Ford Windstar Problems
Please continue discussing and posting your
Windstar troubles here.
Thanks!
KarenS
Vans host
Previous topic:
Ford Windstar Problems
Windstar troubles here.
Thanks!
KarenS
Vans host
Previous topic:
Ford Windstar Problems
0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
You can imagine how dangerous this is when getting on the highway and trying to accelerate. It's been in for fixing twice, the dealer's noticed it too and said that it was "just the way the engine is built" - ridiculous.... anyone else experiencing this?
Also - How long, hard is the process for a Ford Buyback (from the resolution board)?
My dealer (Richmond Ford) tells me that I will be out at least $1000 just to pull the transmission to look at it, not to mention parts. They think that it is a "band" that works reverse and first gear. I guess that I will start a letter writing campaign to Ford to try and get them to pay for some of this now that my warranty has finally run out.
Now, I am beginning to believe those who feel that Ford stands for "Found On Road Dead". This vehicle was great for the first 36K mi, but 2 sets of head gaskets and now the second transmission repair in under 60K mi leaves me doubting about Ford quality. I should have unloaded this bucket of bolts several years ago. The only smart thing that I did do was to get another car for my every day commuting. This thing was retired to weekend duties and hauling of canoes and bicycles.
I have had the following thoughts about this bucket of bolts:
1. Push it off a cliff into the New River (the Ford dealer in Beckley who I initially consulted about this problem liked this idea. They could not get to the vehicle for a week because of an onslaught of transmission problems. I drove it back to Richmond to get it looked at)
2. Leave it where we were rock climbing as a shelter for climbers caught in the rain (the Park Service would probably not approve)
3. Donate it to the Kidney Foundation and take the charity deduction (the best idea, I think, given the crummy trade in value that this thing commands)
I am stuck--the resale value on this bucket of bolts is only $2500 without a new transmission, $6000 - $7000 with a rebuilt one.
I investigated giving the thing to the Kidney Foundation and taking the tax writeoff. The IRS is tricky--you need to get a professional appraisal for anything over $5000 and the appraiser must sign IRS form 8283 where you make the deduction. If the charity sells the vehicle within 2 years, they must declare the sale value on another form to the IRS. As far as I can tell, the only benefit is if you are donating a vehicle worth less than several grand.
I will replace the transmission (it will have a 2 year, 24K warranty on it) and then sell this thing pronto!
2004 Honda Accord EX-L Graphite Pearl
2007 Honda Civic EX - Atomic Blue
2013 Honda Civic LX - Crimson Pearl
Attention Honda, Toyota, GM, and Chrysler: offer 95 Windstar owners a $2000 incentive to buy one of your vans. Ford is offering KBB "poor" trade in values for them, so you can always offer the same and wholesale it to some "Sanford & Son" Ford dealer. I think you might find a lot of Ford owners who are willing to forgo the extra $2,000 and buy one of your vans.
PJYoung's analysis of the "buyback" is pretty correct, and you should consider this carefully. As referenced above, too, many have looked at the economics of the "deal," and found it acceptable, many with the intent of getting rid of the new Ford before the 3 year warranty is up. You can do that, too, if you think that would be the only way to get out of this miserable situation. Only you can decide if you would be able to stand getting into another Ford product again. We lost a lot of money when we traded our 95WS in last year, but it was water under the bridge in my book. And I got to get rid of the knot in my stomach.
I think PJYoung's suggestion to Honda, Toyota, etc is a good one in this climate of the buybacks/trade-ins. But I don't think Honda will take them up on it, considering they don't really have to even try selling the Odys right now!
Good Luck to you anightmare. I hope you can figure out the best plan for your family.
Has anyone else had this problem of this grinding sound, and what do you think it is?
Thanks
I would love to hear from anyone who has solved this problem. I love my van and really hate the thought of getting rid of it.
Thanks
I am now going to get my 95 WS detailed and then off to the used car lot` with it. I will wait awhile before replacing it and make do with my VW Cabrio and my wife's Outback. The only problem is that the Outback is a little small when we pile on the kayak/bicycles/camping stuff/etc. It is also a problem if grandparents want to ride when we are visiting. The Cabrio is a hoot of a commuting vehicle (bombing around with the top down is a great stress reliever) in and thusfar has been trouble free wehicle. I will miss the comfortable ride and big junk carrying capacity of the WS.
I hope that with a rebuilt transmission and ??new and improved head gaskets (second replacement put on in 8/99) my 95 WS will give someone else at least 40 - 50K relatively trouble free miles (or am I being too optimistic?).
I have a '99 Windstar that so far has been fine, but then again it only has 4,000 miles on it! However, ever since we purchased it in January we had trouble getting the cruise control to work. We've taken it in three times to the dealer who said they found nothing wrong with it. My husband and I have both tried to use it and it only works about 20% of the time and sometimes it will not at the beginning of a trip and work 10 minutes later. Now, I know this is not a major problem. Just annoying.
By the way, I have also heard a grinding noise when starting. This has happened only a handful of times and no other problems have shown up yet...Thank goodness.
As for the cruise control, the repairmen said that he has a Windstar that does the same thing and that sometimes you just have to play with it a little to get it to work. I hope that's not his answer for everything that goes wrong from now on!
You see all the commercials about how safe and sound the car is, and it's a piece of crap. Poor engineering, poor build quality. And to think at one time, I was actually considering buying a Windstar (I didn't).
For anyone considering a Windstar, please read these posts and strongly familiarize yourself with the Honda Odyssey and Toyota Sienna.
Unfortunately, you will find that the trade value on the vehicle is bad (to say the least). Most auto dealerships are now aware of the infamous 95 Windstar and the 3.8L engine troubles, therefore, they offer a pittance compared to what it is worth. My 95 with 63000 was worth $4500 to a local dealership when I started looking to trade (Jan-Feb-Mar this year). I have since decided to wait until the van either dies or I manage to pay it off (in about two years).
Whatever you do, please provide a posting of how the dealership treats you and you general experience with the vehicle update process. Good Luck!
2004 Honda Accord EX-L Graphite Pearl
2007 Honda Civic EX - Atomic Blue
2013 Honda Civic LX - Crimson Pearl
Thanks in advance.
P.S. Love the Odyssey and would definitely recommend it (or the Sienna) to those of you who will soon be parting with your current van due to reliability issues.
My second vehicle is a '92 Honda Accord that has 240,000 mi. and I've never had a major problem, and hardly even a minor problem. I'm sorry to say, but generally I've determined that while Ford (WS in particular)is clearly at the bottom of the barrel, domestic cars in general can't stand the reliability tests that Hondas and Toyotas can. I will probably never own anything else again other than a Honda or Toyota.
Read Post #45. Do yourself a favor and go with either a Honda or Toyota. I have a 99 Accord and an 89 Camry. The Camry is rusting away, but it takes licking and keeps on ticking.
Spend the extra $$ on a Honda and Toyota and you won't have to worry anyomre about replacing transmissions and worrying about headgaskets.
Chuck's EMAIL notes that Ford has an internal document about transmission failures and that presently they are compensating transmission victims on a case-by-case basis.
Further information is available at:
http://www.lemonaidcars.com/secret_warranties.htm
and
http://blueovalnews.com/fordtrans.htm
Thanks.
What I had to do was to make sure the seat was as far back as possible to comfortably work both the gas and brake pedal. This allows me to work the brake pedal without pulling my right foot up excessively to get the brake pedal. I pull my foot up at the ankle therefore working the tendons in the top of my foot. You probably lift your whole leg therefore working your knee. Stop and go traffic causes you to work the brake more.
I had to compensate for the seat position further back with a more upright seat back (than I usually like) to maintain the proper arm position.
The car manufacturers raised the brake pedals higher off the floor than the gas pedal so that the idiot drivers wouldn't get the 2 pedals confused (ala Audi 5000s remember).
Let us know if that works.
We have not had any problems at all with this van and love everything about it otherwise, but this grinding noise is something we will be checking into!