DODGE VS CHEVY, FORD, TOYOTA, SORRY DODGE IS NUMBER 1

12357

Comments

  • mgdvhmanmgdvhman Member Posts: 4,157
    just ignore him.....it's not worth the key stroke effort.....

    - Tim
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    Mr. skidmark isn't worth the time of day...was fun while it lasted tho...

    Dean
  • mgdvhmanmgdvhman Member Posts: 4,157
    you seem to be toned down F150....couldn't be the warning now could it?

    - Tim
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    of names....only got Dodge left...and no matter how bad it gets...don't think he wants that..LOL!

    Dean
  • f150rulesf150rules Member Posts: 195
    shake shake shake......shake shake shake........ shakerado.......shakerado! LOL!
  • dodgeram7dodgeram7 Member Posts: 55
    You could make alot of money on that song.
    The thing is that Chevy & Gmc owners would be the only people that that like that song. They could shake going down the road just like the song.
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    Should be good for a few laughs....now at least there is someone for both of them to talk to...LOL
  • rwellbaum2rwellbaum2 Member Posts: 1,006
    Rollin'.....Rollin'.....Rollin' over on the highway!

    sung to the tune of "rollin' on the river"
    Brought to you by ford and their good partners, firestone.

    LOL!!!
  • fordtuffordtuf Member Posts: 101
    Ford didn't put their fuel tanks in the wrong place, 'cause otherwise they'd burn up too. Right?
  • f150rulesf150rules Member Posts: 195
    SHAKE, RATTLE, AND ROLL.....SHAKE, RATTLE, AND ROLL.................SLMAO!!!!!
  • bigal31bigal31 Member Posts: 189
    Toyota are not last in sales..But they are close!!
    I can hear spoog.
    "Hay they can go off road you know so that doesn't matter"..
    Allen-
  • dmdbitdmdbit Member Posts: 23
    i guess ford used the pinto to learn where to put the gas tanks.

    mike
  • mgdvhmanmgdvhman Member Posts: 4,157
    ..That's gonna leave a mark!

    - Tim
  • f150rulesf150rules Member Posts: 195
    yeah, kinda like GM and their trucks. Only it took GM over 13 years to even admit and make anything right about it. Still people got screwed.
  • rwellbaum2rwellbaum2 Member Posts: 1,006
    Ford leads the way in bad sevice. Check out blueovalnews.com. Ford limits the amount of time authorized compensation for repairs to 1/2 the actual time it should take. Do you think the dealerships are going to be interested in quality service? BTW, how's it going at the prison?
  • jcmdiejcmdie Member Posts: 594
    Just how many topics are you gonna duplicate this exact same post?
  • RoclesRocles Member Posts: 982
    rwell,

    Where do aquire your "facts" on Ford service?
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    can't link to the page, I did a no no by cutting and pasting...but figured ford owners would want to know:

    Quality is Job #1...Isn't It?

    Published: May 30, 2000
    Date of revision: None
    Source: None
    By: James Brennan

    "Quality is Job #1". This is how Ford conveys peace of mind to the prospective new car buyer. Quality products backed by a manufacturer's warranty. The question that arises is just what does that warranty mean? This warranty should assure that short of any normal wear and tear, or damage that the owner causes, the vehicle will remain in the condition that it was purchased, while under the manufacturer's warranty. Ford does not do their customers any favors by fixing a car under warranty, because the cost of the warranty repairs is built into the MSRP. Ford owes these repairs to the customer when the buyers agreement is signed.

    I am a Ford Service Technician

    Over the last few years, I have witnessed an alarming trend in Ford labor practices. Ford is now reluctant to pay the labor required to perform quality warranty repairs. In 1995, the labor operation for a Windstar transmission removal and installation paid a qualified technician 6.7 hours. All Ford technicians that work on warranty repairs are paid by the job, not by the hour. If this repair takes the technician 11 hours to complete, he only is paid 6.7. Likewise, if it takes him 5.5 hours, he has made money on the repair, and can now move on to the next vehicle. Should the vehicle return for the same concern, due to a technician's mistake, he is required to re-do the job for free. This is called "flatrate".

    This is an excellent way of compensating technicians, because it promotes good, but timely repairs. Recently, the labor allowance for the Windstar mentioned earlier was arbitrarily reduced to 4.0 hours. This almost guarantees that every technician that has to replace a transmission on this vehicle will lose money. Labor times have been slashed across the board, on all repairs, makes, and models, seemingly for no apparent reason. As a matter of fact, Ford generated a $70 million profit last year alone, simply by reducing what they were willing to pay for warranty labor.

    Ford's stance on this issue is that they set the time for each repair so a reasonably capable technician will be able to meet the time, then add 20% to the allowance to cover things like ordering parts, extracting broken bolts, etc. This sounds like a great method for calculating labor times, but in reality, many of these times are impossible to beat. Some operations have been deleted completely, forcing the technician to work for free, or improvise. Ford has made so many cutbacks that a lot of good technicians are finding it hard to make a living. Many of the best techs out there are leaving the business altogether, leaving the younger, inexperienced technicians to handle warranty repairs. Ford claims that the times were reduced due to the use of air tools, but what about repairs like trim panel replacement, electronic engine control diagnosis, noise diagnosis and others where air tools are not used? These repairs have been affected as well.

    What does this mean to the consumer?

    In regards to symptom diagnosis, many repairs are closed out with "No Problem Found" written in the tech's notes. If the tech knows he is not getting paid to diagnose the customer's concern, he is likely to make a quick inspection, and release the vehicle if it does not act up promptly. As a technician, my goal is to perform the best repair possible. These warranty cuts, however, tend to promote speed, rather than quality, leading to repeat repairs, no problem founds, and customer frustration. Ford has been saving money on warranty costs by taking it from the dealerships, when they could just as easily make changes in manufacturing and engineering processes to keep the vehicles from breaking down in the first place.

    The time has come for Ford Motor Company to take responsibility for the quality of their products, instead of forcing it's dealers and technician's to pick up the slack. There is no reason why Ford should not stand behind their cars, and be willing to pay a fair price for warranty repairs. After all, Quality is Job #1 isn't it?
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    that the article is from Blueovalnews.com and Meredith, copyright permission has been given.
  • ryanbabryanbab Member Posts: 7,240
    First day in my engineering economics class teacher told us "quality is job #1" is totally BS. He worked for ford and didnt say anything bad about em but PROFITS are job #1. Quality isnt job #1 for any company learning this more and more especially in my ethics class.

    Ryan
  • oldharryoldharry Member Posts: 413
    mentioned modifications that increased his horse power. As an uninsured motorist totaled my older car a couple weeks ago I have just acquired a 94 C-1500. The previous owner did some modifcation that really did upgrade the performance, he pulled the V-6, and put in a 350 from a Caprice police cruiser. (I bought it from Veto Enterprises, a police equipment supplier) I suspect this truck got a bigger increase than "rules" truck.

    Harry
  • RoclesRocles Member Posts: 982
    oby,

    I don't know. Sounds like a disgruntled mechanic. I've heard these complaints from many dealer mechanics regardless of brand.
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    I agree, especially the "No problems found" part.
  • RoclesRocles Member Posts: 982
    Just like the family doctor; he's got to find the needle in the haystack.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    Dodge is #1 in trips to the dealer for repairs.
    Dodge is #1 for gallons of gas per mile.
    Dodge is #1 for Hick appeal.
    Dodge is not #1 for resale value.
    Dodge is not #1 for sales volume.
    Dodge is not #1 for initial quality.
    Dodge is a foreign owned company (Chrysler is #2 Diamler-Chrysler).
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    that

    Dodge is #1 for people appearing on Jerry Springer's show.
  • jcmdiejcmdie Member Posts: 594
    You might want to recheck your resale values again. Unless they changed within thje last year Dodge had a higher percentage of retained value than GM or Ford. Something that I'm sure baffles the Ford and GM fans.
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    Go look around! We have a 1997 chev suburban with 74K on it. Full sticker in 1997 was $38,700, today kelly trade in value is 16,000!!! We also have a 1997 dodge ram, sticker $26,300, kelly trade in value is over $18,000. The dodge wins!!! Not to mention the quility is much better on the dodge.
  • dodgeram7dodgeram7 Member Posts: 55
    I am sure that Chevy and Ford are baffled by the truck that Dodge builds is the best on the market.
  • obyoneobyone Member Posts: 7,841
    You have what seems to be the best one liners in Edmunds. Is that because you can't think of anything else to post so your post is always limited to one line....LMAO!!
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    1998 Model; Expected value after 2 years
    Mercedes-Benz M class: 73%
    Chevy Tahoe LS, 4-door, 4-wheel drive: 72
    GMC Yukon, 4-wheel drive: 72
    Ford Expedition XLT, 4-wheel drive: 72
    Lincoln Navigator: 71
    Toyota Land Cruiser: 71
    Porsche Boxter: 70
    GMC/Chevy Suburban, 4-wheel drive: 70
    Honda CR-V: 70
    BMW Z3 with 2.8 liter V-6: 70
    Mercedes-Benz SLK: 70
    Source: Automotive Lease Guide

    I checked resale values and you are right jcmdie. I just forgot that Mercedes is actually a Dodge. And I suppose that Tahoes and Suburbans are Dodges too. Dont forget that up until the current style Dodge Ram was introduced the Dodge was selling about 82,000 trucks a year. I bet a lot of Dodge drivers think the K car is the best car ever built.
    And western6, I have a buyer for your Suburban for $16K, when can you deliver it.
  • jcmdiejcmdie Member Posts: 594
    I don't see a single pickup truck on your list. Whats your point? My reference to resale was strictly having to do with full size pickup trucks, not LeBarron versus a seville sts or any car/ suv you have listed above. Look in Edmunds or Kellys and look up resale of 1996 F150, Chevy 1500 and the Dodge Ram 1500.
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    I can't sell it for 16k, but will make a great deal on it. Keep in mind this burb has a brand new tranny, new front diff, new alternator, all seals are new, u-joints, brake job done in jan and just put new tires on last week. This burb has every option! Color is cherryice with grey leather.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    My point is that there is not a single Dodge on the list! There is a Ford product, a GM Product and a Toyota product, but no Dodge. No there is not a single Pickup on the list, Pickup's are not the vehicle to buy for resale value. How important is resale value? I keep the vehichles I buy for a long time so I am concerned with long term reliability and resale value. Go shop some older trucks (5 to 10 years old) and you will find that the Dodges are worth less and in worse shape than Chevy, Ford, and Toyota. **The old Toyotas still run great, however, usually are far worse than Dodge when it comes to RUST.**
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    I do not know where you get your information, but you should get a new source. Pick up trucks (all brands) have very high resale value. At least in Montana!! You are wrong on the dodge trucks! I own one, It is the best pick up I have ever owned. In 91k I have not done anything but gas, oil and one brake job. Before you ask, YES I have owned a toyata. I was not impressed!!
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    I think the Unibomber had a Dodge when he lived in Montana. Hope your not a friend of his. I could be wrong about resale in Montana. I accidently included the other 49 states when checking my source. I know a lot of people who love Chrysler Products. Transmission Repair Shops are #1 fans of Chrysler Products. Scrap Metal Dealers really like Dodges. Chrysler products are sooo good that Chrysler almost went out of business and was practically on welfare from the government not too many years ago.
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    Wasn't he originally from Chiago. I know he did not believe in the internal combustion engine, just like that democrap al!!
    As far as tranny problems try a chevy.
    My Dodge is a five speed, have never had a problem.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    Q: What is the best motor in a Dodge Pickup?
    A: Cummins Diesel. At least it is not made by Dodge.

    Q: How come Dodge only makes a V10? Why not a V12?
    A: Dodge drivers (and engineers) can't count over 10 without taking off their shoes.

    Q: How do you increase the intelligence of a Dodge driver?
    A: Buy them a Ford.

    Q: Whats the best way to help a Dodge driver?
    A: Call a tow truck for them.

    Q: I heard theres a lot of Dodges in Montana. Is that because there are no speed limits in Montana and Dodges are so fast?
    A: No, that is because there are no speed limits in Montana and Dodges are so slow. In most states there are minimum speed limits that Dodges can't achieve.

    Q: Why not make Firestone Wilderness Tires standard equipment on Dodge trucks?
    A: Good idea.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    Dodge does not believe in the internal combustion engine either.
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    Don't tell me your a ford guy!!
    you know powerjoke is better than cummings, we all have herd that fairy tale!
    Dodge does believe in gas burners. Thats why everbody will be crying for mommy when they bring back the Hemi!!
    The reason there are so many Dodges in Mt, You need power to pull hills!!
  • bigsnagbigsnag Member Posts: 394
    ....would anyone cry for mommy if Dodge brought back outdated technology? Have you ever had any experience with the Powerstroke? Ever driven one to haul/tow anything? Have you ever even read any comparisons in magazines where the Powerstroke outperforms the Cummins? I don't believe everything I read, but the evidence is stacking up.
  • ryanbabryanbab Member Posts: 7,240
    Ok the powerstroke outperforms the cummins. BUT the DMAX outperforms em all.

    Ryan
  • jcmdiejcmdie Member Posts: 594
    You appaarently have a serious comprehension problem. This is a pickup truck confgerence. You brought up resale value(post 330). When I correct your error, you produce a list of cars and thier resale. Trucks, moparmad, Trucks are what we are discussing or move to a relavent topic. The resale value of dodge TRUCKS is better than ford and GM TRUCKS. By the way my baby toyota ran great until I simply couldn't deal with the lack of body (rusted out) after 6 years. My GMC went through not 1 but 2 transmissions in less than 60,000 miles (2500 series pulling a 26' camper), not to mention oodles of electrical problems.
  • lariat1lariat1 Member Posts: 461
    Is dependent on where you are located. A perfect example is up here where I live in Alaska, just try to sell a 2 wheel drive truck up here,your best chance is to find someone who needs a truck and is leaving the state.Right now I don't think there is a 2WD truck on any new car lots up here. But on the other hand if you are trying to sell a Super Duty crew cab with the power stroke you can easily sell it for 33k-36k depending on the condition. Then if you go to some place like California you will sell a 2WD truck a lot easier than a monster crew cab.
    For the most part advertisements spout off all these numbers and "facts" but in reality all they did was crunch some numbers and make themselves look good.How often do you walk up to a truck and say "wow this truck is beautiful it has everything I ever wanted on a truck,but next year when I sell it I wont get as much as a different brand of truck"? If you are in the position to buy a new truck every year more than likely you are not worried about resale value you are more worried about how to get more back on your tax return.
  • ryanbabryanbab Member Posts: 7,240
    I just did a comparison. Im not trying to go one way or another. I took a 98 ford chevy and dodge comparably equipped and put in 65000 mls and those numbers popped out. Just did it for an example.

    Ryan
  • jcmdiejcmdie Member Posts: 594
    I know. No complaints on your post. Moparmad is just a little out there is all.
  • z71billz71bill Member Posts: 1,986
    When I was shopping for a new truck (about 1 1/2 years ago) I found Dodge to be less $$ that GM in a base truck with very few options, the normal A/C, Automatic tranny and steel wheels. But when I compared fully loaded 4x4 X-cab the Dodge had a higher invoice and MSRP then the Chevy.
  • western6western6 Member Posts: 11
    Yes, My father-in-law owned 97 powerstroke, it died with a little over 65k on it. I do not believe a v8 is the best design for a deisel.
    The Hemi will be availible on the 2002 ram.
    go to auto buzz.com to see torque ratings, they are impresive.
  • cdeancdean Member Posts: 1,110
    Jcmdie
    I don't agree with your statement about the starting price of trucks. I think it really depends on area and most of all, dealers. I can get invoice price on a GM truck in my hometown, then go down the road 20 miles to a larger city, and barely get off MSRP. Dodge and Ford are the same...there's no corporate mandate to how the dealer sells the truck....the big 3 get their money no matter what.
  • z71billz71bill Member Posts: 1,986
    My experience is the opposite of yours. Small town dealers have higher prices. The town I grew up in had one dealer for Chevy, one Ford, and one GMC which also sold Pontiac. Now I live in Houston - it must have 25 Chevy dealers within 30 miles of my house. Don't want my business fine I will drive 3 miles to the next dealer. I have bought 2 cars and 2 trucks since living here and all have been at or below invoice. The small town dealer does have better service - they need to because they know if you have a problem everyone in town will find out about it. I also think it is an advantage to know the people at the dealership - maybe went to school with them or see them at church / beer joint (take your pick).
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.