windshield, so it is possible they are having problems on the assembly line getting it installed right. We have no extraneous noises associated with this, but it would not surprise me to learn it could be a source of some of the noises being described on this board.
If I'm planning on driving a new car for the next 10 years or to 200,000 miles, which is better: the Civic or the Corolla? I've heard that the Civic will give you fewer engine problems in the long-run. But then, the Corolla does seem to be a bit better in terms of build quality. Any thoughts on this?
Dan
That said, my dad had a 94 (or 93..same difference) Corolla that required MAJOR transmission work (it was the POS 3sp/1.6L powertrain) at 61K, just after warranty expriration. But because it was so close to milage and before 5 years, and the car was maintained well, and we are loyal customers, Toyota footed something like the 35% of the bill. Good customer relations, I thought. Kept my parents loyal...anyways...
So long term longevity for either... based on our experience... is really a 50/50 type of deal.
I think the Corolla is a better car right now, and it has a better basic warranty, so thats the one I'd go for, but thats my opinion.
~alpha
Have you seen the Letter from the Town Hall Manager on the Town Hall Welcome page? If not, you might want to follow that link to have a look.
And hang on to your seats. Change is never easy - for any of us - but resolving the Search problems we've had will be worth the pain.
Pat
Sedans Host
Not being argumentative - I've already voted with my checkbook. And there are a lot of other things to go wrong over a 200k mile lifespan that I still maintain would make the choice a real crapshoot. Too many variables to answer the question on the table - suffice to say these are both cars that will minimize the cost of ownership over the long haul.
I've always been a Civic fan, but think Honda made the new Civic too evolutionary, while Toyota did a decent job with the 2003 Corolla. Will be interesting to see what Honda does, besides incentives to keep their compact car sales crown. Maybe the Civic 5-door will finally land up here.
Yes, I agree, it is impossible to know if the decision is the right one. So many things can go wrong before 200 k. According to Edmunds the Honda Civic is one of the least expensive cars to own in the long run and there must be a reason so many people buy them. It's just not the right car for me!
~alpha
Does anyone know when the Corolla will be crash tested? We are chosing between a civic or corolla and the civic has excellent scores while the corolla scores are from the 02 model. Thanks...
HOWEVER - it is difficult to believe this car won't significantly surpass the previous-gen Corolla. The chassis is significantly stiffer, and was made using computer-generated design parameters that are designed to insure that all of Toyota's new cars get the highest rating. I can say that I personally had no worries at all in this regard when choosing the new Corolla over the Civic.
Sure those arent exactly real-world ways of getting a 0-60 time (for that look to Car and Driver's "Street Start" 5-60 acceleration test). But if you have a stick Corolla and can't break 10 seconds, I'd say that 1) you arent very good at shifting and 2) you have a particularly slow sample. Jeez, even Consumer Reports (notorious for conservative acceleration tests that dont "brutalize the machinery") managd 9.8 seconds in their AUTOMATIC Corolla.
~alpha
All my cars come with ABS now, I told my 16 years old daughter to watch where she is going when she drives. I hope she will not have to brake hard, but if she needs to brake hard just hold the steering wheel tight and slam the brake as hard as she can and hope she will not hit anything. (Cross my fingers)
I am going to take it to dealer next week. Thanks for any suggestion!