Mazda Protegé

1429430432434435453

Comments

  • gee35coupegee35coupe Member Posts: 3,387
    You can do much better if crash tests are a prority. Including the previous version Protege.

    http://www.iihs.org/vehicle_ratings/ce/html/summary_small_earlier- - .htm#99005
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    especially with the larger wheels and tires that became standard in 2001 or 2002, not sure which. It reminds me of the previous generation Audi A4 or hte current Mercedes C class, and is as good looking as either of them.

    To me, small does not equal cheap, like with the Mini Cooper, another very good-looking small car.

    Don't get me wrong, I'm sure the 3 is much imporved in refinement, but I looked at them side-by-side when I bought my Pro and honestly, I think the Protege looks MUCH better, and more importantly, will look much better five years from now.
  • carguy58carguy58 Member Posts: 2,303
    They are not passing on the 6 where I live. The 6 is not understated to me. Its better looking than the Accord and Camry and will age better than the Altima on the exterior probably.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    is rather classy, very well proportioned. I wish we had the hatch here in the US.

    Actually, when we replace my wife's Saturn L200 it will be with a Mazda 6, unless things change drastically in the mid-size class in the next 18 months.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    My 03 Pro has the most stubborn rattle. The dealer tried to fix it twice, and that is despite it being easy to locate.

    The rattle come from the passenger side dashboard vent. I know this because if while driving, I put my finger right on the wheel that enables or blocks airflow and push slightly, the rattle vanishes immediately and remains silent as long as I maintain pressure. Let go, and its rattle-city.

    The dealer has replaced the bezel that covers the vent, and when that didn't work, he replaced the entire vent. THe rattle is softer than before, but still present and still infuriating.

    Any ideas?

    It really bothers me because the rest of the car is just so good.
  • mazdafunmazdafun Member Posts: 2,329
    Or if not, it might be too much of a gap between the gap subassembly and the dash. They might try wedging some thin felt material between them to dampen the rattle.

    Usually, if there is a rattle coming from one of my outboard dash vents, it's a leaf or a leaf fragment. I have to use small needle-nose pliers to get them out.
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    So, it is favorable, but not as favorable as some others, and 2001+ are probably better than that, but we can't know for sure because it hasn't been tested.

    If all you care about is crash tests, don't buy a Protege, but don't come crying to us when you realize you purchased a boring or unreliable vehicle instead.
  • gee35coupegee35coupe Member Posts: 3,387
    Loved the car...Until about 4500 rpm. Then we sold it. Too buzzy and and the power drops off in higher rpm. Not to mention the short gearing which gets you to high RPM faster.

    If you never drive long distances, high speeds, or leave the city the Protege is perfect.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    Yes the Protege is a bit busier than a typical midsize car, but for a compact its not bad. My automatic DX is quite relaxed up to 70MPH, and still acceptable at 80MPH.

    My old Galant cruised all day at 90MPH in silence which the Protege will never do, but otherwise this is a better car.
  • protegenicprotegenic Member Posts: 199
    Aren't we in the critical mood today? Is the car perfect? We all know it isn't, but it is as good or better than any of the others in the segment. It is all subjective anyways.
  • dinu01dinu01 Member Posts: 2,586
    It's fine. Yes, it could be quieter, but I'd rather have noise over lack of cornering ability.

    Dinu
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    We take our Protege5 on long trips all the time. Could it be quieter? Sure it could. Is it worth the extra weight to make it so? Not in a million years.

    The same goes for my Miata. If your goal is quiet, be prepared to pay for it and buy a Lexus.

    Ted
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    is relative. At 70MPH or less my Protege is just as quiet as the Galant it replaced. Above 70MPH it is wind noise that intrudes most, and this is highly dependant on the angle and velocity of the wind. I cruised down the 101 yesterday at 80MPH and while the engine is always audble (very pleasantly so), the ride was hushed and quiet.

    Next week I'm driving it to Vegas, that will be the test and I'm really looking forward to the drive.
  • gee35coupegee35coupe Member Posts: 3,387
    The Protege WAS perfect around town. Great low end. Super exacto knife handling. Sporty looking. That's why we bought it.

    Then we took it to Florida. That exacto knife handling got kinda nervous. And the great low end didn't turn into a lively top end like the Honda's we had been driving before. Since we live in the boonies and spend a lot of time on the road we found that we favored higher end smoothness over the low end torque. But anyway.

    To each blah blah.
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    Don't mind the buzzy engine on the pro. I do about 80-90 on the freeway for 45 miles each way and it's certainly got some volume. But by the end of the day I don't notice it any longer.

    Still I get in my other car on the weekends and the whole vehicle seems eerily quiet now.
  • tomcivilettitomciviletti Member Posts: 207
    I find my '99 es quite good at high rpm. It could pump more horses with hi-compression [premium fuel] or a turbo [premium fuel], but it's not bad. The gearing of the 5spd does make it busy at hiway speeds, but I find the engine relatively quiet and smooth. Road noise on rough pavement is a much bigger drawback to me.

    On styling, I think the last generation pro is one of the best looking small sedans ever. slightly larger tires help it look more serious. I still haven't seen a 3 in person, so will withhold judgement.
  • gee35coupegee35coupe Member Posts: 3,387
    I'm sure the 1.8 is an entirely different animal. Err machine.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    I've driven the 1.8 in a freind's 93 LX and it is much smoother at high RPM, quieter too. Actually, the old 1.6, while way down on power and torque compared to the 2.0, was also more refined and quieter.

    Still, the 2.0 isn't bad, and I love the torque.
  • newcar31newcar31 Member Posts: 3,711
    The 1.8L in your friend's 93 Protege is an entirely different engine than the 1.8L in the 99-00 Proteges. The 1.8L in the 99-00 originates from the 2.0L, it's a de-stroked version.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    I thought they were all the same, sourced from the Miata? Learn something everyday.

    Speaking of the 2.0, does adding a K&N Filtercharger give noticeable performance boost, and would it void my warranty?
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    To answer your questions, not really and no.
  • fowler3fowler3 Member Posts: 1,919
    didn't open tonight. Maybe pf_flyer had PC problems or was delayed fro other reasons. Too bad Edmunds doesn't have a way to tell us when something happens.

    fowler3
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    ...what happened?
  • patpat Member Posts: 10,421
    It's there, try again. Link on left side of the page. :-)
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    I turned in my brand new pro so the dealer could get it detailed and finally get my fobs.

    So I dropped the car off on Sunday afternoon and had them make a copy of my grad school diploma for the college grad rebate info.

    The next day I called the dealer to see if the car would be ready by 7 pm. The service person said yes. When I asked about the fobs, he said that he couldn't do that as sales didn't authorize it.

    This led to a round of phone calls and the sales manager telling me to call him back. Huh? What sort of customer service training do these guys have? If a customer calls with a question, take his name and number, find out the info and call him back.

    Supposedly, it was all settled and I arrived to pick up my car that evening. The first thing I noticed was that the Pro had obviously not been detailed in any way. The windows on the inside still had the sticky film. The exterior was dirty and not a single scratch had been buffed or removed. Nobody had gone near the car with any wax, that's for certain. It looked as if they vacuumed the interior and that's it. Naturally, the CD player was on (I removed my CDs and turned off the radio when I left the car) . Not sure why one would need to load all my CDs (an arduous process) and fiddle with the radio or drive the car 5 miles. It takes 5-10 minutes just to load 6 CDs into that player! It didn't look they spent 5 minutes in or near the car?! Lastly, the Pro was unlocked and sitting

    I entered the stealership and the first thing I noticed was the reclining sales man. Eyes shut or in the middle of a really long blink. No receptionist. Another salesguy was camped in front of the TV, Tele Mundo displaying some garish harlot demanding players choose a door. Nobody much cared that I entered. They sure make you feel welcome at the dealership!

    A salesman I recognized from my original purchase slithered out of his office, offering a head dipped, eerily obsequious hello. The sales manager appeared and asked if he could help me.
    After he passed on my keys (with the fobs...finally), he then said, "That should take care of everything."

    Not quite. I asked about the college grad rebate and if they sent the info in yet. He said, "You handle that, not us."

    So, the Mazda reps were lying to me? Don't think so. I gently corrected him and asked to speak with the person in charge of finance. The manager shot back, "He's out today and will be back tomorrow. Call him later."

    Great customer service.

    I did call back and the finance guy at first said he doesn't know anything about the college grad rebate. What? When pressed he insisted then that they mailed the info out on Monday. If he was out, who mailed it?

    I'm going to contact Mazda at the end of the week to make sure they did get my college grad rebate. Once I'm positive that's progressing and the dealer didn't screw it up, I'm going to author a invective filled letter that will go to both the stealership and Mazda USA. Attached to the letter will be a receipt from a professional establishment that cleans cars.

    Maybe it won't do a bit of good, maybe it'll anger the dealer or more likely the dealer will chuckle and throw it away. No matter what, Westcott Mazda is by far the worst dealership I've encountered in San Diego. And I'm appending a new signature to my entries that lets people know that.

    Westcott Mazda lied to me about sales practices, didn't deliver what they promised and they have shoddy customer service to match their shoddy business practices.
  • mazdafunmazdafun Member Posts: 2,329
    There are plenty of good dealerships. No need to give the bad ones any business.

    Say, isn't Morries around San Diego somewhere? I've heard good things about them.
  • chicagoprochicagopro Member Posts: 1,009
    I think the good dealership in San Diego is supposed to be John Hine Mazda.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    Anyone know a dealership in the Los Angeles area with a good service department? Alhambra Mazda after three tries cannot identify to cause of my dash rattle (they replaced the vent but noise persists), and it is driving me NUTS.

    Thanks,

    Andrew
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    My family has purchased many cars from Hine - all quality results.

    I only bought from Westcott because they were the last place to have a Pro ES 5 speed in November.

    BGDC
    Westcott Mazda lied to me about sales practices, didn't deliver what they promised and they have shoddy customer service to match their shoddy business practices.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    Small claims court only costs about $50 in most jurisdictions, does not require an attorney and is notoriously pro-plaintiff.

    Get estimates for full detailing, including any needed paint work, then multiply your daily salary by the number of times you had to go back to the dealer. If this totals more than $5000, the redue the amount to $5000 and go file in the whatever courthouse is closest to Westcott Mazda.

    Thats what small claims court is for, to protect the consumer and allow a real remedy in cases too small bother with attorney fees.
  • lawman1967lawman1967 Member Posts: 314
    its also kinda fun. I sued a carpet installer after a shoddy installation and 2 months delays in fixing it. The result was that while I paid for the actual carpet, all of the labor was free and the company had to redo the whole job.
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    This is taken off the purchase price at the time of purchase, and is NOT taxable. They are screwing with you. Call Mazda today at 1-800-639-1000 with the name of the dealer, the finance manager, the sales manager, and your sales vermin.
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    Are you sure? If so, you're right, those evil snakes got another $50 out of me.
  • newcar31newcar31 Member Posts: 3,711
    One of their internet sales people lied to me. They tried real hard to not discuss numbers with me via e-mail and they told me that there is "no such thing as a Mazda6 without options". Really? Why are they called "options" then if they're not optional? I didn't even ask them that though, I started negotiations with a different dealer immediately.
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    The CSR at Mazda, super nice guy, said that the rebate comes after the sale, so sales tax applies. That's good.

    He then offered to look up my car for me. I supplied the VIN and he asked me to spell my name and give my address.

    My first name, last name, street address and zip code were all written incorrectly on the information Westcott sent to Mazda. That info is on my driver's license! It can't be any clearer.

    He told me to call him back in a few days and if they don't have any record of the college grad stuff, he'll do a workaround from Mazda corporate.

    If I ever cross paths with that dealer again I will pour out a string of invectives with such force they will forever hang over South Bay.
  • fowler3fowler3 Member Posts: 1,919
    with car dealers -- semantics plays a big part. When haggling, if a buyer says, "I can't pay that." the dealer knows he can, but doesn't want to if he can help it. But, if the buyer says, "I won't pay that!", firmly enough, the dealer knows he is serious. Don't tip your hand, be careful how you phrase your replies.

    If the dealer lets you walk away and doesn't call you back to talk some more, they don't really want to sell the car. Keep on walking. If you leave your name and telephone number and ask a salesperson to call you and they do not; don't call again. Good salesmen return all calls regardless if they may be wild goose chases -- volume comes from many, not the few who don't haggle much.

    The hardest deal I ever made took nine and half hours of haggling, walking out, haggling some more. I had gone into the dealership at 3 in the afternoon; got my price at 12:30AM. His wife called five times saying she had re-heated his dinner three times and was going to bed. LOL!

    fowler3
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    They must have changed it. The last time I got it was 2001. The dealer subtracted it from the pre-tax price.
  • ashutoshsmashutoshsm Member Posts: 1,007
    IIRC, mine was subtracted pre-tax. But I'd have to check to be sure.

    Also, it didn't happen AFTER the purchase, but was (along with other significant rebates at the time) my only down payment. I went to the dealership without a check book. Drove out with a new car. At 0%, it made no sense to put even a penny down.
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    Mazda changed the program or CA has a different rule.

    As it's a rebate, it should logically come post-tax as you don't buy computer parts with rebates and get coin off on the tax (anyone else even do rebates beyond electronics and cars?).

    I know you get taxed on the $2500 mazda rebate too.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    It is possible that rules could vary from state to state. I'm certain that rebates were post-tax when I sold vehicles and rebates have been post-tax when I've purchased them.

    Update on my Protege experience. I'm satisfied with my 03 LX overall. Now that I've had the opportunity to drive on snow, I'm even more amazed at how DANGEROUS the stock Potenza's are. Terrible traction in rain and snow.
    For $13,1XX for 03 LX w/ auto, airbag-ABS, cassette (did not want), and sunroof-6CD the Protege was hands down the best car value.
  • protegenicprotegenic Member Posts: 199
    Does anyone else have a problem with how all manufacterers are putting performance tires on just about every car? Granted, the Pro's strength is handling, but I would gladly give up a little bit of that walking out the door with a new car knowing I could drive home safely if it was raining!
  • meinradmeinrad Member Posts: 820
  • boggseboggse Member Posts: 1,048
    Good performance tires will do well in wet or dry. My complaint is not that they are putting performance tires on cars. My complaint is that they are making bad choices in general about which performance tire to put on.
  • protegenicprotegenic Member Posts: 199
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    I will echo what boggse stated. I believe there are performance tires with good traction and in general have no objection to a performance oriented tire on the Protege. I've had 17" performance wheels and tires on my VW that performed well in the rain and OK in the snow. Great handling and jarring ride though! It is the simple fact that the OEM Potenza on the Protege is a very poor choice for wet or snowy conditions. An average tire I could accept.

    Do you think I should get my Protege a Christmas present? How about a strut tower brace? Or a fog light kit?
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    How much are those anyway? That's an easy, useful mod.

    I wouldn't mind lowering my Pro an inch or so, adding a strut tower and popping on 17s. That'd make the handling a little more me friendly.

    Still needs a turbo though... :) Driving my bimmer today and it feels like a race car compared to my pro.
  • protege_fanprotege_fan Member Posts: 2,405
    WWW.Mazdastuff.com sells the strut tower bar kit for $99.95
    http://www.mazdastuff.com/product.cfm?ProductID=972
  • tomcivilettitomciviletti Member Posts: 207
    Boggse's correct. the bridgestone s-03's on my pro are "max performance" tires with excellent wet handling and hydroplaning resistance.
  • blueguydotcomblueguydotcom Member Posts: 6,249
    Not bad at all.
  • speedyptspeedypt Member Posts: 200
    I have them on my Pro as well. They have excellent wet characteristics and are the best in the dry, but I don't recommend them in snow.

    That's when I switch to my Artic Alpins by Michellin and move on out no matter what the weather.

    Regards,

    Pete
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.