High End Luxury Cars

1328329331333334463

Comments

  • drfilldrfill Member Posts: 2,484
    7 Series 1,308 10,831 1,833 9,726

    325i (E90 & E46) 3,644 29,276 4,176 25,539

    325xi (E90 & E46) 1,093 9,418 2 2,929

    330i (E90 & E46) 1,320 10,752 2,185 10,416

    5 Series 3,474 31,309 4,381 27,765

    E-CLASS 4,479 5,506 25,199 25,940

    S-CLASS 2,233 1,469 17,817 9,101

    M-CLASS 2,446 3,526 16,772 17,816

    GS 300 1,776 2,785 13,125 15,164

    GS 430/450h 299 589 2,443 3,524

    IS 250/350 4,848 516 31,794 3,133

    The Camry Hybrid, which went on sale in late April, reported sales of 5,023 units in July.

    The Prius gas-electric hybrid mid-size sedan posted July sales of 11,114, an increase of 19.3 percent.

    The Highlander Hybrid gas-electric mid- size SUV reported sales of 2,784 units for the month. The Highlander and Highlander Hybrid posted combined July sales of 11,999.

    Lexus best-ever July at 26,969.

    Toyota best Month EVER! Up 17.7% over last year!:shades:

    GX 470 1,969 2,847 13,728 19,080

    Chrysler 300 83,772 84,167 0% 0%

    Liberty 79,808 103,229 -22% -23%

    Grand Cherokee 82,995 131,865 -37% -37%

    Source: TheAutochannel.com

    Interesting that Chrysler's big models are either flat (first time for the 300), or down significantly.

    Camry Hybrid made up almost 15% of all Camry sales

    Prius is still at or above last years record levels.

    If you compare like models, BMW is less than 1500 units ahead of Lexus IS. The 325/330i/325ix comes to around 6000.

    Everybody feels the hit when gas prices spike. Lexus, Mercedes and BMW SUVs are down big.

    OOps! :blush:

    Forgot Infiniti M numbers. YTD, 100 units behind Lexus GS! Can't get any closer than that!

    I guess what I'm trying to say is.....

    Lexus/Toyota rules! Woo-Hoo! :shades:

    DrFill
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    Generally I like the guy from Joisey, so I'm not gonna get in his face too much. He is, afterall, a proud Lexus owner and fan and I believe that he has the LS600hL on order as well.

    The statement I made (and you re-stated tonight) regarding the affordability of the LS vs. the S is a matter of economics. Pure and simple. From a pure economic perspective, which ljflx well understands, a more expensive car is generally a deeper and more difficult reach in the pocket . . . period. It doesn't get more complicated than that, as some others here have posted.

    We don't need all the twisted baloney about "creative financing" here, just basic fundamentals.

    And all this talk about "insecurity" is ridiculous. Is it insecure to purchase a HELM, or just certain HELMs? Or is it insecurity that feeds the need for a reliable car, as one might be too insecure and fearful regarding the horrible risk associated with owning a car that might actually be more enjoyable to drive? All absurd, IMO.

    TagMan
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    Coises! :sick:
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    I surely hope this is an emotional moment. You are a terrific contributor to this forum, which reaches great heights at the expense of some bad lows.

    As a businessman and investor, you should understand something I will say here . . . you believe in the stock market, and you know that it is like a yo-yo that is traveling up a mountain. Ups and downs, ups and downs, but the climb becomes apparent over time.

    This forum is the same. Ups and downs and ups and downs, but in the end, you are part of something bigger and better.

    Please consider my words and please stay.

    TagMan
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    Never made sense to me Tagman.

    How could anyone prefer a Lexus, when there are BMW's and Porsches out there?
    I don't see the rational of hiding behind the reliability argument.
    Thousands drive BMW's and MB's with very few problems.
    There is an irrational fear there, or perhaps, a masochistic urge to deprive oneself of true driving pleasure, which if true, is a real shame, IMO.
  • drfilldrfill Member Posts: 2,484
    Mellow out, man!

    Don't let 'em get the best of you. I got your back, kid!

    ;)

    Take a few days off and come back next week refreshed!

    I'm good, real good, but the team needs you, man... :cry:

    DrFill
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    hpowders,

    Please consider hitting the "pause" button for a moment.
    Being "right" or "winning" is worthless when people stop participating. I'm not sure exactly what has happened here, as I was out this evening, but I am not glad to see our friend from joisey is considering leaving this forum. I would miss both the agreements and disagreements with him, and I think you would as well. So . . . I'm not in the game right now, my friend. Sorry.

    TagMan
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    See Post # 17503-last line-a derogatory term for Lexus folk.
    I do believe this influenced his decision.
    Using a spelled-out curse word to describe someone is uncalled for. Probably what he was referring to as "trash", which I would surely agree with.
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    It's not the kind of language I would use. We're supposed to be the HELM forum, not the trailer park forum. It's one thing to have an opinion, and I know that many of us are heavyweights . . . it goes with the territory. But so does having an extra bit of class.

    I would like to see Len back here tonight with the realization that he is an important part of this forum, and I am dissapointed in him if he quits on all of us. He's made a mistake or two in all his years, I'm sure, so maybe it's time to take a deep breath and get back on the horse.

    I suggest less finger-pointing and raising the "class" level up a notch on this forum . . . with the INCLUSION of lj.

    Whudda ya say, Len?

    TagMan
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    It's sort of like playing hockey with a 1-man advantage for the whole game-kind of lop-sided.
    No fun in that.
    The penalty box door has opened.
    Time to get back on the ice! ;)
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    As I said, I was out to dinner when all this stuff happened, but I do not want to see you leave this forum.

    This is my last request . . . because as you realize, I'm putting myself out there in the public domain to bring you back into this forum with your friends. Sure, some folks can be rough around the edges, but better to show them the high road and set the example.

    You have a lot to give and contribute here . . . and you know I am telling the truth.

    As I always say at my office . . . "Failure is not an option."

    TM
  • ljflxljflx Member Posts: 4,690
    Tagman,

    Just for you because I like you very much and respect you equally. Hpowders made a post that he subsequently editted out. But I saw it before he did the edit. It was tasteless and a lot more classless than what he referenced you to. He knows damm well what I am referring to. I want no part of discussions like that. I'll check the board in a few weeks. If it has some class and professionalism I'll come back. If it has the bad posting I've seen recently, particularly tonight (some of which you can't see unfortunately), but not limited to tonight, I'm long gone. I deal with professionals and I deal professionally with people. Classless behavior is not something I will ever be apart of. It's that simple.

    My post to Merc was sincere - he and I have had phenomenal disagreements for years now that always ended respectfully and we've been penpals here for 5 or 6 years now.

    Taking things to a personal level on a board about cars is absurd.
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    See you soon, my friend.

    :D:D:D

    TM
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    Makes no sense. I'm not positive on the number but do know over 50% LEASE luxury cars, and if they are paying similar monthly payments for a less expensive sticker priced car, that kind blows your time and time again argument that the LS sells better because of it's cheaper price. I've said it before and I'll say it again, that argument is lame and just plain wrong. And then when you add in the simple facts that: 1) Lexus builds ONE LS model vs. about MB building 7-8 maybe more(who can keep track?) models. 2) the business premise that offering more variations of a product should get you more sales. your argument of the LS outselling S-class because of price is mute at best.

    Equally this constant harping about leasing as if it applies to everyone, makes no sense either. What is so hard to grasp about the fact that not everyone leases? For people to finance or purchase with cash price does matter. If you don't believe it then ask some on these boards who still "buy" their cars as opposed to renting (i.e. leasing) them. If you think that price has absolutely nothing to do with or not bearing on the LS430's sales then you're just plain lost in space. Being cheaper than a comparable Mercedes is Lexus' MO. Period. What difference does it make if MB builds more models, when they're all priced way above anything from Lexus? That cancels out any notion that the S-Class should be outselling a car that sells on average for upper E-Class/5-Series money.

    And when all those people who cross shop a more expensive S-class and the cheaper LS and end up paying about the same for leasing the LS, what does that say about the Lexus LS???

    Same as above re-stated. What for I dunno.

    M
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    Quattro Gmbh is also a more direct competitor to Motorsport than AMG is. Most AMGs are rocket fast, but not usually "sports cars" in the way Audi RS cars are. Watching the CL65 try to get around the Top Gear track was pretty humorous. As they put it "in the corners it turns into just a regular Mercedes".

    Kinda outdated example there LG. The new E63 and current SLK55 have proven that AMG can make them corner nearly as well as anything from BMW's M. Even the European press have put AMGs on top more than once now, and 2 European publications have put the ML63 over the Porsche Cayenne Turbo S. These victories were based on the AMG products being so close to the others in handling, but also being able to provide superior comfort at the same time. Shockingly enough EVO even put the CLS55 over the M5 and our favorite the Quattroporte Sport GT because it was so well rounded.

    The outgoing CL likely wasn't initially developed with that kind of power in mind, but nothing has been said like that about the new S65 (relative to the old one). AMG is definitely making much better handling cars now than they did when the CL65 first appeared.

    M
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    I was under the impression that Audi already outsells BMW on a worldwide basis. Does anyone know if that's accurate?

    No it is still BMW, MB and Audi in that order when it comes to worldwide sales. For the first 1/2 of 2006:

    BMW: 597,120 (+11.0%) ... Group (incl MINI & RR): 698,470 (+8.0%)
    MB: 565,300 (+13.1%) ... Group (incl smart): YTD 627,300 (+8.7%)
    Audi: 463,494 (+9.8%)

    Funny thing is that MB outsold BMW last month here in the U.S. and they're growning a little bit more than BMW so far this year worldwide.

    M
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    Folks, face the truth:
    Anybody who gets an S Class can get an LS, but not all LS buyers can step up to the price and prestige of the magnificent MB S Class- unanimously praised as one of the greatest sedans in the world-and priced accordingly.


    BINGO! What a busy day you've had! Was it really the BMW sales numbers like others have suggest? :P

    M
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    Merc1 - you and I are buddies and I'll always post back to you on the boards I stay on as we've been at this in the right way, and in a positive way (or at least it always ended positive) for so many years now.

    Yeah we often disagree, but we did manage to find some middle ground in between there (sometimes), and more importantly I have always understood where you're coming from, even if I didn't always agree with it. That said, I don't want you to leave. You know how it goes around here, usually I'll incite a riot and then a few days it quiets down, but this time it wasn't me...lol! However if you feel you must leave, don't make it permanent. Please check back in because the board wouldn't be the same without you!

    I haven't seen this many posts in one day around here in years! I'm still reading through them all.

    M
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    Everybody feels the hit when gas prices spike. Lexus, Mercedes and BMW SUVs are down big.

    Mercedes' SUVs as a group are NOT down this year Doc. The GL, R are adding in and making up for the ML's downturn this year.

    The Mercedes-Benz portfolio of luxury light trucks -- M-Class, R-Class, GL-Class and G-Class -- continues to demonstrate impressive gains with a significant 62.3 percent increase over last July and a 91 percent increase
    over the same period last year (35,413 v. 18,544).


    Source

    M
  • brightness04brightness04 Member Posts: 3,148
    I have never seen a MB, Audi or BMW stuck on the side of the road in the last 25 years.

    I see that sad spectacle, especially late model MB's stuck on the side of the road, every couple weeks or so.
  • brightness04brightness04 Member Posts: 3,148
    How could anyone prefer a Lexus, when there are BMW's and Porsches out there?

    How could anyone prefer luxury cars, when motorcycles are out there to put you far more connected to the road than any four-wheel BMW or Porsche?

    Thousands drive BMW's and MB's with very few problems.

    And thousands do have problems

    . . . a masochistic urge to deprive oneself of true driving pleasure . . .

    or a masochistic urge to get one's own stuffings beat up by the road day-in and day-out, between unscheduled get-togethers with the mechanics.

    Seriously, how can anyone even pick a luxury family sedan like the 5 series if the be-all end-all goal and definition of "driving pleasure" is vehicle responsiveness?? It's a frigging family sedan for crying out loud.
  • brightness04brightness04 Member Posts: 3,148
    the magnificent MB S Class- unanimously praised as one of the greatest sedans in the world

    "One of the"?? So is the LS, what's your point?
  • brightness04brightness04 Member Posts: 3,148
    Equally this constant harping about leasing as if it applies to everyone, makes no sense either. What is so hard to grasp about the fact that not everyone leases?

    The only meaningful price for a product is the lowest commonly attainable price. There is no point in discussing MSRP for a Cadillac, for example. Lease subsidies are just a another way of mfr handing out rebate offers . . . some don't take advantage of it . . . most do. That's what matters.
  • lexusguylexusguy Member Posts: 6,419
    Kinda outdated example there LG. The new E63 and current SLK55 have proven that AMG can make them corner nearly as well as anything from BMW's M.

    The fastest AMG in the hands of the Stig (not including the SLR), is the CLS55, which managed a 1:26.9. Faster than the M3, but not as fast as the M5 or the Audi. They haven't track tested the SLK55 or E63 yet. Interestingly, the fastest car they've ever had on the track isn't German, or Italian, but Swedish, the Koenigsegg CCX.
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    The fastest AMG in the hands of the Stig (not including the SLR), is the CLS55, which managed a 1:26.9. Faster than the M3, but not as fast as the M5 or the Audi. They haven't track tested the SLK55 or E63 yet. Interestingly, the fastest car they've ever had on the track isn't German, or Italian, but Swedish, the Koenigsegg CCX.

    Yeah that was the video I posted a while back on the CLS55 AMG. While I enjoy that show a great deal, I don't like it when they track test a car in the rain.

    I really think AMG has turned a corner literally because Auto Zeitung got the facelifted SL55 AMG around the track faster (by 1.6 secs) than the BMW M6. This caused quite an uproar on some of the other boards I frequent. Auto, Motor und Sport also recently put the E63 AMG over the M5. I can't link the article scans because they're on another mesg board, but here is the summary:

    1st Place: Mercedes-Benz E63 AMG - The power of the new V8 leaves you breathless. The E63 AMG doesn't lack dynamic handling. Impressive, the comfort. The E63 is an allround talent.

    2nd Place: BMW M5 - The M5's V10 lacks the punch of the E63 AMG in midrange acceleration, but the V10 impresses as the purist sportscar engine. In handling, the M5 is sportier. The transmission is something one has to get used to, and in comfort, the M5 lags behind.


    Unlike that recent Automobile comparo of the S6/M5/E63, AM&S actually records track data and actually "tests" the cars...lol!

    Somewhat off-topic, but I'm reading the various reviews of the Saleen S7 Turbo like in the Sept issue of Road and Track. Out of all the sports cars they tested in that issue with all their outstanding performance numbers the Saleen blows them away. I mean a 10.6 1/4 mile @140 mph is just sick! What do you think about the Saleen S7 Turbo?

    M
  • sysweisyswei Member Posts: 1,804
    And all this talk about "insecurity" is ridiculous.

    When a person, any person, has purchased a particular car in part because of the status associated with it, does that not imply some insecurity on that person's part? Does it not imply that if the person couldn't be seen owning/driving that particular car (like, pretend it somehow looked like a Chevy to everyone in the world except the owner), he might have made a different choice of car? If a desire for a high-status car doesn't imply insecurity, then what does it imply?

    Is it insecure to purchase a HELM, or just certain HELMs?

    A very intelligent question. If a decision is made in part because of status, then purchasing a HELM, since it has more status than a non-HELM, does imho imply insecurity. It then follows that if a person has purchased the highest-status HELM in part because it has more status than a Lexus, that person might be more insecure than the Lexus buyer. So it isn't that the status-concious Lexus buyer is totally secure, it is that he is less insecure than the status-concious MB buyer. (For the record, I am not suggesting that all MB buyers, or all HELM buyers, are status councious. But my guess is that many are, in their hearts.)

    In the past I have stated clearly that I own Lexus (and probably wouldn't buy a non-HELM minivan) in part because of prestige/status. So by my own definitions I am a bit insecure. But likely less insecure than an MB owner who has purchased in part because of prestige/status, simply because the Lexus has less prestige/status than MB.
  • sysweisyswei Member Posts: 1,804
    How could anyone prefer a Lexus, when there are BMW's and Porsches out there? . . . a masochistic urge to deprive oneself of true driving pleasure . . .

    Would you use the same language against your comrades in arms, the MB fans? Would you say, "How could anyone prefer a Mercedes, when there are BMW's and Porsches out there?"

    The answer, to both questions, is that not everyone in the world has the same balance of priorities, likes, and dislikes as you.
  • patpat Member Posts: 10,421
    You folks had quite a party last night. :sick:

    Look, guys, the personal comments going on in here are inappropriate as most of you know. And name-calling is out of bounds.

    When we get into characterizing owners of vehicles, we get into these food-fights - every time. The comments about each other and the characterizations of owners stops here.

    Posts are going to start disappearing if that has to happen.
  • sysweisyswei Member Posts: 1,804
    You are a valued member of this forum. Hope to see you back onboard soon.
  • lexusguylexusguy Member Posts: 6,419
    I really think AMG has turned a corner literally because Auto Zeitung got the facelifted SL55 AMG around the track faster (by 1.6 secs) than the BMW M6. This caused quite an uproar on some of the other boards I frequent. Auto, Motor und Sport also recently put the E63 AMG over the M5.

    I like how the AMGs are relatively simple machines, stomp on the pedal and they go. With the M5, theres 800 transmission and suspension settings, and a million other things to fiddle with. Ferrari's system that incorporates all of those functions into one switch on the steering wheel makes a lot more sense.

    Somewhat off-topic, but I'm reading the various reviews of the Saleen S7 Turbo like in the Sept issue of Road and Track. Out of all the sports cars they tested in that issue with all their outstanding performance numbers the Saleen blows them away. I mean a 10.6 1/4 mile 140 mph is just sick! What do you think about the Saleen S7 Turbo?

    I'd rather have a Zonda F. Not quite as fast, perhaps, but the inside of the Saleen is just a track day car with a radio in it, nothing more. Certainly nothing to indicate how much money it costs. The inside of the Zonda, on the other hand, WOW!

    http://www.seriouswheels.com/pics-2005/2005-Pagani-Zonda-F-n-Interior-1280x960.j- - pg
  • merc1merc1 Member Posts: 6,081
    I'd rather have a Zonda F. Not quite as fast, perhaps, but the inside of the Saleen is just a track day car with a radio in it, nothing more. Certainly nothing to indicate how much money it costs. The inside of the Zonda, on the other hand, WOW!

    Well yes of course you'd know I'd have a Zonda too considering the connection with Mercees-Benz. I don't think the fact that the Saleen is bascially a street version of their race car hurts anything, that is what bascially made Ferrari such an icon. We're getting the Zonda in 2008 I believe.

    M
  • brightness04brightness04 Member Posts: 3,148
    It goes to show that as sales volume expectation is lowered, price and luxury decouple from each other rapidly. If I don't expect much sales, I can ask $100k for a matchbox car . . . that does not mean the $100k MSRP has anything to do with how much the car is worth.
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    As long as the big 3 are Audi, MB and BMW, I am happy.
    Doesn't really matter, the order.
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    As long as BMW, Audi and MB are the top 3, I am extremely happy!
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    I remember referring to Lexus as "snipers with powerful scopes that had BMW in their crosshairs". Few agreed with me, and I was the lonely poster for the most part on this point of view, but I still maintain my position.

    Tagman,

    I think MB has more to fear from Lexus than any other German marque. You may be correct about Lexus being a future threat to BMW but that threat certainly does not exist with their current product-line.

    As mentioned by somebody else in this forum Audi is BMW's biggest threat right now!
  • drfilldrfill Member Posts: 2,484
    Wasn't counting the R or GL class, as they are brand new.

    The ML and G are down.

    DrFill
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    BMW has a great niche and IMO has to screw up to blow their position. Why risk that niche? Also it sounds like that nonsense about 2/3rd or 3/4's of luxury customers not considering BMW is an overstatement for the purpose of justification.

    I fully agree with you!

    What is forgotten by auto executives in various German firms is that "niche" is not a four lettered word at all. A profitable niche player that provides unique autos is not only good for customers but also good for shareholders (BMW and Porsche shareholders have been quite content these past few years).

    Having said that it ceases to amaze me how many German auto firms are willing to dilute their strong reputations in order to grow out of their niches. The history of "growth in size" for the sake of "growth in size" is not too good for the German marques. Two obvious examples are the BMW/Rover and MB/Chryser situations. God-forbid if a takeover situation happens between VW and Porsche. :(
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    I would like to make a suggestion to all forum members. Please slow the rapid pace of your posts. I have difficulty in finding the time to keep up with your posts ( unfortunately I am no speed reader)
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    It was not a good month for BMW sales.
    True.
    But the trend for the year is solidly up across all segments I care about:

    7 Series -20.7% for July, +11.4% YTD
    S Class +52% for July, +95.8% YTD (Astonishing!)

    5 Series -20.7% for July, +12.8% YTD
    E Class -18.7% for July, -2.9% YTD

    3 Series +0.3% for July, +19.9% YTD
    C Class -1% for July, -10.8% YTD

    So as you can see across the board, Merc, sales growth of BMW vehicles are proceeding ahead at a healthy clip.

    I look for the new S Class to absolutely trounce the new Toyot..er...I mean LEXUS LS.
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    In America Audi is as flat as a nail and this is an American board.

    An American board? I better look at my passport again :P

    I can assure you there are quite a few non-Americans in this forum.

    In this globalized world Audi is a significant power in the HELM/luxury/performance segment independent of its sales results in the USA.
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    Yes. The 5 Series is a family sedan.
    I have a 545.
    For driving pleasure, the 3 Series is at the top of the BMW line.
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    "Would you use the same language...how could anyone prefer a Mercedes, when there are BMW's and Porsches out there?"

    YES!

    The only MB I lust for is the new 550 S Class with the Active Body Control suspension.
    The choice between it and a BMW 7 is a no-brainer, IMO.
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    You may be correct about Lexus being a future threat to BMW but that threat certainly does not exist with their current product-line.

    Really? Tell me which car the "current product" Lexus IS is being compared to most, my friend.

    TagMan
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    BMW 3. But is it really comparable to a 3? That is the question? No manual and vdim defeats the purpose of what the IS is really about.

    Oh yes sales of the IS are good, especially compared to the old model. GS sales were initially good too, especially when compared to the old model.

    How will the IS compete against a new Infiniti G with a potent new engine(even the Infiniti M will not have this great engine). How will the IS compete against the twin turbo BMW 3s?Oh and let us not forget the new MB C.

    Never judge a car's success at it's intro year , especially the Lexus IS. But I do love the competition.

    IMO the Infiniti G, especially the upcoming model will be a true competitior to the BMW 3 series.

    How many BMW owners do you know in this forum or in the outside world that want to buy a Lexus? How many people do you know who are Lexus owners who want to buy a BMW? A few maybe? But not many. Both marques cater to two very different types of drivers. The perpetual battles of this forum proves my point.
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    The only meaningful price for a product is the lowest commonly attainable price.

    To a point. Leasing, while a fine way to drive a car is still only renting, and there is no equity or ownership. Attainment of the contractual USE of the car is not the same as attainment of the vehicle itself. There are restrictions, and at the end of the lease, you have nothing.

    Renting a luxury home as opposed to purchasing it is quite different as well.

    The advantage of renting is simply that the manufacturer's can put a greater number of folks into their cars on a month-to-month basis.

    TagMan
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    Yes, the IS is taking on the 3. And you are watching it for yourself. Don't be naive. The brilliance of Lexus, particularly in the USA, has been witnessed for many years now. Would you have said the same thing about the LS in the early days? Look at it now! It is Lexus that has impacted Mercedes, not Infiniti or Acura . . . and it will be Lexus to impact BMW. The 3 is BMW's largest seller. The IS is targeted at the 3. The media comps them as well, and gives high marks to the IS, and IS sales are strong.

    IMO, The IS is to the 3-Series the same way the LS is to the S-Class.

    I may have slim company on this perspective, but me thinks not for long.

    TagMan
  • deweydewey Member Posts: 5,251
    I may have slim company on this perspective, but me thinks not for long.

    I fully agree with your first sentence but fully disagree with your last sentence ;)

    Only time will tell!
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    I fully agree with your first sentence but fully disagree with your last sentence

    Only time will tell!


    Fair enough.

    TM
  • hpowdershpowders Member Posts: 4,331
    The only way the IS is comparable to the 3 is in horsepower.
    It is not as much fun to drive as the 3 and is much more cramped inside than the 3.
    I do however find the IS better looking than the 3.
  • tagmantagman Member Posts: 8,441
    It's like comparing the LS to the S-Class. Different cars is many respects.

    But . . . what does the public think when it comes time to make that purchase. Have they seen the IS and the 3-series on the covers of many magazines? Do they associate the two cars together somehow?

    Just like the LS, is the performance of the IS "good enough" even if not equivalent to the competition?

    Is the price right?

    These are the reasons I speak of.

    TagMan
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.