Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options
Vehicle Break-In Period
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
a)Driven to my dealer from another dealership
b) Not broken in by me, as the service and sales people said "not to worry - just drive it!"
That poor car had consistent transmission problems that Mazda ws never able to fix and it gave terrible gas mileage - I seldom even made the EPA average.
My next - a '97 Lexus ES picked up brand new, was VERY carefully broken in for 1500 miles, kept at 50-55 or less despite the glares of the truckers on the freeway. After break-in it gave me a steady 24-25 mpg overall, even hitting 30.2 mpg on the long road to Las Vegas! The engine was so quiet you couldn't hear or feel it idling.
Coincidence or Break-In? - you be the judge.
It seems like cheap insurance to me.
first oil change : 7500 miles
2nd oil change : 15000 miles
....and so on (intervals of 7500 miles).
Is this correct or should I go by the dealer who recommends oil change every 3000 miles?
So - while 7500 is "OK", 3K is better, especially if it is short haul driving.
I've been "preaching" the benefits of synthetic oil products for about 10 years and usually it falls on "deaf ears" so to speak. Usually the mechanics say it does not matter that much because they have never used it or done any research on the products. Mechanics are NOT automotive engineers and are generally creatures of habit (i.e. they will use whatever they have always been using, and the general public is pretty much the same for that matter). What is very difficult for the synthetic oil companies (Amsoil, Red Line, etc) is educating consumers regarding the merits of using the stuff, getting them over the cost per quart, and convincing them extended drain intervals are OK. Not many people realize that synthetic oil does NOT chemically "break down" inside the engine environment. As long as you keep the oil clean you can run the same oil fill for 100,000 miles or more. Yes there are synth users that do this successfully and pay MUCH LESS for engine oil in the long term and protect their engine better. Keeping the oil clean is another story - there are ways to do it, primarily with a bypass filter. Anyway, I could go on but I think the biggest benefit and something you "northerners" can benefit from is cold start protection. It has been proven that synthetic is much better at protecting an engine from the perils of "cold start". When I cold start my car in the morning (18 degrees this morning) I have much more confidence my oil is protecting my engine. However, all this is moot if you have the habit of trading or selling you car frequently - then who cares about long-term engine protection anyway.
I may only have a thousand miles, when this Summer I'll be off for long cross country driving. Can I cruise normally, or do the variable speed thing?
If you're not familiar with this book it is "Drive It Forever" by Robert Sikorski. It contains practical info. regarding how to make your car last - a lot of things people don't think about.
If you need any further info. let me know.
After the first change you can change as much as you want. I would point out that I changed my oil every 5000 miles in an 83 Honda Civic and drove it for 12 years and 275,000+ miles without any engine problems.
This is my fourth Honda. First one was an 81 Civic - gave it away @ 175,000 mi., but the engine was still great. Next was an 86 Accord - gave it away last fall after 215,000 miles. Currently have a 95 Odyssey w/ 81,000 miles and the new Accord. My mechanic says the key is the oil changes. Never tried synthetics - just stick with Valvoline 5W-30W.
As far as hurting the engine with a 15-minute jaunt at 75mpg, don't sweat it. The reason the manufacturer says to keep the speeds low at first is because they don't want you running the engine at high-RPMs for an extended period of time (that 1500-mile trip rs_petty mentioned)... at least not until the engine has been broken in.
As someone mentioned earlier, high speeds when new can cause permanent scoring and heat damage to all kinds of bearings. The effect is cumulative, and will reduce your performance, reliability and gas mileage for the life of the car.
I have tried it both ways - got terrible gas mileage with no break-in, and fantastic gas mileage with a long, careful break in with similar cars. It could be coincidence, but why take the chance?
Drove my last vehicle to 170,000.
Careful break in is worth it to me. But I usually run the crap outta the fully warmed up motor once I reach a little over 1000 miles up to before I make the first oil change
I just purchased a 2000 VW Bug GLX (teehee!) and have thought very hard about the break-in period. I was rather nervous, but then someone suggested that VW DOES put a 10 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty on the thing - would they suggest something that would cause damage to the engine? I wouldn't think so. The initial oil will remain in Uber Bug until the 5K miles.
Also - stevec5 - I also own an '89 Prelude Si. Didn't have the heart to trade it in (can get MUCH more for it privately). It has 125K miles on it (we bought it used almost 2yrs ago) and has had some problems recently ONLY because the original owner didn't do his job. Timing belt wasn't replaced (zero clearance engine - that was a big old OUCH!) and now we are having some CV joint/boot problems. Proper maintenance would have been great - like a timing belt change at 90K or whatever the number is. It's probably somewhat our fault that the CV situation exists (doh!). I don't know how to check for such things - I was depending on tire people/tune-up people. Guess I won't do that some more!
I switch to synthetics when subjecting the motor to extreme (<-10F) operation. No problem switching back and forth with modern synthetics and relatively new engines.
1. I have heard varying opinions on using a synthetic the article states wait 6-8K miles for the engine to properly "break-in". But others have stated that the Corvette and BMW use synthetics at the factory. Your opinion?
2. If you know, do dealers usually have a synthetic option, or should I change it myself?
3. Do I use a conventional oil filter?, what do you recommend?
I appreciate your time, thank you. John
2. I think most dealers do. Our Honda dealer will use Mobil 1 if you request. I have always changed oil myself but that's me - I get some sort of weird satisfaction with doing this stuff myself. Also, you may be able to provide the oil and have the dealer change it. Our Honda dealer will do that also and knock some cost off the oil change. Just, if you care about your car at all do NOT patronize one of these quick change oil lube places !! I think others can back me up here with personal experiences - some horrifying.
3. I am partial to Amsoil products. I think they do make the best stuff. They make a larger more heavy duty filter than anyone else, but it cost more of course. I would also recommend the filter available at your dealer.
I am not here to push Amsoil products - I do NOT sell the stuff myself, but their products are top-notch and I do believe you can order their goods directly from the company over the net or via phone. You used to have to order from a dealer and that's sort of a pain. There web site its www.amsoil.com.
2. Once again, agree with rascal, get some perverse pleasure from climbing under and changing myself.
3. I use OEM filters when I can. My AC/Delco filter is a special part number developed just for my application. Also had good luck with Purolater PUREONE filters.
So, if the rings have not seated, you should see some oil usage. But if you monitor your oil very carefully and do not notice any oil consumption, then I would say the rings have seated, and it is OK to switch to synthetic.
Just curious, I plan to follow the advice of rascal8 and markbuck (and yourself I'm assuming).
To all, it seems as I have tried to spread the word about synthetics, even to friends who I thought loved thier cars, all seem to not really care or disbelieve the benefits of synthetic. Call me crazy, but I cannot figure out their apathy. Laziness I guess, too bad.
rascal8 and markbuck: I also have a '91 Infiniti G20 with 187,000 miles on it. No engine trouble whatsoever, but it does burn a quart to a quart and one half per 3,500 miles. Too late to change to synthetic? I recall reading in the article posted at the other site (syn oil #58) that if your car is leaking or burning oil do not bother with synthetic for it will cost you too much money adding syn oil. Your thoughts? Thanks again.
JB
Regarding your older Infiniti I converted my old Toyota at about 140,000 miles with no problems. I do not think it would be a problem in your case. From what I have read synoil and dino oil are completely compatible. If you switch and it burns too much oil you can always switch back. I don't think it will though. BUT, if you do switch the synoil manufacturers highly recommend you use an engine flush first. This flushes out all the "junk" the dino oil left behind. Basically, you dump a can of this into your warm engine and let it idle for several minutes, drain, and refill with the synoil. I did this with my Toyota.
By the way, I changed to Mobil 1 at 1000 miles. I monitored my oil consumption religiously during that time and did not burn a drop. Since changing over, I still have not burned a drop of oil.
I changed because... why not? It's winter and synthetic flows better. Mobil says it can be used from day one. Nissan does not say anything against it. Corvettes and BMW (I think) come with synthetic from the factory. Plus, with all the talk about how great synthetic is that you can't use it until your engine is broken in because it lubricates too well... (which I disagree with, but..., see above posts...) I want to protect my engine from the get go.
One thing I do with synthetics is lengthen my oil change intervals to every 5k miles instead of 3k. But mpg... I'm not doing worse, but better is hard to tell. 5w-30 should be pretty close regardless of type. I think on start-up, I should be getting better mileage, due to synthetics cold weather performance.
Put the M1 in for cold starts during a trip to Jackson Hole WY, where encountered temps of -31 when parking outside.
Will go back to 5W- or 10W-30 Walmart oil when my idiot oil change light comes on.
I30 to Mobil 1 at 500 miles. From what I have read in the past, the sooner the better to start using synthetic.
(To the one from Boston, how do you like the I30. Great car with great standard features, wouldn't you say?)
(OVER 25 YEARS AT A GM DEALER). I RECENTLY ASKED
HIM ABOUT THE OIL BECAUSE I NOTICED THE LEVEL IN
MY IMPALA LS 3800 WAS OVERFILLED. I DRAINED OUT 1/2 QT. OF OIL TO BRING IT TO THE PROPER LEVEL. HE TOLD ME THEY MUST HAVE PUT 5 QTS IN INSTEAD OF THE 4 1/2. I NOTICED THE OIL WAS GREEN LIKE PRESTONE AND HE TOLD ME HAT IT IS FLORESANT DYE IN CASE YOU GET A LEAK IT IS EASY TO FIND AND THE DYE STAYS IN FOR 2 TO 3 OIL CHANGES. I ALSO ASKED WHEN I SHOULD CHANGE THE OIL
FOR THE FIRST TIME. THERE IS A SPECIAL OIL USED FOR BREAK-IN, IT CONTAINS A MILD ABRASIVE TO HELP
WITH BREAK- IN AND GM TELLS THE MECHANICS IT HOULD
STAY IN FOR 1500 TO 2000 MILES FOR PROPER BREAK-IN. I HAVE 480 MILES ON MINE AND HAVE HAD IT
1 MONTH. I PLAN TO CHANGE IT AT 1500. I BELIEVE MY
FRIEND 100%, HE SHOULD KNOW WHAT HE IS TALKINGABOUT.
in oil? usually any kind of compound othe than
jewelers rouge will cause complete break in to
occur at way less than 1500 miles.
Conclusion, I believe there is no break-in oil. Rather, most manufacturers build with standard dino-juice oil and have tested with that, and are most comfortable with the engine leaving the factory with that "flavor" of oil. Further, they are comfortable with that oil in the crankcase for 1k-7.5K before the first oil change.
My $0.02
TB
PS, those of you who know someone who just claimed their manufacturer uses "breakin oil", ask them for a part number for that special oil. Just tell them you are rebuilding a brand xxx engine and need some of that special break-in oil. Oh, also ask them if you can get that oil with a long-block or short-block the parts department sells.
If they can't get you a part# there probably is not such an animal.
Indeed, if the original "break-in" oil in my engine contained a mild abrasive ...as has been rumored to be a characteristic of such oil .... for the sake of the engine bearings I would certainly want to replace it immediately. On the other hand, if this elusive oil were somehow better for the engine than commercially available motor oils, why wouldn't the motor-oil marketing folks play this up and advocate it for normal use?
Ask the service department what they are instructed to use when they rebuild an engine. If you are really curious, ask you local engine rebuilder what oil they use for a newly rebuilt engine. Or if your shop sells new or reman engines, what oil do the documents with that engine say to use. Certainly short blocks don't ship pre-oiled, so you gotta fill 'em with something.
Like I said earlier, just trot on down to the VW (or whatever your favorite manufacturer is) and ask them for some break-in oil for that engine that your brother-in-law (or whoever you know might be rebuilding one, just in case you really feel bad about lying to the dealer...come to think about it, just lie
Food for thought?
The wife just got home from shopping, so I've gotta schlep all that stuff from our new Mazda MPV. OBTW, I am hedging our bets. At 1K miles I am changing oil with a 50/50 mix of M1 and Dino juice. Then at 5K intervals we will go with 5W30 M1.
Furthermore, in my Contour at 10K miles I'll drain four of the eight quarts of ATX fluid and replace them with the synthetic flavor. Since the transmission has a drain plug and a screen instead of a filter, Ford recommends a drain, fill, drain and finally a fill to replace the fluid, wasting four quarts of new fluid at I believe 30K mile intervals. I'll probably drain and fill four quarts at every 10K. I'd like to actually get some road use from all of the fluid I buy. (I just can't see buying fluid just to run it through the ATX.)
TB
I just don't know.
thx kb123