Infiniti G35 Sedan 2006 and earlier

1104105107109110182

Comments

  • pengqirenpengqiren Member Posts: 6
    I too recently visited Coleman Infiniti and took a G35 out for a test ride. They were fine enough in person, though they seem slow/unwilling to deal via email. Earlier I'd submitted a request via autobytel and it took 1 full week for the manager to reply (via phone). Based on the options I've requested (Premium pkg but no moonroof) he said I'd have to order the car and they were offering no discounts on MSRP. I thought this sounded bogus and your post indicated they are willing to deal. Given that they wouldn't have to pay for insurance/other costs of having the car sit on their lot and Infiniti is providing dealer holdback of ~2% - I'd think they'd have some room to give. I plan to shop around if Coleman remains inflexible. Tks.

    Tks.
  • scotth501scotth501 Member Posts: 56
    Does anyone know the specific codes for the options on the VIN? I know they all should be fairly consistant as far as engine, transmission, etc are concerned. From what I understand, 4th-8th position should change by premium, sport, etc. Someone else once provided this information and I've been going off of it, I don't know it's 100% accurate though:

    1st digit is where vehicle is built, 1,4,5=USA, 2=Canada, 3=Mexico, Puerto Rico or Costa Rico, 6=Australia, 9=Brazil, J=Japan, K=South Korea, L=Tawain, S=United Kingdom, V=France or Yugoslavia, W=Germany, Y=Sweeden, Z=Italy.

    2nd and 3rd characters indicate specific manufacturer.

    4th through 8th characters are a portrait of the specific vehicle, Brand, Body Style, Engine Size & Type, etc.

    9th character is a security code that identifies the VIN as being authorized by the manufacturer. Law enforcement can determine if a VIN is authentic or not from this character on a specific vehicle.

    10th character is the model year of the car. 1980=A, H=1987, J=1988, N=1992, P=1993, T=1996, V=1997, through Y=2000. Then 1 = 2001 and so on. There are no I, O, U, or Z years.

    11th character is the specific plant which assembled the vehicle. Each manufacturer uses different codes to identify their plants.

    12th-17th characters are the serial number of the specific vehicle. Not all companies start at #000001, practices vary among manufacturers.
  • cheerioboy26cheerioboy26 Member Posts: 412
    I've had a good experience w/Coleman so far, but I didn't go the email route. Ordered Silver/Graphite/Premium/Sunroof/Winter/Xenon and got a bit more than slasher was offered off MSRP. Ordered last Wednesday, got a call today and said they have my VIN and currently expect delivery late June-mid July. Also worked w/Monica, although when I called to stop by she was on her way out and referred me to Sean, who's only been selling cars for 3 mos., and assumed I would pay MSRP. Ooops. So....made it to Sales Mgr to close the deal.

    I test drove at Rosenthal, but after the 995 markup, and the fact it's like pulling teeth to get a call back - no deal. And I live in VA.
  • slasher617slasher617 Member Posts: 39
    I'm glad someone else got a good deal at Coleman since I plan to do business there in the near future. I hope their rest of their staff is as kind and professional as their sales staff has been.
  • cheerioboy26cheerioboy26 Member Posts: 412
    Well I talked with the sales mgr today, and he searched my VIN and it now shows up "In Transit" so it's already built and on the boat! He's now thinking June as opposed to July since it's already on the way.... :)

    Tonyg35 has high marks for Coleman as well.
  • jagboyxkrjagboyxkr Member Posts: 53
    Yes, I know I had the same conclusion as you had and wrote in your first paragraph. The points I was really asking about were:

    "What else can you ask for for less than $30K?"
    and
    "If Infiniti really wanted luxurious interior to
    compete with Lexus, Audi, and Jag, they could have easily
    upgrade the interior with more luxury amenities. However,
    don't expect the starting MSRP to be $28.5K with leather.
    MSRP will probably start at $32K (which will make it less
    affordable for the intended buyers)"

    I had taken these quotes as saying that no other cars offered the same high-quality, well appointed interiors in all variants of a certain model except for the G35, and that Lexus, Audi, and Jaguar forced people to pay more for their interiors that came in varying degrees of quality depending upon whether one purchased the base or top version of a model. My point was that this idea of one good interior is the same in the ES300, A4, and X-TYPE as it is in the G35, not different; as I had mistakenly believed you were trying to state with the original quote. That was all I was asking about,and your second post addressing this told me that this was not the main point that you were trying to make.

    Aside from that, my other point had been that Jaguar does offer leather in a car for less than $30,000 as well, and that Lexus offers leather for just around $31,000, countering the ""What else can you ask for for less than $30K?" and the "...don't expect the starting MSRP to be $28.5K with leather" statements.

    I do agree 100% with you about the spartan BMW interiors, and that the G35 is a "GREAT value". And as I had posted before, I think that the interior of the G35 is perfect for it, and that it adds to the character of the car.
  • jvalentyjvalenty Member Posts: 41
    My G has been on order since Apr 27. I was told not to expect it until early July, even thought it was in the final stages of being built in Mid May. Any ideas how long the transit takes (Japan to West Coast)?
  • fntfnt Member Posts: 31
    I test drove both the ES300 and the G35 yesterday, and I'm sold on the G35. Even my wife, who I didn't think would like the car, is enthusiastic. (I won't go into the details - that's a topic for another thread.)

    Anyway, I'm looking for a car with nav. Called one dealer in the southeast (AL), where I'll be moving this summer, and was told that nav-equipped G35's are pretty much impossible to get except by special order, which takes 90 days.

    Anyone else have any better luck finding this model?

    Thanks.

    -fnt
  • ivan_99ivan_99 Member Posts: 1,681
    Just finished another tank of gas.

    More steady highway driving, but aggressive city (gotta remember to take off the VDC)
    30/70

    22.44 mpg (best I had so far, and the most times I've gone to red-line).
  • stsurbrookstsurbrook Member Posts: 285
    kd6aw1 - If I were you, I'd go and do some major complaining about the noises. From what I've heard, the Infiniti service departments are a bit anal over this topic and really go out of their way to resolve these problems.

    fnt - My wife got her G35 as a family car. It works well, though we will use the Durango for longer trips (say over 3 hours, benefits of seating 8 vs 4... :).

    HOWEVER, be SURE to put towels (that approximately match your interior color) UNDER the child seats! Apparently, the people who design these things think you are mounting them on plywood and make the bottoms/backs flat, with "sharp" edges that will definitely leave wrinkles in your leather (or cloth). I have a full (folded) towel on the bottom and another layed down the back of the seat (tucked under the headrest) and over the folded towel to minimize any permanent wrinkling. This works pretty well. If you don't, it won't take more than a day or two and you will have a wrinkle you won't like in the seat! (Unfortunately, we know from experience...)

    Scott
  • jvalentyjvalenty Member Posts: 41
    I stop by two of the three dealers in San Diego at least three times a week. Inventory is currently very low and only one or two on each lot with the Nav system. I think the dealers underestimated demand for the dark interior and the nav system, both of which seem to be in high demand. Of the two owners in San Diego I have personally met in the past two weeks, both have the nav and rave about it. I'm glad I ordered it, even thought I am still waiting. From the research I've done of the Xanavi system, with the Birdseye view and all the features that other nav systems don't seem to have, I think it's worth the wait. I don't want any regrets in a vehicle I expect to keep for at least 5 years.
  • bjbird2bjbird2 Member Posts: 647
    The June 02' issue of Road & Track Tested and compared 11 "Super Sedans", and rated the Infiniti G-35 NUMBER ONE over BMW, Audi, Jag Mercedes, Etc!
  • peeetepeeete Member Posts: 136
    Does anyone have any experiences with dealers in the NY metro area, good or bad. I want to avoid some of the hassels people have experienced if possible. thanks
  • bjbird2bjbird2 Member Posts: 647
    Sorry, it's the July 02' issue of Road & Track.
  • ruskiruski Member Posts: 1,566
    this would be better:


    image

  • stsurbrookstsurbrook Member Posts: 285
    I never said that you couldn't buy something like that, but having something like that does not look nearly as good as two $6 black towels under the (graphite interior) car seat. I doubt that you could get the above for ~$13 (including tax).

    Anyway, while I can't tell from looking at it, I don't know that it would provide the protection that the towels do. That is one of the reasons why I have a folded full-size towel under the car seat, to protect against wrinkles in the leather.

    However, if the "onestepahead" product works, great! :)

    Scott
  • hvan3hvan3 Member Posts: 630
    <<The June 02' issue of Road & Track Tested and compared 11 "Super Sedans", and rated the Infiniti G-35 NUMBER ONE over BMW, Audi, Jag Mercedes, Etc>>

    Rated #1? Whoo whoo! Now that R&T has spoken, I wonder what other excuses riez will make up on BMW 3 series vs G35?

    Keep in mind that the G35 was tested with AUTO transmission!
  • fntfnt Member Posts: 31
    jvalenty: I think you're right. In fact, I think that Infiniti underestimated the demand for the G35 altogether. That's probably because they're not used to selling (or promoting) a winner.
  • c3po33c3po33 Member Posts: 67
    This article was in the new Newsweek about the importance of car interiors.


    http://www.msnbc.com/news/753692.asp


    Quote: Automakers that treat interior design as an afterthought risk being left behind. Says J Mays, Ford&#146;s chief designer: &#147;The tipping point of a sale now is the interior.&#148;


    Let's hope Nissan learns this for the Altima. I really am quite happy with the interior of my G. But the Altima got a "D" for the interior in the Sedan comparison from Motor Trend not good at all.

  • claywaterfillclaywaterfill Member Posts: 534
    I'm not here to talk bad about the G35. I like the G35--I wouldn't mind having one myself. I have been reading this board a little and knew the R&T article would come up. It is true that the G35 won the comparo--and more power to them, congrats! However, it should be pointed out that the G35 beat the 330i ONLY because of price. On performance, the 330i won 195.7 points to 193.8--BMW winning the segment. Maybe the upcoming manual transmission may help the G35. In the subjective ratings--such as driving excitement, steering, handling, seats and about a dozen other areas--the 330i won 191.4 points to the G35's 186.5 points, again the BMW winning the segment. In the first two segments, the 300i had 6.8 more points than the G35. The difference came in price. R&T gave the G35 200 points for pricing, and the 330i got 182.3--that gave the the G35 the overall win by about 11 points. Five of the testers said they would pick the 330i for themselves if they were going to buy one of the participants. Again, I'm not here to put the G35 down. I was VERY happy to see it win as I am tired of seeing only BMWs and Hondas winning car magazine shooshoot outs., you must look at the whole article to keep it in perspective before just hammering the "We're number one!" down other people's throats. I think you will know what Hyundai owners go through now. People with Elantras all the time say that the price of their car makes it worth owning over Proteges and Civics. Owners of the G35 will now be able to say that even though the BMW was judged to be the better car with better performance and the car most testers would rather own, the low price will make the G35 worth owning instead.
  • 1pierce1pierce Member Posts: 284
    I couldn't have said it better myself. This reminds me of a comparo from last year between the Cadillac Deville DTS and several high priced Euro luxury cars like the 740i, A8, and the S-Class Mercedes.

    The Deville, of course, was last on pure performance. But, if you factored in the almost $30,000 price difference, the Deville would have been an outright winner. Sadly, that comparo didn't factor in price. Anybody lucky enough to afford a Deville DTS would have been more than satisfied, even if an $80,000 car will never be on their horizon.

    If price had not been factored into this comparo, the G35 would NOT have finished first. But, for those who could never afford a $42,000 330i, the G35 may be the "best" sports sedan in this class.
  • c3po33c3po33 Member Posts: 67
    How long has BMW being building the 3 series for, what generation are they in now? The G35 is in its first year and is basically unchanged from the Nissan Skyline so it is a first generation, first year model. If the G35 could beat or match BMW at their own game or even come in second if price is considered (or not), with a first generation car, IMO Infiniti has won (or at least meet and exceeded their expectations). I think it is even more remarkable that they did do it for a price that is less than what BMW charges. I know BMW is not going to sit still, but hopefully neither will Infinity and a second or third generation G35 should be quite a sight as will a current G with a six-speed manual. I personally have never considered a BMW for myself but I know they are good cars. I just think anybody who likes or owns a BMW has to be impressed with what the G35 has to offer, for a car that is just coming out of the gate.
  • neo_gtrwneo_gtrw Member Posts: 76
    195.7 to 193.8 points on performance is almost a tie. Let's have another comparo in the future between 330ci and G35 coupe which will come with 6speed, LSD, Brembo brakes, firmer suspension and wider tires. Damn it, when is Infiniti going to make all these available for the sedan too?! It's time to kick some butt, Infiniti!

    Knowing the G35 has an auto tranny and four skinny tires, a few points below the 3series is expected. BTW, did the 330i in the R&T test have sports package?
  • bjbird2bjbird2 Member Posts: 647
    The results from the July Road & Track comparo are:

    1. Infiniti G-35
    2. BMW 330i
    3. Lexus IS 300
    4. Saab 9-5 Aero
    6. Audi A-4 3.0 Quattro
    7. Accura 3.2 TL Type S
    8. Mercedes-Benz C320 Sport
    9. Cadillac CTS
    10. Volvo S60 T5
    11. Jaguar X-Type 3.0
  • lenscaplenscap Member Posts: 854
    I didn't get my magazine in the mail yet, so my question is: What happened to the Jaguar that it came in last place?

    I'm sure it had nothing to do with its finish, but the Jaguar X-type was just written up in an auto trade magazine for having many quality glitches and engine problems (and poor customer service from both the dealers and Jaguar itself).
  • bjbird2bjbird2 Member Posts: 647
    They said the Jag is basically overpriced for what you get. It's lacking some features the others have, and that it "lacks some of the subtle grace and suspension magic that has always defined the marque".

    By the way, the Jag wasn't last. I forgot the Lincoln LS which was in 11th place.
  • claywaterfillclaywaterfill Member Posts: 534
    Yeah, the number "5" was left off the list--and the Lincoln LS was last. The last three cars were all from the Ford family of products, not real good for Ford! The Jaguar got beat up pretty badly in the subjective group--most notably the driving excitement, engine, gearbox, and steering. It was also the most expensive car in the group at $46,510--or about $7000 more than the 330i and about $15,000 more than the G35. The Lincoln LS came in last because of performance. They used a V6 equipped LS to keep the price down and to use a stick. It gave up about 20 points to the 330i and G35 there. BTW, the 330i was equipped with the Sport Package--as was the G35. I agree that the G35 did great right out of the box. With a few years of tweaking, the G35 will be even better--of course so will the 3-Series. I can't wait for the manual transmission coupe comparison as well.
  • neo_gtrwneo_gtrw Member Posts: 76
    330i with Sport Package comes with firmer suspension and much wider tires. G35, in contrast, gets only firmer suspension. This may explain the difference in handling that R&T saw between the two cars.
  • drewsrxdrewsrx Member Posts: 57
    The G35 deserves to win. Kudo's to Infiniti for an excellent job. The 1st generation G35 meeting the 3rd generation 3-Series head on.

    Were all of the cars automatics or what? Was the 330i a manual transmission? Did the Audi have the sports package? What were the 0-60, 1/4 mile for the cars? Thanks!
  • riezriez Member Posts: 2,361
    I haven't gotten my copy of R&T yet. I am a subscriber so am waiting with excitement. For those who have read the article, why not post some comparative info on the objective data? What were the numbers for 0-60 mph time, top speed, braking distance, slalom speed, g's pulled, etc? Isn't saying the G35 "won" because it was less expensive a form of damning with faint praise? I say, let the numbers do the talking! So bring on the numbers.
  • g_carg_car Member Posts: 46
    Cheap price for G35 due mostly to the 10+ year sick Japanese economy and resultant low yen to dollar ratio. I own a BMW, Honda and Nissan so I'm by far not an import hater but less be honest about the reason for the low cost of the current Japanese cars.
  • claywaterfillclaywaterfill Member Posts: 534
    All cars except the C320 and G35 had manual transmissions. It is correct that the BMW sport package not only gives a firmer suspension, but high performance tires as well--while the Infiniti sport package keeps the same Eagle RS-A tires.

    0-60 for G35: 6.2 sec, 330i: 6.1 sec
    1/4 mile for G35: 14.7 sec @ 95.2 mph, 330i: 14.7 sec @ 96.3 mph
    Slalom speed for G35: 65 mph, 330i: 65.4
    Braking from 80 mph for G35: 218 ft, 330i: 230 ft
    Both turned .86g on 200 ft skidpad
    The BMW was eletronically limited
    to 128 mph, the G35 hit 151 mph. The 330i did get much better mileage: they recorded 25.9 mpg to the G35's 20.9. The difference allowed them to drive 7 more miles on 3.4 fewer gallons of gas. The biggest differences came in the subjective areas--so no two people will see everything the exact same way. Again, had price not been an issue and the 330i was named the winner, it was still an outstanding job right out of the box--for $7000 less as well.
  • neo_gtrwneo_gtrw Member Posts: 76
    Thanks for posting the data. With an auto tranny, G35 doesn't stand a chance against the 330i with a stick.

    Are you listening, Infiniti? Make the 6speed stick, LSD and high performance tires available to the sedan ASAP or the G35 sedan will only be second best!
  • hvan3hvan3 Member Posts: 630
    <<Owners of the G35 will now be able to say that even though the BMW was judged to be the better car with better performance and the car most testers would rather own, the low price will make the G35 worth owning instead>>

    Considering that the G35 with AUTO was used in the test, I still believe the G35 is a better performance than the 330i. The numbers were basically neck and neck.....
  • monte4monte4 Member Posts: 101
    With those numbers being that close for an auto to the 330's manual most G35 owners will beat out a 330 manual owner on the average strret lighht jaunt. We must realize that these are professional drivers and the every day Joe couldnt produce numbers like that in a manual. When the manual G comes out bye bye 330.
  • bjbird2bjbird2 Member Posts: 647
    Where in the article do you see that all the reviewers would buy a 330i? The editors comments I see are mixed with about equal numbers preferring the G-35 and BMW, some preferring both equally, and some preferring other cars in the group.
  • memphisslim1memphisslim1 Member Posts: 37
    I wash my G at least once a week and when cleaning the front wheels, I've been cutting my fingers washing around the wheels near the brakes. There's a couple of sharp metal clips that catch the fingers, and you'd think I'd learn by now how to avoid them, but just about every wash one of those metal parts hides out waiting for my tender fingers. I'm getting better, but I hate the brake dust on those front wheels. I've waxed the wheels and it keeps the brake dust down, but it still builds after a week of driving on the highway. I've seen a spray (can't remember the name right now) in the auto stores that is meant to be sprayed on the wheels to remove brake dust (then simply spray with a hose), but I'm a little leary of harsh detergents. Anybody have any experience with the best way to clean front wheels?

    BTW, got about 1700 miles on my G and it's still the best performance car I've ever owned, and still a rush and as fun to drive as when I drove it off the lot.
  • bke986sbke986s Member Posts: 7
    As long as you buy the right stuff, you shouldn't have any problems with the spray on cleaner - I used P21 wheel cleaner it on my Boxster S wheels, which worked well. There is a good website that gets very detailed about these products, www.carecareonline.com I'm not suggesting you buy anything there, but there is some good information.

    A soft brush may also be sufficient, in conjunction with normal car washing soap.
  • maxcat1maxcat1 Member Posts: 27
    I agree--I've cut mine a couple of times already (you'd think I'd learn). The problem is that we're trying to reach through from the front to clean the back and catching something in the caliper housing. I think that a bottle brush may solve the problem.
  • faenorfaenor Member Posts: 99
    Well, it finally happened, the inevitable,

    I was doing about 108 on 680 here in California and I saw the lights in the rear view DAAAAAAMMMMMNNNN!

    the CHP was as cool about it as I guess a CHP can be... He told me that he had no hard numbers, but based on his eperience (he looked like a veteran) and how long it took him to catch up at the speed he was going that I was probably doing over 100... Dang, he's good...

    But the freeway was graveyard empty and because of that single fact, two things were confirmed 1) I was an idiot for not looking behind me more often, and 2) He wrote the tcket up for 88. He told me that anything in excess of 100mph was considered reckless endangerment, and furthermore, if I had been weaving in traffic at the speed I was going, he would have hauled me into the station. I guess I have to believe him on that one...

    I don't know though, at 100, my G35 feels like most other cars I have driven at 75...

    One thing I didn't ever know about (I don't get pulled over on a regular basis :P) The Officer new where I bought the car, when I bought the car, and EXACTLY how much I paid for it! He made a comment about how I should be more careful with such an expensive car while its so new, and I asked him how he knew about the details and he said the computer had the full lowdown on everything about it... Geez! I guess if it ever gets stolen that would work in my favor :)

    Oh well... its been about 10 years since I got a ticket so traffic school for me...

    Faenor/Dane4
  • boomer23boomer23 Member Posts: 125
    Condolences, Faenor. You're right, it was inevitable, but that doesn't make it sting less, huh? I usually keep it down to 80 on my way home, but I must admit, the freeway is NOT empty at the time.

    What was the cost of the ticket? Might help the rest of us slow down a bit.
  • hhomerhhomer Member Posts: 15
    First, let me say that I just learned about this message board, and it is awesome! I actually stumbled upon a G35 with Nav and I got it right away!

    Anyway, the dust on the front wheels is really beginning to annoy me too! I heard that there are "performance" brake pads that release less dust. Does anyone know about this?
  • scotth501scotth501 Member Posts: 56
    The cops are usually pretty cool about it as long as you're straight with them. I did learn to continually check mirrors and guages when I was taking pilot lessons, so driving a car is quite a bit simpler. Once, I was pulled over doing about 120mph on old Route 66 just outside of Tulsa, OK in my '68 Mustang because I was late to the last qualifying match for the Junior (under 21) Olympics rifle competition in Colorado Springs at USOC headquarters. 2 things I recommmend: when you're driving, tell the cops when you've got your guns with you, and when you're in the Olympic dorms, find out where the legal-aged female gymnasts are staying. Ever since I got my concealed handgun permit, I haven't gotten a ticket yet. Maybe it's because when I mention both my primary and backup gun the speeding is somehow less significant. As long as the cops know you're truthful and upfront, and you're willing to take the consequences for your actions. I run into them all the time out at the range, and they're all just cool guys. They probably just appreciate your G35 and want you to be as safe as possible. I won't offer condolences for the ticket, you probably deserved it. I for one, am happy you have a car that can surpass the clowns I saw today going 50 mph in the left two lanes in a 60 mph zone. There must have been a full quarter mile of clear road in front of them, but they ignore the Texas law that says slower traffic must stay to the right. There's good explanation here: http://home.att.net/~texhwyman/laws.htm


    When I'm in my Z and want to do 110, and you're only going 100, move over! :)


    Scott

  • stsurbrookstsurbrook Member Posts: 285
    Hey! Long time no hear from! You must have been busy. Wife and I haven't noticed the dust too much as we get the car cleaned weekly. Let someone else cut up their fingers... :)

    We have 4900+ miles (NOT a typo) on our G35 and still like it as much as ever. Only "new" complaint is about the "learning" transmission. Since 95% of the time it is being driven normally, the transmission has "learned" that and doesn't seem as responsive as it used to. Of course, it could just be the "newness" wearing off. :)

    Gas milage has generally been good, but this last tank stinks! Been driving it VERY hard and mucho in-city driving (90%) and I'm under 17mpg right now. My 2-1/2 year old daughter likes it when the car does "vroom-vroom's", so the acceleration's over the +60 miles of this tank have been rather aggressive. (Before people begin telling me I'm irresponsible, it is heavy acceleration from 0-35 or 40mph and on empty roads with no cross streets, well below the speed limits and no loss of traction... :)

    Unfortunately, the nav system seems to over report the mpg's by about 1-2 mpg rather consistently... putting my actual mpg's at 15-16mpg right now. UGH! However, that is the price I pay for the fun I'm having! :)

    Took a friend out who owns a 1999 MB CLK430 today and gave him quite a ride. I could tell he was a bit nervous by how tightly he was holding on to the "panic handle". :) He let me drive his MB and I have to admit (in a most biased fashion) that I don't think it was really any better than the G35. Especially considering it is an AMG version at $55K. He kept mentioning all of the features that the MB had and how he noticed that the G35 had copied many of them. I had to bite my tongue many times to keep from telling him, "Oh, yeah, the G35 has that also..."

    The MB's 275hp/305ft-lb torque are kind of lost in its 3600+ lbs, in comparison. The stats say that it is about 0.3 sec faster 0-60, but I didn't see it. Of course, the fit and finish for the car was a bit nicer (a moderate bit, not a lot). :)

    WISH that Memphis Motorsports Park would do some Autocross or SOLO II events as I would dearly LOVE to take the G35 out on the track. Oh, well! :)

    As for those people here thinking that 0.1 seconds 0-60 time in the R&T is substantial (G35 auto vs. 330i manual), that is less than 1/5 heartbeat in time and could EASILY be the other way on the street.

    Anyway, got to got to bed. We ought to get together some time...

    Scott
  • robmarchrobmarch Member Posts: 482
    Not to beat a dead horse here, but price is only one piece of the puzzle in these comparo's. I like how they break it up into price weighted and non-price weighted. There are some people who want the absolute top performing sedan that they can afford, in whatever categories they choose. What these tests try to do is set a common criteria and evaluate performance. Then, factor in cost.

    Personally, I think this is a good indication of the level of performance to expect with the manual transmission. And, when you combine the larger interior volume and Nissan reliability, as well as the large price difference, I believe you have to agree that the G35 is an excellent product. These comparisons never factor reliability, also.

    For some people, the BMW is a better package, especially those with less restrictive budgets. They're the class benchmark for a reason. But, this test shows me that the 6-speed sedan will be plenty fun enough for me, and come in at a pretty respectable price for the level of equipment, even if the interior feel isn't "class leading".

    Realistically, the top 3 cars are significantly different total packages which appeal to slightly different markets, when you factor in styling, interior volume, and luxury bits. It wouldn't be hard to justify any of those 3 as the best car for a person, depending on their requirements.

    The next 3 cars are excellent front wheel drive based cars(a4 with quattro here) which affects their driving dynamics when pushed to the limits. But, for most drivers shopping these cars, they're a solid performance package that has good snow/foul weather capability. For many consumers, this may be the best compromise, with 3 different quality total packages to shop.

    I believe the Mercedes C320 is a great looking car that is too expensive for what you get, especially with 6 other great options in this market. And, their recent trend has been to downgrade their interior quality, which isn't going to sit well with those interested in paying this premium price.

    CTS - I haven't formulated an opinion yet, but I'm not a big fan of the lincoln LS as a sport sedan, and this reminds me a lot of that experiment. I think these cars are not really shooting at the 3-series benchmark, rather offering fun performance in a large package. not a bad thing, just not a sport sedan, imho.

    Volvo S60 - great looking car, great interior, good performance. but, it is also expensive for what you get, performance wise. Not a bad choice, but not a top performer or top value play in a tightly contested market.

    X type - way too expensive for the performance, without the reliability and luxury to compete for the more luxurious side of this equation. This car is not a compelling value in this market.

    Left off - Nissan Maxima. It's a solid competitor to the TL-S with an available 6-speed manual. It doesn't have the handling manners of the top 3, but is a solid performance competitor to the front wheel drive cars. And, it's a great value play with the HLSD 6-speed SE available at $24k. And, it's got a nice interior to match. The Altima has better handling, but the interior is not a match for this class, unfortunately.

    I'm eagerly awaiting my issue in the mail:)
  • jrct9454jrct9454 Member Posts: 2,363
    Not to hector or lecture, but it is likely you were spotted from the air - which means that no matter how empty the freeway, and no matter how much you pay attention to your mirrors, you were dead meat as soon as you got over 80 mph.

    A caution to all enthusiasts driving in CA: remember the bear in the air. My last ticket came on Christmas morning in 1996 on an equally empty stretch of SR99 near Stockton, and I never went faster than 80. By the time I saw the cruiser [working very hard to close - he had to have come from several miles back], it didn't matter, because the guy in the plane had already made the decision to nail me. Another wasted day out of my life in traffic school...

    This felt like a cheap shot, but the fact is that the CHP has a big job to do and in general, I don't fault their execution. I would prefer them to spend more time working on truckers - and in fact that's what they are trying to do here in the Sacramento area - but catching truckers is very difficult even with the aircraft, since they communicate with each other so easily. As a 57 year old driving enthusiast, it's been alarming and discouraging to see how much dangerous, careless, and inconsiderate behavior now happens with people navigating 80,000 lbs that can't be stopped straight in half the county. In the "olden days of yore", the long-haul truck drivers were the best drivers on the road - too many exceptions these days,

    Anyway, watch yourself, even on seemingly deserted stretches of ex-urban freeway - you might not be as alone as you think.
  • ruskiruski Member Posts: 1,566
    hey I may be able to tell you where you bought your car too, if I pull up behind you and you still have the dealer plate holder and/or dealer's badge on the trunk :)
  • memphisslim1memphisslim1 Member Posts: 37
    Thanks for the useful advice on cleaning the wheels. Don't know why I didn't consider using a bottle brush, although I was fixed on actually 'feeling' the curve of the wheels through my wet wash cloth and working the suds using high quality shampoo (i.e., Maguiere). I eye those metal brake clips (calipers?) with respect now, and I don't need to shed any more blood (although the shampoo cleans the wound nicely). Need to keep my black G35 washed at least once a week as I love the high gloss shine as I drive it around Memphis on the weekend. Still can't believe the number of compliments I continue to get from strangers about the car. Haven't seen too G35s many around Memphis yet (although there is a white one in my neighborhood with a spoiler (but I don't think it's you Scott, as I only see a lady driving it).

    Been out of town for a while and busy with work, and glad to return to this list serv. I must admit it is nice to read the posts that have as much passion for the G (and cars in general) as I have had rekindled in me from driving this car. I do notice the tendency in the transmission to downshift at the slightest touch of the gas pedal, but I guess I take every opportunity to punch it these days (just to get up to the speed limit of course :>)
    and love that kick back in your seat and throaty roar of the engine (and I'm no boy racer).

    Scott: I agree that it would be nice if Memphis Motorsports Park would do some Autocross or SOLO II events so we could take our G35s out on the track (although I think I might find it a humbling experience when I realize I'm not as good a driver as I think I am).

    Thanks.
  • faenorfaenor Member Posts: 99
    Pah! I got my real plates about 2 weeks ago :P I bought my car about 2 days after they first arrived at the dealerships!

    Good thing about that is that although I only gd a modest bit off MSRP, I didn't have to contend with the later measured popularity of the car and the tacked on advertising fee that so many are having to negotiate around these days :)

    Getting busted while still having dealer plates would be absolutely embarassing! I think that CHP officers must give each other points when they stop speeding cars that are THAT new =)

    Faenor/Dane4
This discussion has been closed.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.