Hyundai Sonata vs. Honda Accord vs. Toyota Camry vs. Ford Fusion

1343537394055

Comments

  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    I am 6'5" and absolutely love the seat of my 2006 Accord EX. It keeps you from sliding without pressuring my back. My back, your back, and others' backs are all very different, so I don't see how this topic needs to continue. Seat comfort is different for everyone.
  • patpat Member Posts: 10,421
    Personally, in all that I have experienced and all that I have read here over many years, I don't believe the manufacturer has a single thing to do with how the dealership treats people. It appears to be an individual store thing no matter WHAT the brand is. I've seen complaints and praises for dealers of every manufacturer in our subject (as well as a lot of others). :)
  • bimmer4mebimmer4me Member Posts: 266
    "CamCords are just too popular which is why they are ridiculously expensive"

    Personally, I don't find Camcords expensive. IMO, they're a bargain for what you get. The Sonata I'll admit, is a steal!
  • bimmer4mebimmer4me Member Posts: 266
    I couldn't have said it better!
  • zen2zen2 Member Posts: 226
    "I can't seem to find a review that criticized the Accord's seats for being uncomfortable."

    Is that supposed to be humorous, or a logic test?
    There are no reviews of the 2006 Accord. :):)
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    Has the seat/design been changed in the 2006 Accord? I own an 03 and feel they are the best seats I have sat in. Didn't check out the 06 seats though.
  • ctalkctalk Member Posts: 646
    Is that supposed to be humorous, or a logic test?
    There are no reviews of the 2006 Accord.


    I wasn't aware the 2006 Accord has different seats from the 2003-2005 models. :surprise:

    Btw, that wasn't suppose to be humorous, or a logic test. :):) There are really no reviews that criticize the Accord's front seats.
  • stockmanjoestockmanjoe Member Posts: 353
    They judge people by the way they look. The old judging a book by its cover. If you show up there in flip-flops, tee-shirt and shorts (like I usually dress in FL) they assume you are white trash and ignore you pretty much. If you go nicely dressed you will have salesman all over you and if you pull up there with wife and kids in tow in a late model Honda they will be all over you. It is funny you are still the same person.
  • stockmanjoestockmanjoe Member Posts: 353
    You've made my point about this discussion exactly.
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    I don't know if dealership experience has to do with the car manufacurer; IMO it depends on individual dealerships. People have varied experiences with all dealers.

    I once went to check out the Elantra GT (a car I loved) and the Hyundai dealership was pathetic. I however have experienced some very good Hyundai dealers also. Agian IMO, depends on individual dealerships.
  • ctalkctalk Member Posts: 646
    You've made my point about this discussion exactly.

    How? :confuse:
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    That's what this discussion/forum is all about. Wouldn't it be boring if we all agreed to the same things! To me, the Accord LX is a better car, however the Sonata is definitely a great value.

    TO quote more sources, CD, MT et al picked the Accord over all other midsize cars in their comparisons, right from the time the 03 Accord debuted.
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    The way you are generalizing this is ridiculous!
  • stockmanjoestockmanjoe Member Posts: 353
    The point is we keep arguing back and forth that the Sonata seats are uncomfortable. Many people say they are but there are others of us that say they are not. If they were uncomfortable to me I would tell you. I just have no problem with them.

    The same is true of the Accord. This part is particularly funny to me because this is the one thing my co-worker complains about his Accord is that the seat is soooo uncomfortable. In spite of you saying thatthe reviews don't mention an uncomfortable seat and the Hyundai reviews do.

    There is no right or wrong answer here. Its just what makes your [non-permissible content removed] feel best I guess.
  • patpat Member Posts: 10,421
    You really can't make that kind of sweeping generalization. While what you say might be true at some dealerships, it also will not be true at others.

    For more on this subject, please visit our Smart Shopper board. We're talking about the cars here - let's focus on them.
  • stockmanjoestockmanjoe Member Posts: 353
    Well its true. Maybe not of every single place but try it sometime if you don't believe me. I've read in car buying books recommending to show up to the dealer looking like Warren Buffett not Jimmy Buffett. Why do you think the advice to "Don't judge a book by its cover" has been given out for ages?
  • ctalkctalk Member Posts: 646
    There is no right or wrong answer here. Its just what makes your [non-permissible content removed] feel best I guess.

    Agreed. Everyone has different preferences, and everyone has different body shapes.
  • backybacky Member Posts: 18,949
    It would be a real short discussion if we all agreed on the same things.

    I happen to share Edmunds.com's opinion that the Sonata V6 is a better car (not just better value) than the Accord LX, at the same price point MSRP-wise (although the Sonata V6 is actually less costly when rebates are considered). Note that CD and MT have not done a comparo like Edmunds.com did, in the midsized sedan class--comparing like-priced cars. That makes all the difference I think, and creates different results than when a top-line Accord that costs $5000 MSRP more than cars like the Sonata and Fusion is tested.
  • goodegggoodegg Member Posts: 905
    A top line Accord is so much nicer than a Sonata LX, so yea, it costs more. Manual transmission option, drive by wire, double wishbone suspension, illuminated controls on the steering wheel, daytime running lights, a voice activated navigation option, and a much better overall fit and finish. There is a discussion on this board for the Accord vs the TL where the Accord competes at a much higher level than the comparo done here.

    I don't think the Sonata is a better car than the Accord. Don't care that Edmunds picks it, or that other rags pick the Accord over and over as the best. I know Honda delivers a refined product that commands a higher price than the others, and makes a boatload of money in doing so. Something Ford, GM or even Hyundai envy. Hyundai can't go on too long being the low cost guy on the block without something in the economic equation giving. Unless the South Korean government continues their subsidy programs.

    Yea - different strokes for different folks.
  • blnewtoblnewto Member Posts: 146
    by the chintzy plastic fuel door covers and hinges on these cars??
    Our previous Honda Accord (89 LxI Coupe) went through 2 of them, and our new Hyundai Sonata GLSV6 also has a very similar door and hinges. Why can't they make them out of steel?? This is a part that gets alot of use and should be up to the task, how much can really be saved here? OK, I'm done venting, LOL
  • stockmanjoestockmanjoe Member Posts: 353
    The other day I was dropping my wife's Honda Pilot off at the Honda dealer for service. I parked my brand new 2006, recently washed, waxed and window tinted "dark cinnamon" colored Hyundai Sonata GLS right in front of the large service window. I soon noticed about five salemen huddled looking at my new car. They looked worried - LOL!!!
  • tenpin288tenpin288 Member Posts: 804
    From a national publication:

    When a group of Japan-based Toyota board members visited U.S. headquarters earlier this month, employees didn't assemble their latest models for them to see. Rather, they created a car show of what they viewed as the toughest competition, including the Hyundai Azera, Honda Civic and Dodge Charger.

    "There's this global paranoia," says Michael Robinet, a CSM vice president. Toyota executives are especially worried about the South Koreans — which have the Hyundai and Kia brands in the USA — because of their fast growth.


    The full article can be read here

    The article is about Toyota soon exceeding GM as the world's largest automaker. It's an interesting read.
  • zen2zen2 Member Posts: 226
    You are funny. Anyone who can afford a Sonata
    can afford a CamCord. I currently own two cars,
    a Honda CRV, and a Sonata. The car I traded in on the
    CRV was (gasp) a Honda Accord LX V6. Accords and
    Toyotas aren't Lexus or Acura. The reason I got the
    Sonata was that I got more features for less money,
    period. If someone tried to sell you a Pepsi for 100
    bucks or a Coke for a buck, I guess you would buy the Pepsi, huh?
  • stickguystickguy Member Posts: 53,551
    BOught an Accord tonight, so I guess that answers where I stand.

    Actually, one of the key factors was I wanted the goodies (leather, roof, etc.) but also wanted a manual tranny. That left only the Fusion and Accord, and the content (XM built in, power seat recline, turning radius, etc.) favored the Accord. Doesn't hurt that I got a large discount too.

    2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.

  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    "I happen to share Edmunds.com's opinion that the Sonata V6 is a better car (not just better value) than the Accord LX, at the same price point MSRP-wise (although the Sonata V6 is actually less costly when rebates are considered). Note that CD and MT have not done a comparo like Edmunds.com did, in the midsized sedan class--comparing like-priced cars. That makes all the difference I think, and creates different results than when a top-line Accord that costs $5000 MSRP more than cars like the Sonata and Fusion is tested"

    Edmunds compared strictly based on price, comparing a 4 cyl Camcords with 6 cyl Sonata. In my book this is a complete no-no, and only someone who is on a tight budget would look at a comparison like that. Quote any magazine that has done a comparison of the 4 cyl Accord to a 4 cyl Sonata, or a 6 cyl Accord to a 6 cyl Sonata, where the Sonata has won over the Accord. None that I know of. Where ever cars with similar engines/equipmwent levels were tested, the Accord has always won.

    Mags like CD/MT/RT etc always compare cars with similar engine configurations and also take care to ensure that the price differences are not very big.

    Coming back to the pricing, you mention 5k MSRP difference between an Accord and a Sonata (which is not true, obviously you don't figure in rebates in an MSRP comparison). If you are comparing real world prices, that's different. Similarly the Accord/Fusion MSRP, there is no way that an Accord is 5k MSRP over a similarly equipped Fusion.
  • bimmer4mebimmer4me Member Posts: 266
    It's apparent that you're so compelled to defend your recent Hyundai purchase. It's okay! You own a HYUNDAI, so what. :P
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    ....and, I just did a comparison of similarly equipped Accord/Fusion, below is what I found on Edmunds:

    Accord EXV6 with leather:MSRP 27,300
    Fusion SEL (similarly equipped):MSRP 26,050
    Hyundai Sonata LX: $23,495(again, as closely as I could equip them, could't find one with a power passenger seat, but I am sure there must be some options available on the Sonata that may not be available on an Accord)

    Clearly, the Hyundia has a big price advantage, but not the Fusion
  • scape2scape2 Member Posts: 4,123
    like #1894, stigma. "you own a HYUNDIA"... So what? a person chooses a Hyundia over an Accord or Camry. Why is this so unbelievable? If this person kept up on auto news they would see the Koreans have made leaps and bounds in quality/reliability. To think the Accord/Camry are going to stay ontop forever?? Not going to happen. This is a free market. Its only a matter of time for an automaker to come out with a family sedan that is every bit as good or better than an Accord/Camry and for less$$$.. The Accord/Camry are not inexpensive when comparing a Hyundia or even now a Fusion option for option.
    A Ford dealer in my area is advertising Ford Fusion SEL V6's for $22,499! loaded SEL V6's for $23,888! Not just 1, up to 4 of each to choose from. Walk into a Honda dealership and offer them $24K for an Accord V6 EX Sunrrof, leather ect.. and they will laugh you right out of the showroom...
  • alpha01alpha01 Member Posts: 4,747
    A Sonata LX equipped most closely to an Accord EXV6 is $24,895, shrinking the MSRP price advantage by some $1500. Notably missing on Fusion, in my opinion, is the stability control that is standard on the other two.

    ~alpha
  • goodegggoodegg Member Posts: 905
    Walk into a Honda dealership and offer them $24K for an Accord V6 EX Sunrrof, leather ect.. and they will laugh you right out of the showroom...

    For $1K more you could get that EXV6 AT, which is a hell of a of better vehicle than a Fusion.

    Really. Comparing a Ford to a Honda?
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    like #1894, stigma. "you own a HYUNDIA"... So what? a person chooses a Hyundia over an Accord or Camry. Why is this so unbelievable?

    Because there are some people who develope a cult like attachement to a particular model or type of car. They come to believe that their car is the greatest thing since sliced bread and cant understand why others don't believe the same as they do. Add to that any car thats less expensive it is even worse as then you can't afford such a superior car as they drive.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    For $1K more you could get that EXV6 AT,

    According to edmunds its more like $2k more.

    Really. Comparing a Ford to a Honda?

    Thank you for confirming my post above.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • ontopontop Member Posts: 279
    This is a silly post, comparing a Ford to a Honda as if price is the only thing separating them. But then again, you did buy a Hyundai. And it is a stigma.

    People around here just don't buy Hyundais. They still have the cheap image going on. And who wants that hanging on them?
  • ontopontop Member Posts: 279
    According to edmunds its more like $2k more.

    When I buy a car I don't go to edmunds to buy it. The dealers around here will sell an EXV6 AT for $25K.
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    And a dealer in my area is advertising the Nissan Altima 2.5S for 14,999! Heard of 'bait and switch?'

    And anyway, there is a price difference between the Accord and the Fusion, but it is small.
  • oldjoeoldjoe Member Posts: 132
    Bloomfield TV Financial Reports on last Monday said that projected 2006 sales on Honda/Toyota autos will be up dramatically over 2005. They surmised that GM would be the most hurt by these increased sales. No mention was made of other major auto manufacturers such as CD, Ford, Nissan, Mazda, any EU manufacturer and Mitsubishi. Looks like the American public is still locked on the Honda/Accord auto companies.
  • oldjoeoldjoe Member Posts: 132
    Isn't this an exact repeat of a forum entry from a few months ago?
  • patpat Member Posts: 10,421
    Please tone down the personal comments - we're talking about cars here, not each other.

    If you don't like a car, fine, but there's no need to fling around insults.
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    If it is I am unaware of it.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • cxccxc Member Posts: 122
    For sales occurring from May 1 through Sept. 25, the 2006 Sonata averaged a $19,943 transaction price, according to Power Information Network data.

    That also compares with an average transaction price of $20,332 for the Camry and $21,120 for the Accord over the same period, the Power data show.

    This probably is an early indication of the income level for those who bought 2006 Sonata.
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    This probably is an early indication of the income level for those who bought 2006 Sonata.

    How so? Some people who buy the Sonata may be stretching themselves more than they can actually afford. While others could afford a $75k Benz but think they can put the other $55k to better use than sinking it into a depreciatble asset.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    That's surprising; the prices are close. You would think the gap would be bigger. Maybe more V6 Sonatas are being bought by buyers as opposed to 4cyl Camcords.
  • ontopontop Member Posts: 279
    Hyundais are cheaper and will attract a cheaper customer. The image presented by a Hyundai isn't one of 'I got a bunch of cash but didn't want to sink it into my car'
  • kdhspyderkdhspyder Member Posts: 7,160
    A Ford dealer in my area is advertising Ford Fusion SEL V6's for $22,499! loaded SEL V6's for $23,888! Not just 1, up to 4

    This is a shame if it's throughout the US market. The vehicle is a few month's old and the honeymoon should still be going strong. I thought I saw that they were running fullout at Herosillo.
  • kdhspyderkdhspyder Member Posts: 7,160
    That's surprising; the prices are close. You would think the gap would be bigger. Maybe more V6 Sonatas are being bought by buyers as opposed to 4cyl Camcords.

    I'd guess that to be the case also.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    According to edmunds its more like $2k more.

    When I buy a car I don't go to edmunds to buy it. The dealers around here will sell an EXV6 AT for $25K.

    Yes, here in the south, dealers are pretty willing to swing a little on pricing. I was out the door on my EX 4-cyl cloth for just under $23k. The price before financing (4.5% i think) and tax/title etc...was 21,XXX, down from $23,800.
  • blnewtoblnewto Member Posts: 146
    Hyundais are cheaper and will attract a cheaper customer. The image presented by a Hyundai isn't one of 'I got a bunch of cash but didn't want to sink it into my car'

    I just bought an 06' Sonata, but not because it was cheap, I signed on the dotted line because the car is simply an excellent vehicle at a good price. I was prepared to buy the best car for our family and when the dust settled the Sonata won me over. I spent 6 weeks testing Accord, Camry, Altima, Jetta, Mazda6 and Fusion. After reading the various sites and publications I also reluctanlty looked into teh Sonata, and I'm very glad I did. Please don't insult those of us that aren't cheap, but also don't need to impress others w/ our "status ride", LOL
  • chrisfordchrisford Member Posts: 55
    People around here just don't buy Hyundais. They still have the cheap image going on. And who wants that hanging on them?

    Spoken like a true sheep. Do the research then make an informed decision base on facts, not unfounded useless comments.
    The Sonata reliability is as good as the Accord it not better. Maybe you are basing your comment on five year old data.

    This is a silly post, comparing a Ford to a Honda

    true because the Fusion has more class and style than Accord can ever hope to....
    Another follow the leader comment. Ford Reliability has been improving every year, do the research.
    IMHO most cars today are very reliable. It's not as big of a difference as it once was.
  • 03accordman03accordman Member Posts: 671
    "The Sonata reliability is as good as the Accord it not better"

    Please provide us some data on which your statement is based, or a link.

    "true because the Fusion has more class and style than Accord can ever hope to...."

    Pity the consumer is not taking to that 'Style' what with rebates galore on the Fusion
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    Please don't insult those of us that aren't cheap, but also don't need to impress others w/ our "status ride", LOL

    Yes, it is a sad day when my Accord or Joe Schmo's Camry is a status ride! I'll admit to you that it is DEFINITELY not. I think that title is reserved for three-pointed stars, blue and white propellers, and prancing horses.
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.