Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see May lease deals!

Are we getting duped?

ksims96ksims96 Member Posts: 1
edited May 2016 in Nissan
Hi everyone, thanks in advanced for your help. I have basically no knowledge of cars so any attempts to keep it really simple are highly appreciated!

My friend was borrowing another friend's car while hers is in the shop, and yesterday she hit someone while backing out in a parking lot. She only hit the lower-middle of the front right door, the woman in the other car was able to open the door with no issues after the accident. Because it's not her car my friend wanted to go under the table and pay her cash so as not to hike up our friend's insurance rates since her car was not damaged. Anyways, the woman sent us a photo of the estimate from her shop and the total to replace the front right door for her 2010 Nissan Cube came to $1500 including labor, and on the sheet they also noted something about the rear door actuator and the right fender needing work. Now I don't know much about car repair but that doesn't seem right if we watched the woman make sure her car was functioning and the damage to the front right door was literally the ONLY damage caused to her car.

She did tell us that her husband also got into an accident a couple of weeks before and was given the wrong information by the person that hit him so they're missing the deductible from that accident, so we're just being cautious and making sure my friend doesn't pay for more than she has to.


  • Options
    Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Can't tell very much from that photograph, and since you weren't a witness, you probably can't fill in the details fsor us.

    So at this point, all I could recommend is that your friend ask the woman to get a second estimate, even if she insists on having it fixed at her shop. If the two estimates are close, then no problem. If they differ by a significant amount, then further negotiation may be necessary.

    If the car really needs a new door skin, I could see that costing $1500.
  • Options
    carboy21carboy21 Member Posts: 760
    Better to get it fixed via car insurance and pay your friend the deductible. Less chance of being scalped in this cash deal.
Sign In or Register to comment.