Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

Navigation GPS Systems

1101113151647

Comments

  • piarpiar Member Posts: 1
    The coolest thing about GPS nav is that it knows all the roads in the world -- or its database -- and can calculate the fastest route between two points using shortcuts you didn't even know existed. Having experience with TomTom and Volvo nav, I decided to buy my new 06 Civic EX with navigation. I had heard the Acura/Honda system was the best so I had high expectations. The driver interface is outstanding -- a clear, bright display; excellent presentation of data; good controls for changing displays, modes, etc; and the voice-activated feature is great fun. After living with it awhile, if I had it to do over again I wouldn't buy it. Other navs I've used calculate fastest or shortest routes with options to maximize or minimize freeways as well as avoid toll roads. The Honda system calculates most direct and easiest instead of fastest and shortest. It also categorizes roads as verified, unverified or not digitized. Despite a menu option that allows the use of unverified roads, the system only uses them when absolutely necessary and really gets hesitant about using not-digitized roads. In rural Virginia, the system showed a 12-mile route when I could have taken a two-mile route on an unverified road which the system was fully aware existed. All of this taken together means the system takes you the way the Honda programmers (and probably lawyers) see as 'best' rather than fastest. A great toy, but I'd recommend a system that does 'fastest.' Buy a TomTom; you can add your own points of interest and have John Cleese’s voice order you around.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    You gotta trust these devices!

    My wife got lost this morning in an unfamiliar area. Turns out she was "sure" that the place was near a certain road, and while the Garmin kept telling her otherwise, she refused to listen and got lost.

    Well, turns out the GPS was right, and she only found the place when she decided to listen to the directions.

    To err is human, I guess. NAV is not perfect, but it almost always gets you there.

    piar: interesting. I'd rate the NAV on the Subaru I tried about equal to my Garmin GPS (StreetPilot c320). Have not tried a Tom Tom yet, but I too had heard good things about Honda's system. The Garmin loves taking short cuts.

    -juice
  • manish500manish500 Member Posts: 2
    Hello

    I consistently hear acura has the best navigation system, but I want to know what makes their system superior. I want to know how far off the BMW and lexus systems are, or even compare it to some aftermarket systems. Does anyone know how I can get this information? Are there any comparison guides available?

    Thanks!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Only comparo I've seen is for the aftermarket systems as described above.

    -juice
  • navguynavguy Member Posts: 61
    First, the BMW iDrive system is consistently rated the poorest due to its substandard user interface. While they have made improvements to the system it still isn't intuitive.

    The main reason why users rank the Honda system the highest, in my humble opinion, is because the navigation system can be operated while the vehicle is in motion. Other navigation systems from Lexus, Mazda, SAAB, Cadillac and Toyota do not allow complex operations to be performed while the vehicle is in motion.

    To my knowledge, as I regularly follow this topic, there is not comprehensive review of either portable or factory navigation systems.
  • navguynavguy Member Posts: 61
    The key word is 'verified.' That means no one has actually driven the road to make sure that it is a maintained road, and to confirm if the posted traffic signs match the map database. Like most automobile manufacturers, they do not want to send a user the wrong way on a one-way street. Other companies have a more relaxed standard when it comes to guidance.

    As always, the navigation system will direct you to an unknown destination. If you know a better way... take it. No system will ever be as adaptive as the human brain.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Subaru's system also does not allow you to use most functions while the vehicle is in motion. Kind of a pain when we used it, because even when you have a passenger to do it for you, you can't.

    Portable units of course allow it, because they're not integrated. An advantage, I guess. The lawyer screen on the Garmin also disappears after a while even if you don't respond to it.

    -juice
  • bernarddbernardd Member Posts: 1
    Please HELP!!! I bought on line a new GPS system from a 06 expedition and installed it in my 01 250 van. I bought the antenna from ford and installed it and got the correct cd for my area but I cannot get it to create a map or know where I am. If anyone can help me with this I will be extremely grateful. Thank you--Bernard
  • 204meca204meca Member Posts: 369
    We are planning big E Coast Fall trip & considering a portable GPS. I am glad to have found this discussion Yea Edmunds!

    I was leaning toward Garmin, but the The Verizon cell phone looks pretty cool & for someone who may not use the GPS much looks like a good deal. Could use it for for over 10 months for the cost of a Garmin. That could be years for the occasional user.

    Once purchased, are there "subscription" costs (monthly or annual fees, periodic upgrade fees...) for the handheld GPS units?

    I tried the Verizon demo. It seems a bit complex, but due to lack of experience don't know who it compares to a GArmin. Anyone have experience with both systems that can answer the ease of use question?

    Mucho Gracis!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Yes, and that's the catch. I think my carrier charged $10 per month when I looked, and that adds up.

    I've had my GPS for about a year now, that would have been $120 already. I paid $405 for it but that is lifetime, no fees ever, unless I want to pay for new maps.

    Other issues? Functionality, see if it has voice prompts, of course no touch screen so check out the menus and see if they are easy to use.

    BlackBerry offers it, but again, I don't really want to pay a fee and the screen is comparatively tiny. It's about the size of the Garmin i series, and you can get one of those for less than $250. That's about 2 years' worth of service, so the Garmin is a better deal in the long run IMHO.

    -juice
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Yep, $216.99 for a B&W i2 model, a bit more for the color i3 model but still under $300.

    I'd do that rather than pay a fee every month, over time it'll cost you more.

    Bernard: wow, that's going to be a tough one. You're using OE equipment on a different model, something probably very few people do. They usually either let the dealer do it all with equipment like that, or go aftermarket for the entire system.

    Make sure the antennae also is getting power, there are two cables connected to it, right?

    As for the mapping question, I would try calling whoever manufactures the NAV system for help, usually it's someone like Kenwood or Pioneer. The catch is they may only offer tech support for trained and authorized service technicians.

    Maybe Crutchfield could help, but then again maybe not if you didn't buy it there. Or the dealer that sold you the parts?

    -juice
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    Sorry, I've been away for a while here!

    I think they where talking about the TomTom Plus service which has TomTom Traffic (I think that's what it's called) which is a subscription based service (monthly)that you can get.
    I looked around to make sure I got my facts straight- have you ever seen the mytomtomgo page? I thought that was helpful towards answer questions...

    I noticed they put up a pretty good review of the newest one they have too the 910. Can't wait to try one of those out in the store!
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    204meca-- I've been pretty happy with the TomTom's I've used. The maps are on-the-spot and they're easy to use (sounds like you're new to the GPS world).
    There is no subscription fee outside of the basic cost of the unit (other than the aforementioned traffic service, but that is an option).
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Interesting site, the prices are listed in pounds so I guess it's run from the UK.

    Where do you "test drive" the GPS? Best Buy has a display but not a very good one. They usually only have 1 or 2 that actually are working.

    -juice
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    In pounds sterling? AH! I know what you did. If you look in the upper right corner, you can switch from "UK english" to "US English" which changes the site around. Funny that isn't clearer!

    I know that Circuit City is selling the 910 (and maybe the 510) as of this week- so you might want to try there for a "test drive".
    I have a geek buddy of mine that had a TomTom 700 he let me fool around with for a week or so (and I STILL borrow it more often than not :)), so that's where I got the best test drive from!

    If you head over to C. City, lemme know what you think (is the diplay they have any better?)?
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    OK, I'll check them out. I wanted to go there for a camcorder battery anyway.

    -juice
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    Piar- I did a little research on the TomTom Maps. They're supplied by a third party supplier called Tele Atlas (sp?). From what I read, I guess the do work with all sorts of companies..providing...map information/data.
    I'm pretty sure, now that I think of it..I've seen their logo on the google earth or google maps before.

    Whatever, as long as the thing is accurate- I'm game!
  • jimstrenkjimstrenk Member Posts: 56
    I've hear radio advertising about Tom Tom on dash GPS/Navigation Systems.

    Anyone have any experience using these??

    Tips, suggestions and comments are welcomed! :D
  • bizonbizon Member Posts: 2
    What do y'all think of nav4all. Its new free gps software and i read some good reviews about it
  • pernaperna Member Posts: 521
    I've hear radio advertising about Tom Tom on dash GPS/Navigation Systems.

    Anyone have any experience using these??


    IMO, the Garmin units are better, particularly in regards to the "freshness" of the maps. Garmin's customer service is also the best in the industry. I have a GPS V, which is an antique by this point, and they have still given me support for it free of charge.

    Last year, when I'd owned the thing for 3+ years, I realized 3 days before a trip that I'd misplaced my mapping CDs (and had reformatted my computer). I called Garmin expecting to pay out the nose, and they actually sent me a full set of mapping CDs, next day air - for free.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Check out the review posted above from PC Magazine, IIRC.

    I'm happy with my Garmin.

    As for those freebie maps, you still need an antennae, it seems a bit piece meal to me, I'd rather have an all-in-one unit personally.

    -juice
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    I agree ateixeria, that does seem more piece-meal than I'd like for something in the car. Too much stuff sliding around, thats why I think TomToms/Portable Navs are the way to go.

    I've got enough going on in the car!
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    I've been pretty impressed I've seen with the TT units that are provided by Tele Atlas. I know they try to keep their updated every 6-9 months as well. It takes a lot of time to drive around everywhere and gather all that data. Kudos to them for getting it right.

    If I remember right, I think Tele Atlas provides a lot of Map data for GoogleMaps as well. I figure it Google sources their maps from them, they've got to be pretty good!
  • jaxs1jaxs1 Member Posts: 2,697
    What new cars besides the Honda Civic EX are available with factory navigation and no leather.

    I mean cars that are really available on dealer lots and produced that way.
    For example, theoretically, nav is available on some cars like the Camry XLE 4 cylinder with cloth seats, but in reality that is not a combination that the factory builds or ships so it is only available that way on paper.
    Also, you cannot order a car from Toyota with just the options you want. Toyota sets mandatory option bundles for each region of the country. They change the option bundling occassionaly, but they control it.
  • jaxs1jaxs1 Member Posts: 2,697
    Google absolutley does not use Tele Atlas maps.
    It says NAVTEQ right on the Google Maps web page.
  • pathstar1pathstar1 Member Posts: 1,015
    Just a slight correction - Toyota US sets the option bundles. Toyota Japan just builds/ships what Toyota US orders. Ditto for other manufacturers. The reason is a Japanese worker has no accurate idea of what those in other countries want. This is due to language barriers and local society customs/trends which he/she can't possibly know of.

    So the solution is you can use a Garmin or Tom Tom or Magellin etc. Some of them can even be integrated into your car, such as the Garmin 2650 which is connected to your odometer output (by a "qualified installer").
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    "The reason is a Japanese worker has no accurate idea of what those in other countries want"

    Funny, to read the forum, that sentence could say Toyota USA (or Ford or Chevy) has no accurate idea of what consumers want.

    I want NAV to cost about what a handheld GPS costs. :shades:

    Steve, Host
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    You sure about that jaxs1? I don't think your "absolutley" sure about that. From what I've read the data for Google Maps is jointly produced by the two companies. (I guess I should have made that more clear, so my bad there!).

    Google Earth is provided entirely by Tele Atlas. THAT is an awesome program! I love being able to manipulate the maps and whatnot.

    In fact, I think I'm going to waste some time before lunch and play with it now.....
  • jaxs1jaxs1 Member Posts: 2,697
    Yes, I am considering a Garmin Nuvi, but I just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing any vehicles available with factory nav and cloth seats.
    Besides the Honda Civic EX, I'm pretty sure the new 2007 Jeep Wrangler will have factory nav available and I don't even think leather will be an option, but the Wrangler will probably be too much of a gas guzzler to be a real option for me.
    Mazda3 has optional nav, but it is always bundled with some kind of grand touring package which inludes leather, so that's off my list too.
  • lmn908lmn908 Member Posts: 34
    2006 Subaru Outback Special Edition wagons come with cloth seats and factory navigation. I think that the Mazda 5 can also come with Nav and cloth seats.

    Larry
  • jaxs1jaxs1 Member Posts: 2,697
    I think those are always fully loaded with leather if they have nav.
  • lmn908lmn908 Member Posts: 34
    Well I can't be 100% sure about the Mazda 5, but both Edmunds and the Mazda USA website list the touring edition as coming with cloth seats, and Nav as an option.

    I am certain about the Subaru Outback SE, as we have one. This was a mid-year model, available in only two colors (Diamond Gray and Seacrest Green.) Also comes with automatic climate control and 6 disc CD changer over the base outback. MSRP of option package is $2500, but that includes the cost of the auto transmission. Definitely does not have leather (or a sunroof.) We got ours in March; I don't know about current availability.
  • jaxs1jaxs1 Member Posts: 2,697
    I may check out the Subaru.
    Even when the options list shows standard cloth seats, what usually happens is that the dealers just order all options on cars that have nav. They just assume that buyers who want nav always want leather and every other option to go with it and that will be how all cars are on the dealer lots.
    So, you can't go by the website or what the brochure says.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Yeah, Subaru puts leather in the Limited models, but not on the SE. The SE packages are generally a screaming bargain, and that's true for the OB (it adds NAV) or the Legacy (it adds a moonroof and power seats) or even the Outback Sport (it adds a lot of minor features for next to nothing).

    Go for an SE.

    -juice
  • utterutter Member Posts: 79
    I was just reading this in the Biz section- it reminds me of when Hertz first put their "Neverlost" GPS units in their cars, except these guys are using the TomTom Rider units. Interesting concept- self guided, "first rate" or I guess you could say "luxury" motorbike tours. I wonder if they'll become popular...

    http://biz.yahoo.com/iw/060523/0130998.html



    EagleRider Revolutionizes Motorcycle Travel

    Tuesday May 23, 2:34 pm ET



    LOS ANGELES, CA--(MARKET WIRE)--May 23, 2006 -- EagleRider, already the world's leading motorcycle rental company, is now paving the way for a revolution in the way enthusiasts travel. EagleRider's world-renowned self-drive tours are now better than ever and experiencing an explosion in popularity.

    Companies like EagleRider are springing up everywhere and are more than just motorcycle rental or tour organizations. They are complete travel and concierge service companies tailored for the motorcycle market. EagleRider offers the personal service of your own in-house trip planner with customized itineraries focusing on the most majestic motorcycle touring routes.

    Joe Ricketts, Chairman and founder of Ameritrade, said, "Being able to leave a blustery winter in Omaha, go to Southern California and rent a motorcycle for a ride to Cabo is absolutely wonderful. EagleRider provides truly great service."

    EagleRider self-drive tour customers rent a late model motorcycle, stay at first-rate accommodations, and receive a personalized Road Book designed with everything a rider would need including all mapped routing, suggestions for excellent restaurants, and interesting stops along the way. Round the clock roadside assistance and motorcycle concierge services come standard with your EagleRider rental, and customers can even choose to have a TomTom GPS navigation system installed with their personal trip routing for the ultimate in ease of travel.

    EagleRider does all the planning and provides all the gear, leaving travelers the freedom to marvel at the scenery and experience the thrill of adventure on the road alone, or with the company of their own friends and family. Over a hundred self-drive tours are available out of every EagleRider location.
  • precisionprecision Member Posts: 1
    hi , i have the same problem , there is an update that came for the jaguar 2006 , i live in puerto rico , jaguar dont know if puerto rico is on the dvd , but it comes in the dvd for maguellan ,hertz and many others , but i will like to know if there is compability with other softwares ,, thanks,plus there is other dvd called pure adrenalin for the 2005 , good luck
  • normkolnormkol Member Posts: 135
    I broke down and went for the new C550. The combination of Bluetooth, voice giving street names and built in traffic alerts got me to spend the $800.

    We have four cars, and this is the most economical way of having GPS available in any of them.

    I should have it by next week, I can't wait to see how it works.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Oh, man, I'm sooo jealous!

    I have the c320. Yours adds a whole bunch of features. I might spring for one. We actually want a 2nd one because my wife and I argue over ours. ;)

    -juice
  • bat1161bat1161 Member Posts: 1,784
    I'll be curious how effective you find the traffic reporting part in the NYC area. I have the older Garmin Streetpilot 2610 and love it, except for the lack of traffic routing.

    Mark
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I'm not sure how much I'd use that, especially since you have to pay a monthly fee. I would not mind sampling it for a while to see if I'd use it.

    Here is a chart that compares what features all the C series have, look to the right:

    http://www.garmin.com/products/sp550/

    -juice
  • bat1161bat1161 Member Posts: 1,784
    Being a gadget person (according to my wife) I would be interested in the traffic part, nominally. The only problems with it are having to pay for the service, and the limited areas it works in.

    I bought the GPS for when I travel, but to get the traffic benefit I would have to be using it in NYC all the time.

    Mark
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I'm a gadget guy as well, but I'm cheap. :blush:

    I'm waiting for a good GPS kit for my BlackBerry 8700, that I have with T-Mobile. I don't think I can get the monthly service because it's a work phone.

    Some new products are supposed to come out soon that add that capability with a one-time up front fee, no monthly fees. We'll see.

    The c550 is $800 or so. The Nuvi 310 (cheapest BT from Garmin) is not out yet, but it should cost about the same as the UK model, so figure about $580. I can get another c320 like mine for $325, so that's a pretty big step up for Bluetooth.

    -juice
  • normkolnormkol Member Posts: 135
    You get three months free service with the C550, so I'll be able to try it out without signing up for anything.

    My main concern, being in NYC, is keeping it hidden but not totally inaccessible, so it doesn't get stolen. I drive a Mazda Tribute, so no trunk to keep it in.
  • tmarttmart Member Posts: 2,397
    I'm very pleased with my C320. Only real problem is daytime viewing with the top down. The anti-glare display on the 500's sounds like a good improvement, if it really works. Wish Garmin made an aftermarket screen that could be added. I saw a visor online, but when I tried to "copy" it by using a ball cap on top of the unit, it really didn't do much. Don't need the traffic, MP3, Bluetooth, etc. I really like the size and portability of the Nuvi. Basically the size of a deck of cards. Sweet! :shades:
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I hear both of you.

    I'm in the 'burbs so I guess I take my chances. If I park in an urban area I'll hide it somewhere.

    3 months of free service sounds great. Just enough time to see if you think it's worth it.

    I get glare on my Miata, too. Makes it a lot less useful - so I rely on the voice commands. It's fine in my Forester, though, because I have tinted windows. I've never had a problem seeing the screen, or even with finger prints for that matter.

    -juice
  • bat1161bat1161 Member Posts: 1,784
    This past weekend I kind of wished I had the traffic info on my Streetpilot 2610. We were on our way to a wedding upstate NY when ran into traffic at a dead stop in Newark on I-280. Tried the different news station, but nobody metnioned the cause, or location of the problem. After going 0.25 miles in about 40 minutes I decided to try using my Garmin to get me out of there. Wound up taking the local streets for a good 25 miles or so, but it worked! Without the GPS, I would have just sat there for who knows how long.

    On the other hand, if I had the traffic update feature, I wonder how it would have routed me, and if it would have picked it up before I got stuck.

    Mark
  • normkolnormkol Member Posts: 135
    I should have listened to it. There was a traffic problem where I was going, and it was giving directions for an alternate. I thought it was just wrong, so I ignored the messages until it was too late. When it said, "Recalculating", and I was stuck in traffic, I realized I should have listened

    Next time.

    Otherwise, it seems fine. The voice instructions are clear, the map is clear. Connecting to my Bluetooth phone was simple. The initial setup only took about 10 minutes, and was very intuitive.

    This is my first GPS, so I don't have anything to compare to. But so far, it's doing what I expected of it.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Last time we drove to CT I did the same thing. Got away from a jack-knifed tractor trailer, though, because I got out in time. NAV got me thu via local roads. :)

    -juice
  • blaneblane Member Posts: 2,017
    bat1161,

    The traffic information on navigation units is only as good as the data source. If you tried all of the local radio news reports, and didn't hear of the particular tieup, the navigation system will probably be in the dark too.
  • bat1161bat1161 Member Posts: 1,784
    That's what I figured; one of the reasons I am not ready to do any "upgrading" of the NAV system I have. It is my understanding that the traffic updates come from the news stations. Anyone know if that is correct or not?

    Mark
Sign In or Register to comment.