By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
In order to know which is a better deal, you have to give more details. How often can the variable rate be raised? Is there a limit on much it can go up each year? A ceiling on how high it can go up over the life of the loan?
Variable rate loans were invented to unload the risk of rising interest rates onto the borrower. If you take the fixed interest rate, and suddenly the Fed raises rates a bunch (they won't, but if they did) then suddenly the bank is losing money by loaning it to you at a fixed, relatively low rate.
But lets suppose the rate can only go up .5% per year. And you have decided to pay the whole 19k off in one year. The you would be better off with the variable rate loan.
All in all, I don't think the difference between the variable and fixed rates is high enough to warrant you taking the risk of the variable rate loan. I'd go with the fixed rate.
I believe the person I talked to on the phone said that my variable rate (8.65%) could never go higher than the fixed rate they offered me (9.35%), but I'm not 100% sure now. If this is the case I may take my chances with the variable rate interest, but if it's not the case, I think you are right, I should try to switch to the fixed rate as the difference is indeed not worth the risk.
Thanks for your help!
Mike
I have read in several car buying guides that I should only take the vehicle off the lot when the loan has been received and I am assured that it was approved, in my case, by my credit union. This is to prevent any unnecessary games by the dealerships finance dept.. Is this accurate?
I assume this is some sort of expedited depreciation or something, but I am not sure.
I am planning on starting a small company myself, and I am wondering if anyone can tell me if there are any benefits to buying a car in your company's name.
Thanks.
Jeff in Salt Lake.
done at the home sight.
But, have your contract looked at by profesionals...you never know when someone has forgot to dot an I.
Good luck.
Thx in adv.
Even though your salesperson is not directly involved in the dealership's finance department, he/she must let consumers know that they are not entitled to both the cash and the special financing. If he/she hadn't you would have been very angry when you agreed to a price and then realized in the finance department that you can't take advantage of the 2.9% as well.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
Peoplefirst and Eloan both use credit scoring, and rely on it heavily. Factors such as your total number of credit accounts, their age, debt to income ratio, late payments, etc. all contribute to your score.
Signed: Alan Amico, Chief Privacy Officer, PeopleFirst.com
My question, therefore, is: If they refuse the .com draft, is it enough (legal)reason to walk out of a deal and get my deposit back? I am not going to take the vehicle if my other option is more than 0.25% more than my .com rate. That is, of course, if I can waklk away from it.
Thanks for your advice.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
I don't actually intend to walk away from this deal because I've already waited for so long (5 weeks) for this build-to-order vehicle, and I really want it. I just forgot to tell them that I was going to pay with a .com draft. For all I know, it might actually be perfectly fine with them. My only worry is that they will give me a hard time about the .com draft and force me into their "alternative" financing at a HIGHER rate. The only 'escape clause" in the contract is if the vehicle "does not conform to the specifications as ordered."
I agree, walking out and actually getting your money are two different things.
One thing I will have to do out there is buy a car, and I am somewhat concerned about getting approved for an auto loan. The reason is that I have a very high credit card bill, and consequently limited cash assets. However, I have never missed any payments and other than that bill my credit should be excellent. (Got a copy from Equifax.) Can anyone give me any feedback as to whether I might have trouble getting a loan, what questions financial institutions might ask, how to deal with them, etc.
Thanks in advance.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
My wife and I just bought a new 2001 Honda Accord 2 days ago. The total cost of the car is $24,456.61. We put down $9,456.61 for down payment and financed with American Honda Finance Corportation for the amount of $15,000. The interest rate that they gave us is 8% (we didn't qualify for the special 3.9% financing that Honda is offering right now). I called PeopleFirst Yesterday and they gave us 6.95% for refinancing with them. We refinanced with PeopleFirst for the amount of $10,000. My brother is also lending us $5,000. My question is, am I just sending the check that PeopleFirst is going to send to me($10,000) and write
another check of $5,000 to the American Honda Finance Corporation? How does it work? Is there any fee or penalty that I have to pay? Thanks.
Leo
How is the check you are recieving PF being made out? I presume its made out to AHFC? If that's the case, then ask AHFC what your payoff amount if, and include the PF check, the check from your brother, plus any extra amount you have to chip in so the sum equals the payoff.
You'll have to check with AHFC (or carefully read your contract) to see what (if any) early payment fees you may have to pay.
Leo:
That's a complicated question. I personally don't like any loan longer than 3 years, but cars can cost alot and many people can only get the monthly payment down to something they can handle by extending the loan out to 60 or even 72 months.
It depends on alot of factors, including what sort of factory incentive exists for the vehicle you want. Usually, you get better rates for shorter periods of time, but if the factory is offering 0.9% (for example) on a 60 month loan, I would take that. If they were offering 0.9% on 36 months and 3.9% on 48 months and 5.9% on 60 month, I'd probably go with the 36 month. Others would do differently.
I wouldn't want a market rate loan (8% say) for 60 months. I'd be looking for a smaller car before I did that.
I was looking at the Subaru Foresters. Subaru doesn't usually offer any rebates on these cars, maybe $500 at most. Their financing isn't anything special 5.9% for 36&48 months and 6.9% for 60 months. I like the S trim on the Forester but would need to take out the loan for 60 months to get the payments down. I could step down to the lower L trim and take the loan out for 48 months at the highest monthly payment I would want to go.
The other option is to look at a different category of car---the Hatchbacks, which would consist of the Mazda Protege 5, Subura Impreza OBS, or the Toyota Matrix/Pontiac Vibe. All three of these would be easily handle on 4 year payment. Perhaps go down to 3 years at max payemnts I would want if the deal went well.
I typically keep my cars for 8 years and put 200,000 miles on them in that time peroid. I need something reliable, not expensive to maintain or fix, plus be verstatile enough to carry passengers and cargo/stuff that typically doesn't fit in trunks of sedans. Any opinions?
Thanks,
Leo
Thank you for your response. The check that I am receiving from PF is a blank check. My dealer sent my loan application to AHFC 2 days ago and my account hasn't been set up yet. I'll wait for my account to be set up with AHFC before I can check with them.
My $.02 is to buy the least options you can live with for as long as possible. For ex, if you take the Forester S and drive it for 8 years that is cheaper in the long run than getting a cheaper car and trading it in after 4 years.
Now if you will be happy with the cheaper car for 8 years, buy that and put the extra money into savings for car repairs or for your next car.
Good luck whatever you get.
Many people around here (myself included) would tell you to keep driving your current car until what you owe equals trade value. Even better, drive it until you pay it off.
The only other advice I can give you with a trade is to watch out for reconditioning charges. What they do is give you credit for your trade, say $10000, and then they charge you maybe $500 to recondition your car so it can be resold. In effect, this means you are getting $9500 for your trade. But again, if you can follow the computation of the amount financed you will see what they are doing. If they can't show you how the numbers add up, you are probably better off going somewhere else.
the problem is sometimes you let your emotions get the better of you when it comes to new cars. For example, those Hatchbacks I mentioned earlier--all of those would comfortably fit my budget for a four year loan. Then what happens, I see the Forester L for 2 grand more. That would definitely stretch the budget to the max on a four year loan (I'm trying to stay away from a 5 year car loan). The S trim is even nicer but cost another 2 grand more. That would require a 5 year payment loan. What happened? Started within my budget but started looking and then tried to see if you can stretch it another two, then another two. The first stretch one might be able to make but the other stretch would be getting yourself into financial trouble.
Now you can play devil's advocate very easily and justify the more expensive car with: 'but I keep my cars for 8 years and put 200,000 miles on them, buy the car you really like'. Then there the other side that realizes that cars depreciate and there are other things to save for like a houses, or starting a family.
Ah, cars and women can be a dangerous thing
Leo
You reminded me of a column I read in a newspaper...the writer's friend had told him how he spent his money--one third he spent on women, another third he spent drinking, and the last third he just wasted
But you are right about stretching car budgets. The less you spend on the car the more you'll have for other stuff later.
Leo
I'm looking to by my first new car at the end of this year/beginning of next year (thank you, thank you. You're too kind with your applause and congrats
Also, I currently have an '89 LeBaron Convertible (I appreciate your sympathy). According to Kelly's I should be able to get $1-$2K for it (it has roughly 83K on it). The car is slightly beat up, so what I'll be able to get will be on the low end of the scale. Which brings me to Question 2, which would I be better off doing? Trading it in or selling it myself?
Question 3: Anyone got any ideas on how to go about getting a good deal on financing? Aside from student loans, this will be the first I will be going into.
Thank you to all of my new best friends in advance!!
May 7 2001,I leased a new car,I was very pleased w/the apr and monthly payment set. Now three weeks later the bank is telling my delaership that they are not satisfied w/my credit teir and my dealership is asking me to accept a new lease under a differnt bank at a higher monthly rate or i can return my car. I feel that the dealership is obligated to grant me the monthly payment they promised as i would not have agreed to go above for fear of starving. Any advice here, do i have a case to plead. I like my new car, but i feel the bank and dealership should have known this before they let me drive away. Im so confused.
Please e-mail me w/any feedback as this is an urgent matter and i have to decide if i should accept this bogus deal or give the car back and take my business elsewhere.
Lauri7823@Aol.com
Thanks
Lauri
I suspect that the terms are conditional upon acceptance of the leasing company; in which case you have no recourse because they didn't accept it. Returning the vehicle is the most favorable option for you.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong (wink, wink, nudge, nudge).
PS: Cooltibby, bblaha is right. Check you leasing contract first before you do anything. Contracts like that usually take into account all possible scenarios (however improbable) and the only loopholes there are will probably be for the dealership's benefit. Also check with the Better Buisness Bureau, they may be able to give you some advice. Good Luck!!
mmcbride1: It's official, I have premature Alzheimer's (either that or I REALLY must have had a good time in college!). I graduated in May 1999 with a BS in Engineering (go figure...). Sorry 'bout that! For some reason Ford still thinks I'm eligible for a rebate. 8)
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
I played with the Calculator, and assuming that I would get 6.9% with the $1K rebate, turns out I could save $20/month.
Would taking the rebate almost always result in a lesser payment, and if so why? I realize that the answer to the latter part of the question has something to do with a lesser loan amount, but why would there be such a significant difference?
Try repeating the example only using 48 months, and you'll find you'd be better to go with the lower rate.
That basically is an ok generalism: The longer the loan period, the more important the low rate; the shorter the loan period, the more important the rebate.
If you are looking for a VERY rough estimate of which is better (the kind of estimate you can just almost do in your head), try this.
- Estimate the total interest paid for each case by multiplying the interest rate by the "average loan balance" (= loan amount divided by 2), and then multiplying by the number of years.
- If the interst you pay for the high rate loan (which includes the rebate) exceeds the interest you'd pay on the low rate by more than the rebate, then you should go for the low rate deal. If its less, take the rebate.
So for example, a $20K vehicle at either 2.9% no rebate, or 6.9% $1K rebate, each for 2 years becomes:
2.9%/0 rebate
Interest paid estimate = (0.029)*(2)*(20000/2) =$580
6.9%, $1000 rebate
Interest paid est = (0.069)*(2)*(19000/2) = $1311.
Since the difference is only $731, you should go with the rebate.
Repeating for 4 years:
2.9%/0 rebate
Interest paid est = (0.029)*(4)*(20000/2) = $1160
6.9%/1000 rebate
= (0.069)*(4)*(19000/2) = $2622
Difference is $1462, so you should take the low rate.
Hope this is helpful...
I hope others are reading this because it is a good thing to keep in mind.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
No, this is NOT normal, nor should you shop there any further.
If you complete the purchase on a vehicle sight-unseen, you own it when it comes in. If there's anythig about the car that you don't like, you have no recourse - it's your car, lock stock and barrel.
You may wish to check the BBB in your area and see if similar complaints have been filed. If so, add yours. The more people this has happened to, the better chance that an investigation and regulatory action can be taken against the dealer.
kcram
Host
Smart Shopper and FWI Message Boards
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
Still sound not on the up-and-up? Like I said, I think I got a good price and a good loan - 7.99%, which appears about right based on some other research I have done, so other than this weird financing thing I am relatively happy with my experience. Any other comments?
Rather than trying to be "beneficial to you", it almost sounds like the dealer is trying to move merchandise to make their own quotas. If you pay in full today, that's now a car "sold and delivered" in July, even if it won't show until August.
I'd check to see what the new or renewed incentives are later this week before making any deals.
kcram
Host
Smart Shopper and FWI Message Boards
I absolutely agree with KC, it sounds like the dealership that you are working with is more concerned about adding a car to their June sales total than you as a consumer. I definitely would not pay for a new car or truck until I actually saw it.
Car_Man
Host
Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards