Ford Escape Mazda Tribute Maintenance and Repair

1242527293080

Comments

  • draymond2draymond2 Member Posts: 134
    My wife has a 2002 tribute with approx 2500 miles. The noise is the one thing I noticed the most when I drove it. It is VERY LOUD on the highway. The gas mileage is around 17mpg which I thought would be a little better for that size vehicle, We had a Ford Supercrew and we avg around 16mpg. Other than those 2 items we are very pleased with the vehicle.
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    Yes D Raymond 2.

    That about sums it up for me too. I test drove a Highlander and it was smooth and very refined (of course its 10% more money).

    I'm currently looking at the VUE. Nice package. Still can't figure out how it can be longer and wider but have less cargo room, legroom and shoulder room than the Escape.
  • maltbmaltb Member Posts: 3,572
    It looks like the Triscape won an award:
    Most troubled vehicle per consumer reports readers.
  • tribute_girltribute_girl Member Posts: 4
    I have a Tribute 2002 and it is not loud at all. The seats are extremely comfortable too. I've been averaging 20-21 mpg. The only complaint I have is the gear shift, other than that this car has been running beautifully.
  • maynardf1maynardf1 Member Posts: 127
    Seems like every board I visit, there's a disagreement about whether a given vehicle is loud on the highway, around town, whatever.
    Since it's obviously a subjective judgement, wouldn't it be nice to have a little interior decibel display on the dash?
    Not holding my breath.
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    Maynardf1 - Yeah, it's getting a bit silly isn't it. Folks are starting to look for luxury car noise levels in entry level vehicles.

    I think anyone with sound concerns should just test drive the thing and make up their own mind.
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    "Yeah it's getting a bit silly isn't it. Folks are starting to look for luxury car noise levels"?

    Most people I've spoken to have agreed the Escabute is a loud car on the highway - cost cutting on the insulation I would guess.
    I rented one and put 200 Km on it this weekend.
    With me and 3 others taking a highway trip we had to elevate our voices pretty high to get over the noise. That wasn't comfortable past the first 20 minutes so then we just blared the radio at #12 volume or something. If you want to call that just above luxury car levels, then so be it but I'd hate to see what you call loud.
  • varmintvarmint Member Posts: 6,326
    Jafo - This has nothing to do with the Tribape. I was responding to Maynardf1's remarks about the trend we're seeing in these threads. There has been a huge amount of discussion lately about "how loud is too loud". People are looking for other people's opinions on the matter despite the fact that it's become pretty clear that everyone has a different level of tollerance.

    I don't mean to poke fun at anyone for their opinions, but there are CR-V owners complaining about the clicking of a solenoid that can only be heard if they listen carefully and completely shut off the radio. In fact, some can't hear it, instead they have hold their hand on the steering column and "feel" the slight vibration.

    So, yeah, I think it's getting a bit silly.
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    All the same, it was pretty funny when we test drove an Escape on the highway and the sales lady had to shout at us from the back seat and pretend it wasn't anything unusual.
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    She had to shout because the back seat is so roomy and far away! None of these things are quiet. If they were, we'd have to pay closer to or more than $30,000 for one. Go drive a Civic, Neon, or ZX2 on the highway if you want to hear a really noisy interior.
  • draymond2draymond2 Member Posts: 134
    I'm not the type of person that notices every little nuance about a vehicle, but I can say with out a doubt the Tribute is LOUD, it is very LOUD!!

    No, I don't expect it to be as quiet as a luxury car, if I did, I would have bought a Lexus.
  • draymond2draymond2 Member Posts: 134
    By the way, I drive a Protege and it isn't as nearly as loud as the Tribute..
  • tribute_girltribute_girl Member Posts: 4
    I think it all comes down to the drivers opinion and each individual built car. Some of you say that that the Escape and Tribute are loud. Well I have a Tribute and it's not loud at all. It's comparable to the Accord and Corolla I previously owned. I drive on the highway daily to work and never have any noise issues. So I don't think one can say all Tributes are loud. My brother currently has a Protege which is the most unpleasant car I have ever drive. It makes tons of funny sounds, handles horribly, etc. But I know other Protege owners who love their car. Again it comes down to owners opinion and that specific car that came off the assembly line.
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    Hi everyone,

    Well, I was driving home from work tonight on U.S. 1 - major road in Miami - and my Escape stalled while I was doing 45 mph. I managed to stay calm and drift over to the right lane - I was in the process of going over to the right when it happened and I put on the hazards and then stopped. The Escape started up right away.

    This is the second time this has happened. I have the XLT 2001 Escape - it has 6000 miles on it and I purchased it in April 2001.

    I took the Escape to the Ford dealer immediately and went into the service manager. He totally denied ever having heard of this problem in any Escape but mine (he did remember me from the last time) and told me to bring the car in Monday. He said he knows I will take this the whole way through to the lemon law in Florida - he said it like I was trying to set him up.

    This is so upsetting. I am afraid to drive my lemon and yet I need to get to work.

    Any word on the NTSB investigation. Any suggestions. Any class action lawsuit going on.

    Murphy
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    Actually I found both the CRV and the VUE rather subdued on the highway.
  • lavalleylavalley Member Posts: 2
    I have a 2002 Tribute will 2800 miles on it. The first two times it stalled I thought it was a fluke. The third time it stalled I took it to the dealer and they replaced a relay and re-programmed the computer. The fourth time it stalled I took it to the dealer and they replaced the throttle body, gasket and valves. My service rep admitted that this was a know problem and they had gotten to service updates about it from Mazda. My car stalled again this morning on my way to work, so it's back to the dealer. As my others have expressed here, I don't like the feeling of being afraid to drive my car. I'm going to start looking into the lemon law in Texas which is too bad, because except for this I love my Tribute.
  • whatnextwhatnext Member Posts: 6
    There is a sensor of some kind in the gas tank
    that shuts off the fuel pump if the fuel level
    drops. The dealers have a crib-sheet for this
    problem should it occur during customer test
    drives! Maybe this is the problem being noted
    by several unhappy owners. I regret that I did
    not save the copy I got from the newbie sales
    rep at Mazda when I was pressuring him to give
    me information about the rotary blade coupling.
    There was a particular sequence of turning the
    key on-off-on and pressing the gas or something
    like that to get the vehicle to start up again.
    If you folks were "low" on gas, maybe this is
    the source of your troubles - fuel pump cutout.
    Ford vehicles seem to have problems with fuel
    gauges that show empty when there is 4 or 5 gallons
    left. Maybe this problem is related? Try asking
    for the "test drive tip sheet".
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Since we're throwing ideas out there, I thought I'd add my theory to this board. You can tell me if you think I'm crazy because I am not by any means an expert in this area. Here's my Escape info: 2002 XLT, V6, 4WD, bought in mid-January 2002. It stalled going down a hill, 30-40 mph, wife was driving and had just let off of the gas completely in order to drift down a winding hill. The defroster and floor vents were on, and I think it stalled when she started to hit the brakes several seconds after letting off of the gas although I'm not sure. It may have stalled before she hit the brakes. Here's what I posted in another forum (escape-central.com if anyone cares). "One of the very first things I noticed while we were driving the Escape home from the dealer was the low idle speed. It seemed really low to me because of what I was used to, and after our only stall a few weeks ago, I really think it's low now. I've been trying to reproduce the stall everytime I drive, but I can't. A few things I have noticed though, 1. The RPM's only drop low (about 400-500) after I quickly let off of the gas before going into a drift, not when I slowly ease off. 2. As in all vehicles with A/C, the RPM's dip a little when the A/C compressor kicks on. 3. We had the defrosters on when we stalled and the A/C compressor cycles on and off when the defrosters are on. From this I've derived a theory for the cause of the stalling. Tell me if you think I'm crazy or if this sounds possible. While the RPM's are rapidly dropping to about 400-500 after you completely let off of the gas (downhill or on a slight grade otherwise you'd be going uphill and need to use the gas pedal, right?), if the A/C compressor kicks on at the RPM's lowest point, it could drop them enough to kill the engine. To me this doesn't seem like something that could happen on a regular basis, hence the sporadic occurances. Raising the idle RPM sounds like a good thing to me as long as they corrected the lowest RPM allowed as well." We still have not stalled again so I haven't been able to witness any of this again. Also, it seems that anything running off of the serpentine belt, not just the A/C compressor, can drop the rpm's when activated, along with moderate to hard braking. I still think it is a computer problem in most cases, but I can't even try to explain why some people have had theirs reprogrammed only to stall again whle some have been fixed by it. To those who have had the reprogram done, do you notice any differences?
  • whattobuy1whattobuy1 Member Posts: 2
    I am considering a tribute but with some of the posts about the stalling its making me rethink....is this a problem that many are having, has it really been fixed??

    what other problems should i be aware of??

    What else should I consider buying??

    thanks
  • jagpanzerjagpanzer Member Posts: 1
    My Tribute will be a year old next month, and it has 30,000 miles on it. I just found out on Friday that it needs a new engine! I had been smelling a burning oil smell for a few months, took it in 3 times and they told me it was a plastic bag melted on to the exhaust, then it was a leak, then it was nothing, then on the 4th visit, they put it on the computer and said the engine is shot! I don't know exactly what is wrong, I had someone else take the car in for me. I will find out when I take it in for the work and post it here. I have also had problems with the fan (heater/air). It was making a squeaking noise, so they replaced the squirrel cage. That was fine for awhile, now it makes horribly loud noise and they say the motor needs to be replaced. Just wondering if anyone else had had these same types of problems?
  • lescapelescape Member Posts: 3
    I have so far owned four different vehicles - a 1974 Datsun B210, 1984 Pontiac Firebird, 1992 Plymouth Colt Vista and my 2001 Ford Escape XLT. The B210 and the Colt Vista were noisy. The Firebird was fairly quiet. The Escape has wind noise that sounds like it's mostly from the outside mirrors, but I would say it's as quiet as the Firebird was. If they've changed the mirrors for 2002 that would probably help a lot for highway driving. For city or just plain stuck in traffic driving, it's quiet enough for me, as long as the sunroof is closed! The quietest car I've driven was when I had to borrow my mom's Caddy Eldorado for a couple months when I was between cars. One could get spoiled easily by that, but I have never expected any of my own cars to be as quiet as a Cadillac, or ride like one. I don't know how the Escape compares with similar SUVs, but I would say the best thing to do is to test drive them all on the highway if possible and make your own decision.
  • carseeker4carseeker4 Member Posts: 228
    I test drove the Trib and Santa Fe only moments apart and the SF was a bit quieter than the Trib... IMHO....
  • dadx4dadx4 Member Posts: 11
    Anyone else notice that the front brakes seem to leave a lot of dust on the alloy wheels? Is the reason for this the type of pads Mazda is using on the Tribute? Can this be fixed by changing the pads to a non-Mazda type with better composition? Such as NAPA or some other brand. Just wondering..
  • airbearmaairbearma Member Posts: 9
    I bought my Escape XLT Premium in mid February after checking out all the other mini SUV's. One of the strongest points causing me to make this purchase was the (supposed) reliability of the Duratec V6. I had this motor in my 96 Taurus and it ran without a fault for 175,000 miles without a hint of an oil leak and zero maintenance other than oil changes and filter replacements. I am a fanatic about changing my oil often and I used synthetic oil since day 1
    At 1400 miles, I changed the oil (Amzoil 5W-20 Synthetic) in my Escape. I also checked the antifreeze with a hydrometer and checked all fluid levels to make sure I had no problems. I was surprised that at this point I could not find any factory defects other than a missing battery terminal boot. I ran full OBD2 diagnostic scans and found all readings almost dead perfect. I thought I had bought a quality built car.
    At 2450 miles, while checking the oil and fluids, I discovered a thick oil slick in my coolant reservoir. My thoughts on quality were pretty much dashed at this point.
    I brought it into the dealer and told them that if the motor was toast, I expected a NEW and not rebuilt motor to be installed. I also requested a free power train warranty extension to 100,000 miles as this is supposed to be the mileage it should be able to run without as much as a tune up. Since literally the whole power train needs to be removed to swap the motor and there are literally 100's of sensors to be swapped, I feel the probability of having future problems are much higher than if Ford had built the car correctly at the factory. The dealer declined the warranty extension and said I would have to take my case up to Ford Customer Service. (which I intend to do) Hopefully Ford will stand behind their product and will alleviate my worries that I'm going to have a short life vehicle.

    Has anyone had the Duratec replaced in their Escape and if so, how many additional trips to the dealer did it take before they had everything running correctly. I do not feel too good about this.

    I'll let you all know how this turns out.
  • lavalleylavalley Member Posts: 2
    The dealer told me today that Mazda believes that a radio frequency is disrupting the auto theft system causing the system to turn the car off. They ordered new parts that are protected from radio frequencies. Has anyone else been told this?
  • dielectric7bbdielectric7bb Member Posts: 324
    are way too weak. This is just an excuse for poor engineering. In may be a true reason why, but the power behind radio waves is virtually zero and that would mean the electronic system was just poorly designed if it can be interfered with so badly (hence poor engineering). FYI: I have heard rumors about car manufactures testing for radio wave interference prior to production of course.
  • carseeker4carseeker4 Member Posts: 228
    .... anti cell-phone activists across the land will pass a law making all Americans possessing cell phones to own Tributes or Escapes, so as soon as they use their cell phone on the road, their engine will stall! ... on the serious side, while I was researching vehicles a month or so ago, there was a post from someone owning a Mazda B-Series pickup, who never got the stalling problem solved, even with a PCM reprogram, but it was the location of the PCM, where it was likely to overheat, that was the cause of the problem... as dielectric put it... "poor engineering"!
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    Did the dealer also mention you should wear aluminum foil on your head so that the aliens can't read your brain waves?
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    try a good wheel polish, this helps defect some of the brake dust.. Granted not all of it..
    The Escapes/Tribs braking distances are top notch and soft brake pads are the reason why....
  • mdaffronmdaffron Member Posts: 4,421
    Guys and gals, don't get all over me. I don't own a Tribute or Escape, but I'm a five-time Mazda owner (three Proteges, one Protege5 and a Mazda B2300 pickup built by Ford). I read this board every now and then because I have a buddy in the office next to me whose 2001 Tribute stalled on him a few weeks ago. I came here since I hang out a lot on the Protege board and knew how good the Town Hall is at finding answers.

    Anyway, in reading your posts about stalling for the past few weeks, I've noticed one thing they all seem to have in common -- the vehicles seem to stall when they're going downhill. If it was just a low-engine-speed occurrence, then you'd be experiencing stalls coming up to traffic lights, idling, etc. But that's not what's happening. It's happening when you're going downhill.

    This simply HAS to be a problem either in the design of the gas tank or (more probably) the fuel line from the tank to the engine. In my layman's opinion, it sounds like gravity is causing a "burp" somewhere when the vehicle is nose-down.

    Just a thought after reading all your posts! You know, my Ford-built Mazda pickup had fuel pump relay problems and problems with fuel pressure causing the truck to stall when I purchased it. I would have just driven to the end of my street in the morning -- making my first stop since turning on the ignition -- and the moment I hit the gas again, the truck would stall and I'd smell gas. I'd have to sit there and crank it for at least 15 seconds before it would finally turn over and let me go again. After taking it in a couple of times, I was finally told that there was a fix -- and they installed a new PCM. (That did fix the problem but caused others that were never resolved until I got rid of the truck -- mostly lean fuel mixtures and incessant engine pinging no matter what kind of gas I used. It's a long story.)

    Anyway, Ford seems to have a history of releasing vehicles that haven't been fully tested and then updating PCMs to take care of problems. I'd be surprised if you guys don't find out about a "PCM Upgrade" under warranty before too long.

    Meade
  • jmlagascajmlagasca Member Posts: 37
    I had irks with the fuel system right off the bat. Albeit, it wasn't to the magnitude that the Tribute would stall. My fuel gauge would take huge dives (still does occasionally) depending on the incline and the position of the car... I had this checked out by the dealer and they found that the fuel line was faulty (this February of 2001) and replaced the whole system (fuel line, pump and gas tank), I don't know whether they used different parts than the ones that my Trib came with. I've never had a stall and boy do I feel lucky right now!

    Overall, I think that Ford/Mazda's design of the fuel tank and the fuel line sucks. There have been numerous complaints resembling mine about the fuel tank as well as the fuel line. What different steps has Mazda/Ford taken to try to resolve this problem with those of you who've had the stalling? Your solution may be as simple as getting that fuel line fixed.
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    Hi all -
    After the second stalling incident - while doing 45 mph on US 1 in Miami - not going downhill - Miami is flat - I took the Escape back to the dealer armed with the knowledge from this board and my first complaint, etc. There is a Ford bulletin out on the problem; The Ford Dealer replaced PCM and re-programmed. BUT - I know this sounds like a tin foil hat alert - the service manager said the same thing posted above - that perhaps a radio frequency is interfering with the Escapes and all of the Escapes and Tributes have the potential to stall - you just have to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.
    Well, if that is the case, this will be an even bigger problem for Ford (like I care). I did check Yahoo Finance and the Escape stalling problem is already become a stock value problem.

    Anyway, will keep checking in. I have the whole service bulletin but it is rather long. Let me know if anyone wants a copy and I will try and scan it and send it to whomever.

    Still afraid to drive my car even with no hills in Miami.

    Murphy
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    is not a hill issue. I live by the Cascade range and have traversed many hills to reach skiing and fishing spots in my Escape. Never stalled on me??
  • maynardf1maynardf1 Member Posts: 127
    Scapey:
    Wouldn't it be better to determine whether hills are a factor by examining conditions when a vehicle stalled?
    I've picked up some subtle hints from you that yours has not stalled, so the terrain on which you drive is irrelevant. No?
  • rotarykidrotarykid Member Posts: 191
    the stalling issue is related to decel, and that is the reason why it happens going downhill.(most people are laying off the gas pedal when going downhill........most). in past weeks i have peformed mazdas fix for this issue by reprogramming, and in some cases, replacing pcm's. they are replaced if they meet a certain build date criteria, and then the new one that is installed must also be updated. we have had NO returns visits for stalling problems thus far from any of the customers having the update.(approx. 8-10 vehicles).
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    ...why some people here and on other boards have had either the re-program, or the PCM replaced without any luck. According to rotarykid, you man have to have both done in some cases. Rotarykid, do you happen to know off hand what the build date cutoff is? Our Escape was built on December 21, 2001. I'm told by the dealer that it just needs a PCM flash. Thanks for your help.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    What mileage are these vehicles at? Does it happen after a certain amount of miles?
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    Hi all -
    Here is the info from the Ford bulletin:
    reprogram PCM W/WDS Version B17.1 or later. Some 2001MY PCMs cannot be reprogrammed and must be replaced. this is determined by the MPC# located in the upper left corner of the bar code on the PCM. If MPC# is 160 then replace with part #1U7Z-12A650-AXA and reprogram. If the MPC# is 161 then just reprogram. All 2002MY PCMs can be reprogrammed. Disconnect the vent line in the EVAP emissions system from the check valve side. Using shop air, blow air through the vent line from the check valve forward. Check for revised EEC power relay. If relay has white lettering, replace W/F0AZ-14N089-A. Make sure relay pin connections are tight in pwer distribution box.

    Hope this helps.
    Murphy
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Thanks for the info. It will come in handy if the service depts. try to play dumb with us. Do you happen to know the ID number of the service bulletin too? Also, have you noticed any performance differences? Things like faster idle speeds, different shift patterns, gain/loss in fuel economy.

    Thanks again.
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    They were very crafty in not letting me see all of the bulletins they pulled but the one I was given is on page 3 of page 5 (when the service rep left his desk I scanned the five pages but did not have time to aborb the information. On the one given to me, the title is 15589 Escape 3.0L -Reprogrammer/Replace Drivability Checklist: some 2001/2002 3.0L Escapes may exhibit an intermittent engine quit condition, usually one time during closed throttle decel with no DTC's or MIL. The engine restarts immediately. . . .
    The bulletin then continues with what I wrote approve re the fix.

    Murphy
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    I have not driven the Escape much since it got out of the shop but the idle seems lower - but that is speculation. Will let you know if I notice anything this week on my commute.

    Murphy
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    Thanks murphy27. Your information will be a big help.
  • jafo2001jafo2001 Member Posts: 98
    Murphy, you should have brought your spy camera with you. As soon as he left the room you could have snapped pictures of the secret documents and developped them in your basement lab.
  • murphy27murphy27 Member Posts: 31
    What makes you think I have a basement lab - very funny though. Ford guards this information like we wish airport security would work.

    Maybe I should have just taken them off the work order and put the papers in my briefcase.

    Murphy
  • sembergersemberger Member Posts: 2
    Ok I am not one of the "hysterical" owners but FYI I bought a 2001 Mazda Tribute last February. Had the engine cutoff problem 6 times and had every tweak known to man done by the Mazda dealer. Finally, Mazda agreed to trade it out for a 2002 which I got two weeks ago. The engine has cut off on this one twice already. This is rediculious. Period.
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    I hate to tell you but this is not happening in the 2002s. Better take a look at the TSB, it shows the PCM#'s.. Someone here at Edmunds also listed the PCMs... The 2002's don't have these....
  • maynardf1maynardf1 Member Posts: 127
    OK, here's a guy with a level-headed post about his truck stalling. He reports his 2002 has stalled twice since mazda swapped vehicles. Scape's response? Couldn't have happened. Your mistake.
    Denial must be the 51st state, and scape is governor.
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    As I have posted here several times, our 2002 Escape did stall once at around 814 miles. We bought it in January 2002, and it was built on 12/21/2001. Neither my wife or I think it is really a big deal, and we still love our Escape to death. We're waiting for it to happen again to take it to the dealer for the PCM update because it seems that people are having success with that fix so far.
  • gdosonogdosono Member Posts: 1
    I'm having the same stalling problems with my 2001 Tribute. It's happened 4 or 5 times since I bought it last year. When I brought it to the dealer in Renton, WA they couldn't figure out what was wrong. At least I know that I'm not the only one that is having this problem.
  • jguy69jguy69 Member Posts: 1
    Scape2, check NTHSA.GOV under the 2002 Escape and see if it's happening or not... One anecdote for those frustrated with this: We are attempting to lemon-law our car, and Ford is even slower to make good on this than they are in fixing the stalling problem! Our 2001 Escape has been stalling since April of 2001, and despite numerous attempts at fixes (and 45 days in the shop) and 3 PCM replacements, it stalled again two days ago and has stalled a total of 6 times since last fix. It has been 6 months since we filed our lemon-law action, and we have gone through 6 car payments and still no resolution. When I see Bill Ford on those stupid Ford commercials now, I have a nerf brick I throw at the TV. I would be willing to bet that Billy Boy doesn't drive and Escape!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.