VW Jetta TDI

1737476787993

Comments

  • andys120andys120 Member Posts: 23,675
    I put 107,000 miles on an '87 9000 Turbo (non-intercoooled) with no issues relating to the (Garret) turbocharger. I was careful to observe the recommended 60 seconds of idle before shutting it off.

    The car had plenty of issues relating to the transaxle and switchgear but none with the engine or turbo.

    2001 BMW 330ci/E46, 2008 BMW 335i conv/E93

  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    My Saab turbo gave up at 156K, but it was noisy for a couple years. However, removing it was very easy and a rebuild was only $350.
  • griff6griff6 Member Posts: 2
    edited February 2010
    I have never looked to the VW line up before for a car, but with the miles my wife puts on a car and her lead foot, I thought why not. I'm wondering if TDI holds up under high mileage? She drives about 3200 a month and is not easy on an engine! Is this the motor and car for her? :confuse:
  • jogousajogousa Member Posts: 402
    If I were you, I would get her a Honda. My wife commutes about 100 miles a day and for that reason, we sold her Saab (9-3 convertible) and she bought a Honda Civic. Generally speaking I think you can rack up more trouble free miles on Honda or Toyota than on any other make.

    Mind you, I don't have a long time experience with VW as I only have my Tdi Jetta Wagon exactly 1 year. But I am sure there are many VW owners out there with more long time experience than me.
  • driverberndriverbern Member Posts: 23
    I've had my 2006.5 TDI for 2 yrs. and 8 months now and it has 115,000 mi on it.
    I've done nothing to it beyond the recommended maintenance. Fuel mileage is saving me considerable money - my monthly average is always over 45 mpg (mostly highway miles). I would not hesitate to buy another one.
  • shriftyshrifty Member Posts: 255
    So far I've put on about 45K miles on my 09 sedan, and it has been running quite well with no issues (except for a fuel relay the day after I purchased the car). My driving consists of 95% or more highway and like your wife, our DNA in our right foot is similar :) and I still get around 44 MPG overall. Unfortunately my car has been garaged since the beginning of the year, and won't be driven until May at the earliest. :(

    On a side note, I am planning a road trip around May/June that will cover a few thousand miles, will there be anything I need to watch for, as my car will have been sitting for a few months without being driven?
  • eliaselias Member Posts: 2,209
    yes VW TDI is fantastic for the highway-mega-miles driver.

    For a few years I drove 5000 neutronium-foot miles monthly and found VW TDI jetta, passat, NewBeetle all optimal for such driving especially during seasons of peak snow, peak glacier, peak arbitrary-atmosphere-gas, peak ADBLUE, peak anything.

    There's no "adblue" required for Jetta "clean diesel" TDI, by the way.

    For me it's been only unclean diesels so far. here in USA diesels remain in a lower automotive caste than gassers even though diesels emit less, burn less and cost less for the Big-Dog Distance-Drivers. (I mean 'dog' in the good way the kids say nowadays - no disrespect meant to your wife sir!)
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    edited February 2010
    If I drove that many miles, I'd be in a TDI without question. If fact, when I drove that much that's what I had. My '00 went 200k miles without many issues and the best part was I drove the snot out of it and still got terrific mpg. My neighbor drives about 45k per year and is on his second. His '06 had the cam melt-down just short of 200k miles because he didn't use the correct oil. Dealer gave him some good-will toward a new one so now he has about 50k on his 2009. Moral of the story: Do the maintenance EXACTLY as VW specifies and you should be good for a very long time.
  • griff6griff6 Member Posts: 2
    So judging by the comments the TDI is good for more than your standard 150K that most non-diesels will get?.?. has there been any changes to the TDI in the last year. I'm not interested in buying the first generation of any motor... Too many bugs need to get worked! :confuse:
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    The motor was newish in 2005 and had some revisions along with a lot of emissions crap in 2009. I've seen a couple of the '05+ models with 200k miles and a lot of the prior gens with 300k+. I wouldnt' be worried about the motor and manual transmission much at all for long term use. Some of the electronics and other stuff might be another story. I personally wouldn't buy the DSG if I was planning to keep it long-term. It's a great tranny but requires expensive maintenance every 40k miles and will cost a fortune to repair/replace.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    gas engines will average out around 150-175K and diesel car engines around 225K before they exhibit serious wear or require serious overhaul. Some go more, some go less, but if I were buying, that's where I'd place my bets.

    Commercial big rig engines, busses, etc. can double that.
  • longo2longo2 Member Posts: 347
    Sent off a question to these guys about the VW turbo's and if a Garrett was available ...here's the reply..

    No, they don't, at least not in this market. The Borg-Warner/KKK OE
    replacement turbo seems to be the only plug-and-play new replacement.
    We have those, and are investigating larger turbos but haven't found
    any yet.

    Thanks for asking,

    Peter
    IDParts
    781-333-8343
  • eliaselias Member Posts: 2,209
    edited February 2010
    no, unless it's parked outside and you want to watch out for wildlife living in the wheelwells.

    your 09 sedan mpg is an exact match for my 06 TDI 5-spd mpg. Somehow i've been getting 45+ this winter with mine, apparently because I bet right and went with new 'mastercraft' all-seasons instead of putting on the winter-wheels&blizzaks.

    ok, here's something to watch out for:
    for long TDI drives be kind to your behind and requisite biological systems. rule #32: "enjoy the little things".
    take many bio-breaks inbetween fuel stops.
    just because some TDIs can drive 1000 miles on one tank doesn't mean you HAVE to do 1000 miles without stopping for a break !
  • biomassbiomass Member Posts: 7
    Curious to know if anybody else is having hesitation problem with their VW Jetta. I just got mine a few months ago and have what I consider a very serious hesitation problem. This is a major safety concern that to me is greater than any Toyota gas pedal problem. At least you can throw the car in neutral. What do you do when you are pulling out into traffic and you give it gas (diesel) and the car hesitates with no warning? I had my car back to the dealer once so far and they did not fix the problem. Its happened numerous times in a variety of different situations - none of which were safe. Warm or cold I've had the problem and I live in central Florida. Please help
  • gagricegagrice Member Posts: 31,450
    What brand of diesel do you use? Have you replaced your fuel filter? How many miles on the car? My Passat TDI had a slight hesitation that I soon got used to and took into account when taking off from a stop.
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    Using google search type

    09' shudder problem

    you should obtain results directing you to a TDI specific site. Start reading and good luck.
  • longo2longo2 Member Posts: 347
    edited February 2010
    I have a 2006 Jetta TDI and for a while thought I had a similar issue with it hesitating in slow traffic, just when you wanted to accelerate. For what it's worth here's what I found.
    When slowing down at an intersection the DSG shifts down to 2nd gear and holds it there unless you almost come to a complete stop..then it shifts into 'first' and you are now ready to scoot away with no problem. However if you are rolling slowly and goose it in 2nd, it can't quite get going immediately in that gear and you get that OMG it's going to stall feeling.
    This could be miles off your problem, but I solved mine by making sure the shift indicator is in '1' (first gear) when I take off, it quickly shifts to '2' without any hesitation or feeling like it's going to stall, or 'lag'.
    I find my DSG set up great now that I give it a chance to shift down into 'first' before I take off from a stop, or very slow roll. :)
  • eliaselias Member Posts: 2,209
    this DSG behavior has been mentioned on freds forum and in auto-rag reviews. I thnk the C&D reviewer said he would *trade in* the car due to the DSG behavior.
    Seems like Long-O has explained it's because the DSG has selected 2nd gear in that situation.
    Is there a sport/economy button - Maybe that would affect it's "fuel-conserving hold-2nd-as-long-as-possible" behavior which has got to increasing turbo-lag if you need to accelerate suddenly - in addition to the delay for the software to decide to shift to 1st.

    (DSG in NewBeetle TDI was the best "automanual" I've driven- but also as annoying to me as any automatic other than an old-school slushbox.)
  • mike91326mike91326 Member Posts: 251
    Do you have the DSG and if so are you a two foot driver? That is, do you use your left foot for the brake and right foot for the gas? I thought I had the same problem until I learned that when you step on the brake the clutch is disengaged and no power goes to the wheels. First time it happened to me it scared the crap out of me because I was in heavy traffic and it felt like I had lost all power.
  • longo2longo2 Member Posts: 347
    Off track a bit here, but this is my question...

    I have had 5 different quotes on my next DSG service (from $275 to $595) and two of the VW dealerships said this,,,you need to leave it with us overnight for the transmission to cool off or we can't do the oil change.

    Three of the VW dealerships said "Bring it in, it takes about 2 hours"

    When asked about the 'cooling off part' 3 of them said.... What?

    Can anyone shed some light in this dark corner? :confuse:
  • moparbadmoparbad Member Posts: 3,870
    It is preferred that the engine is still hot, not cold.

    Using google search,

    DIY: DSG Transmission scheduled maintenance (40K miles interval)

    Search for the above, follow the link and you may research and shed some light on the dark corner mystery of DSG service procedure.

    Expected cost is $300 to $500 with $330 to $400 the range of reasonable.
  • biomassbiomass Member Posts: 7
    Thanks for the follow-up. No I do not have anyway to change the transmission from sport to economy. I am concerned about my wife driving this car now.
  • depadderdepadder Member Posts: 1
    It is the strangest thing, but my 4 month old Jetta TDI has a very strong antifreeze smell when driving and when in the garage. There are no leaks, it is not burning hot at all and the temp is right where it is supposed to be. The dealer found no leaks and has no explanation for the smell. Has this happened to anybody and did you find a fix? Thanks
  • shriftyshrifty Member Posts: 255
    I believe my car is currently garaged, and should be until the middle of May.

    Thanks for the advice, but I was referring to the mechanics of the vehicle :)

    I plan on heading up to Labrador City, then over to St. John's, haven't been up to Newfoundland/Labrador yet and will have enough time off to visit. I'm heading up to the Trans-Labrador Highway (scenic I'm sure, definitely stopping along the way), is anyone familiar with the availability of diesel in this area? I think I can "only" get around 600-650 miles to a tank, so I'll be stopping way before 1000.
  • bpeeblesbpeebles Member Posts: 4,085
    edited February 2010
    You only get about 600-650 miles per tank??? (approx 14 gallon tank)

    If we assume you you likely refuel BEFORE the tank is totally empty... (lets say at 12 gallons) 650/12 =54.1 MPG that is not too shabby for overall MPG but is low for highway trip MPG.

    If my TDI gets less than 700 per tank, there is a serious problem. On a highway trip, I expect more like 800+ miles per tank.

    I wonder if you are forgetting to add your cetane enhancer with every fillup?
    ..or perhaps you do not have a manual xmission?
  • 204meca204meca Member Posts: 369
    Interesting wind up article in latest Car & Driver after 39,000 on their Jetta TDI. They stated that it was the 3rd most fuel efficient car they had ever had for a long term test. Their opinions were mixed and they got 38 mpg overall did which they said were only bettered by 2 long termers: 2000 Insight (48 mpg over 40K miles) and 1992 Honda Civic VX (41 mpg over 35K miles).

    That VX was an quite a car - 1 mag got 56 mpg on freeway test. Cost about $3,200 new. Of course it only had 1 air bag, wind up windows & no power steering Amazing how things change.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Yeah most mags are reporting 38-44 mpg on a longterm basis in normal city/hwy mixed driving, with no attempts at hypermiling.

    That's pretty darn good for a modern car with all the amenities. A Prius would do no better and would be about 1/9th the fun.
  • shriftyshrifty Member Posts: 255
    The tank is about 14 gallon, and that range is about correct for a tank running around 75+- on the highway. Roughly 44 MPG. I do not use any additives and have the DSG. If I were to use cetane during each fillup, how much better could I expect on MPG? Also, would this be cost effective?
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    edited February 2010
    I doubt it's cost effective in terms of gas mileage savings vs. cost of the additive, but when I had my diesels I always used an additive of some sort. My two cents is that the secret to a happy life with a diesel includes additives, good quality fuel, and frequent filter changes.

    I used to use REDLINE

    At $7 bucks a pop, you are adding .50 a gallon to a 14 gallon fillup cost, if you dump the whole thing in there.

    So to break even that cetane booster would have to improve your mileage from 44 mpg to 51.5 mpg.

    Not likely.
  • bpeeblesbpeebles Member Posts: 4,085
    edited February 2010
    Anyone who is driving a diesel to get MPG should be using additive at every fillup. Do not forget that diesel-fuel additives are NOT like gasoline additives which have doubious results. Instead, diesel-fuel additives improve the fuel-quality to near European levels... our TDI engines are DESIGNED for European fuel.

    Diesel fuel available in North America is intended for use in TRUCKS and really needs to be improved to satisfy a finely-tuned modern TDI engine which wants to feed on European diesel fuel.

    A quality diesel additive proides several benifets
    1) CETANE INCREASE
    Modern TDI engines are designed to run on fuel that is not available in North America. Increasing CETANE approptately can and will provide better MPG and less engine-noise.

    2) LUBRICANT
    Protecting your expensive fuel-pump is great insurance against $1000+ bill if it wears. Technically, this is known as "lubricity". Bosch specifies 400 micron wear scar MAXIMUM using HFRR test. The lower the number is better. There are not many diesel-fuels available in North America which meet this spec.

    3) ANTI_GEL
    In the winter, using diesel-additive which has anti-gel can prevent engine-stalling out due to fuel-starvation.

    Personally, I use Power Service products. (White bottle in winter and Grey bottle in summer) Available at WallyMart.
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    edited February 2010
    And to add....the cost of more common additives like PowerService is minimal. Less than $1 per fill IIRC.
  • eliaselias Member Posts: 2,209
    you are most welcome, biomass. i Is it possible that it is merely turbo-lag that your wife reports as 'hesitation'? (I suppose turbo-lag can be worse with a car that has automatic transmission.)

    For me any safety-risk behavior like that from any car is a dealbreaker/showstopper, exactly along the lines of the recent toyota failures. Dealership would get a very low # of tries to fix a safety before I traded or lemon-lawed the car, whatever it took to get out of it.

    can your wife drive a stickshift? it can be fun and rewarding to learn if the teacher is kind about it.
    (also after she learns, she may drive circles around you. )

    personally I don't vouch for any automatic transmission except for the good old slushbox.
  • dieselfitter1dieselfitter1 Member Posts: 42
    Elias; I think it is the DSG that is causing the hesitation. There is going to be a bit of turbo lag,but it is not noticeable, and it is not a safety problem. It looks like the same problem as I had with my 09 dsg jetta. They reflashed the DSG, but it still occasionally hesitates in some situations. eg Coasting up to a yield sign,then hitting the throttle. It is like the DSG 'does not know what gear to be in' or it is trying to 'think what to do next'
  • jogousajogousa Member Posts: 402
    And that "hesitation" also occurs (to me) if you have a manual tranny. So it's not just "DSG" problem...it's an overall turbo lag problem no matter what transmiision you have...
  • dieselfitter1dieselfitter1 Member Posts: 42
    OK ,so then you might have a Turbo Problem. All I know is that it takes a short while for a Turbo to Spool Up. I still think it's the DSG Tranny.

    Also , after the DSG 'Reflash' my problem for the most part went away, but still does it occasionally.
  • blundyblundy Member Posts: 15
    Got a problem with 2002 Jetta TDI security system. My patient spouse drove to a nearby town, turned off the ignition and loaded with fuel, tried to restart and in turned over like it should but, it would only chug once and then shut down. Typical security system symptom when it turns off the fuel pump. She had to retrieve another key that was made for it two years ago. She returned to the car, inserted that key and it started. She then drove to another location and the new key would not start it. Same symptom. Waited several moments with the key in the ignition and turned to ON position and it started again. Last couple of attempts, hours later, resulted in good start condition, now with either key. Anyone have a similar experience and if so, what causes it and what cures it? Thanks.
  • rremer1rremer1 Member Posts: 7
    I've been offered by VW dealer the following on a 2010 Sportswagen TDI, white exterior with tan interior, no major options (I didn't want any except heated seats):
    He'll give me $10k for my 04 Audi A6 Wagon, apply $2k of that to the lease and do 36 months for $355/month. All service included. The price he based this on was $25,350 for the car. What do you all think? Should I go for it? I've never done a lease before, so I'm a little unsure if this is a good deal or not!
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    Okay, first off you need to know:

    1. What is the mileage restriction on this lease, and if you go over, how much per mile penalty?

    2. So you're getting $8K cash in your pocket and $2K toward the lease? If so, that's upfront money, so really your lease is not $355 a month, it's $355 +$55 ($2000 divided by 36 months), so $410 a month is what you're paying.

    3. Did you negotiate the MSRP? Lease cars can be negotiated just like you were buying it.

    4. What is the "money factor" on this lease (the interest rate expressed in the Martian language so as to confuse you).

    If you can't answer these question for us, DON'T sign anything just yet.
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    edited March 2010
    Agree with Mr.Shiftright and IMHO this seems too expensive for three reasons:

    1) $25,350 is about $600 more than MSRP on a base which includes heated seats. I'm guessing this one has the protection package which is fine, but it looks like you're paying MSRP. You should be able to get at LEAST $500 off the sticker on these anywhere and I've seen some folks pay much closer to invoice by shopping around. There is a dealer near you in Langhorne, PA that will sell them at invoice which is $23,400 on a base. So there's your spread...about $2,000. Ask for Chris.

    2) No mention made of the $1,300 Alternative Motor Vehicle Credit. This will go into the leasing company's pocket and should be kicked back to you in a reduction of purchase price. If they're already kicking that back in your deal, something else is too high.

    3) Residual value on a diesel should be fairly significant. The numbers you're bouncing around tell me the residual is about the same as any other VW which is too low for a used TDI.

    If you bought this outright at the dealer mentioned above...figure $23,500 plus tax say $25,000 out the door. Payment with nothing down, and a lousy interest rate for 60 months would be $495. At 36 months you owe $11,000 which is far less than what this will be worth so no problem trading out/selling at that time and be well ahead. Plus when you file your 2010 taxes you'll get a $1,300 tax credit for buying the car.
  • british_roverbritish_rover Member Posts: 8,502
    VW doesn't put residuals on the TDIs that are anywhere near where they should be for the car.

    The leasing programs on the TDI are just frankly stupid. We have a VW dealership and people come in wanting to lease the TDIs every once in a while and usually they can convince them to just buy it as the leases are stupid. Every once in a while you get people that just have to lease because they don't like buying cars and they freak out about the lease payments on the car. The dealership has no control over the residual that is set by VW or the bank and on the TDI's will always be low.

    Just like you said better to buy it on a 60 month term.
  • fho2008fho2008 Member Posts: 393
    Never sign a lease.
  • rremer1rremer1 Member Posts: 7
    Thanks so much for the advice. I believe I'm just going to pay for it in cash, after my trade. That way I'll get the tax credit. Once I learned the residual I realized it really didn't make much sense. I appreciate the info from you guys!
  • longo2longo2 Member Posts: 347
    What have you discovered is the best amount of the "Grey Bottle" to add to a Jetta TDI fill up for increased mpgs?
  • bpeeblesbpeebles Member Posts: 4,085
    I estimate how much to put into the tank based on;

    *) The instructions on the Power Service bottle.
    *) Gauging how many gallons I will be pumping into the tank.

    I keep a log of every drop of fuel ever pumped into my vehicles. My average fillup is about 12.67 gallons.

    I keep a supply of 8oz paper cups in my trunk with the Power Service. I know that a full 14 gallons would need about 6oz of Power Service. I approxamate how much Power Service I will need and use the paper cup as a disposable measuring-device. Then I fill the tank with Diesel fule and make sure to use the burping button to fill it up till I see the fuel near the rim of the filler-neck.

    Does this answer your question?
  • british_roverbritish_rover Member Posts: 8,502
    I wouldn't say that. Sometimes a lease is the best deal on a new car you just have to look at all the avaliable options and incentives.

    For example last year around this time Volvo had extra incentives if you leased certain cars that you only got if you leased them.

    The Volvo S80 V8 AWD had a 4,000 dollar cash incentive for a purchase or finance but if you leased you got the 4,000 dollars and an extra 10,000 dollars on top.

    You could lease a S80 V8 AWD with thousands of dollars in more standard equipment for the same lease payment as a S80 T6 AWD.

    The buy out at the end of the 36 month residual was about the same as what you would owe at the 36 month mark of a 60 month finance if you put down a few thousand dollars. Plus you could star the 36 month lease with about $1,500 out of pocket. At the time there was no way to do a regular finance contract with that little out of pocket.
  • longo2longo2 Member Posts: 347
    I guess what I was hoping for was your experience in testing the 'what it says on the bottle' transposed into a real world ratio of additive/gallons number.

    You say you generally put in less than 13 gallons and the specs are 6 OZ for 14 gallons, so does it make any real difference to your mpgs if you use 6 oz, 5 oz or 4 oz for your 12.67 gallons?

    And inquiring minds want to know from your extensive record keeping just how much increased mpg's this Cetane additive might translate into on your TDI.

    I read a post from someone who asked various oil companies what their Cetane rating was at the pumps and it varied from 50 down to 40 depending on the brand.

    What do you think the optimum Cetane rating for our TDIs should be?
  • fho2008fho2008 Member Posts: 393
    Leases are huge money makers for the dealers, a huge loss for the buyer. And it takes away your ability to make a deal if you trade in because you have to go back to the dealer you bought it from. Too many miles? $$ for the dealer and so on.

    Buying, even if you are still making payments you have the option of trading it in wherever you want.
  • jogousajogousa Member Posts: 402
    edited March 2010
    Leases make sense for certain people. Other than tax deduction advantage for businesses, the common sense and rule is that, if you lease, you can get a car that you could not otherwise afford because basically you are "financing" (lease payments) only appx. half of the value of the car (depending on "open" or "close" lease).
    Additionally, if you want to get a brand new car each 2, 3 or 4 years, the lease makes sense. Also, if you buy a car, your money is tight up in the value of the car. That money, if properly invested, could bring you some return.
    Car buying (owning) is one the worst investments (other than kids, to be sarcastic) - there is limited or no return on your investment.
    Consumer Reports summed it up nicely along the above statements not long ago...
    It's much easier to write off car lease payments, if you own a business, than figure out complicated schedule of depreciation, if you own a car.
    When I had my own business, I always leased cars... nowadays, I always buy cars (I don't have a business anymore).
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    edited March 2010
    You're a bit confused on leases. Unless a particular dealer is the lessor, not much of what you've stated is correct. Leases are generally written by a few large banks or the manufacturer's captive finance company. You can generally trade in a lease anywhere because that dealer simply buys the vehicle (for the stated residual plus remaining payments or however it's worded in that contract) from the lessor. When you need to turn in the lease, that would either be done at one of the captive financing companies dealerships or if a big bank, somewhere they've designated.

    I would agree that in general, leases are more expensive than buying and I rarely recommend them to my clients (i'm a cpa). They also can be more confusing and as proven here many folks don't understand them and could be more likely to get overcharged. There are times when the captive finance companies and manufacturer's are offering incentives that make leasing less costly. It's getting less and less common though.

    A high dollar vehicle for someone that can deduct the lease payment for business purposes, usually will work out as an ok deal if they invest the cash or payment difference. Some of the incentive deals work out to be as good or similar to conventional financing.

    Your best bet is to only buy what you can afford to pay with cash and this all becomes a non-issue. But somehow everyone thinks they need to buy more car than they can afford which is truly the case with the vast majority of lease deals.
  • sebring95sebring95 Member Posts: 3,241
    because basically you are "financing" (lease payments) only appx. half of the value of the car (depending on "open" or "close" lease).

    That's not quite accurate either. You're still financing the entire amount of the car but only making payments based on the residual. Assuming the same money factor/apr between leases/conventional financing....you'd pay the same interest over the same time period. Problem is, most leases have a much higher interest rate than a conventional loan partly because there is a lot more risk on the part of the bank. They are basically stuck with that residual amount and chances are quite high they will get the vehicle back so there's a potential loss. Conventional financing they only have to worry about residual/wholesale on a default.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Your Privacy

By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our Visitor Agreement.