By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
I wanted something fun to drive. I'm a Honda guy from way back, but I have to admit I took a hard look at a new Mustang GT. I think it's a great looking car, and it has that wonderful V8 rumble. But after driving one, I couldn't pull the trigger. It would be a great weekend car, but I wasn't sure I would be happy with it day in and day out.
Once I gave up on the Mustang GT and its 300 hp, I began to focus on the Civic Si. My dealer, like most, didn't have one to drive. I had driven an '06 EX coupe, though, so I thought I had an idea what an Si would be like. I wanted a relatively tame color, and decided on silver. I talked to the powers that be at my dealer, and asked how long it would take to get a silver Si with nav. The answer: nearly three months. What??? Does the phrase "instant gratification" mean anything to anyone other than me? Sure I talk about cars for months, but when I decide on something I want it NOW.
They made some calls, and allegedly pulled in some favors. Did I want a silver Si without nav (rats), and with high performance tires that I could have in a week or two? Well SURE I do! I figured I'd add a compass mirror to make myself feel better about the lack of nav and see what the tires were all about when I got the car.
I got the call just five days later: my car was in. Picked it up late in the afternoon. Wow. Very nice fit and finish, sleek look. Hit the road. It corners wonderfully. The 6-speeds is slick as all get-out, though 5th and 6th are farther to the right than you'd expect. And the exhaust note....what a sweet siren song! I stayed below 6k rpm for the first 600 miles, but it still sounded terrific. Not like a ricer with a coffee can exhaust, more of a Formula One inspired sound. And now that I wind it out, I can enjoy the multi-valve dohc harmony right up to the redline.
The two-tiered dash? I got used to it in a heartbeat. To me, it seems natural and logical to not have to take my eyes far from the road to determine my speed. And the dbw (drive by wire) throttle hang I've read about? I forgot all about it until late the first night, made a mental note to look for it the next morning. It's there, but it's not disruptive. The rpm's float downward when you lift off the accelerator, instead of dropping rapidly like you are used to. Not an issue, just different.
A 2006 Si with high performance tires retails for $21,040. I've owned and driven a lot of different cars in a lot of different price ranges. This does not feel like a $21k car by any stretch of the imagination. It's too well-finished. The steering and handling are too precise. The engine is too dynamic, and the transmission sublime. This is the real world, of course, so there are no heated leather seats or six-disc cd changer, etc. But it is a terrific car, and if it performs as my other Hondas have I will continue to be a happy driver.
Go for it ! Had no problems with my coupe and am close to 5K in mileage, mt first oil change is still a bit away(shows 40% left) and I am a Happy Camper!
Come join in!
Thanks
Katzkin Leather
The sedans receive a four-star rating for side impacts in the front and five stars for side impacts in the rear.
I know that crash test ratings are only one element of the overall dynamics of accident avoidance and occupant safety, but it still concerns me that the front side-impact rating was only three stars. Anyone have any thoughts about how meaningful this rating is and whether Honda might attempt to address it.
I've had my silver 2006 Si for nearly three months, and have put 3,600 miles on it. Mileage for eleven fill-ups has ranged from a low of 26.9 to a high of 32.3 in mixed driving. I really enjoy the Jeckyl-and-Hyde nature of this car. I can drive around casually, accelerate gently, short-shift at about 2500 rpm, and get good mileage. If I want to run it to redline and go like stink, it's always ready. And no matter how you drive, it corners superbly. A whole lot of car for the money.
OhioCarGuy
Highs:
Snappy short-throw 6 speed
Eager little engine
Light car
Lows:
Awkward design makes dash seem long and hard to see out of car (gen 2 and gen 3 integra designs were far better)
Rough ride on all but smoothest pavement
Lots of chassis flex and shake over uneven pavement
Buzzy exhaust
Cloth interior
Lack of xenon
High rpm at mild speeds (80 mph)
Seems like a decent value at 20k. Found nothing special about the handling: FWD - LSD be damned - robs the car of fun. Not sure why it gets so much praise. I'm a RWD person though, so maybe i just felt the understeer in the car was a tad much for me to be comfortable with. This could have been related to the seating and my inability to find a comfortable position for heel-toeing. The car never felt like it was a part of me. I felt more like I was riding on a skateboard. BMW's Mini feels the same way to me - dettached.
The GTI's got the buttoned-down interior, creature comforts and docile around town feel. Plus that 2.0T pulls like a monster anywhere in the rev range while the Si's engine screams to life above 6k rpm. At high speeds the GTI's quiet and composed - plus it returns better mileage.
In the end I think the Si's more athletic but offers a bigger compromise: loudness, rougher ride, must beat on the engine. Day-to-day I think I'd rather a GTI that I can mod for better handling and have the ability to take long, leisurely drives, more comfortable interior and an engine that responds near instantly. If one is willing, the DSG tranny is insanely fun too.
Of course, the Si has amazing resale (check autotrader and some folks have Sis for above sticker used. And it will probably be very reliable.
How come in the written story, though, there is no direct reference to the Si being quieter, though? They always say the GTI is more refined...etc, blah blah
No one ever mentions that the Si is quieter on the freeway?
Could it be because the sound meter measures the loudness of the GTI in frequencies that the human ear is insensitive to?
Has anyone driven both these cars and can say which one is quieter on the highway?
From what I have read, the Si has more road noise but the GTI more engine noise @ highway? Then if this is true, is road noise more objectionable than engine noise or whatever it is that is registering louder on the 'more refined' GTI?
Also, is the Si significantly more bumpy on the highway than the GTI on 17 or 18 wheels?
Thanks cya
Bob
Thanks!
My main concern on an Si is the in everyday driving you will have to rev high and hard. This is great for back roads or the racetrack but everyday commuting could be tiring. Fun is of course key but other cars like the GTi and MS3 are fun without being tiring for everyday use.
Also noticing heat discoloration in spots on the rear windshield where the defroster electric lines enter the defroster grid in both upper corners. You know, that kind of bubbling or mottling appearance in auto glass sun screens when they have broken down in the sun. Haven't shown this to the dealer yet. My impression is the car isn't quite engineered for American heat/sun.
Nuff said-Car runs like a dream. So happy with it. I'd buy one again anytime. Great driving experience!
All three fast compacts (Si, GTi and MS3) are good cars and the MS3 is at least based on a good handling compact. Honda obviously realised consumers also wanted practicality with their performance hence the 4 door sedan version of the Si to compete with the more practical GTi and MS3.
Curt
Now I want to do some mods - Does anyone here have advice or experience on the following:
1. power mods (perferably non turbo or blower related)
2. suspension (slight lowering and something to help the frontwheel drive pull)
3. wheels + tires (What is the best performance option here?)
Any help is greatly appreciated.
pete in half moon bay
i put in the honda music link thing which is definitely not worth the price but convenient.
love the car
I just bought my new Civic EX coupe, and only have 1020 miles on it, but there were some scratches on the rear bumper. The scratches were deep enough that you could see the black paint. Do anyone know if the dealership is willing to fix it. Is that cover under my 3 year warranty?
Thank you very much