Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

13132343637385

Comments

  • originalbitmanoriginalbitman Member Posts: 920
    I had posted some questions regarding Autolux on the TintDude.com message board and a former tinter replied saying he had some left over Autolux if I was interested. YOu can find the post by going to http://www.angelfire.com/nd/tint/messframe.html then going to the Window Tinting Message Board and clicking on the Madico thread. Could save you having to do a complete retint.


    bit

  • hciaffahciaffa Member Posts: 454
    I communicated with you previously on this but need to clarify the pinging sound. Does your sound occur while the engine is under load such as accelerating or going up hill or even on flat level ground. If not when does the rattling sound occur? On acceleration or de-acceleration. About your post, I wish I could get my dealer to get a rep to hear the sound that our Forester makes. Thanks
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Mario,
    I can't offer any technical help, but maybe some District Svc. Op. Mgr. advice.

    I had a case a while back regarding my clutch. After being lied to by the Service Manager, I said I wanted to speak with the District Svc. Manager. He didn't even know it was his place to set up the appointment. I called SoA and told them. They said it was the dealer's responsibility but they would set it up.

    Anyway, it took a little over two months, IIRC. One guy is the DSOM for all of Northern Jersey and usually sticks to his dealer visit schedule. I called SoA reguarly to get updates on the meeting. I finally met him and it was well worth it. He rolled up his sleeves and started looking under the hood while I was pressing the clutch. I think some name-dropping may have helped too. ;-)
    I never got his direct phone number until I met him. I copied him on a couple of emails to SoA because the dealer was still being "bone-headed" on some things. After opening up the tranny twice, they finally fixed it.

    I don't buy the part where they said you can't be there. That just doesn't make sense.

    Dennis
  • nygregnygreg Member Posts: 1,936
    service station or mechanic wants the customer involved since nobody knows the problem better than the owner! With owner participation the problem will be fixed quicker.

    -Greg
  • vincer2vincer2 Member Posts: 97
    Hugo,

    When the engine decides to ping and knock it will do it under just about any condition but most predominantly under easy acceleration between 20 and 40 mph. It will also ping and knock when simply holding a steady speed around 40mph on level ground in high gear (auto trans) and the A/C turned off.

    Hopefully there will be some corrective action that I can post after I drive the car to make sure the problem has been fixed. As I previously mentioned the service people believe it's "sensor adjustment related".

    Vince
  • vincer2vincer2 Member Posts: 97
    sorry for all the posts on engine pinging but a several people have expressed interest in the resolution.

    new news is there's no news. dealer still has the car and will have it into next week because they've been unable, as of late friday, to correct the problem.

    I'm traveling all next week and will be unable to pick up the car until the weekend (5/19), if its fixed. I will have my laptop with me and will post any corrective action that the service people have taken.

    Vince
  • mav61mav61 Member Posts: 8
    Thanks for your replies and info- this is much appreciated. By the way I do believe the Forester is a good car and aside from this engine ping issue it has been fine and I really do like the car very much. However the bad taste left from my continuing bad service/cust service experiences and daily constant reminder of the engine problem are difficult to ignore or justify.

    As i said I am new here and do not know who Patti is other than gleaning that she works at SOA from reading the posts. It sounds as if she is very well respected and dedicated so I am hopeful she can shed some insight/assistance if she wants to get involved. I dont know if her involvement will be limited by the fact that I already have an open case which supposedly is being handled by a senior cust. service manager? As I said SOA has not been overly sympathetic to the problem. In fact I have a letter from SOA saying engine redesign in 1997 to increase power and fuel economy has resulted in increased engine noise which they "are confident are not indicative of damage or a defect within your engine". Unfortunately the letter discusses cold engine noises which are not at all the symptoms of my problem. This is one of many examples of the poor level of communication occurring between the dealership, their SOA tech advisors and SOA cust service....if I could only figure out a way to find out who the mysterious District tech manager is for Massachusetts so I could arrange a face to face meeting. Dennis I too got nowhere with the dealer svc manager setting this up but so far SOA has provided only limited assistance and advised a face to face is not possible. Maybe this lack of a face to face is the preference of the local district manager but if it is, that is truly an example of poor customer service. Someday soon I suppose I will get another a call to leave the car at the dealerhip on a day when I am going to be away on business and the SOA calling circle will begin again...sorry for the sarcasm but I am truly telling it like it is. Subaru really needs to do something about this "beyond the dealer" process. Never in my life have I been unable to locate and discuss resolution of an issue with the corporate individual responsible for making the decision. To shell out $25,000 for this level of support is really shameful. Maybe and hopefully this case is just an anomoly.
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    Sorry about the problems. I'll be on this immediately on Monday morning. Our Reps. in the New England area are not all technical. As they are an independent distributor there is a different process that we use to get help for our customer's up there. Frequently, we do not have their schedules and it takes some "extra" steps to get things moving. I'll make sure those steps are followed.

    Just so you know, I do not usually get directly involved in cases. I am the manager responsible for QC and Training for the Customer Dealer Services department. I will consult with the "Sr. Representative" for your team and make sure he understands what he needs to do.

    1 clarification that I need (I can't access your case from home) - are you experiencing a knock or a ping? There are different noises from "normal" cold start piston slap to a "ping" on acceleration.

    I can commit to you that I will get the best resources involved in your case. I'm sorry it has not been a good experience so far. I hope to change your opinion of us.

    Thanks for your patience,

    Patti
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    I'll check this out on Monday also. During my recent training class, I do not recall their mentioning any special type grease - but - the mind......

    I'll post Monday!

    Patti
  • mav61mav61 Member Posts: 8
    Thanks for your reply and concern. Any assistance you can offer is much appreciated. Prior post 1639 described some of my history and condition but to clarify for you, I believe what I am experiencing is referred to as ping or "octane ping" as the dealer technician who rode with me said it sounded like. It is most prevalent (sometimes severe) on a warm engine, in very warm weather, while accelerating, especially on hills or after the AT downshifts (when engine is under greater load). It is not a cold engine piston slap condition or the more pronounced engine knock. As I found out om my last dealer visit it can be replicated (to a lesser degree) at standstill by accelerating while hard braking at about 2200-2500 rpm. Over the past 9 months the technician has been unable to offer any help on what to do--after replacing the timing belt and tensioners at 2500 miles, they retorqued the knock sensor one time and on my last visit he put solvents in the engine to clean out any "carbon deposits", an action that was really bothersome to me. All this apparently after consultation with the SOA technical help center and while at the same time claiming to me that SOA believes there is really nothing wrong and it is just a vehicle "characteristic". Dealer service manager even told me that every subaru that comes through his shop has engine ping, something which I find very hard to believe. It is as if they want me to feel like I am complaining over nothing but I have had enough vehicles in my life and know just enough technically to know this is not a normal or acceptable condition--while it truly may not ultimately damage the engine as SOA claims, I cannot just take their verbal word for it-- there is no proof of that and I cant afford the risk of having to replace an engine prematurely at my expense as a result of a manufacturing defect that existed from day 1.

    Thanks again for your concern and assistance. I am appreciative of anything you can do or find out ....Mario
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Colin: no I didn't notice the damage, but that's cool that you're getting the side skirts painted at the same time. It'll lower the car visually and ought to look good.

    -juice
  • tlimatlima Member Posts: 124
    Changing oil in the Forester is really easy. Just did my first one yesterday. The only problem I had is that the drain plug was torqued to 100lbs. Any idea what the proper torque should be? I torqued to 60lbs. Vertical mount filter is really nice as it allows loading up the new filter first.

    First 2 changes were done at dealer (first free, second 16.95), so they are the ones who did this, along with the lug nuts. BTW, punching hole in filter and letting it drain is a great idea - belated thanks on this one folks.

    I put in Mobil 1 syn 5w30 - had to try it. Seems to run a bit smoother, but that may be the placebo effect the 4.50 a quart is having on my brain. We'll see.

    -Tony
  • erics6erics6 Member Posts: 684
    Mario and Vince-

    As I indicated in earlier posts, the district service rep. duplicated the noise on my Outback - mostly under moderate load at around 2000 rpm. However, he thought it was coming from the drivetrain area. He sent the datastream off to the engineers, so hopefully they'll come up with some solutions. I'm going to switch back to super unleaded and see if the noise goes away. If that works, then it's got to be an engine pinging problem, and not drivetrain related. I'll keep you posted on my experiences.

    -Eric
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    I'm getting new front struts installed next week (one is currently bad) and lately I have a bad shake in the steering wheel while braking. It usually occurs between 45 and 35.

    Could this be the bad strut or is it more likely the brake rotor? I had the rotors re-surfaced at Meineke recently.

    TIA,
    Dennis
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    Probably rotors. If the rotors are resurfaced and the pads are not smoothed down, or the pads are replaced and the rotors not turned, this is common.

    If you have new pads and they turned the rotors... hmmm, better just head back and have them take a looksee. ;-)

    -Colin
  • subearusubearu Member Posts: 3,613
    they could've over torqued the lug nuts and warped the rotor.

    -Brian
  • locke2clocke2c Member Posts: 5,038
    Good point, I'd be quite wealthy if I had a dollar every time I saw a service jockey going wild with the impact wrench. Nearly always totally ignorant or uncaring of the correct torque spec.

    -Colin
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Those guys and their air wrenches...

    Yeah, I'd have it checked. It's only going to get worse, and probably quickly.

    -juice
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Over torqued parts. Grrrrrr. That's becoming a pet peeve of mine the more I do my own maintenance.

    Recently, I learned from the dealer that the rear diffy fluid plugs need to be broken open with a tool with a 2' lever arm because they come so over torqued from the factory. Not only do you need a special tool, but your vehicle also needs to be up in the air to do that.

    Ken
  • yerrotyerrot Member Posts: 2
    See post 1627 for details, briefly clutch replaced x2 (at 3200, and 7500 mi). Still having problems with shaking and new groaning/clunking sound. Dealer suggested changing transmission oil.. I complained and they took a closer look. Turns out that at last clutch replacement the dealer didn't put the nuts on the transmission mount!!!. So that groaning and clunking was the transmission.. Nuts are on and it is driving like a different car. Anyone know what kind of added wear/tear I can expect??
    Thanks Patti for the post I will contact SOA-- I want to be sure this is documented..(although I wasn't really impressed with them the first clutch repair..)
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Thanks for the advice everyone. Time to break out my Meineke warranty (and find a different shop).
    edit: I should have expected problems from a place that didn't
    know how to remove the wheel covers. Instead of following the rotate
    this way arrow, they proceeded to remove all 30 or so of the screws holding the cover.

    Ken - That explains why I couldn't remove my rear diff plugs last weekend. I pounded and pounded the ratchet with a hammer and they didn't budge. I don't think my last dealer even inspected the rear diff oil at my 30,000 service.

    Dennis
  • hammersleyhammersley Member Posts: 684
    My tire shop guys have air wrenches that are throttled-down, and they finish with a torque wrench. My own air wrench (Sears Craftsman Nothing Special) has an adjustbale valve to control oomph. Guess I'm lucky that way... I can remember helping my cousin pull a drum on an old Studebaker... had to use a breaker bar & jump on it to break it free... now THAT was torque!

    Cheers!
    Paul
  • originalbitmanoriginalbitman Member Posts: 920
    Some shops use torque sockets set to aspecific ft/lb.

    bit
  • evilizardevilizard Member Posts: 195
    Another reason that you are having problems with those rear differentials is because they are not just "overtorqued" they are GLUED in.

    I did my own 30K maintiance on my 96 OB. Getting the rear differential plugs out was a mighty effort. Then looking at them after they were removed I found a ceramic based epoxy like substance on the threads of the screw and the case. It took me an hour and a half with a dental pick to get all this stuff off. I really doubt the dealership does such things. Of course if you dont when you put the screw back on it is introducing ceramic grit into your rear differental (some of it powders or flakes when you take it off and stick it back in). Yummy, yummy.

    Another Glue job you might want to avoid is the transmission pan. I wanted to inspect the screen (just like it called for in the manual). Undid a load of screws and discovered it was still tightly held. After much prying I got it off only to discover it had been glued on by some form of silicone based glue. Another 2 hours with a wooden scraper to get that stuff off!. Do yourself a favor and just get a reverse flush on the transmission fluid!
  • joolsjools Member Posts: 1
    Can anybody advise how to remove genuine stereo from my 94 legacy
    All trim removed but I cannot extract it from its housing
    Are there any special tools

    Thanks
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    That's what I would expect, bit. I think the thing is few take the time to adjust the torque for each job.

    Epoxy? Man, talk about a seal!

    Sorry, can't help you on radios.

    -juice
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Tom,
    Any chance the color is brown? I definately noticed something that appeared to have dripped before drying around the diff plugs.

    Maybe I'll just leave the rear diff alone and throw the gear oil that I bought into my wife's auto OB's front diff.

    Dennis
  • subaru_teamsubaru_team Member Posts: 1,676
    Hi Ken -

    And the answer is "Multemp AC-D or equivalent".

    I hope that answers your questions!
  • kenskens Member Posts: 5,869
    Hi Patti,

    Thanks for looking that up. I did some research and it looks like Multemp AC-D is a product made by a Japanese chemical company. I don't think it's something I can just buy at an auto parts store.

    I guess the more relevant question is, will regular white lithium grease harm the shifter parts?

    Ken
  • evilizardevilizard Member Posts: 195
    I seem to recall it being a redish brown, but the lighting was not really very good under my car so I can't say for sure. But if it has oozed out on the rear transaxle case chances are we are talking about the same stuff. Get a metal pick and pick at it, see if it is gritty after chipping off a bit.

    I don't know if epoxy is what it really is but thats the closest word to describe something used as a sealant that is a pain to get out...
    heck of a seal though!

    I don't remeber if the front diff uses the same stuff, I want to say it was tied up in the tranny fluid but I can't remeber. Also might have changed for the 00 and beyond. Check the manual.
  • originalbitmanoriginalbitman Member Posts: 920
    The cool thing about torque sockets is that there are different sockets for different ft/lbs and nut sizes. Each is color coded and they come in a set. Grab the one for 19mm/65ftlbs...

    bit
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    Yup - make sure you call us on this. I think the orginal work needs a look at by our claims folks.

    I'm glad it's better.

    Patti
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    I have to admit - I had the most fun using the air tools in my tech. training. They had to pry the thing out of my hands. Ohhhhh - the power!! Especially trying to break engine bolts (don't worry, they made me do it by hand).

    I felt like I was on Tool Time - I needed more power!!! ;~)

    Patti

    P. S. I have forwarded your comments to our tech. group so other power hungry dealer personnel can be reigned in like I was!
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    I'll ask around for you!

    Patti
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    FYI - We've got some of the best folks looking at your case now. I'm sure they will figure it out. If you get a chance, call us tomorrow.

    My calendar isn't too bad tomorrow, so you can ask for me.

    Thanks for hanging in there!

    Patti
  • mav61mav61 Member Posts: 8
    Hi Patti:

    Thanks so much for getting this ball rolling again...your influence was immediately obvious today! I flew out to Chicago early this morning and when I arrived there was a voice message on my cell from SOA (Chris) advising he was working on setting up a new appointment. Shortly thereafter I received a call on my cell from the dealer service manager saying the reps wanted to look at the car on the 20th. Fortunately Im in Town that day so I told then to go ahead. They still want me to drop it off with them for the day but supposedley they will drive it for an hour or so to make a determination of what is happening. Hopefully I will be able to personally discuss their findings with them but I will wait and see on that. Not sure what will come of this but I am very grateful for your dedication and help in getting this moving forward again. Busy travel day for me Tuesday but I will try to give yoyu a call if I can or perhaps later in the week....Thanks again Patti!
  • mav61mav61 Member Posts: 8
    Thanks....since my car is going in for a look by the Sube reps next monday, I will also keep you guys appraised of any findings that may be relevant....
  • helpmedecidehelpmedecide Member Posts: 1
    We bought a 95 Subaru Impreza a few months ago. Just last week during regular maintenance the mechanic suggested that we get the front and back struts changed. He said that it would cost $524 including labor. Does anybody have any idea about whether or not this price is reasonable. Any advice is appreciated. Thanks.
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    Sounds a little high. Unless they are including springs with the struts.

    -mike
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Ken: you mean you don't have any Multemp AC-D laying around in your garage? ;-)

    I'd imagine the price would be about half of what you were quoted for those struts. Shop around for those.

    -juice
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    The retail for my 97 OBS struts are $99.99 each so that sounds about right. You can get them cheaper from www.subaruparts.com and take them to the dealer for installation. I have the part no.'s for the front but I'm not sure if they're the same.

    Dennis
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Checked out my Meineke warranty last night (re: steering shaking on braking post). The rotor warranty is only 90 days and it's been 6 months. Guess I'll have the dealer take a look when I get my struts next week.

    Can rotors be turned after they've already been re-surfaced?

    That's the last time I use Meineke.
    Dennis
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I think if they've already been done and you're still getting a vibration at the pedal, it's time for new discs.

    -juice
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Oh, I had the discs replaced in November at the same time as the resurfacing. The discs carry a lifetime warranty.
    Dennis
  • paisanpaisan Member Posts: 21,181
    Are you sure you don't mean the pads? I usually refer to the disc as the rotor.

    -mike
  • bluesubiebluesubie Member Posts: 3,497
    Pads = lifetime warranty
    Brake rotor resurfacing = 90 days.
    (the earlier post was pre-coffee).

    I guess I could ask the dealer to look and tell me what they think. If it's just the pads, I'll head back to Meineke. If it's the rotors ... :(

    Dennis
  • evilizardevilizard Member Posts: 195
    It may not be just a warped rotor. Could be a warped hub. High spot caused by enthusastic air wrench. Had that happen to me. Griding out the high spot was oh so much fun.
  • vincer2vincer2 Member Posts: 97
    Talked to the shop foreman today and he thinks they may have the problem corrected.

    Adjusting the sensors (??) didn't fix the problem so they checked the knock sensor that was replaced last summer and discovered the knock sensor now has a new part number. He decided to replace it again but with the one with the new part number. After driving the car for two days he believes the problem appears to have been corrected.

    Since I'm on the west coast this week and my car is on the east coast I won't be able to "see for myself" until Saturday.

    Patti, would you have any idea what was changed in the knock sensor and if a problem was found with the previous one why weren't dealers notified of a possible problem with the previous one? Just curious because this has been a long drawn out, and at times, frustrating problem to correct.

    Thanks,
    Vince
  • lexomanlexoman Member Posts: 4
    new sooby owner. 98 forester used. Very fun car. heard many references to qsubaru and darlene. Do you know how I can reach them? thanks
  • pattim3pattim3 Member Posts: 533
    Sorry about all of the agg. I don't know about a change to the sensor off hand, but I'll check at work today and post later. I'm glad it's finally fixed.

    Patti
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.