By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
Sebring, you mentioned space heaters and yes that's what I've been planning. Most 12v car heaters I've seen are pretty weak for our harsh Canadian winters. So will be getting one of those ceramic 110v home heater fan and I prolly an inverter to go with it. A real kludge really as all those wires and fan will be pain inside the car but what the heck, I'm trying to save money here so can't complain too much.
The market for a used Prius here in Canada isn't too great yet for the price. Mine goes at around Cdn $17.5K, which is what a brand new basic Civic or Corolla would go. Canadians are smart value oriented consumers and that price is a hard sell. I imagine once the price dips below 15 grand, there will be takers. Plus heres the rub, mine got some needed repairs I inherited right off the dealer. Unfortunately as hard as I tried to have them fixed, they refused. I even called Toyota Canada but they stood by their dealer. So I figure I'm just gonna let them have the problem back at lease end.
Anyway, lets stop talking about my Prius as this is a Civic Hybrid and Jetta TDI thread. The only reason I posted here was to point out some hybrid advantages in winter which I've already mentioned in prevous posts. I havent mentioned yet that due to the large batteries and big electric motors doubling as starters, starting is much more gentler to the ICE than conventional cars. You should try starting a hybrid, there is no falter, starts very gently, and is an amazingly quiet event.
On the Jetta TDI, I test drove a 97 last weekend. I was surprised at the noise. From reviews and comments I've read I expected a lot less noise in the freeway but I was severely disappointed. My '00 Mazda MPV with its tiny 2.5 litre engine reving at 3000rpm sounded lexus quiet on the way home in comparison.
I also conked out the engine turning back to the dealer... tsk tsk tsk. Gotta work on that stick shift skills again. At home I learned in the net TDI's could be shifted without me stepping on the accelerator (true?), so kept that in my mental file for future use.
The net review of VW's also is very scary, one even advised not owning a Vdub if you are not mechanically enclined to fixing your own car as it can be very expensive if you have to bring it to the shop often. Man...with the disappointing test drive and lousy reliability reviews, I'm almost ready to chicken out on this.
Can anybody pls give me a more reasurring reviews than this?
However today here in Canada, if I were in the market for a new 2 door I would consider the Smart with its 6 speed auto manual. But thats just only me as I would try to run it in Biodiesel or SVO.
On the VW Jetta TDI, I currently run 15,000-20,000 mile oil and filter change intervals! The Honda Civic dealer (one of the absolute best in this area within a 50 mile radius, I might add) did an absolute full court press to sign me up for 5,000 mile oil and filter change intervals!!!!!
Honda Civic was always a contender in my book for a daily driver commute car! I got the 2004 Honda Civic VP almost as a no brainer due to the fact that I was almost pleasantly shocked to find out my 2003 Jetta TDI was selling for more than I paid for it new. I was also eligible for a 1,000 dollar prior owners discount with VW. This would have dropped the purchase price significantly below invoice. Unfortunately no new TDI products for 2004/5 was available in CA!
My goals are thus: 1. 500,000 to 1,000,000 miles with the diesel 2003 Jetta TDI 2. 250,000 miles with the 2004 Honda Civic VP
Did you keep the Jetta or trade it in? How do they compare in handling and braking. One reason I am interested in a diesel, is the next time the middle east squeezes off our oil I can head to McDonalds for a fillup of old cooking oil.....
Pete Blackshaw. The Cincinnati marketing exec bought a Honda Civic hybrid last year and proudly outfitted it with MO MILES vanity plates. But instead of the 48mpg his window sticker promised, he gets 33mpg. "All I want is a damn car that lives up to its promise," he gripes, "and that won't make my wife repeatedly tell me I'm a big fool."
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6480057/site/newsweek/
Uhhh, I don't use a space heater on my car. The heater I use is a 1000 watt Zero-start brand coolant heater. It's hooked into the coolant lines and the plug is located in my front grille. It heats and circulates the coolant (i have it on a timer) and when I start the car it instantly blows hot-air through the HVAC system. You can buy one already set-up for the TDI motor at www.tdiheater.com
I believe you'll find the newer diesels to be quieter than a 1997 model. Not only are the engines a bit different, the new ones have more sound deadening and ride a completely different chassis. 1999 was the first year for the newer diesels, with slightly updated motors again in 2004. Fuel quality also effects noise levels. My TDI is very quiet on the highway, most folks have no clue it's a diesel. With the exception of idling, I think it's very quiet and I drive/own a couple luxury vehicles as well. It's not Lexus quiet, but not many vehicles are, lol!
Handling and braking by the numbers is actually pretty similar. Feeling wise, for me the verdict is still out(not enough miles at 2500). The Civic seems to have a more nervous ride (faster ocillations) Contrary to what I have been lead to believe, the consumable replacement parts are actually cheaper on the VW Jetta!!?? This is surprizing for my rice rocket vendors indicated WAY more choices and options that say the pickled herring side.
In regards to your "do you want fries with that?" comment, all you need is a roughly 1800 dollar portable processing unit and I am sure the places that pay folks to take old cooking oil away will be almost glad to GIVE it to you, although I have not dug into the regulations that govern oil disposal. The salesman that sold me my TDI indicates that he planted 8 acres in soybeans with the calculation that it should be enough for his diesel fuel needs per year!!(plus a slight profit i.e.,at worst: no cost for energy for a years time!! (He's got farm tractors, diesel van and a VW TDI Jetta wagon) I guess I should go up to visit him and talk more seriously about this with him!! He also goes to those classes in Berkeley CA about alternative fuels!
I am starting to see that getting a biodiesel system going is regulatory intense and challenged!!! A member of our VW TDI get together group brought down some biodiesel (from the Berkely coop or some such), but I had to decline for I was filled already!
What the auto makers, the politicians and the world leaders don't know is how serious the average consumer is about this energy + environment issue is. I'm no tree hugger or greenie and I my income is not excessive, yet I voted with my money on the hybrid when I could not realy afford it becuase I thought that was the only solution back then. Now, I'm hoping this diesel/used veggie oil will give me what I want for lesser.
Now if ordinary Joe's like us are looking into this (and I really mean ordinary when talking about me), there IS a strong undercurrent going on here, and that right or wrong is why I think the Hybrids are selling.
ruking1, when you said that fits your description did you mean the spotty vdub reliability or the techy know how? (both?) How much do I have to know to keep a vdub running for the least $$$? What about those timing belt changes, do I really have to have them changed as soon as I buy a used Jetta?
He can get 48 "clean" MPG in his Hybrid by slowing down and driving more fuel consciously. It's for COMMUTING, not HOT RODDING. I'm AMAZED by how many people ZOOM BY ME when I'm doing at or slightly below the speed limit and then HELLO there we sit by them at the next red light. Most people drive like DUMMIES and waste a TON of fuel just zooming between red lights.
Hybrid is not hype if you embrace it and live with it...I'm getting 46.6 over about 4000 miles in my HCH, with a VERY "mpg unfriendly" short commute on city streets, no hwy usage at all, and using HEAVY A/C in July/Aug/Sept in Phoenix.
I'm taking a road trip to TX in December which will force me to drive 75-80 MPH to keep with the flow, a loaded car (two kids and me plus bags) and we will see how well the HCH does under those circumstances. I hope to get at least 40 MPG. But this is a once or twice a year trip - not the norm.
Thanks for that info. I wonder tho how that will interact with the SVO kits I read in greasel or greasecar. Those kits seem to use the same heat source to heat up the used oil tank.
1999 TDI's? Man that's out of my leaque again for now. My Prius is 2001, just 2 years difference so the prices won't be that far away anyway to make a difference. Now if I could find a high mileage 1999 maybe that'll be much cheaper, hmmm....
Insofar as changing the timing belts, having the vehicles history would be helpful. Otherwise because it is so critical (expensive) if it breaks, sometimes without the historical knowledge it might be better to change the belt, which would establish a KNOWN baseline!
The Honda Civic requires a timing belt change at 120,000 miles vs TDI at 100,000 miles. So really both vehicles are in the same boat. Inidcations are the prices are app the same for this procedure.
I'm just now beginning to appreciate my MPV's Ford duratec engine. For all it's suspect origin it at least uses a timing chain that doesn't need replacement and doesn't clatter. 5 years and 110k km later it's only run smoother.
Thanks for the info, guess I'll need to do more research on this vdub thing, see if I can stand the reliability issue. Should also look for other diesel engines out there - maybe some old Toyota PU diesel.
Most of the grease kits I've seen use the coolant of the car to heat the grease. Soooo, the faster your coolant heats up, the faster you can switch to grease. The Zerostart heater should be a huge asset if you're running an SVO vehicle.
As for prices, I guess you'll have to figure that out. I don't know the TDI market in Canada at all. If you're shopping a TDI, I would find a private seller that way you know the repair history. I'm probably selling mine soon and already have someone interested in it, simply because private-sale TDI's with pristine maintenance histories are easy to sell. But they can be good buys too.
There are two issues that really hit VW reliability - one was a faulty design of the power windows regulator, the old design had a nylon part that would break causing the window to fall into the door. VW redesigned the regulator and replaced all the faulty ones (even if the car was way out of warranty), plus put a 7 year warranty on them - problem solved.
The next issue was coil packs - obviously not a diesel issue. VW's supplier of coil packs for the gas engines had quality control issues. VW found an different supplier and replaced every faulty coil pack under warranty - even if the car was way out of warranty.
These two issues are responsible for VW's percieved reliability issues - I'll compare my Jetta to any Honda any day as far as reliability is concerned.
If low sulfur diesel arrives, people will FLOCK to the diesels - they offer a simpler, proven technology to get higher MPG (albeit with slower acceleration). I will certainly buy one if they become available. The important point is that the European diesels are not dirty, they are clean. They are also very fuel efficient and provide tons of torque at low RPMs.
Added to this is the fact that diesel requires less refining than gasoline.
I agree, BUT it is the fault of the EPA. They were able to get lead out of gasoline 30 years ago. Why has it taken so long to get the sulfur out of diesel? How many millions of barrels of oil would we have saved if people were driving clean diesel cars as they are in Europe. You want people to give up the efficient diesel engine cars because the EPA & CARB have their heads up you know where. Worse they were probably bought off by the Oil companies. It seems we have had this discussion before. You want to blame the cars for the pollution when it is the fuel that we as little people have very little control over. You would be driving a car burning leaded gas which is even worse than diesel, if it were not for regulations. The bottom line is people want reliable high mileage cars. Diesel cars are proven high mileage vehicles. Hybrids are still unproven for the long haul. Tell me you love your hybrid when it has 150k miles on it...
Regular Civics possibly but the HCH has a chain.
Not sure if I'd give up the MPG I'm getting from my gas powered car:
http://www.greenhybrid.com/compare/mileage/details.php?cid=70
More than 25K miles and I've averaged just under 60MPG.
Most folks are averaging around 48, as someone said earlier.
Somehow when I see a TDI it reminds me of a reworked Chevy Citation. Check the comparative links:
http://memimage.cardomain.net/member_images/1/web/433000-433999/4- - 33604_35_full.jpg
http://www.familycar.com/RoadTests/VolkswagenGolfTDI/Images/LeftF- - ront.jpg
But hey, that's just me, I doubt anyone else could make the similarities.
I admit being biased against diesel cars.
Back in the 1970's the mags & reviews said the technology had matured and my dad bought one. An Isuzu, it was difficult to start in the Minnesota winters and really noisy. When it began to stink my dad had it fixed for $$$ and got rid of it.
Then in the 80's the claims were made again for diesel cars, then in the 90's if you were on the highway and saw a heavily smoking car you could bet it was ether one of these...an older Mercedes or Volvo diesel.
Same claims in the 90's of new & improved technology....still today if you are in a drivethrough or on the highway, your eyes begin to sting and "That smell" look for the diesel car, you'll find one almost every time.
So when today the mags & reviews say the technology is new and improved many of us take it with the porverbial "grain of salt"
With the TDI MSPR higher than the HCH and comparable MPG to the average user, the potential for diesel to smoke and the potential $$$ for emission repair, the MFG endless Mag review promises I'll steer clear of it.
I bet you've stood next to a 2000-era diesel car at the pump, and not even realized it. Modern diesels meet the same emissions requirements as gasoline cars with *no visible exhaust.*
That stinging can also be from burning unleaded gas in most states. It is also very high in sulfur, causing NoX.
Sounds like you are as hard to convince on diesel as I am on hybrid. It is a matter of proven efficiency vs unproven hybrid technology. I would be more interested after there is a history of many 150k mile hybrids without any major troubles.
So far the posters that own VW TDI vehicles have gotten good reliability.
But they DO seem very reliable, some are still selling at 750k km and I could get one at 300k for just a grand - the ultimate cheapo.
Some may look at this quote and see part of it as being pejorative, but I do not! One of the overwhelmingly interesting points that really sold me on the TDI and the VW is the 12 year rust through unlimited mile rust warranty and the fact that the TDI engine can easily go 500,000 miles and with some care and inevitable replacement parts 1,000,000 miles!
In the past, I have been fortunate to buy (16,000) and to sell (9,000) a 1987 Toyota Landcruiser, with ownership of 14 years and 250,000 miles.
Not in my wildest dreams, do I expect either the Honda or the VW to duplicate this; but it would be pretty neat if it did or was even close!
Just in case somebody does, I meant that as a compliment!
My quest is to own a cheap reliable diesel vehicle I can play with to convert to a grease burner. So far, I'm beginning to think this is the way I should go: A pre 1993 Jetta with 300k km for about a grand. At least if I mess it up, I won't end up bawling.... hmmmm.
We'll see....
Just think for less than 3k you have transportation, means of fuel production/conversion and perform a valuable business and environmental service! What is not to like about that!!
I thought they stopped sales of the TDI in early 2004? Anyway, I'm not in the market at the moment.
It's not the availability, it is the CARB regulations that keep the diesels out of California. Plus, I don't think that any vehicles sold in the US are engineered to take advantage of the ULSD formulation.
No actually 2003 VW (among others) in the USA are engineered to run the 2006 (new) formulation.
The ULSD burns cleaner regardless of any fancy scrubbers, catalysts, etc. Pour some 50 cetane 30ppm ULSD into my TDI and it immediately quiets down, runs smoother, and will NOT puff any smoke under any conditions. The problem is, ULSD is not available everywhere yet, therefore the manufacturers cannot equip the vehicles with additional emissions control that requires ULSD. Biodiesel/blends takes care of the smell, although ULSD is a low aromatic fuel anyway.
Won't the engine controls be damaged by the higher sulfer in the fuels? I believe the European models have special scrubbers to remove particulates & etc?
In the U.S. the sulfur is high, so VW does not install the European catalysts.
Other than that, I am lead to believe the 2006 standard formulation has higher cetane ratings, much lower sulfur content and resultantly lower structural emissions. Obviously one benefit is cleaner burning and one that is yet untested on the wide scale market is slightly better fuel mileage. My response is yippee, yahoo! A down side might be higher prices!
Well, that's what I was saying, that the US models are not set up for ULSD fuel...
Is this price increase just one of those things or are we already paying for ULSD ?
http://www.tnrcc.state.tx.us/air/ms/fuelprograms.html#dsl1
If you want to talk , please take it to the dedicated discussion.
European TDI has the same thing. It's clean too.
American TDIs do not, because the high sulfur fuel would poison the catalyst. So they are dirty (high NOx output).
.
I hope that's clear. That's the simplest way I know to explain it.
"If ULSD fuel came on line today, I could run it on my 2003 TDI with no adaptation and no equipment damage, as stated in the above post: cleaner emissions and probably better mileage!!?? "
NO. SOx would drop, but that is all. It would still be dirty, still the same mpg, still the same car, because you don't have the advanced NOx catalyst like the Euro-TDI & Civic Hybrid has.
Troy
And yeah I know about cetane, but you don't need to wait. You can buy 50 cetane right now. Just look for the "premium diesel" logo, which is what I use in my Beetle.
Personally, I can't wait for 2006 when TDIs will be just as clean as the Civic Hybrids.
This is not true. Diesel exhaust will NEVER be as clean as gasoline exhaust. Period. There are more carcinogens in diesel exhaust, and low sulfur does not end that.
2006 Jetta TDI will not be as clean as the 2006 HCH, or in 2008, or in 2012, or 2016.
Second, diesels are already cleaner than gasoline in every category except NOx: - 2000 VW Manual Beetle (grams/mile)
----- Gas TDI
NOx 1.3 2.7
PMs ----- ----- (not measured)
CO2 7.0 4.7
CO 1.10 0.01
HC 0.15 0.00 (evaporative)
VW TDI diesels have already been promoted by fueleconomy.gov's green score:
2000 = 1
2005 = 6
I fully expect to see 2007 = 9 with the European clean-diesel technologies. In other words, equal to a Civic Hybrid.
troy
The funny part is the environmental rules actually encourage the growth! How do you think diesel in Euro is getting to be 65% of the vehicle fleet from a low of 33-45%?
(USA, I'm guessing might be 2% in anybodys wildest dreams and or nightmares)
Pretty easy motivator, just keep raising the price of gasoline!
Fully 98% of our economy is run by some sort of diesel! So say you were able to ban diesel use inside of say a major metropoliton area such as Boston, MA or even NYC. You think they have nightmare traffic problems now!!!!
If you are NOT directly - and I mean directly as in features, seat, ride - comparing the Honda Civic Hybrid v. the TDI, the post will be deleted or moved. I just moved posts to the Hybrid v. Diesel discussion.
Comparing TDI v. Civic Hybrid technologies (HYBRID v DIESEL) will get those posts moved as well.
This is a good article on emissions...
http://www.caranddriver.com/article.asp?section_id=4&article_- id=7816&page_number=1
Please post your source for this test, as the post is rediculous.
From the emission link you provided:
"The trouble with diesels in the U.S. is at the tailpipe. They can't pass the emissions regs that go into effect in California this year and phase in across the country over the next four years."
Please post your source for this test, as the post is rediculous.
It is on the first page of the article you just quoted.
The article fails to quote any test conditions...or is this just the writers opinion of hybrid vehicles?
I could write many opinions about vehicles I don't like but doesn't mean a thing without facts.
Actually I was more interested in the specifics of why the diesel emissions are not passing the EPA & CARB standards.
The best example of this is the fact that the majority of long-range tractor-trailers have turbocharged diesel engines just for that reason.
Bottom line:
At high altitudes, any turbocharged engine has a tremendous advantage over any normally aspirated or hybrid vehicle....
"leaving the battery-depleted hybrids well below the tree line gasping along"
Given the lack of any test credentials this strong statement is only an exaggerated opinion.
I can't speak for Prius but I can for HCH...
The electric motor is there to provide optimum MPG, not as a primary motive power source.
It's only 16HP @ a full SOC.
Yes, you will loose speed as the SOC reaches its minimum..but how much will you loose as related to a comparable diesel? 5MPH perhaps?
My point is that it won't be left below the tree line, gasping along...The author forgot to leave out more of his likely opinions: "crippled, broken down and useless"