By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
Well, obviously, for couples with a larger family or need for more room and who ARE prepared for a full size minivan for image or financial reasons.
You know, like the several hundreds of thousands of buyers who chose a DCX, Sienna, Odyssey, or Quest every year INSTEAD of an MPV because the current MPV is too small.
Forget pictures, have you actually SAT in it? I have. I'm a 6 foot, 250 pound guy. The second row passengers have plenty of room for my boat-anchor size 12 feet behind and beneath the front seats...even with the front seats also set up for my 6 foot frame.
I'll agree on the third row...that's basically a kiddie-row only. What you might be forgetting is that, in most 3 row vehicles short of full-size mini/vans and Suburbans/Excursions, the 3rd row is usually kiddie-room only. That's just normal.
Also keep in mind that this is not a $21k+ minivan. it's an $18k microvan. Some people can't hack the extra 3 grand to get a full size minivan new. The ONLY other minivan starting down at $18k is the piece of junk Dodge Caravan. And they charge for emissions compliance, and a rear defroster is "optional" instantly driving the base price here in NY to $19k.
The fact is, the Mazda5 is the ONLY game in town that can reasonably seat 6 and start at $18k. It's also the only game for $18k that can reasonably seat 4 adults COMFORTABLY (Except maybe an Accord DX with no A/C). That makes it unique in the market. Unless you want to sit with 3 other adults in that Accord DX. In which case I highly recommend you keep the windows all the way down.
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Find me at kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
2015 Kia Soul, 2021 Subaru Forester (kirstie_h), 2024 GMC Sierra 1500 (mr. kirstie_h)
Review your vehicle
That being said, here in NJ the price of the Mazda 5 definitely makes it appealing to me. We're going to have our first child, we want a car with a good amount of storage, and my wife insists that our new car have side-curtain airbags. I've looked at a Toyota Matrix with side-curtain airbags, and the best we can get it for is roughly $18k (we were told that they only put the airbags into models that also have lots of other option packages). The Mazda 5 comes with everything that we want as standard equipment, is bigger than the Matrix, has more horsepower than the Matrix, and would cost us roughly the same. Other alternatives we're considering, such as the Honda CR-V, would definitely cost us more than 20k. Even though we'd generally not use the third row of the Mazda 5, the advantage is the flexibilty that the third row offers if we ever need to carry more people (friends, etc.).
My wife and I don't want a minivan right now. Not just because of image, but because we don't need something as big as a full minivan for just one child (we wouldn't often use the third row). Our concern is that a nice minivan would cost a lot more and would be a waste of fuel. We're also not terribly happy with the fuel economy of the Mazda 5, give it a few more MPG and it'd be a no-brainer for us.
http://homepage.mac.com/trancefusion/Mazda3/PhotoAlbum46.html
...along with this description: "These pictures were taken at Port Hueneme, California, one of four ports Mazda uses in the US (two on the west coast and two on the east coast)."
Maybe Mazda can make an expandable van? just put an accordian section on the back so you can extend the cargo area when you need more room!
And yes, that was a joke.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
This is exactly the reason I gave up my minivan over a year ago for a 5-door hatchback--99% of the time we don't need the 6th-7th seats and the extra cargo room. When we need the extra seats, we either drive two small cars (happens about 4 times a year) or for the once-every-two-years long trip, we rent a minivan. If the Mazda5 had been available last spring, I would have considered it then but the price ($18k vs. the $13k I paid for a loaded car) and fuel economy would have been turn-offs. If the middle seats really do have good room for two large kids or adults that would make it much more desirable. The rear seat would have to be OK for at least 5.5' people for short trips to be practical for me.
http://photos.yahoo.com/lenfink52
You will see it next to a Nissan Pathfinder and a Pontiac Grand Am.There is a picture of someone in the second and third rows. There are two shots with a standard size brochure in the storage area to give some size perspective.
After thinking about this some more. I find that the best fit for this car is not the small start-up family. With a baby seat taking up one of the second row spots this car shrinks quickly. I think this car works best the college bound or college grad. It supplies a good amount of space for that individual at a price point that works.
Hopefully you can drive it and see if it works for you.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
Please, don't try to peg Mazda5 against SUVs. Or minivans. "... If it had bigger third row room...", "... If it had a bigger engine...". "...If it had all wheel drive..." But it does not! It is what it is. Six seats, one engine, two configuration with few options. At this point Mazda5 is unique to an american market. It may be the sign of things to come. Personally, I like if not the car, but at least the direction it points to.
"I think this car works best [for] the college bound or college grad." How did they get into the same boat??? :surprise:
--------------------------
True, but they don't all have sliding doors and a stick option or Mazda's better handling. Even a bench isn't good for three in a vehicle the size of the 5. Unless they are "very" friendly or under the age of 10.
I give credit to the Element for having 4 roomy bucket seats. They probably lose some sales with only 4 but at least they aren't cramming in seats where there isn't room.
Six bucket seats is a good idea but I think the vehicle needs to be long for them to be practical. Freestyle size.
Consider that the closest thing to the 5 that's available right now might be the Pacifica. It's much larger, but has more room in the third row, has no stick option, doesn't have sliding doors (a pro or con depending on your point of view), and is more expensive with sale prices starting just under $20k and going way up from there with AWD and other options.
Hope that link works...
-juice
Meade
http://www.mazda.nl/content/pdf/Mazda5_accessoiresbrochure.pdf
I don't think the 5 will attract the same customer as the bigger minivans or Freestyle. Singles, couples and families of three or four. Anyone who hauls more people or a lot of stuff will want something bigger.
I'm with you on the third row but I wish it could be removed completely for more room.
My wife is driving a 95 Camry wagon (7 seats, 170K) that is comfortable and extremely economical that just keeps on going and going and going... However, both my wife and I prefer to drive a stick shift and either of us likes driving a minivan. The only negative I've heard from my wife so far is that the Mazda5 looks a little like the Matrix and she doesn't like the looks of the Matrix at all. My sister has a Matrix that I've driven and it is not especially fun to drive. It feels like a maxed out Echo (sorry Matrix owners).
So, even after reading all the "I'm dissapointed about..." posts to this forum and agreeing that it really isn't perfect...seven spacious seats, 30 mpg, cargo space galore...I still am interested in a mini_minivan with a stick shift that is fun to drive.
Here are my two cents...I hate the looks of the Touring option. I would never purchase a vehicle with running boards, new or used. Manual transmission & running boards? These are two diametrically opposed options. Fun/ugly. As far as I'm concerned, if the Touring were the only option in the U.S., I'd dissuade my wife from considering the Mazda5. I agree that the European options are superior. Just one consumer... I want a factory installed roof rack. Duh..
I hope someone from Mazda reads this forum! They would be dumb not to.
Man, you sound just like me - but up here in Canada we have no choice - it's Touring or nothing.
And to think I was in Oxnard (where Port Hueneme is located) last Friday. Had I known my future car was sitting at the docs, I would have made a detour for an in-person look instead of heading over to the Wal-Mart!