Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to learn more!
Options
Midsize Sedans Comparison Thread
This discussion has been closed.
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
While some cars could benefit from an ESP the Legacy (and Forester) do not need them. (Having had two cars with an ESP, I have some basis of comparison) I'm more concerned about being rear-ended or t-boned.
I read somewhere that Forester's side wall is so strong that the jaws of life can't even cut through them? If you look at it another way that could be bad, though. :surprise:
My concern living in NYC, since it doesn't snow much, is the other drunk moron running the light and hitting me with my kids in the back. A smart man once said "DTA, DON'T TRUST ANYBODY!" :P
I felt the same way. The Fusion is a nice attempt by Ford, but its tough for any competitor to come close to the aircraft-tight look and feel of Honda interiors.
Plus the Accord comes standard with a sterling reputation earned from millions of gleeful owners. The Fusion has a 'cross your fingers' reputation from a manufacturer with a dubious reputation for quality and reliability.
Why do you say it won't last as long? Why? is this one of those assumptions again?
I never said the Fusions interior was "best". I am implying though the Fusion SEL interior is on par with Camry/Accord. Perception is key here.
Kind of funny how the "big butt look" is ok on your more upscale sedans... :confuse:
Agreed! Why take a chance when you don't have to in this class of cars? Ford's version of warm and fuzzy isn't for me.
Good joke! Ha ha! I'm done laughing. That was a good one.
However, I don't think the Fusion's interior is any worse than say the Sonata, Altima, Optima or any other car in this class.
I have yet to see the new Altima's interior in person...but it's supposedly on par with the new Accord and Camry...but then again with the last generation we were promised materials on par with VW's and we know that never happened.
If you look at it as you're alive and the JOL can't get through, that's good. If you're dead, it doesn't matter how long it takes.
I agree with your comment about being rear-ended. That's why the ability for the occupants of a car to survive a rear-ender is more important than ESP. Would I like both? Sure! But if one has to give ESP. It would never be a deal maker or deal breaker for me. The Legacy and it's AWD, minimize the necessity of an ESP. Although the SPEC B will have one.
Don't underestimate ESC. A recent NHSTA study hails it as a major advance in auto safety. I was surprised that it prevents so many serious and fatal injuries. Even NHSTA was surprised.
/paste NHSTA remarks
- ESC was found to reduce crashes with personal
injuries, especially serious and fatal injuries.
- The effectiveness ranged from at least 13% for
car occupants in all types of crashes with serious or
fatal outcome to a minimum of 35% effectiveness
for single/oncoming/overtaking serious and fatal
crashes on wet or icy road surface.
- Consumers should be recommended to buy cars
with ESC, and automotive industry should only
market cars with ESC as quickly as possible. Such
a policy statement has increased the fitment rate on
new cars in Sweden to almost 70% in less than two
years.
/end paste
As far as DSC on an icy road surface, I turn it off. On a snowy road a good AWD can compensate for lack of DSC, especially if the car has some type of TC. A FWD or RWD can benefit much more from DSC. (I don't have to say this is of course in my opinion, having enough experience to form this opionion). YMMV.
I wonder how the 2008 Accord's interior will look like. I hope they don't follow what they did with the Civic's interior. The Civic's interior is nice, but too daring for me.
and about the Fusion's interior...
Ford did a great job, it's well put together with quality materials. But I still don't feel that it's as good as the Accord or Camry.
I am also going to throw another great interior in the mix. Take a look at the Impala interior.. nicely done GM.. :surprise:
I have real difficulty believing that ESC saves so many accidents and saves lives in "single/oncoming/overtaking serious and fatal crashes on wet or icy surfaces."
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
IIHS position
The European statement is even stronger. They recommend that no vehicle should be without it. ( click 'Recommendation' ):
EURO/NCAP position
HAHAHAHHAHAHHA....
Okay, at least now I understand why you think Fusion's interior is on par with the Camcords. I guess some of us's standard are higher than the other's.
That's a funny one!
-Loren
There is not best car in a sedan, unless we are talking lots of bucks, like a BMW5 may be considered. In cheaper cars, Hyundai has the value plays, as does Dodge in a RWD car in the Charger. Everything in-between is a lot of personal preferences, like handling, seating, comfort, and style. It's all good! Oh yeah, an Altima has good resale.
-Loren
ABS if you read up on it, actually lengthens stopping distances. The function of ABS is to let the driver remain in control of the vehicle for panic stops, but in doing so, will increase the distance to stop.
In this whole segment, I think the Legacy Spec B is the standout. Powerful engine, ESC, AWD, nice interior, reliability, good IIHS ratings.
I think the ESC's don't repeal the laws of physics. Many hotrodders think ESC will save them from skidding off the road at 65 on that curve marked for 35, will save them from skidding on 3 inches of ice-snow mix at 65 mph on the interstate, etc.
The articles were saying that it will save many drivers form their own errors and overcorrections which often lead to single vehicle accidents. I can see where that would help for those drivers less capable than those of us who are fully able to control our own cars... grin. :P
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
Seat belts: "I don't like seatbelts, I feel that it's safer to be thrown free of the car in the crash and what if the seat belt jams while the car is on fire or underwater?!!"
Motorcycle helmets: "I can hear better without a helmet and they look dorky when on my Harley."
Air bags: "What if I really want to have my baby in the front seat with me so I can watch the baby more carefully as I drive?"
ABS: "I'd rather not have ABS because I can pump the brakes myself and I can have shorter stopping distances if I lock the brakes on loose snow and gravel than with ABS. What if I'm driving on loose snow and have to make an emergency stop in front of a washed out bridge and the extra feet of braking distance causes my car to go off the edge of a cliff?"
Traction control: "What if I have seconds to get across a slippery train track and the traction control kicks in and stops the wheels from turning causing my family to be hit by an oncoming train?"
ESC: "I'm a great driver, so I will never benefit from ESC, plus I don't want that 'electronic nanny' to stop me from doing high speed drifting skids like in the '2 Fast 2 Furious' movie."
Or maybe driving lessons would help? Just a thought. I don't own an SUV but I see some pretty crazy moves on the freeway, mixed with the issue of speed, I am amazed some idiots don't crash every day. People seem to think their SUV or truck should handle like a Forumula 1 car.
Anyway, for those buying safety + cost + comfort, must be looking for a Hyundai Sonata. All the safety gismos, and air bags galore! They look decent too. Good HP for the bucks.
-Loren
I owned one car with ABS. The Olds Achieva. Freaky brakes. On stopping, sometime even completely stopped, the back end would give a little jump, like it decided to let the back go an extra few inches. Stopping distance was nothing close to the Stealth with only four wheel disc and no ABS. If I get a car with ABS again fine, but I am not actively looking for it. It will likely just be on the list of the sticker of the next car anyway.
Air bags can add an extra 15 to what is it, something like 20% over the safety of seatbelts. Getting people to use the belts is number one. I am thinking the side air bags may be something I would add, if it is opt. only.
Never owned a car with traction control, as far as I can recall, but would get it with a Mustang. May come with the Charger. Thinking about those cars lately. With FWD, I guess it helps. I don't have it, but I do have plenty of torque steer. Not a fan of FWD. On full acceleration, off the line, FWD is just awful as the weight shifts to the back and the tires lift.
ESC may work as billed. Or in the case of the wrong programming, not work. Some Sonata got recalled, as in banked cornering it came on too aggressively. A computer doesn't really know all the conditions at hand. As for drifting, I can't afford new tires every day or week. Don't have rich parents supporting strange habits.
-Loren
Trying to "threshold brake" would be pretty difficult to do manually since you would never know if you were really at the threshold until the wheel locked, so you would never be at the maximum braking effort. Most people end up slamming on the brakes anyway if there is really some unexpected object in their path and are making a true "panic stop." Their ability to carefully and skillfully brake to the exact threshold of wheel lock may exist only in their minds or while practicing on a track.
That is what ABS is supposed to do for you. You simply slam on the brakes and it will brake to the threshold and adjust braking on individual wheels as needed (which you cannot do yourself with manual brakes)
I think all of today's brakes stop like magic compared to the 1960's cars. Another interesting thing is when asked, most people I talked to, did not know if their car had anti-lock brakes. So how do they know how to react?
As for steering and braking. I always look for an out first, then stopping second if pretty close to what is ahead. Nice to steer without braking, with or without anti-lock. You are sending the weight to the front wheels when braking - not the best deal for steering. When I have a stick, I like the gear down on turns, and use the braking early on, and use the power to pull on through. I think with the understeer and possible complete lockup of the front wheels due to FWD, the ABS became the life saver. Well, I guess it is. Hopefully better than that of GM in 1992. Trying to get the front to turn on FWD with all the weight and the braking and the redistribution of weight, is pretty exciting in some cases no doubt if you are entering a turn with recklous abandon. I guess the back end on FWD would get light though, so maybe it comes around on you as sort of a forced oversteer, then you could lightly accelerate again.
Never really pushed a FWD that much. And no, never got the RWD really sideways, just a little chirp or two out of the groove. I am fairly conservative. The Miata brings out a strange sense of overconfidence. No longer own one, but they are fun.
-loren
That is inaccurate. The lowest-price car Hyundai makes with ESC is the Sonata GLS for just under $18k. Toyota makes some less-expensive models with ESC, such as the Corolla (optional) and xB (standard). Now, Hyundai is to be commended for making ESC standard on the Sonata. But it hasn't brought ESC to below the mid-sized class yet as has Toyota.
So, maybe the xB is the cheapest with ESC if ESC is standard, but the xB doesn't have side curtain airbags, so the Sonata probably is the safest new car for the money.
Just because the website lets you check the ESC box without checking boxes on other options doesn't mean you will ever find one like that.
Anyway, suppose you can really buy a new Rabbit 4-door with ESC, automatic and no other options. The MSRP is still $19,145.
The MSRP for a 2007 Sonata GLS automatic is $18,295.
Still cheaper anyway. I still don't see any other new vehicle with all the safety features for less than a Sonata.
None at all, not even in lower size classes.
The Rabbit is not that inexpensive at all.
There's no excuse for not having ESC. Those who think they are a legendary driver can always switch it off. ESC is an important piece of a good overall safety package. I feel a little better with ESC when my wife is driving in the rain.
Personally I would put crash protection ahead of ESC. But everyone has his/her own priorities. With a little work, Hyundai could improve the side crash protection on the Sonata and then have a truly class-leading car for safety, both active and passive.
Anyway, I said for the money and even subtracting the $450 optional ESC, the Rabbit 4-door with automatic costs more than a Sonata automatic and it's in a lower size class yet still has worse fuel economy.
Not to diminish safety features, but most cars have air bags and Stability Control and anti-lock brakes, crumple zones etc. etc. etc. and buyers know this.
Avoiding accidents carries as much, if not more weight in my book. And that's where the driver comes in. A weak driver in a 'safer' car is still in jeopardy.
Best bang for the buck, I imagine is the Sonata. Not everyone is going to want a Sonata however. I am thinking the starting price with discounts on a Sonata should be around $16K. Best deal in RWD must go to Dodge, with the Charger at $23K, and discounted to say $21K or less. Must be the value leader. As for size, it is a mid-size car, if in the 1960s, and is not really but perhaps 9" longer than others in the mid-sized class.
-Loren
I wasn't implying that the Malibu is a better car, because it's not, but you would think that, with the all the money your paying for the Maxima, you'd receive better protection, at least on par with an inferior Malibu. :P
I agree the Sonata is a great value in its class, especially the V6 with its higher rebates than the I4s.
I agree a weak driver in a safer car is still in jeopardy. But I can do nothing about all the weaker drivers out there, except to watch out for them and drive in as safe a car that I can, all things considered.
The VW manages worse mpg than an automatic Sonata despite the optional 6-speed automatic that should have increased the fuel economy.
Until he new Elantra comes out, the Sonata is the lowest priced 4-door automatic car you can buy with side curtain airbags and ESC.
At the same time the Golf having some advantages over the Sonata, the Sonata has other advantages over the Golf (e.g. ESC w/ TCS); not too mention the Sonata is larger, rommier, powerful, and quiter for a large sedan.
PS. The Jetta is over priced and should have been still born. I am fair, I list the goods with the bads.
Surprised to see GM mid-sized cars still selling, but ya never know. Not the lowest price and value like the Hyundai, the reputation and resale of Toyota and Honda, or AWD like the Subaru, or the handling of a German car, one would think a GM to be a hard sell. What is left; GM style? I think that left a few decades ago. G6 GTP Coupe is sorta in the ballpark on looks, but this thread is sedans of mid-size. Go up a little in size and the Charger offers RWD. Ford sort of hangs in there with the Fusion, which has some style, even with the big butt. Taken with all things considered, will the Fusion be enough to win over customers. What is the selling point to todays American car vs. all the rest?
-Loren