Employee / Supplier Purchase Programs

135678

Comments

  • tcdatcda Member Posts: 9
    I have had a hell of a time finding a Blue P5 w/ stick and ABS. My dealer has been looking for one for the last 10 days and only just found one. I find it strange that they (Mazda) is marketing the P5 as a sporty car and yet seems to have made the majority of the P5 automatic trans.

    Thanks for the help. (You too wireless1).
  • audia8qaudia8q Member Posts: 3,138
    You can never ever predict the market...as Mazda has figured out. They underestimated the demand for Manual trans for the P5 and now have a manual trans shortage. I have 17 P5 Sticks due on a boat that arrives next week at port newark and they cant get here fast enough!!!

    hang in there...it will be worth the wait. We are all in the same situation...locating a P5 stick has become a joke. We are expecting a mad scramble of swaps the minute they hit the ground.

    Rich
  • jroth33jroth33 Member Posts: 4
    On A Plan or X Plan, do you have to pay destination fee???
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Yes
  • scottdudescottdude Member Posts: 177
    For those of you who bought with the X or S plan and had a trade in, did you find that the dealer basically offered you wholesale price for your car or were they still competitive, coming close to the KBB or Edmunds trade-in value?
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Basically,

    I still believe (And this is how I work) that a trade is only worth what it is worth (Wholesale). Irrespective of what Black Book, Galves, Blue Book, NADA, Edmunds..etc say.

    On an X/A/S/J/Y/Z plan deal, there is no room for an overallowance though.

    Bill
  • planemechanicplanemechanic Member Posts: 1
    Please clarify how the x-plan lease works. Is the price of the vehicle the same wether I buy or lease?

    If the x-plan price is 35000 ( A-plan plus 4% ) is that the price used to figure out the lease payments? I know other things can change the actual monthly payment on a lease but the starting point is always the purchase price of the car.

    G
  • landru2landru2 Member Posts: 638
    It makes no difference whether you buy or lease. It's all based on the X-plan price. The bottom line with A/X/Z plan is that the dealer cannot deviate from the set price. If a dealer tried to inflate the price on an X-Plan deal, Ford would just send it back and make them correct it.
  • evets50evets50 Member Posts: 12
    If you buy a Ford Escape under the X-Plan, are you also able to deduct the $400 College Grad discount off of the X-Plan price?
  • tronsr1tronsr1 Member Posts: 149
    YES
  • landru2landru2 Member Posts: 638
    Can't combine grad rebate with X-Plan here. I wouldn't have expected it to be different in the U.S.
  • evets50evets50 Member Posts: 12
    tronsr1...Thanks...Have you actually done it?
  • tronsr1tronsr1 Member Posts: 149
    No, however; several people at the Ford Escape Yahoo Club have done it.I graduated from Glassboro State {now Rowan University} too many...I repeat....too many years ago!
    Tron
  • im_brentwoodim_brentwood Member Posts: 4,883
    Ahh! A good friend of mine went there. Nice campus...

    Bill
  • ntaylorntaylor Member Posts: 13
    Our company is a supplier for GM and we can get GM vehicles for "4% over the price a General Motors employee would pay for a vehicle purchased out of dealer stock"

    A couple of questions:
    1) how does one know what the GM employee price is, and 2) how does this compare to the price one can get by negotiating from the price the dealer paid?

    Thanks,
    NTaylor
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    In general, the GM employee pricing is roughly about 13% off MSRP depending on which car you are pricing. In addition, you would get any rebates and dealer incentive that is available on that particular car. Since your price is 4% above that, then you can subtract 9% from the MSRP and get a "ballpark" number of what the car will cost you. That price is well below invoice. The only way you can get the actual price is to pick a car out of the dealer inventory, provide the dealer with the proof you are entitled to the discount and they will provide the price. The price is non-negotiable.

    GM subsidizes the dealer to complete such a deal and no dealer that I know of would come anywhere near the price since there is essentially no profit margin in it unless they get the GM subsidy.
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    The dealer will gladly whip out the invoice
    if you are a serious buyer. The GM employee,
    and GM supplier prices are on it ! But be
    aware the dealer DOES not have to do it.
    Especially a HOT model such as a CTS, Vette
    z06................geo
  • ntaylorntaylor Member Posts: 13
    I just ran some numbers for a particular vehicle (truck) and the results are different from what I'd have expected. 9% below MSRP (the suggested 'ballpark' number) comes out to just above the TMV, about $1200 above the invoice. Maybe the percentages are different for this particular vehicle, or maybe there is really no benefit for the program (when compared with a negotiable price) with this particular vehicle? Thanks for your previous responses, and TIA for any additional insight!

    Invoice MSRP TMV®
    Regional Base Price $31,673 $36,229 $32,897
    Color Adjustment - - -$42
    Optional Equipment $185 $215 $193
    Destination Charge $745 $745 $745

    Total $32,603 $37,189 $33,793
  • montanafanmontanafan Member Posts: 945
    graphicguy's ball park was for cars, is my guess. Brother-In-Law was just over, looking at a Tahoe with supplier pricing MSRP was $36,725 and Supplier was $32,395.64. These numbers look simular to the one you priced at Edmunds. So supplier looks to be a smidge above Edmunds invoice. This should give you a smaller ballpark to guess in.
  • tblazer503tblazer503 Member Posts: 620
    heres another resource for ya...
    www.carsdirect.com
    you can pick your vehicle, see invoice, etc, etc. I just priced out a tahoe, and with the 1g rebate, its $100 above invoice. BTW, you can print these pages out and a local dealer will usually sell it for that price as long as the zip is the same. In anycase, gives you a good idea as to how much someone in your area is willing to sell it for. I used the carsdirect.com as my baseline when I bought my truck, and got it for about 400 below carsdirect.com pricing. Lotso negotiating. The nice thing about the GMO plan is that you dont have to negotiate. I have the Ford X plan as an option, but I know I can get a better price by negotiating and waiting for the right rebates... =o)
  • sevenfeet0sevenfeet0 Member Posts: 486
    I was in the same situation at my local Cadillac dealer. Finally, I got a bit of information that helped me figure out about what the discount is supposed to be.

    When you get the GM Supplier Discount paperwork, it comes with a couple of examples of GM cars priced at MSRP, then priced with the GM Supplier discount. Simple math reveals the discount to be about 8.2%. It's not as good as GM Employee price, but it's better than TMV (though not below invoice).

    The problem with the GM Supplier Discount program is that it is completely optional for dealers to participate. Why? GM does not reimburse the dealers for the difference, unlike the GM Employee discount, which is under invoice.

    So while a dealership might give you the car at GM Supplier price for "goodwill", they are really reticent about giving the discount for popular cars. Finding a Chevy dealership willing to give that discount for a Corvette is like finding Osama. In my case, I wanted a Cadillac CTS, which is another hot car. The dealership compromised and priced the car within $300 of the GM Supplier Price. I still saved over $1000 over Edmunds' TMV and I was a very happy camper.
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    HEY...Lucky you got a CTS with ANY discount !
    I ended up with a new Deville instead. Thats
    ok too.....No dealer in my syracuse NY area
    would do a GM employee discount on CTS !
    They DO NOT have to do it ! I found that out
    last year when the full size GM HD 4x4 excab
    pickups came out! Dealer said YOU gotta WAIT!
    Caddy dealer called me last week and said...We
    have your black CTS waiting, GM discount OK!~
    I said DUH...remember I bought a 02 Deville
    3 wks ago from a different dealer? He says
    why elsewhere? 3500 trade or 6000 trade at
    the other dealer. Wonder why? lol.......geo

    BTW: Both the GMS and GM supplier prices are
    right on the invoice ! Ask the dealer to see
    them ! If they won't show the invoice to you
    RUN don't walk ! Also ask about advertising
    fees. GM employees DO NOT have to pay them.
    Not sure about on GM Supplier deals tho !
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    Dad just bought a new S-10. Took his 99 S-10
    to same dealer 3900 trade...Other dealer where
    we bought the Caddy... 6200 trade ! Guess
    where he bought ?
    Dad when back to the first dealer and said
    see ya lost out on 2 new car sales. Have a
    great day he says !..............geo
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    As montanafan said, I was using cars as the benchmark. Still, best thing to do to find out what that price is would be to go to the closest dealer and ask him/her what the supplier discount is on that particular model. It's been a few years since I bought via GM0/GMS (employee purchase plans), so they may have changed it and the supplier plans, too. Employee plans are below invoice. Supplier plans may be at invoice or a bit above. Don't forget to deduct any rebates or incentives from the supplier discount, too.

    It used to be easier to find out what the employee price of a particular vehicle. You just took the MSRP and deducted a certain percentage off the base price and another percentage off MSRP for all the options. A few years ago, they stopped doing that and had everyone go to the dealer to get the official price for employee/supplier.

    sonjaab is correct, too. Employee pricing does not allow the dealer to charge for doc fees as this is rebated back to the dealer from GM. Don't know about supplier doc fees, though. All the terms should be spelled out in the paperwork you give to the dealer. Look at the paperwork closely to see what is/isn't included.

    Probably the main advantage to the supplier discount is you walk in, pick a vehicle, show the dealer your supplier paperwork and the deal is finished. I doubt you'll save much more (if any) by going through the tedious negotiation process to get to the same price (if you can).
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    I/ we have bought 6 new GMs this year with
    my moms GM employee discount. Limit is 6
    per model year. 4 others bought with uncles
    employee dis.

    ON the adv. fees...They are waived on GM
    employee deals..Not sure about supplier
    deals !

    About the doc. fee tho....In Syracuse NY
    area the doc. fee was 20 bucks. I have
    been told by other GM dealers on these
    threads the dealer CANNOT charge doc fees
    on GM employee deals. I asked on the last
    2 vehicle purchases and the salesman said
    different! I am not gonna argue over 20
    bucks ! Everyone is happy with their new
    GMs and the excellent deals they got!
    ...........geo
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    If the dealer is audited by GM they will get their hand slapped. Doc is waived on supplier and employee. Both supplier and employee are printed on invoice. FWIW GMO (ordered unit) is no longer cheaper than GMS (out of stock) I will happily do either employee or supplier but will spend as little time as possible. Some of my worst customers have been suppliers. I think it has something to do with being new to the program, had a Sonoma in the paper. The price was very aggressive. Had a supplier come in expecting to save thousands more with his supplier discount. His supplier price was $87 less than my advertised price. This was an extreme example but it got ugly real quick and he left in a huff.
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    Does GM compensate you for the time you invest in a GMO/GMS/Supplier deal? Or is it just a waste of your time?
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    does not compensate me, my owner pays me $50 per deal. So, no, it is not a waste of my time but I refuse to be screamed at by someone that has no idea of what they are talking about for $50. I don't want to sound flippant about it but I would rather make phone calls or send off e-mails instead. Now if a person is good to work with they will recieve my best treatment but it will be done QUICKLY.
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    I have to say, I don't think it would be worth my time for a GMS/GMO/Supplier deal for $50 considering the hour or two spent for paperwork, test drive, demonstration of features and delivery of the vehicle.

    That said, I've bought 3 cars via GMS and 2 via GMO (all Pontiacs, btw). Sales people were courteous and helpful considering they didn't make much money on the sale.

    Don't consider you flippant at all given those facts.
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    I was just handed a program good until end of september. Extra $500 rebate for 02 Grand Prix for supplier and employee. Extra $500 for 02 or 03 Grand Am, extra $1000 for 02 or 03 Montana. Great deals.
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    When dad was looking for a new S-10-Sonoma
    xcab 4x4 we browsed GM buypower. Your
    dea;er didn't have one. You guys had a 4
    cyl no v-6. Fox swapped a
    Trailblazer for one from East Syr. chevy. Salesman said the
    holdback was bigger on the Blazer and the
    other dealer wanted it bad. So they would
    make extra $$$$. And you know east syr.
    chevy is FAMOUS for standard mop and glow
    pkg. on all new cars! We got it for free !
    LOL....But we were charged 20 bucks doc.
    fee tho...............geo
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    GM is making a great push to gather more market share. They've got some great new designs coming and Lutz has everyone "buzzing" about them. They will be just fine. If I was in the market, I'd probably come in and put in an order for the new GP that's supposed to be out in '03 or '04.
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    I would not take an order unless you were after the 5.7 liter. Just kidding.
  • ntaylorntaylor Member Posts: 13
    went looking last Friday night after dark and a salesperson approached us. We told him we get GMS pricing and he was very helpful, friendly, courteous..

    We talked about model, color, etc. He said he'd be happy to do a search, and would also be happy to try and show us an example of the GMS price, but warned us that the sales mgr would probably balk at the request. He took us in and introduced us to the mgr, who quickly jumped into a speach about how he has the biggest inventory, the envy of the area, blah, blah...he was very flippant, told us that he would not sell a Crew Cab or a Duramax w/ GMS. We saved him additional time and breath and walked. We totally respect their choice to not deal the high demand/high margin vehicles. We're now thinking about maxing the GMCard in the next 22 months @ $3500 and using it w/ GMS to get a different vehicle - - after, of course, we have bought the new Ford SuperDuty.

    NTaylor
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    Did you see the NEW rules for GM Card?
    I kept the old black one. Used like 3500
    bucks off my 02 Caddy. Along with GMS.
    Something like they are cutting the amt.
    you can amass in a certain time period.
    With the old or new GM cards!
    Just got a flyer this month with my bill.
    Will have to reread again !..geo
  • ntaylorntaylor Member Posts: 13
    I stuck w/ the old card. Seemed to me that being able to max at $3500 w/ the old program vs maxing at $2500 w/ the new was of greater benefit to me. Plus, I think I read that you cannot use GMCard $ from the newest program for GMS purchases. Is that how you understand it? If they want to change the rules in the middle of the game then I suppose that is their option. Last time I looked there were other automobile mfg's out there. Plus, I'm not really too thrilled w/ the direction they have chosen w/ their truck styles. Ford's new SD engine/tranny combo coupled w/ their superior (imho) styling may really hurt GM. At this point, the scales would tip in favor of a GM truck only if I could get the truck of my choosing + GMS purchase + use GM Card $ + 0% financing.

    NT
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    Although, I like the pictures I've seen of the new GTO, from what I've read, they've gone away from the pure performance of the original concept and turned it into a very quick "luxo-cruiser".

    My hope of hopes, being a Pontiac fan (even though I own Chryslers now), is the new GP will fill the bill for a performance sedan.

    The GTP I owned had to be the performance sedan bargain when it first came out in the late '90s. Now, the bar has been raised via the competion. I'm anxious to see how the new GP GTP turns out.
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    Still scratching my head.......Prob. just
    call them and ask. Good thing I used all
    my GM card points up ! I bought a 01 truck
    last year. So 3 or so winters down the road
    when I trade the truck ( Use for snowplowing
    so I dump em' before warranty expires.) The
    Caddy I keep for 5-6 years 100k miles.
    I will see what the "NEW" program holds for
    me............geo

    BTW: When I bought my 01 truck last year if
    I had the NEW GM card max I could use was
    $1500 bucks...My old black one I used $2000
  • fortopfortop Member Posts: 239
    that GMO and GMS are the same price? I don't see anything on the GM Buypower site for GM employees that indicates this change. The web site is still set up to quote GMO price, but only GMS price displays - so maybe that is the only confirmation we will get. I just thought that there would be some official notification of the end of GMO pricing.
  • fortopfortop Member Posts: 239
    confirmation. I just got a mailing form GM family first that confirms the change this month.
    But here is another question. I have a 2002 Tahoe with only 2200 miles on it and I want to order a similar 2003 Tahoe. I buy a new GM vehicle every 6 months, but would rather not go through the hassle of selling the vehicle outright. I can buy from any dealer, but the local dealers (understandably) won't quote a trade in value on my 2002 unless I sign a deal to order the 2003. Any suggestions on how to get a trade in value (at least a range) from a dealer without comitting to another vehicle.
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    try a different dealer. That does not make sense. GMS is pretty cut and dry in price. Maybe they are trying to prevent you from shopping your trade. Why noy put them through the paces and then back out at the last minute? That is what I would do. Maybe they are not taking you serious with your trade being so new. If I was standing around and you walked in looking for prices on a 2003 and had a 2002 to trade I would ask why you are trading. I would not be interested in much back and forth on your trade value. I would simply look at recent auction numbers and give you what I could buy one for from the auction. What part of the country are you from and describe your trade in DETAIL and I can give you a ballpark.
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    How many miles will you be putting on the trade in the next 2 months?
  • outhereouthere Member Posts: 16
    take advantage of dealer cash or incentive finance when I go GM supplier? Case in point : Saab 9-5. Will I pay supplier price minus dealer cash as long as I do not finance with GM?
  • CarMan@EdmundsCarMan@Edmunds Member Posts: 38,514
    Hi outhere. Yes, consumers who purchase new vehicles through manufacturers' employee and supplier purchase programs should have any available incentives subtracted from their prices.

    Car_man
    Host
    Smart Shoppers / FWI Message Boards
  • alindaalinda Member Posts: 67
    I've had someone working GMO price -- he still thinks there's some meat on the bone, or something, cause our GMO price isn't good enough. Of course, he's comparing our GMO price to another dealership's GMO price on a car that is the same -- except for a 5k option package. Duh. I've spent 3 hours working him already, and I'm cutting him loose as of tonight. He's either in or he's out, right?
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    There is NO MORE GMO price. GM has changed
    the employee discount plan to GMS only recently.
    GMS price is right on the invoice anyway !
    NO price difference if you order or take from
    dealer stock ! Have your client take the sponsors
    SS# to www.gmfamilyfirst.com
    Then they can see for themselves that you are
    not trying any funny business with them ! Also
    remind them that GM employee discount plans
    they will pay NO adv fees either ! Not sure
    about GM supplier deals tho......geo

    BTW: My family has bought 10 new GMs this year
    with mom and uncles GM discount !!!!
  • graphicguygraphicguy Member Posts: 14,071
    Yep, set him to pasture.

    I've bought 3 cars under GMS/GMO as my brother-in-law is a retired GM engineer. Great deals. I can't believe that they want to negotiate the GMS price...?????

    GMS price also does away with doc fees (if that hasn't changed over the last couple of years, too)
    2024 Kia EV6 GT-Line AWD Long Range
  • jasmith52jasmith52 Member Posts: 462
    The company that I have been working for for the last 13 years was formerly owned by GM. One of the perks that I get is that I have been eligible for the GM employee price on cars.

    I watch the employee deals fairly closely over the years and have bought a few for myself and family members. What I have noticed is that the employee price has been getting higher over the years.

    It used to be that the price we got was generally the invoice price minus about 4 percent. Now as a previous poster wrote our price is at invoice.

    We used to also get an additional year-end model year clearance discount of 5 percent of of list in October of the model year. This was in addition to any available incentives.

    Now GM will take away the coupling of the GM credit card rebate points with an employee sale.

    I have bought GM cars in the past because of the exceptional employee price. I don't believe this will be the case in the future. I could probably walk into any GM dealership and bargain with them on a car to within a few hundred dollars of invoice price.

    So I guess my discount is now worth only a few hundred dollars. This is not enough to keep me buying GM cars. And the loss of the GM credit card discount makes it even worse.

    I read somewhere that GM sells about 10 percent of it's cars to employees and suppliers. Maybe GM needs to rethink the (Big) discount they offer employees.
  • sonjaabsonjaab Member Posts: 1,057
    I/WE were charged 20 bucks doc fees on all
    of the new Gms this year. Some of the dealer
    guys on the smart shopper thread told me the
    dealer is NOT supposed to charge DOC on GM
    emp. deals. I questioned them and they let
    us say "played dumb". But it was only 20
    bucks for them to run around to the DMV !

    When I bought my 01 GM truck GMO price was only
    like $380? cheaper than GMS. ....geo
  • isellpotiacisellpotiac Member Posts: 122
    How have you been? I recently had a customer that was GMsupplier. This started about 8 weeks ago when I "upped" him on the lot. I took one look at his trade and wanted to run. It was slow so I decided to practice my walk around. I had this guy under the car showing him stuff. We went on a test drive and I started trying to kick the trade. Miled out Ford product. I am standing around about 6 weeks later and in walks the customer. He tells me he has sold his trade and is ready to do the deal.
    I grab the invoice, he is a supplier. I show him supplier price and he notices that it is $28 higher than invoice. He decides he will be paying invoice and we will throw in about $350 worth of extras. Furthermore we will be "running his trade thru the books" for his tax benefit.
    I am about to crumple up the up sheet and go have a cigarette but decide to desk the deal anyways. Unknown to the customer we have $500 dealer cash on this vehicle. We also have a $500 consumer rebate that he has not mentioned yet. I explain to the manager that this guy wants all this AND 10% off all parts and labor in the future.
    After we get done chuckling to ourselves we look at the deal and it is doable. I am debating on if I even want this guy as a customer.
    Now, if he had stuck with his supplier paperwork we would have not charged him the $20 for the doc fee, that brings the difference to $8. We also would have to disclose the $500 dealer cash. We did give him the $500 rebate. So after it was all said and done this guy cost himself about $150 trying to save $28.
    The day we deliver the vehicle GM comes out with a $250 rebate for all GMS and supplier deals. The bottom line is this guy cost himself $400 trying to save $28. He did end up being a VERY likeable guy and bought me a dozen Titleist golf balls.
    I will most likely be flamed for this post but with this guy the only way we could have done the deal is the way we did it. If he came in and was supplier and wanted $350 worth of extras I would of launched him inside of 10 seconds, no questions asked. I am sure the customer thinks he got an AWESOME deal. I am happy he is my customer.
This discussion has been closed.