Edmunds dealer partner, Bayway Leasing, is now offering transparent lease deals via these forums. Click here to see May lease deals!
Options
Popular New Cars
Popular Used Sedans
Popular Used SUVs
Popular Used Pickup Trucks
Popular Used Hatchbacks
Popular Used Minivans
Popular Used Coupes
Popular Used Wagons
Comments
What do you think?
Andy
It is a bit like comparing apples to oranges, but that does not mean it is not a valid comparison, especially from an economic or dollar point of view.
While I can't tell you what SHOULD be important to you over the whole plethora of variables, perhaps the question: does the money (1500-3000) feel better in your pocket invested at 13% over 5 years (plus 1125 to 1925) vs what you are actually getting for the money expended and the interest rate (3%) you would PAY over 5 years (-45 to -90 per year x 5years or minus-225-450?
Another structural thing is the difference in mph over 5 years 24/34 (as you say, for the Accord) vs 29/38 epa for the Civic. So say you are an average driver that puts in 12,000-15,000 miles per year. Over 5 years that would be 60,000-75,000 miles.
So at todays price of 2.25 just the differences in the epa mpg ratings can cost you an extra 522-1212 dollars. You also might want to compare the difference per year in insurance, tax, license, etc.
So for example, I am on track to put on 26,000 miles per year. Again the savings alone over 5 years in mpg at 2.25 per gal can be 180-418 per year x 5years = 405-2092.
What do you think?
Andy
What do you think?
Andy
You are looking at it from a wrong perspective. Were you in the market for a compact car or a midsize car? If you were in the market for a compact, then the Accord was not in your sights.
If you were in the market for a mid-size sedan, why were you even considering the Civic then?
Sounds like you were just looking for A CAR and any car with 4 wheels and an engine would have sufficed.
I drove the new Accord when I just came out in the fall of 2002. Although it is nice, and the manual shifter in the 4 cylinder LX is buttery smooth, the car is the size of my grandma's Buick. Way too big for me to consider. Luckily, Honda also makes a 160 hp Civic, and that was the end of my search. Yes the Accord LX with manual is probably as much as the Civic EX auto, but they are in different classes of cars. A used Accord is EX auto is cheaper than new Civic EX, I can go on comparing apples and oranges all day.
I assume you are not in the US. We only get US made, Japan made, Canada made and UK made Hondas. I have a UK made Honda, and it had some teething problems that were fixed by the dealer, but nonetheless, it was a pain to get such low craftsmanship from a Honda. I assume Turkey made car was meant for the Mideterranian/Middle Eastern sales, and may come with a weaker heater and stronger A/C, and beefed up cooling system. Whereas a car made for Nordic sales would come with a stronger heater and may have no A/c.
Each country may have its own requirements for a vehicle. Because US is so big we get heater and A/c in the north and south. But Canadian cars are slightly different that US, as far as optional and mandatory equipment (low washer light, and heated mirrors come to mind)
I seriously doubt whether the heater or A/C are different. The US Civic is the same throughout North America and the climate differences are huge, nevermind the Middle East. Yes, Hondas in Canada may get heated mirrors, etc., but a stonger heater? I'd like to see how that's done.
FYI - Everyone should register on Hondas website. Under there Honda's Owner's Link when you register your car that you own automatically comes out with all reccomendations by honda and will answer questions with right answers as opposed to many wrong ones I see on here - I listed below answers to two frequently asked questions
Honda strongly reccomends not doing the oil change till at least 5000 miles since there ARE special additives in the oil for engine break in.
It also says that there is absolutly no advantage to using a higher octane than recommended in the manual.
Please everyone read your manual - why spend thousands of dollars and not take a few hours to read?
in general though, the one from turkey is a sedan, and the one from england is a '5door' ie - hatchback. that's another question. plus, the jazz is available here. the small size and gas milage are nice, but the civic isnt that much more expensive. this is similar to the discussion on accord v. civic, though i dont see as big a difference in size between the jazz and civic.
As far as UK made vs. Turkey made goes, I can tell you that UK made car I have is inferior to Japan made, Canada made, and US made (in that order). Almost all of the warranty issues I had were due to sloppy assembly work. Yes it was the first year the Swindon plant was producing cars for global market, but they should have worked out the problems before releasing the vehicles to the public. The 2003's made in UK have had less prblems reported than the 2002.
If you want to make a rought judgement call on quality of UK made vs. Turkey made. Go to the dealer lot and measure the panel gaps and the variation. Japan made car would have very minimal gaps and very minimal variations, where as my UK made Civic has bigger gaps and they are varied throughout the car. It has to do with the pride employee takes in his/her work. Japanese workers generally have more pride in what they do.
I am not sure about the Irael laws, but make sure either the UK or Turkey made vehicle is certified for sale in Israel, as opposed to gray market vehicle. Honda will not honor warranty if the car is gray market. If I, as US resident went over to Canada and bought a Honda to bring back to US. Honda US will not honor the warranty on the car.
More on topic, I'd get a Honda diesel product in a heartbeat if the proponents of world trade would let a Honda diesel product into this country!
http://www.vtec.net/news/news-item?news_item_id=136769
But you are right, I also would avoid the Izusu diesel.
I anticipate, according to what I have read, the Honda diesel to be better than the VW diesel. I do however enjoy the VW TDI. It still absolutely amazing to me to cruise 600 miles at 85,95 mph with passing bursts to 100 mph on I 70 south in Utah, fuel in Las Vegas NV and get 48 mpg!!!
Doesn't sound like Isuzu had anything to do with the Honda diesel to me.
If that's the case, why did a Japanese company (Honda) build a plant in the UK? Sounds like Honda wasn't too proud after all if they let the Brits put their cars together. I've heard the opposite, that the UK Honda plants are top-notch. Still, after checking the panel gaps on one Si, you must know more than the industry.
Doesn't sound like Isuzu had anything to do with the Honda diesel to me.
post 3669 was the retraction of the statement I made earlier with a nice movie file, if you missed it.
It has to do with the cost of labor in Japan. UK, Canada and US to Japan is what Mexico is to US and Eastern Europe to Germany, developing industrial country with cheap labor. Still, most of the cars for JDM are made in Japan, except a few that are imported back to Japan. All of the world's Civic hatchbacks are supposedly made in UK.
I'd be interested in hearing what other people think of the new design. Looks a lot like the current Prius, of all things!
MotorTrend has recently provided a "sketch" of the 06 Si coupe in their December 2004 issue. Is it accurate you may ask? Very unlikely. Due to some of their past forecasts we would recommend waiting for information from other, more credible sources.
http://www.hondapreview.com/civic/
as for the HRV, it is available, but we already have the honda shuttle (old model odessey in US) and are looking for something smaller.
and it has snowed more than once in jerusalem, things shut down when it does, and it melts pretty quickly too :-)
Also it recommends using 5w-20 oil, how about using 10w-30? I live in the SF bay area so the weather here is not a concern. Thanks
For example: What is poor performance? What other vehicles get 35/38 mpg EPA?
Too bad it is auto, only if you knew how much power your Civic has at or above 5000 rpm, you would wish you bought a stick. Try and hold that pedal until the tach goes above 5000 and close to the readline.
This is the first time I have come to the Honda Civic board. Perhaps a current owner would be best to answer this: Is this engine relatively weak at 115 HP. The ex model has 127 HP, but has less power than a 130 HP focus or corrola engine. This one factor has kept me from seriously considering this vehicle. I test drove a 2001 civic and it was a poor performer.
And to the person asking about Corolla and a Civic and whether the 127 HP was less than 130 hp. Go with a Corolla. Honda engines are not for every day people who want point and shoot power. Honda engines are revvers and require some forcasting as to where you want to be in the RPM range when you make a maneuver. Honda is an engine company, automatics are not Honda's strong point and most of the automatic transmissions kill the fun factor that high revving engine can provide in a clutch environment with its precise shifting and engagement. Also, Honda's manual tranmissions are sometimes rated higher than BMW's which is the standard for most other "fun driving" vehicles.
So, yes, a Civic will run cirles around a "more powerfull" (3 hp, can anyone notice that?) in the hands of a skilled driver. If you want a car to get you from point A to point B then get a Corolla. Unless you are looking at Corolla XRS (or GTS) one of them 180 hp Corolla's with a high revving Yamaha engine and 6 spd manual. Those are revvers too, and require more neural activity.
It's the torque rating at low range that most people should look at. If you can find a published graph of the torque rating/curve vs rpm, the car with the torque highest in the 2-3K range is what most drivers will rate as the better engine.
Horsepower is only at rpms like blueie is talking about. Most of us don't drive cars like that. I used to compare horsepower when I was young buying Mustangs, but later I realized it's the torque that you use from a stoplight and stopsigns that makes the car feel strong.
"Honda is an engine company, automatics are not Honda's strong point"
You can sure say that again with all the trans recalls and extended warranties they had to give for Odyssey and Accord v6 transmissions through the last ?10 years...
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
But different driving styles and seasons for those of us who have snow and summer or high temps for those in the hot-hot southern climes mean that everyone really should change their oil at different intervals.
I watch my oil's "contaminant" load by putting 3 drops on a piece of kitchen paper towel. When the oil spreads it leaves behind a center dark area of dirt and oxidation. If that center patch is about the size of a dime after letting the oil spread for 5 or 10 mintues, I start thinking about changing it.
This varies from 2500 miles in winter with my wife's short drives to 3000 on my older car in winter (Ohio). In summer I just went 4500 miles on the newer car with two 700 mile trips and longer drives through the summer mixed in with 5-mile trips to my wife's school.
The oil change indicator in the computer indicated 25% left on the oil. So I'm real comfortable with using my paper towel method.
If you care enough about your car to ask here what you should do, I suggest that you try the paper towel with oil from a hot motor and see how it matches up with the change interval you select.
BTW: I change filter every time. I do my own oil changes.
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
It depends on what your driving conditions are. If you fall under SEVERE then you should change at 5000 and then every 5000. If you fall under Normal conditions, then change at 10,000. Anything in between is your call. It is your car after all.
Pesonally, I do 5000 miles on Mobil 1 and change filter very time. I have a 7 mile commute with most highway. The car never gets warm enough, not like it used to when I had a 60 mile commute. But, either way, I was doing 5000 mile intervals with Mobil 1 and Honda OEM filter, until the warranty expires. Then I will switch to Mobil 1 filter and may go 7500 miles. My main reason for doing 5000 miles was questionable media used in Honda OEM filter. Although Honda recommends changing the filter every other time, I highly doubt that recycled toilet paper media can withstand 10,000 miles of pressure fluctuations (accelerate to red line, decelerate)
I personally will use regular oil and change frequently by some's standards. Cheaper and it gets contaminants out of the system.
Oil filters: I read that Honda filters are made by Fram. Point made.
I don't know where the 'toilet paper media' reference comes from. The medium used for filtering is made from materials of which I don't know the content. They may look like toilet paper, but if you put toilet paper in there, you'll quickly have nothing left, same as putting toilet paper in the toilet: it dissolves into separate fibers. The reference may come from the 50 and 60s when someone sold filter holds for toilet paper rolls for engines. These were like some of the original filters in the 50s which were tanks where a filter was dropped in that was about the size of toilet paper rolls.
Oil pressure: cars have a pressure relief valve that prevents the oil pressure from going above a certain level. Revving the engine fast may reach taht maximum output of the pump and start dumping the excess oil to keep the pressure at the maximum allowed. These rarely, if ever fail to control max pressure. More often they drop resistance and start dumping at lower pressures.
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
See Bobtheoilguy.com where tests have been done on filters in a somewhat scientific method. I'll change mine every oil chanage, thank you...
I'll use the money I save to buy better filters for the oil and for the air that goes into the motor. That's the source of some dirt that ends up in the oil.
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
The torque to weight would be involved in the
driving most people do in stop and go and suburban traffic. Horsepower to weight would be for those doing 1/4 mile drags where they rev the engine up to 5K.
The gear ratios of the transmissions and final drive ratios would be at play here too.
2014 Malibu 2LT, 2015 Cruze 2LT,
I also follow the Bobstheoilguy web site. One thing is clear about the scientific method that is missing: They do not do comparative oil analysis measurement across filters to see which one is actually filtering better/worse and more importantly at what levels does it matter/not matter. It is very clear for example they do a construction quality analysis comparison but then again how does this affect effect actual oil analysis!??
The truth is that you can go the other way and get preoilers and bypass filters which in theory can cut down total wear by 50-80% OVER what you think you are cutting down wear by unneeded more frequent oil changes and so called "BETTER" filters.
I agree with you GregoryC, I should be following Honda recommended one filter change for two oil changes. Maybe I will try it next time, and see what happens.
The purpose of the US type synthetics (which are actually blends, not synthetics from what I read in the Passat discussion) is to allow extended oil change intervals.
Not all synthetics are created equal. Mobil 1, German made Castrol, Red line, Royal purple (or whatever the name is) and Amsoil are all pure synthetics with a controlled olefin chain length. Valvoline, US made Castrol, Quaker state, Pensoil are very highly purified dyno oils that have a better chain distribution than regular oil, but not as perfect as artificially made true synthetics.
The cost of Synth to quality dyno oil is 3-4X. But synth will flow instantly at sub freezing temps, because its rheology is not affected as much by temperature as dyno oil. Mobil 1 0W-20 has almost the same viscosity at 200°C as it does at -30°C, as per Mobil 1 specifications. Exxon's own superflo 5W-20's viscosity varies greatley with temperature. What that means for someone who lives in Buffalo NY? You don't need to have an oil heater when it is -30°F and your car is outside. The oil will flow the instant you crank the engine. Whereas dyno oil will take a second of dry running before the pistons get lubrication in the engine. With time all these seconds will add up and you lose compression. No, there is no need to warm up the engine. It only takes a second to get the dyno oil flowing, but synth would not have an issue.
Also, in the souther climates the synth will not deteriorate with higher operating temps, although the cooling system should keep the engine temps in check.
...but if you put toilet paper in there, you'll quickly have nothing left, same as putting toilet paper in the toilet: it dissolves into separate fibers.
One thing you forgot is that toilet paper is made/designed to dissolve in water. It should hold up pretty well in anhydrous conditions, such as engine oil, which may have very low percentage of water.
1. Retain current factory AM/FM/tape unit and add Honda single CD player ($120 from H and A).
2. Replace factory unit with aftermarket unit that incorporates CD player in head unit. I'd like to spend $200 or less.
Option 1 thoughts
- Seems to be cleaner cosmetically. Retains original styling.
- Satisfied w/ factory head unit (Majestic says made by Alpine). Ample power for my purposes and OK audio quality.
- Lose storage bin below head unit (never use)
- If head unit ever fails, costly to replace. Honda CD player only works with factory head unit.
Option 2 thoughts
- Requires adapter faceplate. Anyone used the adpater offered by Crutchfield?
- Perhaps better audio quality
- Added features (better display, satellite?)
Any comments appreciated. BTW, rear deck speakers have been replaced with Polk coaxials, front speakers are factory.
As for the speakers, you replaced the rear but kept the factory front? I would think the front speakers are more important for you as the driver.