@hank39: To put it bluntly, the bottom of the door, instead of terminating above the car's rocker panel, actually reaches the bottom of the car. Take for example (and I'm just picking one car out of the fleet) the Passat. The door bottom terminates before
My CX-9 has these doors and I agree with all the benefits outlined here. I will share two drawbacks that are worth noting as well. By wrapping around, the door extends lower (below the sill height) than it would on a more traditional design where the bottom of the door would end at the sill height. Why does this matter. If you park next to a high curb or a tree well or other obstruction you might not be able to open the door. This doesn't happen often but in NYC I can't be picky about my parking spots and I've found myself having to climb out the passenger side on more than one occasion where a more traditional door would have been able to open. The other downside is that I've noticed than in rain or slushy snow conditions, the doors transmit a lot of the splashing noise up into the cabin. This might only be the case with the CX-9 where the doors really wrap around the underside of the car.
@banhugh. Not so. If the door was of a more traditional design, the door would end below the area where the white paint meets the black plastic. You would see that line and then another cut line lower down separating the black plastic on the door from bla
@duck87: Thank you for clarifying the post. I got it now. Interesting thing is that I went and looked up pics of the Kia Sorrento (which is the Santa Fe's cousin and built at the same LaGrange Kia plant) and it has doors that do NOT go all the way to th
@legacygt: yes, that can be a disadvantage, though I've only had it happen once where the curb or adjacent lawn atop the curb was particularly high. The noise thing is specific to particular seal designs that will vary from application to application, I t
@tysalpha: I think you explained why they don't have them yourself. Sedans and coups sit low enough that the curb issue is more significant. Taller SUVs and crossovers have more body-to-ground clearance to work with.
Coming late to this party, but it would be greatly appreciated if you list all vehicles with this particular feature. BTW, Consumer Reports calls it a flush or nearly-flush sill. It appears that the 2014 RAV4, CX-5, Highlander, Santa Fe, and a handful of others have this feature.
Comments
Twitter: @Edmunds_Test
Twitter: @Edmunds_Test