Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see the latest vehicles!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
They were disappointed by the low performance of the base engine, and felt that despite the tall cabin, the driver's seat should have been elevated a few more inches. They couldn't get a comfortable fit -- the pedals were too close and the steering wheel too far away.
Rankings were:
1st: Protege5
2nd: Chrysler PT Cruiser
3rd: Toyota Matrix (180hp)
4th: Ford Focus ZX5
5th: Pontiac Vibe
6th: Suzuki Aerio
I was looking forward to this comparison, and wished the Vibe had done better.
Back in Feb 2002 they wrote a good review of the Vibe GT. What happened from then to now. I am thinking of writing to C&D about this oversight.
npaladin2000,
You can't really put the Subaru or VW along with them since they probably would consider it in a different class on it's own in terms of price and performance.
Glad to hear the Pont. dealer bargained a toyo.
price for the GT.
Re: C/D: just switch the 180HP Matrix for the Vibe 130 HP and you see it comes in 3rd. What is amazing to me is the the Cruiser was 2nd? Come now.
These days, they don't outright say, but I don't think they test these cars for longer than just a few days.....each driver only gets but a precious few miles in each vehicle. I'd bet each driver doesn't put more than maybe 1000 miles on each car, if even that....no way to gain an unbiased opinion of a car in that short of a time.
In a case as such, they will vote for a pretty face or for reputation.
zircon : Our old Cavalier used to use the A/C with the defrost also. Apparently it works better that way and many cars work that way. Didn't use it much as our cars are garaged in the winter anyway.
Take it all with a grain of salt.
ANd that's not even touching the oft-quoted concerns about their sampling techniques as far as their reliability surveys go. But they DO have to fix their comparision choices..they compared 4 sport coupe convertibles against a Ford Thunderbird, and expected the Thunderbird to keep up? The new one I mean..this was just last month. The Thunderbird is a luxo-cruiser, not a sports car! And what about pitting the Land Rover Freelander and Jeep Liberty against the Saturn VUE, and keeping it in the same category as the CR-V and RAV4? I realize they're similarly-sized SUVs, but the first two I mentioned are more meant for off-road work, while the others are meant for on-road work. Gearing and suspensiuon differences will lead to great ride differences, and CR basically penalizes for heavy duty suspension...at least when driven on the road calling it an unsteady or stiff ride.
I still read CR, actually. I don't trust their ratings though. I read them for the same reason I read any other car review...for information only, and not for the ratings. Take the information presented (and interpret it, in the case of CR) and you'll be fine.
They should be reviewing the Vibe/Matrix soon...at least I hope so.
As far as J.D. Power and Consumer Reports go, IMO, they are too biased. I work for a company that buys the J.D. Power award annually. They look nice in the Executive Office Suites. As far as Consumer Reports goes, they gave great scores to all the Toyotas that have been prone to sludging, ie. Sienna, Camry, Solara, Avalon, Highlander, RX 300, ES300, even after Toyota announced its special policy adjustment for the issue. My advise, is ask someone you see driving the car you like, "What do you like/dislike, about your car, if you don't mind me asking?"
"according to our
factory rep, the Vibe is scheduled for a dramatic price increase
shortly...i do not know when or how much"
has anyone here heard anything along these lines?
Thanks in advance.
hud :)
If it's not selling hotcakes there..it is selling hotcakes here in CANADA due to the lack of supply.
zircon2,
How much is the Toyota Celica selling for ? Maybe it was priced relatively since they use the same engine.
I think 3 items are not standard on the Toyota Matrix XRS: Side Airbags, Block heater, Roof Racks if someone is comparing both. OOops I forgot about the side claddings .
The small town dealers all have 5 or 6 in stock. Gainesville had five yesterday morning and they are discounting $1000 !! Not exactly a repeat of the lunacy seen @ the intro of the PT would you say. The bloom is OFF that rose too. Mopar dealer in my little town (6oK pop.)has 20 PT Cruisers in stock !! Too much hype and now too much inventory.
hud :)
Are there any Matrix/Vibde owners out here that have actual experience with vehicles which they have test driven or own with their A/C's? What's your feedback on the A/C?
TIA!
A sales manager at Boch told me that the Matrix was not as popular as Toyota expected, but quess what is far exceeding their plans - the new Corolla. Inventory is very low here for that car.
I checked and found that South Eastern Toyota zone dealerships (GA, FL, AL, SC, NC) have 940 Matrix in inventory, including 140 XRS's. I got an internet quote from one of the dealers in that region for about $1500 under MSRP. It looked attractive until I chased the option list and found over $1000 worth of 'port' options they stuff the cars with - including $660 worth of fabric protector and paint sealant. (They must have a 1970's sales approach in that part of the country I guess....).
FYI
Or, this is one time when the dealer would be right if s/he said: They are all like that!
Um, is it just me, or is that kinda absurd that a car that is not cheap by any means (we're not talking Kia here), doesn't have support from the manufacturer to handle what sounds like a fairly common problem?
With regards to the stereo, I know that when I was first shopping for them all the places I looked had a 200 watt Monsoon stereo listed as part of the moons & tunes package. I don't know the difference right off, but I'll admit that the standard speakers don't exactly have the best bass response. Anyone know if anyone is developing some aftermarket speakers that could provide some lows without eating up my precious cargo space?
I really love that little storage spot under there...now if I could somehow mount my cell charger into the little pocket so that when I put the phone in there, it starts charging on it's own....hmm....