Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see May lease deals!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
Riswami: I guess you don't know what you're talking about. My '97 Camry LE cost $18,700 new. The '90 Sable GS I bought in 1990 cost $15,700.
Big premium for the Camry considering 7 years had gone by!
Actually, neither car ever broke down on the road, leaving me stranded. But the Sable did fail to start at home a few times(when the battery died suddenly and when the alternator failed and allowed the battery to discharge).
And I continue to frequent this forum because I had a Taurus twin (the Sable) and thought maybe I could provide assistance to people.
Let's remember, often, you get what you pay for!
That's what people thought when the '96 and '97s came out.
97 Camry Le 97 Taurus Gl
Safety 7.4 7.8
Reliability 8.2 7.7
Performance 8.6 8.0
Comfort 8.1 8.0
Value 5.0 9.1
Overall 7.5 8.1
Wow, the Taurus is a much better value! The reliability isn't that different. That has been my personal experience.
210 Delray - You paid 18,700 for a 4 cylinder Camry. In Rhode Island during the same time you could get a great deal on 97 Sables, with Duratec 6, Leather,ABS, Alloys, Sunroof etc were being sold for $17,900. That is brandy new!
My Dad bought a 2000 Sable with the above options for under 19k. He traded a 92 Sable with a 3.8 with 93k that need a starter and a battery in 8 years.
Late January 1998 I bought a program Taurus for 12.9K. It had 23k. My choice was the loaded Taurus with Alloys, ABS, power everything or a stripped Honda Accord with a 5 speed (which I like) for just over 16k. That 3 thou difference invested at a reasonable 7% is now worth 4k. It's in my pocket and still making money. At the same time I called my insurance agent. The Accord was $300 more a year to insure.Still think I don't know what I'm talking about 210delray?
Now it gets better - the Accord will need a timing belt at 90k. Most mechanics recommend the water pump being done at the same time. That is a 500 dollar job. The Taurus has a timing chain. It is rare to have to repair them.
So I'm ahead right now about 5 thousand. You paid 6k more than I did and I'm not sure you can justify that. Or maybe you can, I can't.
Maybe Edmunds can provide info on reliability info. In their opinion the Camry is better, how you translate that into dollars becomes personal.
I know plenty of people who have owned Taurus and Sables and for the most part their ownership experiences have been positive.
I read one of your older post. Your Sable needed a starter, struts and water pump. Those are wear items. They don't go on every car, but they are pretty common for needing replacement.Or do you have data that shows that Camrys never need these replaced? Last time I checked auto parts stores carried parts for Toyotas! Seems to me they need maitenance also. I know someone who bought a 97 Camry and had to replace the tires at 20k. My Taurus has two original tires with 60k on them; their in good shape.
My point - you got on another post for using the term "moron". Yet you lash out with "You don't know what your talking about to my post". What is up with that?
You're entitled to your opinion. Your example of a 90 Sable to a 97 Camry doesn't hold water. Cars in the 90s got a lot more content for not much more money. Toyota is famous for charging thru the nose for options. Doubt me on that. Read the Edmunds comments, pros and cons.
Oh what a feeling! Taurus!!!!!
Why don't you try and become one of the few who can add something that is usefull?
But make sure you get your current alternator checked out first. It's hard to make an accurate diagnosis over the web!
Riswami: I thought you were leaving. Looks like the Camry beats the Taurus in most of Edmunds rankings except the highly subjective "value" category. Plus have you read just the last 30 posts or so about others' tales of woe?
I'll give you more concrete examples of the repair costs on my Sable compared to those of my Camry, when I have more time.
'97 Taurus GL: $7625 (NADA retail price, 6/01)
'97 Camry LE 4-cyl: $12,025
No surprise here; after all it's common knowledge that Taurus and Sable depreciate like the proverbial rock.
Be glad you didn't get my Taurus, or else the thousands you saved would be almost depleated.
Everyone,
Since the weather has changed, I've noticed that dashboard (all the way at the top need the defroster vents) creaks, and actually appears to be seperating from the dashboard in many places. Has anyone else experienced this? I guess I'll find out what the problem is when I take it in on Friday for other problems.
#1 1986. 50k. 3.0L. Blew heater hose. (Big Whup)
#2 1988. 125k. 3.8L. Wear items (i.e. struts, tires)
#3 1991. 175k. 3.8L Wear items + alternator.
#4 1996. 100k+ (still have). 3.0L Duratec. Struts, tires, battery, water pump, A/C fan clutch, crankshaft bearing (it is external).
The money that I spent on normal wear items is insignificant to the money saved on initial purchase! These are GREAT cars!!!!
Mike
This is the second Taurus/Sable I've owned.
1. 1993 Mercury Sable GS = 2 head gasket jobs
Cost = $2800
2. 1997 Ford Taurus = new transmission + other
Cost = $4000
Luckily, the Sable's head gaskets went under a three month warranty I got with the car in 1999. Then, they went again a little under a year, so it was also covered under warranty. I was not as fortunate with the Taurus though.
I've had MAJOR powertrain problems with both my midsized Fords, so from my experiences, Ford will not have a repeat customer anymore.
Anyway, this last trip to the dealership has been grueling. Last weekend it started to hesitate when you first start to pull out. Then it went to starting ok, but when I put it in drive it will stall. Now, when I brake, it revs on it's own and tries to inch me into traffic (I am sure it is possessed) The O/D light seemed to be flashing a code and the check engine light was on.
I had it towed to my dealer (Bought the Ford extended warranty) they have had it all week and replaced a few little things and said it was fixed.
I got 10 miles from the dealership and it is doing it again. They told me to drive it until another light comes on because their "computer" they hook to the car says everything is ok.
I am at my wits end, anyone have any ideas? Please feel free to email me also, as I have pulled out all of my hair and cannot leave the house..:)
Many thanks
Take the car to a transmission specialist and have them check it out carefully. If it gets a clean bill of health you might want to seriously consider it.
My Dad has owned 2 Taurus' and has absolutely loved them. Domestics really build comfortable cars. His first did have transmission problems, but he never maintained it. I also had a tranmission problem on a truck that I purchased new. I would take it in every 15,000 miles and say, to the dealer do your scheduled service. Well, at 90,000 miles I had to have a transmission overhaul. The dealer had never changed out the transmisison fluid. The service manuals uniformly say "Inspect" the transmission fluid. THIS is BOGUS. By the time the tranny fluid smells, and looks black it's too late.
You have a much better chance if you do the following: change the transmission fluid every 30,000 miles or 2 years, put in synthetic transmission fluid, and put in Lubegard at the time of change. (see www.lubegard.com) It might also be good to install a transmission cooler. The Toyota Higlander comes with a factory installed one.
Why? Heat is the enemy of transmissions. It produces acids that destroy seals and metal. Synthetic fluid and Lubegard provide better heat transfer and durability. Frequent changes will maintain the best qualities of the fluids.
Also, strictly follow the SEVERE maintence schedule. I also take the car in for an annual checkup. You will save a lot of money in the long run.
Example, I didn't repair a wobbly tire for 30,000 miles once. It was a bad wheel bearing. Because I didn't repair it, I also had to pay for a ball joint, and control idler arm. A $150 repair turned into a $600 one. I'm not a mechanic, but I have learned these things over the years in the school of expensive repairs.
Since I followed this conservative maintenence procedure I have been able to get many more miles out of my car before major repairs.
Numerous trivial problems since its purchase with 15,000 mi...
Since purchase, power steering system made a miserable groaning noise while braking and turning at low speed. Dealer adjusted a pressure release valve in steering pump, and the problem is now less frequent.
Broken shift indicator (console shift), replaced under warranty.
Keyless entry retainer broke at 25,000, now works intermittently
Fuel guage suffers from a ridiculous variation since purchase. It fluctuates by as much as 1/3 tank while driving, depending on direction and angle. NEVER registers more than 3/4 tank, even when full. Dealer supposedly replaced sending unit in tank at 30,000mi (my cost), but condition never improved.
Washer fluid light quit at 30,000, dealer supposedly replaced washer motor (my cost), but didn't fix it.
Passenger front window motor quit at 40,000 mi (my cost).
Over the past month, engine accessories have been squealing, and the charge light came on last weekend. Upon inspection, I found the washer fluid hose torn and spitting on the drive belt! Rigged up the hose with gasket seal and duct tape, hit the drive belt with some belt sticky to stop the slippage.
Wiper/washer switch is very erratic, and seems to be worsening.
Driver's seat seems to be loosening from the floorboard (power seats). I don't know if it's a bad motor or loosening bolts in the floorpan, but it's getting unnerving.
Slightly more serious:
Continual rotor warpage (4 wheel discs), all four machined, then replaced, then machined again. Now warped again with the hot Va weather.
Breakdown @ 55,000 mi. (Failed fuel pump)
Also irritating me is the bizzare shift pattern of the automatic. Harsh 1-2 shift, buttery smooth 2-3, and somehwere in between 3-4. It's so slow to downshift, ("Duh, which gear should I pick?")
that it sometimes takes a full two seconds to engage a lower gear when I mash the gas. A real waste of 200 hp. The upshift patten under heavy throttle is really strange, as 1-2 lurches harshly, but 2-3 and 3-4 actually SLOW DOWN, as if the transmission has a hard time engaging the bands under power. Plus, the A/C doesn't blow as cold as it did when new(er), as it takes a full 8-10 minutes to cool the interior now. It's not an airflow problem which might be caused by a restricted pollen filter, but an air temp problem. An A/C problem at such low miles just might be the last straw. It's been an OK vehicle, but not one that changes my opinion of American engineering and manufacturing. This car so far has been typical of previous domestics I've owned, which is not a compliment. I wonder if there are good factories and bad factories (mine was built in Chicago).
The one that I found is a program car, it might be off lease or off rental however it looks like brand new.
Have you get any cooler installed yet? If yes than what is the cost for it? I am definetely considering extended warranty too even tough I take care of my cars well.
Wijoko, Sorry to hear all those problems. I have been using imports for last 10 years. What I learned so far is they don't worth the premium pricing. Imports-even though they build here- don't cause severe problems but little annoying things are very expensive to fix. Also their quilatiy is slipping too. I had an 99 accord up until last march, it was wrecked so I was following the accord problems topic. it was unbelievable, so many problems. Civics, accords, camrys...What I say is I think there is no difference between domestic and import. It is all luck.
I decided to let it go and see if it happens again. After a month nothing happened then it started up again so I brought it into the dealer (under extended warranty) and they said that they could look at it in about a week because they are backed up with other Taurus transmission problems (go figure) the guy at the service counter said that it the fluid was low and that it needed to be replaced (he figured this out with out looking at the vehicle) and that it would cost me because that is no covered under the warranty, I told him that it is no the fluid because I had that looked at and it was something else. He got snotty then said well, I don't know what it is and you will have to leave it with us and we will look at when we are not busy (which could be after a couple of years.) I told him that I would have to bring it back.
My question is: Has anyone else had this similar problem, if so what did you do to fix it? Thank you for all your help.
While the other brands of Synthetic are good For this new car I would recommend the Ford Synthetic available at the dealer. I believe that it is the type already in your transmission. My Dad's service rep still recommends the 30,000 even with the synthetic. It's a lot less than a new tranny.
I've been reading this board on and off for a while, but finally decided to share my thoughts.
On Dec.31 1997 I bought a 97 Taurus GL with 5K miles.
The dealer drove it for a couple of months and they just moved it into the showroom.
It has all the options that I ever needed (and didn't need) - Leather, moonroof, 6-disc CD changer, power seat and etc. The only thing it doesn't have is a power antenna (hek, who needs it anyway).
Total cost out of my pocket $17,500 + tax.
The day before, I checked out all Toyota lots in town, and the cheapest Camry I could get was for
22,000 with no options. So, it was no brainer I went with Taurus since I wanted to buy it in a first place anyway.
I've seen somebody saying about "rental car look"
and etc about Taurus. Come on, you are not buying a school bus, it's a good looking car!
Next month I bought an extended warranty up to 100K (not from a dealership, but thru my bank - they were offering this deal from some insurance company for $700 bumber-to-bumper).
So, I paid $18,200 + tax for a new car with 100K warranty.
I got 51K miles as of last month.
For 3.5 years I had no problems at all!
I used synt. oil since 35K, changed tansmission fluid, gas filter and tires at 40K.
That's it!
So far I'd been very happy with my car.
A lot was said here about reliability and durability, but there is no car out there that never breaks down! It happens sooner or later, you just have to expect it and live with it.
I was wondering when this is going to happen with my car, and it did happen this month at 52K.
So,
1. Rear window motor broke (I was lucky - the wondow was closed). I decided it wasn't a big deal. A week later -
2. AC selector switch worked only in AC position
(vent, max AC, defrost seemed to disappear).
I knew it was a $10 part, since AC was still freezing me to death. I put it off for a while.
Here is where the next problem showed up the same week -
3. When slowing down quickly, or making tight turns at speeds just above "slow" I heard that cracking noise right beneath me. It seems like something was cracking, but just couldn't break yet. After driving for a week, trying to persuade myself that it is either debris on the road or sound of my neck cracing on turns I finally took it to the dealership where I bought it.
Here comes the familiar part. It took them 7 days to identify the problem. The service adviser was telling me everyday that the best mechanics are working on it (they had a sign in the customer area - "Factory trained mechanics" ). At least I was happy that they hear the same noise as I did, they could just say they didn't hear anything, or blame it on breaks or come up with some lame excuses. On the seventh day, finaly he told me that
the rear subframe bushings
got worn out. Not that I'm a slow driver, but I never abused my car or anything, so it was kind odd to hear that. I looked on the net, and found that this part might need replacement after 100k.
So, my extended warranty came in handy and absorbed 400$ total cost (I paid $25 deductable).
Conclusion: I'm still happy with my Taurus.
I'm planning on driving it up to 150k.
I think I can make it. I just expect more things to break from now on as I would expect in any other car. I still think that Taurus is a better value if you buy it new compared to Camry.
I'm glad I didn't pay $5000-$7000 extra for Camry. The next car I want to buy will probably be some kind of hybrid or electrical sometime in
2007 - I'm sure I can squize 10 yrs. out of my Taurus! (BTW I get city/hwy 20/28 mpg)
Taurus lovers, don't beleive this "Japanise is better" talk. I work for GE, and even though we don't make cars, I can assure you that the emphasise on quality has been tramendous over the last years in our company. I know the same is true with Ford (they make Rangers and Explorers in my town). I feel confident in american products. Japanise cars are probably better, but not for the same money! And that's the key to the market!
Starting at 65K, things went downhill in a hurry, front rotors, a/c (repeatedly and expensively), water pump, alternator, starter, one rear window motor (not fixed), front struts, c-v joint boots, rear brake rotors, both rear door lock actuators, intermittent wipers(again), engine mounts, and the kicker - a failed tranny at 93K miles.
I held on to 135K miles, way longer than I should have, in hindsight. Sold for $1800 last summer.
Are they better today? Don't think so -- look at all the horror stories in this thread alone.
After enduring an annoying popping sound when turning slowly, I examined driver's front wheel well and discovered ALL of the front retaining screws on the stupid driver's side "rocker panel" have disappeared, and the panel is flopping around loose, scraping the lower body. Ridiculous.
I shouldn't have to spend my Saturdays working on a 4-year old car with only 56,000 miles. My 79 F 100 is less trouble than this thing!!!
Mine is a 93 3.8L with 81K miles. I am the second owner (bought it with 23K on it). So far no major engine/tranny problems; oil/filter change every 3K, tranny fluid/filter every 30K. By the posts I've been reading it seems like I might be on borrowed time.
1. I now have a small coolant leak at the timing chain case. Right now (according to the tech), it appears to be an external leak only. Very small leak (add a bit of coolant every couple months). My question...should I be concerned, given the nature of this engine?
2. Temp Gauge Question. When driving in stop/go traffic, the engine heats up enough for the fan to run. It comes on when the temp gauge is at about the "A" in "NORMAL" and the fan runs until the gauge is down to between the R and the M. On the highway it typically runs between the O and the R. Is this amount of fluctuation common? The car has never overheated, but wanted to know if other 3.8L owners experience a similar range. Given the problems with this engine, would a thermostat opening at lower temperature make sense?
TIA,
Roger
Don't change the thermostat. It will only trick the computer into thinking the engine hasn't warmed up.
My Dad has had 2 and absolutely loves them.
I have a 97 with 62k and love it. No problems.
You get a lot of bitching on these boards - some of it is legit - some of it is BS.
The only major thing I had done to it was replace the alternator at 63k. Mechanic said that the bearing was shot in the alternator and had to be replaced. 280.00 dollars later, car is driving like a champ. Have about 68k now. I get the tranny tuned up every 30k, tires rotated at 10k, oil change every 3-4k, etc and have not any problems. Don't let people fool you, they're great reliable cars and would recommend them to anyone looking for a 4door sedan.
Tony
aftermarket white(Xenox type)?
What are kind and where did you buy it?
Also last wk. in opening tailgate - oh my gosh...noticed high-mount third brake light lens and housing missing. First thought someone came in our driveway and removed, but then noticed a '97 wagon in dealer lot w/ same missing part. Possible adhesive worn and just 'blew' off ? Just paid $145 to local body shop to replace entire unit ($85) plus paint housing and assemble.
Thanks, hockeymom3
Does anybody have any good advice
I just lived with it.
Could you give me more info???