Much Improved for Wider Appeal - 2014 Mini Cooper Hardtop Long-Term Road Test

Comments

• 7driver Member Posts: 145

  March 2015

  I think going for wider appeal has ruined its value proposition. Before, you could say that it was so quirky and offbeat that you can't really compare it with anything else. Now that it's gone mainstream, you *can* compare it with something else. And when you run the comparison, you find you're spending a whole lot of extra money unnecessarily.

  0
• darex Member Posts: 187

  March 2015

  Disagree. Like Brent says, no other car is as customizable or build-to-order as this car can be, and every other car in its class forces compromises (e.g. If you want stick, you cannot have loaded) that are irksome. As well, it's still plenty quirky.

  1
• kirkhilles1 Member Posts: 863

  March 2015

  Sorry, maybe I'd have a different opinion if I drove it, but I just don't get the Mini. Want a great performing small convertible that's affordable to buy and maintain? Get a Miata. Looking for an expensive to buy, expensive to maintain vehicle, get a Mini. Quirky, I don't get. Get a Mustang, pick up a used S2000, something other than a Mini. You might as well get a 3 series if you can afford the maintenance.

  1
• darex Member Posts: 187

  March 2015

  You're comparing a hatchback to impractical two-seater cars. Maybe it's the utility of hatchbacks that you "don't get?" A Mustang!? Where did that come from!? Why not suggest a minivan while you're at it!?

  0
• chol92594 Member Posts: 208

  March 2015

  As much as I like Minis, I just can't see the point in spending $25k-$35k for such a small car. Yes, it may be surprisingly practical, but it's still small, especially when you consider what else could be had for the same price. Factor in the BMW engineering and you've got a car that simply can't be cross-shopped with your average hatchback due to higher cost of purchase and cost of ownership. A Golf/GTI is the only thing I could even consider cross-shopping a Mini with, and even then, I'd much rather have the Golf.
  
  Minis are no longer affordable and simple cars for the masses. True, they're very customizable, and if you keep the options down, they can be decently affordable, but I'd rather buy a Golf for a little less money and get a somewhat larger and more practical car.

  1
• bankerdanny Member Posts: 1,021

  March 2015

  He compared the Mini Convertible to the Miata, not the hatch. And while the MC has a back seat, it's really just a heavily padded parcel shelf.

  0
• darex Member Posts: 187

  March 2015 edited March 2015

  bankerdanny said:

  He compared the Mini Convertible to the Miata, not the hatch. And while the MC has a back seat, it's really just a heavily padded parcel shelf.

  He also mentioned the S2000 -- another two-seater
  
  Besides, any back seat is better than no back seat, plus the cargo area folds completely flat now, making for a very versatile car for hauling dogs and objects.
  

  0