Hyundai Sonata 2005 and earlier

13468958

Comments

  • gonofurthergonofurther Member Posts: 5
    Hey Sonatafan, how's your baby doing at the pump? I've run two tanks through mine and have gotten 23 mpg just tooling around town. My wife was very concerned about gas mileage when we were looking around but loves this car so much that she hasn't mentioned it. Can't believe how much oomph this car has for a 4 banger, either. Did you read in the owner's manual that Hyundai recommends not exceeding 60 mph for the first 1000 miles? If I drove that slowly on the brief stretches of freeway I have to travel daily I'd be a menace. I'm really hoping that that old saw about letting the rings get worn in is hogwash. Thoughts?
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    I too have the 4cyl and thats what i get for mileage in town. It gets up to 28 easy on the highway.

    It is my wife's car and I am amazed how fast and easy it goes too. It is an automatic too. This is plenty fast for me. I would have a hard time keeping the 6 cyl on the ground, unless it is a dog as some reports say, but I doubt it is.

    I saw this ad today and well, I liked it alot and made a webpage of sorts. It may also be considered as KIA standard equipment. Look at the traditional KIA engineering in the product. Here is the link http://www.geocities.com/tonykrapil/CI/handsfree.htm

    See ya

    Tony
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    My Sonata averages between 22 and 24 MPG city. Most driving it gets is a good mix of the two and pushes 24+. I'm very happy with the performance of mine. Sometimes the transmission shift pattern bothers me but when I thump my right foot, she complies swiftly. I remember when I forst bought this car, I received a few comments from people about the large size of the 4 cyl. The block is big enough to be mistaken for a small 6.
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    I know you mention the seperate controller which I do have on the 6 disc unit I installed in my Echo. The funny part is, I have a KEH-P4800 Pioneer HU installed which has the IP Bus for direct connect changer, mini disc or single disc/EQ add ons. I bought a seperate Aiwa changer because I can't stand how teeny tiny the buttons are on the Pioneer. It's hard enough to use as it is, let alone add double function to some of the buttons! When I was in consumer electronics service, I hated Aiwa for their constant laser problems but I got a 4 year warranty thru Best Buy on it so no worries!!
  • drimpledrimple Member Posts: 47
    Curious that you guys are only get 22-24 mpg. My wife and I do about a 50/50 mix of city and freeway in our 2000 GLS and we get 24-25 mpg on average.
  • jomorisinjomorisin Member Posts: 11
    Yeah man I hear ya. I think the salesman there must have other jobs that are their primary source of income because playing games is their #1 activity and selling cars is somewhere way down on the list of things to do. Huntington Hyundai was mentioned as decent and Atlantic I was ok with too. I think I'm going for the 2001 from one of those 2 dealers, depending on who can beat at 19400 price for a loaded GLS w/Leather. Meanwhile, the players from Hempstead have been calling me non-stop for the past week. They can - with all due respect which isn't much - go scratch.

    Lets Go Mets!
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    gonofurther,

    I strongly suggest you follow the break-in procedures. All cars, from the most expensive to the least, require a break-in period. The first 500 miles are the most critical, but some manufacturers even have break-in procedures that stretch beyond 1000 miles. Follow it you must, if you care about the long term health of your engine. The break-in procedures are no hogwash - and it isn't only about ring seating either.

    Then again, if you leased the car or are gonna trade it in after 2 years, then you may not care (though the next owner may not appreciate it too much :-).

    We have a '99 4cyl 5sp Sonata and we typically get 25-28 city, 30+ hwy.

    Sonatafan, I understand about the tiny controls and button. This is the main reason I've always been partial to Sony car audio product. IMHO they've always had the best ergonomically designed UI. BTW, I believe Sony is the parent company of Aiwa.
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    I made my wife follow my break-in instructions to a Tee, and my own procedures make the factory recommendation look like a lap around Formula One circuit. ;-)

    A good break-in will manifest itself in more ways than one, not the least of which is better fuel economy.
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    Your'e correct, Sony is the parent company. All Aiwa CD players use Sony diode assemblies.
  • frdnotfarmfrdnotfarm Member Posts: 3
    I bought my glspk13 in Jan00, now have 29,000 +
    miles and it is great. But! my insurance company-FARM FAMILY-- is going nuts with the rate-- and it looks like ever since we bought another glspk13 for my wife in May, it has gotten worse.They just sent me an adjustment sheet that shows my 95 Montero going down by $550 a year and the gls going up by 1200 a year for a net increase of 770 a year with no accidents etc. to explain the change.
    Does anyone know of a less expensive carrier?
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    geezallmighty, those are some high rates. Is that for zero deductible in NYC? How much do you pay for your premiums a year? I pay less than $500 for two '99 cars.
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    I pay $1,300/year in Columbus, OH through Nationwide Ins. I am 22 and my wife is 25. We have a 2000 Hyundai Sonata and a 2000 Toyota Echo both insured 100/300 and a $100 deductible.
  • rich310rich310 Member Posts: 34
    Don't complain about high insurance rates until you move to New Jersey. When I was car shopping I inquired about premiums for different mid-size cars both with ABS and without ABS. Sonata was similar to its competitors.
  • suddenlysonatasuddenlysonata Member Posts: 19
    I hear you Rich, NJ does have the highest rates. But any company will rake you over the coals for high mileage, and I dare say that 29k miles since january is quite a lot! i personally use geico and pay about $1800 for full coverage on my 2000 Sonata GLS w/ pkg 13, w/ $1000 deductible, 100/300/50 and additional PIP/OBEL coverage. i'm 35yo F w/ a clean New York license (clean well over 10 yrs). The above rate also includes 100/300/50 w/ no comp/coll on a 1987 Toyota Cressida. I get a multi-car discount, defensive driver discount as well as the air bag discount. I have not yet installed an alarm so I'm not yet receiving the anti-theft discount. Hope this helps.
  • ayratayrat Member Posts: 26
    Hello,
    I'm considering Sonata. How is it for tall person?
    I'm 6'3". Did anybody notice the problems related
    to the subject so far? I'm riding Pontiac
    Bonneville '87 in its last days, very spacious.
    Any comments? Thanks.
    Ayrat.
  • drimpledrimple Member Posts: 47
    I am 6'4" and found that the headroom was a little squished in Sonatas that have the moon roof. However, I don't have any problems with my Sonata GLS, which has no moon roof.
  • ayratayrat Member Posts: 26
    What about driver's LegRoom? Is it big enough not to get tired during long trips? Any problems with the knees?
  • drimpledrimple Member Posts: 47
    I have no problem. The Sonata has quite a bit of legroom and a good amount of hiproom as well. However, every body is different so I recommend going to a dealership and actually sitting in one to see if it is comfortable for you.
  • allez1allez1 Member Posts: 3
    well, have decided on the Sonata 4 cyln. Any pro/con with the 5 speed vs auto? Thanks much.
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    Wouldn't a test drive answer these questions best? :-)

    About manual vs. auto. This is an intensely personal choice. We can argue till the cows come home, but it would mean nothing to you. I will say this though: Hyundai seems to have problems with their slushboxes in the recent past. Whether they've had them all worked out or not I do not know. The 5sp seems to be free of problems, but then again that may be because very few of them are sold here in NA.

    Drive both and decide for yourself whether the auto is worth an extra $500 and a hit on fuel economy.
  • allez1allez1 Member Posts: 3
    I ask only because I would like the stick...wife auto. I realize that with the stick you do have the wear and tear on a clutch. I though I had read somewhere of some problems with the stick.(?)
  • ayratayrat Member Posts: 26
    I went to dealer just to find out that headroom in moonroof models indeed is not enough. In certain positions my scalp was touching the roof with the seat lowered all the way down.
    Was so much disappointed, since everything else I liked much including legroom also. Unfortunately
    there is no pkg13 without moonroof :((( and ABS was my main concern. Seems I should think of different make...unfortunately.


    manual vs auto(to allezl): I think you do not need to worry about wear and tear on a clutch since, I guess, it covered by 10yrs-powertrain warranty.
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    Sorry to hear about the lack of room. You might want to try the XG300 if you can find one. There may be more room and the L version has memory seating. Of course, there is an increase in cost over the GLS w/pkg. 13. Just something to consider.
  • giowagiowa Member Posts: 599
    After putting about 9,200 miles on my '00 Sonata GLS V-6 w/5-speed & Pkg 13...

    1. The headroom with the sunroof is a bit tight, but can be overcome if you adjust the seat properly. No shortage of legroom, front or back.

    2. Manual significantly improves acceleration. However, due to gearing differences, the automatic turns over about 250 RPMs less at highway speeds. Thus there isn't too much difference in highway mileage; manual should get better city mileage. In the manual both 4th and 5th are overdrives. Sometimes forces you to downshift to 3rd when you want a direct drive 4th. 4th should be direct. Have had no problems with clutch. Seems to be wearing nicely. Shifting was a bit too notchy at first but has improved. Still not up to Nissan/Infiniti or BMW quality. Is really easy to spin the tires or just get out and go with the 5-speed. Automatic really saps power, esp. for passing.
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    I'm not absolutely sure but I think clutch is considered a wear and tear item like brake pads and therefore not covered under warranty, unless the wears are abnormal and not caused by owner abuse.

    That said, the clutch should last at the very least 60,000 mile and typically much more. My last car's original clutch lasted 150,000+ miles. Now, if you use the clutch pedal as a foot rest and/or pull jack rabbit starts at every green light, you might have a problem sooner. :-) Otherwise, the 5sp manual gearbox is much more maintenance-free than a slushbox.

    The only problem I've heard on the Sonata 5sp is winter cold start hard shifting.
  • greg_ggreg_g Member Posts: 9
    I'm just shy of 6'3'' and have found that any car in the Sonata's size category with a moonroof gives me no headroom at all (Camry,Maxima,626). Unless one opts for a TOwncar or Crown Vic there is little choice except to buy without that that option. LET's GO METS!!!!!! YA GOTTA BELIEVE!!!
  • frdnotfarmfrdnotfarm Member Posts: 3
    Thanks for the info on rates. I had called my agent about the increases and she finally got back to me and left a message that those increases were a huge mistake etc. and I will be getting a new bill with much lower rated. Squeakeywheel? who knows but I will be really shopping around. Did I ever mention how long it was before I realized that the key hole is illuminated at night?(after you pull on the handle)
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    Got the ol' recall notice late last week. My dealer has his Hyundai Techs in class learning how to re-program the engine control module. Won't start doing the work until next week at the earliest.
    Jeez---I hope they don't screw up the programming. This car's performance has been flawless. I'd prefer them to only do the re-route of the harness but Hyundai wants to go the whole nine yards.
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    I wish *sob* that MY Sonata had an illuminated keyhole!
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    Your post took me a sec to figure out, I did not read it as sobbing.

    I will probably take mine in tomorrow. I do have a drivers door lock trouble where it does not open all the doors, but that is not going to be touched. The window washer pump is not working. The relay operates but no pump effort. Could be pump or wiring from relay.

    Let ya know how they do if I get it in.

    Tony
  • paul155paul155 Member Posts: 1
    Just bought a 2000 GSL last night. Price was 16650 including mats, Cal. emissions, destination, and advertising. I also got the 0.9% financing.
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    Wife tells me the Window washer dont spray any juice. I see her press the button and nothing happens. I pressed it a few times too and nothing but wipers goin.

    Not even a thought of doubting MY wife on which button is REALLY the window washer button I go to he dealer at lunch.

    He wants me to come back on Monday. I ask him if he has the parts NOW, so I dont waste my time on MOnday. While he is checking a mechanic comments 'nice car, we dont see many of them, is there something wrong?' I tell him and he says NO WAY, Hyundai's dont have troubles.... Gimmme the key he says.

    He hopes in and has it spraying allllllll over the place. DUH, ya dont push the intermittent wipe button on the end, ya PULL the lever back to make it spray! I was their Friday Joke.

    NOW, you guys know how to do it!! This is worse that the child proof locks!!

    Tony
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    I did the EXACT same thing way back when I bought mine last January!!!! My wife was pushing the button and saying the washer didn't work and, of course, I didn't challenge her intelligence and I continued whacking the button on the end as well. I ended up going so far as to pop the panel below the bumper to access the washer motor! We ended up taking the car in and just like you, he hopped in and sprayed it right away. Of course I didn't admit it to him but my wife and I just looked at each other. The tech said "must have been frozen and thawed out on the way down here". I said "yup must've been it, ummmm thanks man". Now I don't feel so bad!
  • dunn3dunn3 Member Posts: 29
    I don't know what to say; feel bad for both of you about the washer. but you should have looked at the little stalk and figured it out. I didn't realize that the button was for the wipers going by just once until driving it for a while; by the way; 5500 miles and loving my GLS
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    Am I the only one who actually reads the owners manual? I mean---that's what it's for---to answer these little questions.
    Just kidding, guys. We've all done something similar at sometime in our lives. Just today my keyless stopped working. Light would glow when buttons were pressed but nothing would happen. My wife's worked fine. Took me awhile to figure out maybe it needed to be reprogrammed. I was only minutes away from running off to the dealer for a quick fix. Haven't been able to test it yet but I'm hoping that's all it is.
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    Astrol,

    You have read the owners manual EVEN after your wife identified a problem???? Are you nuts man?

    Sonatfan and myself have encyclopedias for sale since we have gotten married. We dont need all them books anymore, we have a wife.

    Tony
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    Yes, sometimes I foolishly brave new territory without thought of the consequences. It is dangerous, I know, but then the Mrs. isn't always on her game...some things just kind of slide under the radar.
    This is a long-winded way of saying I got LUCKY.
  • giowagiowa Member Posts: 599
    In today's Omaha World-Herald's Automotive section they've published a story from the San Antonio Express-News on the Kia Optima. Excerpt:

    "Two trim levels will be offered: the base LX, which includes AC, PW/PL/PM, and intermittent wipers; and the top-of-the-line SE, which adds alloy wheels with Michelin tires, heated exterior mirros, FOG LIGHTS, moon roof, keyless entry with alarm, cruise control, premium stereo with cassette and CD player, leather-wrapped steering wheel, 8-way power driver's seat and wood interior trim ... STANDALONE OPTIONS INCLUDE 4-speed automatic transmission, ANTILOCK BRAKES, cruise control, and LEATHER INTERIOR." (emphasis added)

    So unlike the Sonata, the Optima buyer can get ABS without having to go to a Pkg 13. And they can get fog lights! Now why in the heck can't Hyundai do this??? And why won't Hyundai or Kia add a sport suspension and 16" tire upgrade as options? Too bad Hyundai isn't using Kia to address a different market, i.e., sports oriented.

    When it comes to cars, you guys gotta put the pants on in the family. Wife and I have our respective spheres of dominance. She controls the house & yard while I control the cars. This division of labor works great. God intended woman to ride not drive; that is why there are illuminated visor vanity mirrors on the passenger side. They should be banned from the driver's side. (Just kidding!) :)
  • suddenlysonatasuddenlysonata Member Posts: 19
    Count me in as one of the stalk-pushers. Guess I should have read the manual too. Funny I really thought the guy who showed me all the bells and whistles was very thorough, but he didn't show me how to do the child safety locks either! So tell me, are there any other hidden surprises in this baby? BTW I'm getting the alarm w/ the remote start put in next weekend, now that I've found my car is NOT affected by the recall (phew!). Too bad it won't be in time for the snow they are predicting tomorrow! So tell me, those of you with the experience, how does the Sonata GLS w/ pkg 13 handle in the snow? Does the traction control make any difference?
  • frdnotfarmfrdnotfarm Member Posts: 3
    Last winter I got stuck driving in a freezing rain/snow mix for about 2 1/2 hours to go what is a normal 45 min. drive. Much stop and roll and saw about four or five accidents. Terrible conditions with slush, rutted roads with compacted ice--get the picture? The traction control only engaged one time and that was when I punched the accelerator on an up hill section just to see if it was working. The suspension etc. was so good that I never needed the tc. My opinion is that the car really does not need the tc but the abs is very important so since you can't get one with out the other.....On the other hand I had a Buick that the tc was vital on since it engaged quite often in snowy weather.
    In short the car handles quite well in the snow--just as good as my Montero LS in 4 wheel drive--for on road snowey driving.
  • sonatafansonatafan Member Posts: 171
    Here's another one: If you open the trunk and look at the latch mechanism (the part on the trunk lid itself) you will see a little lever, either black or white in color. This lever can be flipped to disengage the remote trunk release by the driver's seat. Comes in handy when you leave your car with a valet or if you have valuables in the trunk.
  • giowagiowa Member Posts: 599
    1. I only bought my '00 Sonata GLS w/Pkg 13 in May, so I haven't had her in snow or ice yet. However, the TC routinely comes on when I drive on gravel roads or in rain. It may be because I have the 5-speed. She is much easier, and more fun, to drive her hard than in the much slower automatic GLS. Just this morning on way to church I was accelerating through a stop light while turning right hard. TC kicked in for a second, doing what it is designed to do. The road was wet and it was raining.

    I remember test driving an automatic GLS w/Pkg 13. Had it up to 100 mph. Tried to drive it hard and fast over the same roads I normally do. She accelerated very slow. Even flooring from a complete stop it was hard to spin the tires. That tranny really saps power. So I can see why the TC might not come on much in an automatic. They just aren't as fun to drive and I doubt they get driven too hard. Buyers of manuals tend to wring more out of their vehicles.

    2. Is t-h-c down again? I haven't been able to get into the discussion area for days. Computer says something about some problem accessing. I can get to all the other portions of t-h-c, just not the discussion area.
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    The T-H-C.org site is having probs. with the forums access...probably related to the earlier downtime episode. The error message I get is related to the compiler libraries.
    Enough already with the auto put-downs. You never miss an opportunity. Why is it that the auto owners NEVER feel the need to point out the downsides of manual trannys. Perhaps it is because they are able to give people credit for having a brain of their own with which they can make up their own minds.
    For the record, the auto car you drove must have been one hell of a dog as I can make my tires chirp any time I want. All cars can be driven hard, no matter the tranny. It is a matter of personal choice.
    What kind of personal insecurity drives you on this point? It must truly be a sore spot to keep the never-ending remarks flowing. You are a 5-speed fan. Great for you. End of story.
    Jeeeesh!
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    First off, Astrol, it was needed to said, Yo da Man!


    Second, Car Insurance. I have a teenager that will be licensed any day now and have been shopping for insurance. I used to have nationwide and they have always had some good rates. I was looking at Edmunds site and noticed that had some on-line insurance companies so I took a look. My rate for two cars went from 660 for 6 months to 530 with some great coverage. You may want to check em out. eCOVERAGE is the name they go by. It was actually a pleasant experience to be your own agent. You can see the costs before you actually sign up. It gave me the same feeling as someone we know gets while shifting his Fisher-Price busy box transmission.

    Thirdly, I was a bit bored the other day. I have read some reports that faulty spark plugs were the culprit on some Hyundai 'check engine lights' and have always been curious about Hyundai NOT advertising a LONG interval for tune-ups and long life plugs and coolant etc.

    I got some Bosch Platimum+4 plugz and put em in my base model Sonata. It was a simple job and took all of about 30 mins max.

    The old plugs looked fine in every respect, BUT I did notice BOTH spark pacs did not have fully seated control connectors. I am sure they were fine, BUT was able to push them together a significant amount.

    Now, for the rewarding news. Wife called today from work and asked what I did to the car. She said it has a lot more power than usual. See surprised me as I didnt think she would notice a thing. Her comment made it all worth it.

    See ya,

    Tony
  • dunn3dunn3 Member Posts: 29
    I went to turn her on this morning ("Moony" as my 00 GLS w/ pckg. 13 is more commonly know around these parts) and she wouldn't turn on; only 5900 miles. My girlfriend did kill that battery a couple of days ago by leaving the lights on, so I don't know what the trouble is..... Left the car b/c I had to go to work; will keep you all posted; don't know whether I should blame Hyundai or my girlfirend :(
  • giowagiowa Member Posts: 599
    Do you know how hard it is in middle America to actually buy a V-6 4-dr sedan with manual transmission? Almost an instant collectible (not) but at least a real conversation piece. Can't count the number of compliments and questions I get from people who see it, ride it, sell it, or service it. All are positive.

    Have you driven a manual GLS V-6? If not, give it a try! If you are ever in Omaha, NE, or Des Moines, IA, or Kansas City, MO, let me know and maybe we could meet? I'd be happy to let you drive her!

    What, pray tell, are the downsides to a manual transmission? I drive both types regularly and I know of only one: can't say I like parallel parking them on hills. But depending upon my mood, I either try or just find another spot. Other than that, as long as the clutch is light and the engagement smooth, even stop & go traffic doesn't bother me much. But I do know the serious disadvantages of automatics, regardless of how good they are. Add weight, complexity, reliability issues, cost, reduce performance, decrease fuel economy, etc. And in winter, the manual gives you so much more control and options than the automatic does.

    Check out what the Automotive press and various testers have said about the Sonata 4-speed automatic. C&D, 9/99: GLS "Lows: slow-to-react transmission... drivetrain is hobbled by a fuzzy-logic four-speed that is fuzzy about which gear to select. Deep stabs into the gas are required before downshifts snap to." Or Bob Geffen, Arizona Republic, 7/17/99: "Compounding this problem, the automatic transmission seemed reluctant to downshift unless I pressed hard on the accelerator...I would have much preferred the available stick shift." Daniel Heraud's ROAD TEST 2000: "CONS:... Transmission. The automatic is balky and shifting can be jarring at low speeds. Kickdown is far from instantaneous and drivers have to allow a delay to take advantage of engine braking or to accelerate."

    All I know is I verified these attributes myself when I took an automatic GLS V-6 out into the empty rural countryside for a lengthy and demanding spin (e.g., had her up to 100 mph and slammed the brakes, floored it from stops, etc.). I knew quickly that the automatic, just like the one in my wife's $39,400 Lincoln LS8 Sport, isn't up to a decent manual tranny. They are fine for some, but I say go with what gives you maximum driving pleasure and performance (and saves you money up front and at the pumps). I immediately special ordered my manual. It was worth it!
  • tonykrapiltonykrapil Member Posts: 211
    C'mon already give it a rest. Unlike you, I could NOT care less if Hyundai makes another manual transmission automobile. Same goes for specific color etc. There seems to be an obsession in the air over this transmission.

    We are not going to tell you how to think and what to think about...... however, your transmission [non-permissible content removed] is starting to really stink.

    Drop it already.
  • giowagiowa Member Posts: 599
    I really don't see any need to swear. Least you could do is say something like "s**t".

    The one thing you don't argue about is the serious degradation in overall performance of the automatic transmission Sonata GLS V-6s in comparison to manual transmission.

    I'd like to see Hyundai improve the breed and offer more choices. And I think owners should know what they are getting into with the car, not unrealistically assessments. Why not be honest with people who read these posts? The V-6 automatic transmission's performance has been routinely panned by many, many reviewers.

    The performance figures generated by automatic models haven't lived up to what a 6-cyl car in this weight category should produce. 9/99 C&D comparison test, Sonata GLS V-6 auto tied for second-to-last place 0-60 mph w/4-cyl auto Altima at 9.9 secs and only better than the 4-cyl auto Camry (10.5 secs). It had the worst 30-50 mph top gear time and third worst 50-70 mph top gear time. C&D's 4/99 test had 0-60 in 9.5 secs; MT's 5/99 test in 10.3 secs; Heraud's '99 Guide in 10.0 secs; and Heraud's '00 Guide in 9.1 secs. Regardless of how you slice it, that's pretty much 4-cyl performance in a 6-cyl. Shouldn't a 6 perform like a 6? And yes, I know, performance figures, including 0-60 times, aren't everything. But Hyundai does charge a lot more to get the 6 cyl. Buyers should get a commensurate increase in performance. The automatic lets the buyer down. :)
  • volfyvolfy Member Posts: 274
    Had one too many martinis again, huh? :-) Sounded like you're back to yer old self again there, giowa.

    I like rowing gears too, but everyone's needs and wants are different. There's no need to beat everybody's head bloody preaching the virtues of a good 5sp.

    I just came back from a 12-hr road trip that should have taken 9hrs max - all because of a 15-car pile up over a bridge on I-35 south of Denton, TX. My still spazzing left thigh is currently twice the size of my right one.

    Like the Porsche commercial says: "Even Heaven has its moments of Hell." :-)

    Chill out, giowa.
  • astrolastrol Member Posts: 312
    My friend---
    Sounds like you're "on a mission from God". Please cease this personal 'Blues Brothers' routine. There are always going to be valid reasons why manual trannys will simply not do for some people. Ever heard of of arthritic knees? Ankles? Ever considered the fact that ANYONE who can drive can operate an automatic? In an emergency? Ever heard of people just getting tired of all the kinetics involved in daily bumper-to-bumper commutes? I know I have.

    I am very glad that you have the vehicle you want with the tranny you desire. I have said this before and it bears repeating. Now, please show the rest of us the same courtesy.

    I understand your concerns about performance. All engines are not equal as all trannys are not equal. Some manuals have horrific action and continuously detract from the driving experience, performance or no. This 2.5 V-6 is certainly no stoplight winner with either tranny. Engine-wise there is a torque hole which can be managed only through proper gear usage. Much of this has to do with the final gearing of both trannys. It is deliberately relaxed in the auto for EPA numbers. A 3.36 final drive ratio is not going to help a torque bereft engine no matter what tranny it relates to. I know you will agree.
    As to personal experience, I find no problems with this autobox that cannot be managed to my satisfaction. As you know, I like to shift my autos for better performance and therefore will agree with you on the vagueries of 'thinking autoboxes'. For most of my cut and thrust driving I prefer to control the action leaving the 'D' out of the picture until suitable road and speed conditions are attained. This is just my personal preference. I make no demands upon other autobox drivers. They may drive as they wish.

    You know full well that the trend is against you. I do not blame you for 'fighting the good fight' as you see it but must you do it at the expense of your fellow forum buds. The proper place for your concerns would be better directed towards the manufacturers. They are the ones who are trending against your desires. But they see the writing on the wall. The future is in the automatic transmission...5 speeds and tiptronic control. This may be a sad fact to you but it is likely a happy one to the rest of us.
    Peace brother.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.