We are aware of the login problems affecting the forums, and appreciate your patience as we work on a fix.
Did you recently purchase a new Tesla, Rivian or Lucid vehicle directly from the manufacturer and willing to share how your experience compared to previous vehicle purchases made through a traditional dealer? A reporter would like to speak with you; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 2/19 for details.
Comments
C.B.
But -- want a new car! If I could buy a Caprice Wagon or equivalent, would do so in a heartbeat.
Since that is not possible, am considering subject 3 cars. I've given each a short test drive and decided I can fit my arthritic 6'2" frame with 35" inseam in all three as long as they have a tilt wheel. (Toyata Sienna and H. Odessey are out because I can't do that).
I haul long or big stuff not infrequently and haul a lot of luggage, etc on quarterly trips between Florida, Virginia, and Texas. Have no need for a 3rd seat and like the Stow & Go of the G. Caravan.
Seldom have 2nd seat passengers, but, of course, need comfort there for when I do.
Have never owned a truck or SUV and do not know if I will like the Durango (although the short test ride was very good). Am now in process of arranging a 1-day rental for each of these (no mean feat, especially for Magnum).
Will also look at Taurus Wagon as a friend has had excellent experience with a 98 and I like to drive her car.
Overall cost to own is important to me (but over a 10-year period).
Would love to hear opinions as to what I should consider and watch out for. (Will also post this on specific car sites).
However, I have never heard of a lighted turn signal/washer stalk or hood release and parking brake release. Wiper/washer/turn signal stalks are (ir should be) so easily intuitive that no one should have trouble operating these even blindfolded after just a day or two of use.
The hood release shouldn't be used when the car is moving anyway and is so rarely used it needs no lighting as you can turn on your interior lights when stopped and see everything.
Almost the same goes for the parking brake release, and again, these handles are usually fairly large and easy to feel for without lighting if you have driven the car a few times.
Two months later, it died again and the dealer replaced the battery. I hadn't left the lights on that time, so I figured I had a bad battery.
Now, less than a month later and only 200 miles, the new battery completely drained. This time, I was told it had not been connected properly and that I'm driving it long enough distances.
Glad to hear that I'm not the only one with this problem. It's riduculous. Especially on a new car.
About the lighted steering wheel controls, the following vans have them lighted:
- Honda Odyssey (Audio controls)
- Toyota Sienna (Audio controls)
- Ford Freestar (Audio + Cruise controls)
- GM Minivans (Audio controls)
- Nissan Quest (Audio - don't know about cruise/climate).
So Chrysler/Dodge are among the few vans who don't offer anything of the above.
GM, Ford & the new Odyssey are the only vans to offer lighted controls for power windows & door locks. GM is the only one who offers lighted mirror controls as well.
My memory is sufficient that I can recall the controls on the steering wheel.
For me, the quiet, smooth ride of a DC minivan with separately controlled temperature for driver and front passenger is MUCH more important than lighted steering wheel controls.
1) long wheelbase
2) the rear zone a/c and controls
3) rear seat dvd system
What is the most economical configuration of a T&C model & options to get this?
1. Do you want 2nd row bucket seats?
2. Do you want "Stow-N-Go"?
3. Do you want the 3.8L or is the 3.3L enough?
The Grand Caravan SE does NOT have 2nd row bucket seats, no Stow-N-Go, and has the 3.3L. You can add tri-zone (driver, front passenger, rear) and the DVD "Rear Entertainment" to the GC SE and it will COST thousands less than the Chrysler T&C LX with Stow-N-Go or GC SE Plus.
If you want Stow-N-Go, the best value is the GC SXT that has cast wheels and the 3.8L V6 for about $100 more than the T&C LX or GC SE Plus. The rear dvd comes as a stand alone package on almost any Chrysler or Dodge minivan.
However, a volume DC dealer may have a minivan with the options you want + a few extra and will give a BIG discount to move it. In this situation, you may get more than you want than to just order a plain GC SE with tri-zone and DVD rear entertainment system.
P.S. I have almost 6,000 miles on my 3rd Chysler mini van and the 2005 is by far the best yet and having only taken my 2005 back to the dealer once and that was for an oil change and a missing clip for the over head console.
The 60/40 split fold into the floor 3rd row seat is a BIG advantage (copied from Sienna) but the compromise with 2nd row is not worth it to me: armrests too narrow and uncomfortable, sharp edges with mechanisms that are very likely to pinch fingers, and the lack of toe room under 2nd row seats for the 3rd row passengers.
The lazy susan feature of the 2005 Odyssey is of lesser value than the loss of storage space in the left rear where the spare tire now resides.
It appears that vehicle designers are more interested in getting some clever gimmicks than just adding significant new features and keeping nice features included in earlier models. DC should have copied the 2nd row design of the 1999 Odyssey that was also copied by the Mazda MPV. DC should have also used a 5 speed automatic like Odyssey, Sienna, Chrysler 300C, etc. have.
DC should have kept the heating coils at the base of the windshield and the "Instant Economy" reading on the Trip Computer for example. The small additional cost of these items is not worth the loss of sales caused by removing these items.
However, one of premium group options is a "Touring Suspension". Does anybody know the difference between the regular suspension and the Touring suspension?
Other options in the Premium package includes power liftgate, auto temp., vehicle information center, power adjustable pedals, all worthwhile options (for me, at least).
Too bad I can't get the upgraded stereo w/o leather seats for am additional $2,000.
So, do you know anything about the touring suspension?
Having said that, I have just taken delivery of my new GC SXT with premium group, and I am very pleased. I ordered black with the light greystone/khaki leather interior, and it is really nice looking. I gather this is an unusual combination, and several of the sales and service staff were ogling the vehicle, this colour combination apparently being uncommom. The leather colour is quite light so it might not please people with kids, but it makes the interior very light and open. I was disappointed that I had to give up the option of side air bags because I really wanted the sunroof. I don't know why anyone would spend the extra money it costs for a TC.
http://www.allpar.com/model/m/grand-caravan-2005.html
The Chrysler T&C offers some more gadgets than GC SXT, that's why it cost you more $$. It have, among others, auto headlamps; auto dim rearview mirrors (both inside and outside); more chrome and wood trim; memory feature on the Limited, and more.
Do you feel the ride stiff?
Dodge have changed around the power liftgate option within the groups. Since you took delivery recently, please let me know.
Disclaimer: my normal ride is a 530i with the Sport Package (including a stiffer suspension and lower profile tires), so any review I give on this matter might be a little suspect. ;-)
Best Regards,
Shipo
C.B.
C.B.
We got a Linen Gold model with the power tailgate as the only option. This is the van I wish Honda and Toyota would build...cloth seats, no DVD, and power sliders/tailgate.
We are leasing for 24 mos. so not worried about long term durability. I'll update occasionally to tell how it's going.
I have it for nearly a week now, and am almost satisfied, but (hold your breath) there are still some things I like way better in my Windstar – every change is difficult, and changing a vehicle is no different.
I was undecided which way to go, Ford Freestar (SEL) or Dodge Grand Caravan (SXT) – they are both very similar equipped, and are much lower priced than any other van. I definitely needed the rear seat which flushes into the floor, so GM vans were out of the question. And since I’m leasing (now called “smart buy”), long term reliability and resale value was 2 things I did not care about.
Let me say first what I like about the new Dodge Caravan. The ride is smooth and quiet; power is more than enough for my needs, although the engine is not as quiet as I expected; turning circle is also much tighter than Windstar/Freestar; the LCD of the radio is much superior over the Windstar/Freestar; much more room for passengers in all seating positions (except toe room for 3rd row seaters); the 60/40 rear seat is just terrific and much superior to the one piece design of the Freestar (though I don’t need the second row stow’n’go seats which are very uncomfortable – according to many of my passengers); And from what I’ve read, mileage should also be much better than the Ford vans. So far I can not test it because I still have less than 300 miles, and my trip computer averages 14.6 MPG; I also like the 8-way power seats over 6-way from Ford.
Now what I like better in the Ford Freestar: Lights! So many more lights all over, including lamps at the bottom of the car (where the pedals are located) for the driver & passenger, and second row stepwell lamps, and I love the baby sleeping mode (where all bottom lights illuminate and none of the overhead lights, so if you (or a baby) sleep it won’t disturb you when a passenger opens a door to leave).
Then there is the illuminated cruise control, illuminated audio controls, signal mirrors and puddle lamps below the outside mirrors; and illuminated controls for power door locks & windows. I also like the cargo lamp in the Freestar over the liftgate lamp in the Caravan, since the Freestar’s lamp lights straight on the cargo, unlike the Caravan which illuminated the outside of the van when liftgate is open, not on the cargo direct. But the Caravan does have standard 3rd row reading lamps (which helps brighten the rear area), where the Freestar only offers it on the Limited model. I also like in the Freestar when you unlock the van, the headlamps automatically comes on (even on the manual controlled headlamps equipped models).
I think the seats in the Freestar are a little more comfortable, but this may change soon, since the seats in the Caravan are still extremely firm, and will probably get better and softer with the time.
After test driving the Freestar, I must say that the handling is much better than the Windstar, and not far away from DC vans. Actually, to say the truth, I think that the 2005 DC vans are way too soft (the ’03 T&C I drive in business is much better in both, firm ride and handling), even though I have the “touring” suspension, the ride is way too soft, and you don’t feel connected to the road at all, plus it have some side to side rocking. This may be due to the underbody redesign with the stow’n’go seats. So I would prefer the ride and handling of the Freestar over the ’05 Dodge Grand Caravan (but not over the ’03). Too bad I did not test driven the DC before, b/c I assumed it will be the same as the T&C I drive at work.
Glove box is extremely small and useless in the Dodge Caravan, and not much better in the Freestar. I’ve rented 2 weeks ago a small Mazda3, which, among other excellent things, have a HUGE glove box (about 4 times as big) which was, by the way, illuminated. Both, the Freestar and Caravan, lack a light in the glove box.
Today was the first real snow here in upstate NY, and I just wished myself that DC vans should still offer the heated stripes in the bottom of the windshield (wiper de-icer). It would be so useful.
Another thing I like in the Dodge Caravan which Freestar lacks, is a drawer under the front passenger seat, which is very useful to store smaller items. On the other hand, the Freestar has a cover on the bin below the climate controls which is also very useful. The Caravans bin is useless with no cover. And Freestar also have the bin on top of the windshield, and much more useful storage bins and bottle holders on the doors which DC don’t have.
The Freestar offers panic assist brakes, all-speed traction control and stability control, while DC vans offer none of them, with the exception of low-speed traction (up to 30 or 35 mph). Big difference in safety.
I also think the transmission in the Freestar is a bit smoother than the DC. But the engine is definitely much more refined in the DC vans, although my van still vibrates slightly while idle.
Other things I like in the Freestar over the DC vans: 10 minute power accessory delay (vs. 45 seconds on the DC); separate remote control for lock/unlock doors – although you schlep less things with all the buttons built-into the key (as DC vans), it’s very difficult to use without looking each time what button you press; Keypad entry; Controls for rear wiper much smarter design in the Freestar; Outside mirrors is closer to the doors and don’t have that big blind spot DC vans have – but both, the Freestar and Caravan have relatively small mirrors, in contrast to the Toyota Sienna and Nissan Quest which have HUGE useful mirrors; fuel tank capacity (Freestar have 26 gallon vs. DC have 20 gallon – even though the DC have better mileage.)
That’s approximately my observes the first few days, having had a Windstar for 3 years (with almost no problems) and test driving Freestars, and decided on a Dodge Grand Caravan. I will definitely find some more issues as time passes, and I will probably post them here.
If Chrysler / Dodge read this board, I again ask them: Please restore all the good stuff you eliminated the last few years from your vans! You used to be the best and most luxury on the market; don’t let yourself fall more and more. True, you have stow’n’go seats, but that’s not enough to compete with other competitions. Bring back the illuminated key ring; The safety/reflector lamps on the front doors; Dual liftgate lamps; Dual lamps on sun visors with variable brightness; Visor extender; Covers for all the storage bins around the van, included the bin below the climate control and cup holders, and included the 3d row seat bins; Light in the glove box; Wiper de-icer; Illuminate all controls for easy night viewing; and then copy some more stuff from your competitors. I really hope the
My Chrysler T&C LX has most of those nice items you mentioned...and the LX was the "bottom of the line" Town & Country in 2002.
SO, what is the difference in the two and should I just buy the cheaper of the two.
4roses
Problem in the Town Country is that you need to get leather in order to get some of the above features, and I HATE leather. So I went with the Dodge SXT with premium package and I was all set, plus I got it for about $1,300 cheaper.
So it comes down to leather choice: If you need the leather, and you take the luxury group with the T&C, yes, it will cost you more but get some more stuff (but NOT more isolation - they are both equal quiet and your dealer don't know what he is talking about). You'll get on the T&C auto dimming mirrors inside and out; I think the vehicle information center with tire pressure monitor, and some upscale materials (I mean aluminum or wood), better stereo, Automatic headlamps (which also turns on when wipers is engaged - of course you can turn it off if you don't like it), and appearance - T&C looks better than Caravan in the front, grille, headlamps, fog lamps, bodyside cladding, and rear chrome piece on the liftgate.
If you don't want leather, Dodge Caravan is the way to go as I did. If you take the leather with the Caravan SXT, it will not be much cheaper than T&C, and you loose some stuff.
But Dodge is definitely the cheaper if money is the object here. They are both the same with only different packages. Both have the same noise isolation.
The one option the TC does not have that she wants is a trunk lid release button on the dash. Does anyone know of an aftermarket version?
Is there anything to pick between them? It doesn't appear you can get the 3.8. Is there an equivilent of the Sport package - larger wheels and tirs, stiffer suspension - for the SWB versions?
I want a well appointed one for business, other things like power doors make no difference, in fact for me they are a negative.
You can price one with options here at Edmunds New Cars to see exactly the available options or you could go to either Dodge or Chrysler web site and do the same. Edmunds usually has more up to date and easier to use data than either Dodge or Chrysler.
The Dodge Caravan SXT or Grand Caravan SXT has better content for less money than the Chrysler T&C clone.
By the way, I feel that in the DC vans, the horn is not easy to operate. You have to push the horn (steering wheel) very firmly, with more effort than other vehicles, and avoids me to give sometimes a last second warning to other drivers. I don't know - my Windstar's horn has been much more easy to use. It's a minor issue unless it's a second before an emergency and you can't warn the other driver.
We drive a 96 Merc Villager, which was great for 9 years, but has recently had an expensive transmission repair and other annoying problems (air conditioning that can’t hold a charge, etc.), and we also would like something a bit bigger. My wife’s overall impression was that the 2005 GC SXT was cheaply built in comparison to our Villager, the GC engine was rougher and felt weak, and the Villager drove like a car while the GC SXT drove like a boat. We liked the Stow-n-Go, but the show-stopper for us was the resonance/ear drumming at our normal autobahn cruising speed from 70-80 mph. Does the SXT we drove have a quirk, or is this normal?
Does your Villager (Nissan Quest) have a luggage rack and cross bars? Most owners of DC minivans are impressed with the lack of wind noise common to most other minivans.
Anyone else experience anything like this with a DGC SXT?
Today was the second snow here in upstate NY, and my wipers wiped the ice all over the windshield - CRAP! I need the windshield wiper de-icer back SO BAD! Chrysler! DO YOU HEAR ME? I'M SCREAMING! Please give it back - I will pay you for that even an additional 200 bucks!
(Source: Chrysler's web site).
However, I think there would have been road noise if I had been driving on the rough cement roads of Oklahoma. Oklahoma has the worst roads for causing noise of any of the 33 states I have driven in.