By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
You still haven't shown us a prioritized list of your selection criteria. If Sport is wayyy up there (and it definitely was when I first graduated and got an Acura Integra), I'd say stop looking here and try a BMW. You probably won't appreciate luxury and safety until you're old enough to complain about back pain going over potholes ;-)
In different leagues are the E and S. A used E is at the upper end of Luxo and not very sporty (entirely different buyer). An S is ultimate luxo, and if you get the ABC package, it does well in sportiness.
As for MB safety versus others, I think the latest MB commercials about safety (the one w/ the little kid in B&W) and the M-Class "staying alive" one are the best statements on why "safety" in most people's minds mean MB or Volvo. The C, because it is so new, has just about every new safety feature, including nice curtain bags instead of the BMW head tubes. I am very impressed w/ BMW's X5 crash testing though. Safe often means more mass, which usually means worse handling.
I understand what you are saying. I do not think a person could go wrong with any of those cars. We have a family friend who manages a Pontiac dealership. I asked him how they could possibly unload so many bad cars(Read:Aztek) and he said "Well, our favorite saying is 'there is an [non-permissible content removed] born for every seat'"
It died every year and had to be towed. The body panels didn't fit right inside or out.
We went from that to Acura/Toyota for reliability and perfect fit...and now MB for safety and durability since my Integra melted in the winter salt baths :-)
I suspect your friend is right. A better way to say it is: what's good for you is not necessarily good for me.
Pop back in if you do a back-to-back test drive of the 325 against the C w/ details. If you have any questions, I'm sure someone here has probably compared the two and others...
If you're still curious about the C, try out the Sport. You didn't mention which C you tried, but the price doesn't sound like a C320 Sport. Irregardless, though, the 323 will be cheaper and if you're happy w/ something that costs less, do it...you can always use the extra to get toys like the Valentine1. I think the 3 series looks cool, too...has this nice muscular look :-)
I have a 1999 C280 with 24,500 miles and have had wonderful performance all along save for a leak in the rear end (axel) which was discovered by the dealer and fixed post haste.
For what it's worth, as I mentioned last year, a taxi owner in Heidelberg, Germany took us to the train station in his MB taxi. I asked him if any of the taxi companies in Germany used the BMW product. He said - "hell no!" we can't afford the down time for repairs on that piece of junk! He spoke beautiful english since he had spent a few years in the U.S. That was interesting to hear.
Then, another fellow in this thread talked about the tremendous number of BMW lemon sites on the internet. I won't provide internet addresses because when I did that in 1999, the Edmund's hosts read me the riot act (via email).
CTIC - you remember some of the blasts that the bimmer owners were firing off all the time?
Some of them got downright mean in their posts. We don't need that here. Bimmer owners:Go cry somewhere else. Or if you prefer, I will send you a 25 cent coin so you can call someone that really gives a damn! This is not the place to [non-permissible content removed] about MB's folks - unless of course, you have had a problem that has been difficult to deal with - ON YOUR MB. We want to hear about your (MB) problems and the solutions - not about some guys "stick shift" bimmer. etc., etc.
the differences between the best of the best becomes more or less subjective..some want more looks.. some more power.. some more luxury.. all in some balance.. to each their own..but life is to tasted...not digested entirely from car mags..therefore.. go out and drive these cars like many of us have.. dont depend on a predigested..non-subjective opinon..
not at all a personal attack.. i just like the usual balanced,thoughtful ,and empirical opinions that this room is known for.
Likes: Great driving car. Very smooth and responsive. Hope it stays problem free. My last car was a Contour SVT... no issues, but a different kind of car.
Dislikes: Price of the CD changer.. what a ripoff. Then they put mediocre tape deck in with only Dolby B NR. At least the old C had Dolby C. Think the dealer will take the unit out so I can adjust the asimuth to my Nakamichi deck? I had to dig it out of mothballs and start dubbing tapes again. There's no excuse for this. Didn't the audio engineers ever hear of a loudness/contour switch to boost the low end at low volume? That multi-function display should do more and provide a nice display of oil-pressure/temp and voltage as well. I hoping that a programming update might add this.
Problems: Very slight brake squeel. My wife's key seems to have mind of it's own. Sometimes the remote works, sometimes it don't. The front passenger seat has this annoying problem where it feels like it's moving and then it 'pops'. I've noticed the lower part of the seats are spring loaded, but I think mine has a problem.
Plans: Those 5 spoke AMG wheels(the real AMG ones, not the sport ones) look really good.
BMW: Is always rated #1 or close by US rags. It's the horsepower/handling factor only. A good friend has a '98 M3. Great handling/accelerating car but it is stark and plain. Now if the plastic bits would quit falling off...
Personally, I think MB builds a better car and I expect it to last much longer than the equivalent BMW.
A picture says more than a thousand words, this is what a typical Taxi stand anywhere in Germany looks like. It even holds true for Munich (BMW) and Ingolstadt (AUDI). If not a Benz, you will only see a bunch of Passats (for roominess) and a few FIATs (cheaper).
Tarik
It all depends on what you're looking for. The C240 with a manual transmission offers responsive acceleration, and feels relatively sporty. With the automatic it will be nondescript. You are the only person who can answer whether it's enough power for you though. It irritates me when car salesmen make these kind of blanket statements.
How do you drive? If sporty driving isn't important to you, then you should be fine. What do you drive now? How do you like it?
the salesperson insisted i speed up on a 25mph 360 degree turn onramp.. so i downshifted to 2nd and floored it...this one stayed flat, did not lean a bit
tried to make a deal but did not happen, the msrp is 36.9k.. as much as i like the sport it had options i did not need. no discounts from the dealer . i had trade equity of 10.5k (hoping to get more) and trying to get no or minimal monthly payments on a 24 month lease but they still needed 5k out of pocket to make it work
so i went to bmw in escondido,CA down the street and was greeted with rudeness. i was up front and told them i just left the mb dealer and the deal did not go through. i told him i wanted to drive their 3 series to see if i would like it as i never seen the inside or driven one before. he was more interested of the lease specifics and said that it didn't matter whether i liked their car, the deal will not work and i would be wasting each others time, he excused himself and helped another customer. still curious what a 3 series looked like another salesperson greeted me , all she did was bad mouthed mb, saying their cars are always sold out and they do not discount their cars either and mb is having to raise residual to attract customers. they were very unprofessional compared to the mb sales people
i'm sticking with the c240mt and wait til the right vehicle with less options comes along, i'm in no hurry, not a lot of people want the 6 speed. the black on black c240 i drove has been at the dealer for a month now.FYI the residual for a 24 month lease is 78%, 36 is at 70%
http://www.curtrich.com/january2001.html
Sounds like price is the same once optioned similiarly, but you still get more w/ the C and also 4 yrs of free service...
I probably will not get it until late Feb or early March now and will end up with out a car for a month as the lease on my current ride expires 2/22.
Here is what I was quoted for a lease today.
$35,000.00 MSRP 15,000 mi/yr,
$2687.84 Cap Reduction ,
$61.00 for plates,
$148.00 DOC fees (Which make me sick),
$522.52 First Lease Payment,
$80.64 tax.
$3500.00 out the door and $522.52/mo.
69% Residual
All Seems a little steep to me. The Lease factor was 0.00445
They will also finance at %9.95 for 60 Months. The rate is the same if I put 10, 20 or 30 percent down. This was all through MBCCL.
I think I will stick with my %8.5 Home Equity rate and take advantage of the tax break.
I asked if there were any squeaky brake problems that he know of and I got an explanation that I would just have to learn how to drive a Mercedes????????????????????????????????
Keep up with all the great information. Every time I start to get impatient and start looking at the bimmers, I just come back here.
One safety feature Curt left out is the Latch babyseat foldable mount points on the new C. If you haven't looked check your back seats, there are little square latches that fold out from between the base of the seatback and the bottom cushion. If you pull them they pop out and then release and disappear by pressing a release button in the back center of the latch. This new mounting system will be required in all US cars by the fall of 2002, and I think the C is the first car to have the system. Most cars will have them hard mounted unlike the C'c hidden latches. If you don't have a child you probably don't care, but because all cars will have these in 2 years all babyseats will be made to simply insert and then release from the latch. It's much safer and much easier than current babyseats, believe me I have hassle with my 7 month old's seat everytime I go anywhere. The big problem is that no one makes a Latch compatible seat yet!! :-( MB is supposed to have one availible anytime, to go with the new C, but I have a bad feeling it will be much more expensive than all the generic car seat manufactures' prices will be in a year or so. Oh well, my son's current seat will fit him for another few months, we'll see what's availible for the Latch then. Still loving the C!!!
the driver adaptive trans will.when cold..give a slow start..as engine warms up..it is very responsive..as fast as the 320 or the beemer? no.
how much speed do i personally need off a red light? im not into racing.but..from 40 mph and up.. passing torque is great..and..if you want to really feel the torque for passing, use the shifter to hold in 3rd,or 4th gear..and see what this engine can do!but even in overdrive(5th) passing at 60-80mph is quick and responsive.i still feel mb has struck a fine balance of performance/luxury/safety.all at reasonably good value..will be interesting to see how it does in this nor'easter in jersey
What in the world did they mean "learn to drive your Mercedes?????" Are they saying, if you drive right the brakes don't squeal??? In my very limited exposure to some of these MB sales people, I get the impression they think they are talking to car buyers who have tons of money but don't have a clue as to how the thing works!
I went shopping for a salesperson/dealership in the Boston area I could trust (Jerry Pillary at Clair was who I felt comfortable w/ eventually).
Some dealerships "demo" new cars. I.e., instead of beating the crap out of a few demos, they'll put some miles on each new one they get.
Some dealerships have salesmen just out to make a deal (went to one where the salesman had come from a Tweeter..audio/electronics store for those not around here) and seem a bit pushy.
Others won't even acknowledge you when you walk in the door because they're too "busy".
One more comment...I really like the car, but like others, I've had trouble with brake squeal. After putting up with it for 1000 miles, I took it to my dealer, and they replaced all 4 pads. One day later, they still squealed...and I have another appointment. As others have mentioned, perhaps there is a break in period. For about 4 days prior to the original brakes being replaced, and after one last god-awful squeal, they were fine. Since I waited 2+ weeks for the appointment, I went ahead and had them worked on, and hence the new pads. But maybe, just maybe, the originals had the squeak worked out. That's my one complaint...when I go into a slow, controlled brake around town, my $35K car sounds like an 85 Hyundai.
Unfortunately, mine wasn't it. I just had to reset the whole remote and try to re program.
All you need to do is press left and right button(button 1 and 3) and hold it for 20 sec. it will start blinking rapidly. then let go. your Remote is reset. Now, try to reprogram by pressing both your garage door opener and MB's remote button(one of three, which ever you want) at the same time. it should blink slowly, and then rapidly. Now it should work.
I am a gr8 MB fan and I am going to be a owner of C240 soon; I would like to know - is there a scope of price negotiation exists on this CARS? if yes what range one should go
I am posting this question second time and hope somebody will reply. Thanks
I thought it was a really arrogant statement! He also did not deny that they have had some problems. I have been reading this board for a couple of months and it seems to be the only significant and recurring problem. Some folks like zeemenow don't seem to have any problem and it drives others nuts.
All I know is that if the brakes squeal, so will mama!
What do you do at work if someone has an opinion different than yours? Do you automatically say
"OK, YOUR not allowed to talk anymore!" Sorry that I made for such interesting discussion that you were still posting about me two days later. The things I said were not without merit either.
Look...I know this is a C-Class board, since I have not actually bought my car yet and the C-Class is one of the cars I am choosing from, than allow me please to maintain my presence here...however painful for you that may be.
That said a couple of things. I do not read the NY Times but thank you for update. That you would take the opinion of a newspaper over a automobile magazine is your choice. Second, saying that the 323 will have electrical problems because the X5 has been is kind of a stretch. Sport utilities are more notorious for problems of any kind than cars. But using your same logic, what kind of reliability is the new C-Class going to have based on short history of the M-Class. HA! The M-Class has had VERY POOR reliabilty. This years consumers reports said "Reliabilty-POOR" "Avoid Years 98-99"
re: postings that are non productive? yawn...i DO have an echo!!
happy new yrs all!
I bet many owners will not try this because they don't spend more MONEY to their status symbol MB and will prefer something else that is costly (snow tires perhaps?).
"Mercedes Benz, permitting bald divorced men who otherwise could not, to get dates"
Jay Leno
Car Collector
if i had a complaint..id complain!..if i had a beef id beef!
i dont.. my car is performing to specs
as to jay leno?..sorry ,im not his fan either.
does he collect cars? fascinating....
id rather hear how your ford (pickup?)
is performimg...on the ford bulletin board of course.
finally drove in the snow..the esp did keep the car from fishtailing in any major way..id say its closer to frontwheel dr with torque steer.. a slight sidewards pull..did have some trouble getting up an unplowed inclined driveway
(taking off my rose colored glasses now)