By accessing this website, you acknowledge that Edmunds and its third party business partners may use cookies, pixels, and similar technologies to collect information about you and your interactions with the website as described in our
Privacy Statement, and you agree that your use of the website is subject to our
Visitor Agreement.
Comments
These are considered "crossover" vehicles that are more car like than SUV's, but don't carry the stigma of the "mommy-mobile" minivan.
My wife absolutely refused to drive a minivan. We owned two 3-row SUV's (Ford Expedition and Ford Explorer) which were perfect for getting our kids through their teenage years - plus, here in Colorado, the 4WD was great for the winter months.
Now that our kids have their own licenses, my wife drives a smaller SUV - a Saturn VUE.
The great thing is that there are so many choices in the market now, with so many niche vehicles available, that it's pretty much impossible to not get what you want. You need to ask yourself the following:
1) how much am I willing to pay? factor insurance into this, as well
2) do I want a new car or will I be OK with a late model used car?
3) how often do I tote all 3 kids around?
4)how often do they bring friends with them?
5) do I take long road trips or mostly around town errand running?
6) is mileage important? You stated that you live in SoCal, where gas is more expensive than most other places in the US.
7) do you prefer the ride and handling of a car, or are you more comforatable with the "high-upedness" (wife's term; don't ask) of an SUV?
Let us know the answers to these questions, then we can start throwing out more specific suggestions.
One thing I can assure you is that the regulars in these forums just love to spend other people's money! but, we also strive to make sure that you are getting what you want.
Good luck!
In April 2001, I asked my wife what kind of new car she wanted, offering anything she desired. I was certain that she wouldn't nick me for a Benz or BMW as she has always been a "keeper." She answered, "Another van." Practicality at its best. I queried further, "Are you sure? You've had a van for almost 12 years. Don't you want a "regular" car?" "To me, a van is a "regular" car. I like the extra passenger and cargo-carrying space."
So, I sprung the cash for the "top" minivan back then, a 2001 Odyssey EX. We're at 68K now and I'm looking at another vehicle. Either a new Pilot or Odyssey, while KEEPING the '01 Ody (we'll have everyone in the house licensed soon). We have endured the "soccer mom" image and found the minivan great for scouting activities (I was even a "cubmaster" at one time).
She just decided that the extra room for stuff and people was needed, and it drove nicer than the SUVs. Plus it was cheaper to buy, and had better MPG ratings.
It does drive nice, but I find it too big for normal use. Great fro travelling though.
When this one is ready for replacement (assuming it is reliable to get 10 years out of it), one kid will be out of college, and the other will be in college. At that point, I'm sure we will move to something smaller.
Wife does also like the higher seating position (getting in and the view of the road), so a small X-over is a likely choice. Or something like the Mazda 5.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
Stickguy, while we are among those who chose the practicality of the minivan over the SUV, others like my brother-in-law did not. They also had an MPV followed by a Quest, but these were purchased after toying with the idea of getting an SUV. He also had access to an Odyssey at work. They finally traded the Quest for an '01 Acura MDX. My sister drives an '04 TL.
Six months ago, he seriously thought of trading out of the MDX, partly because of the gas prices around here ($2.50+/gallon for premium), but the trade value offered was on the low end. So, no deal.
"If" you decide to go towards an SUV .. take a look at Buick Rendezvous, probably an 03 CXL AWD with all the stuff and miles in the 10/15k range, leather, 3rd seat, cold pack, slider, all the junk ... I have a funny feelin' you can pick one up for $20,000 or less ..... lotta bang for the buck .....
Terry.
when one of my kids was 10, i had them try out the 3rd row in a highlander. all i got was darts from that. we already had the explorer, at that point, so they knew better.
if you don't need 4wd, forget the explorer. gas mileage on the sticker is in the ballpark.
One of our journalists is writing an article about women and trucks: why they love their trucks, the decisions that they have to make when purchasing a truck versus a car, and whether or not they’ve encountered discrimination or bias when buying or driving a truck. If you’d like to share your story, please respond to jhelperin@edmunds by Sunday, March 26th. Thanks!
That said, though, regardless of our features of interest when buying a car, we're still not given any credit in the car dealership. A guy can choose a car strictly for its horsepower, and yet know nothing about what the specs really mean (except that higher numbers are better), yet still have an easier time getting a good deal out of a car salesman.
Now here is my problem: I'm about to graduate from grad school, will be starting a decently-paying job in the spring or summer, and thus will be in the market at last to buy my first car. I'm 23 - but often get perceived as younger, since I'm shy and not naturally assertive; I don't have a boyfriend to bring with me; and even if I bring my parents, they're horrible at negotiating (they bought their last car by getting prices from 3 dealers and then paying the price requested by the dealer who offered the lowest price -- no negotiation on their part, simply a dealer who could give a higher figure for their trade-in).
While 23 isn't all that young, I don't know anyone my age who has bought a car with their own money - they've all had cars bought for them by parents, or else their parents did the negotiating for them. Also, since I'm thinking of buying a new car, it might also be a bigger deal than if I were looking to buy used, which is what most younger people do.
So, the question is this: if I go to look for cars, should I go in by myself? Should I bring my parents? (or does this make me look even younger? even though I'll be the one paying - aside from them possibly cosigning on a loan if I can't get the best financing rate).. Do I need to plan hard for a "strategy" to bring into the dealership? On the one hand, I think I need to convince them (through my dress, demeanour, etc) that I am not just a kid but am actually looking to purchase a car; on the other hand, I don't want to try too hard to prove I can afford it - without them gouging me on the price once they realize they can.
Any advice? Should I emphasize certain things, or bring certain people with me? Will dealers trust me to take test-drives??
Would it be smarter to try negotiating/building a buying relationship through email first, so that a dealer can't prejudge me by my age, and thus I might have a better chance of getting a fair deal? Would it be useful to pay to get the dealer price for the car, so that I have a stronger bargaining chip? (I'm Canadian, so I can't get the price on Edmunds)...
Then you will be more inclined to keep it for a long time, so you can get it paid off and save enough money to buy your next car without getting a loan.
http://www.edmunds.com/advice/specialreports/articles/105204/article.html
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Find me at kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
2015 Kia Soul, 2021 Subaru Forester (kirstie_h), 2024 GMC Sierra 1500 (mr. kirstie_h)
Review your vehicle
Not sure if that's really what your point was, but one course in economics has sort of undone the hoity toity mentality my mom passed down to me about saving up to buy things rather than buying on credit. $1 today is not $1 tomorrow whether you finance it today or save it for tomorrow.
I obviously need something that will last a while, preferably with good gas milage. Ideally, I'm looking for something kind of sporty-looking thats fun to drive and won't look run-of-the-mill or super dated in 5+ years. I am currently thinking of:
1) VW Jetta
-This one is my favorite. Is the 2001 worth getting over a 2002? There is a big price difference.
2) Honda Civic
3) Toyota Corolla
4) Saturn Ion
5) Open for suggestions!
Thanks!
Used CIvics are still likely to be pricey, but take a look. Good cars. Same for Corollas, but not as much fun. You just pay a premium price.
Ions? Yuck (my opinion).
Add to your list the Mazda Protege or Pro5. Great cars (IMO the Japanese Jetta), but don't cost as much used as a Civic or Corolla.
ALso don't forget that a Geo/Checy Prism is the same car as a Corolla, but normally costs less.
2020 Acura RDX tech SH-AWD, 2023 Maverick hybrid Lariat luxury package.
Don't buy a VW unless you love frustration. No reliability.
'24 Chevy Blazer EV 2LT
Because they're not as popular as Civics, you can get them for considerably less money on the used car market. Lot of bang for the buck.
I havn't even done any test-driving and this is already so draining. There is so much out there. I'm so tempted to just say "screw it" and get a '00 Mustang! Ha, but I'm not so sure that is what you would necessarily call a wise investment, as much as I love them!
I think out of everything so far, the hardest choice in budget car shopping is choosing either to go for a late model and get an "affordable" make (i.e. newer Ford Focus) or sacrifice a few years for something a little flashier ( '00 Audi A4 for $10K)
Oh yeah, and technically I am looking for an automatic. Personally, I am a fast learner and wouldn't mind to learn to drive a stick, but I have a hard time seeing my mom try to remember how her manual transmission works. She doesn't do so well with things that don't just work when you push a button.
The second thing is to research the price. Edmunds has a DG for that.
Then learn what options the dealer may sell (gap insurance, mop n' glow, choke n' croak, rust n' dust) and decide if you want them.
If you are not good at numbers or have problems keeping up with fast talkers, take someone else with you and ask questions of your salesperson. If they don't give straight answers - WALK. DO NOT SIGN ANYTHING THAT YOU DO NOT UNDERSTAND OR LOOKS DIFFERENT ON PAPER THAN WHAT YOU UNDERSTOOD WHEN DISCUSSING IT.
My most important piece of advice is: Remember, when you think you've found the perfect car, it's not the only one out there. Don't let your want for a car put you in a bad money deal. If you can afford the time, get the numbers from your salesperson and take them home to look at them. Plug them into programs on the internet to see what kind of payments you come up with. Know what a 1 or 2% increase or decrease in the interest rate means for your payment. You can not have too much information.
I am a woman and have been buying my cars independently for the past 7 years. I've learned some hard lessons, but good lessons. Car-buying doesn't have to involve torture and misery and you should walk away from any place that makes you uncomfortable.
I'm going blind over here .....................................
Terry.
A lot of info here...If you do bring a friend along as a "first baseman" please make sure that person isn't a jerk. I've had first basemen literally cause the loss of a sale as they have dispensed their "expert" advise.
When my customer returned sans the jerk friend, she discovered, sadly, that the used car of her dreams had bben sold to someone else.
And, please,,,don't try to outsmart us with the "appointment" story. We've heard that one many times.
It really doesn't have to be hard.
If you ever find yourself at a dealership at 23:00 and you don't work there, you're doing it wrong. Buying a car is not difficult, it really isn't.
This next comment isn't directed at you, but is a general observation: People will forever concentrate on getting the best price, rather than taking the time to really figure out what will work best for them.
I'll pay fair market value on a 2003 Taurus before I pay "trade-in value" on a 2003 Neon.
I'll buy a new Civic before I buy a 3-year-old one for $2,500 less.
-Mathias
What Are Automakers Doing for Women?
Part I: GM
Part II: Toyota
Part III: Volvo
Its sad but true - I've been car shopping for a few weeks, and my husband wants to be left out of it. Whatever I pick is fine with him. So, I went to several dealers to see the cars by myself or with my daughter, to check out the cars on my short list. Treated nicely, but not seriously.
However, when I took my 5 year old son (not a man yet, but still a male), many of the dealers were very attentive - but to my son, not me! At Honda, Toyota, Lexus, and Dodge, we got the same reaction. They walked up and shook his hand and started showing him all the features that he would get - cup holders, distance from his sister in the back seat, how easy it was to work the windows, and get into the third row seats.
To give them the benefit of the doubt, they could simply have thought they were being cute, or that I was bringing him along to see if he liked it. :confuse:
I'm not making excuses for your dealer and they should be selling you the car not the child but I understand where they are coming from.
Yeah, but most women can't. I'd say not 1 woman in 20 "knows about engines" or cares to. My wife certainly doesn't, but she knows enough to rely on me for that.
As far as "fair price", most men can't do that either. And it's getting so most men can't even drive a stick shift... the days of technical knowledge being taken for granted by males are over.
" AND sign the contract. ALL WITHOUT A MAN AT MY SIDE".
I think that the problem may be that the salesman knows with only one spouse present, he's got another person to sell. Male or female. However, bring along the 5-year-old, now there's a good chance it's a single mom he's talking to, in which case he just needs to sell the people he's got in front of him.
I think it's not so different when a guy comes in alone to pick out a minivan... a good salesperson knows he better not fill in the color until the guy comes back with the wife...
Not every situation fits within the stereotypes of "women can't get respect at car dealerships". Though I'm sure that happens a lot, too.
-Mathias
I agree, most men and women are pretty much clueless when it comes to cars, but I make myself fairly clear when I'm on the lot or on the phone with a salesperson. I know what I want, I know what I want to pay and I know that i'm good for that deal if I can get it. Most salespeople still can't adjust and sell to ME.
PS I can even drive a stick and currently own one!!
Well, if you know what you want to pay, then I suggest you skip the sales person. Just walk up to the sales manager and make your offer, preferably written. That's what we did when we bought our lovely Acura RSX.
Why do you need the sales person to 'adjust' to you? Do you ask the same thing of the cashier at McDonalds when you get a cheeseburger?
I personally think it's a little arogant to pass up the salespeople and go straight to the sales manager. The salespeople are out there working to earn a living and some of them are very good at what they do. My last salesman was great and I was more than happy to know that he got a commission off my deal - he deserved it.
Since you know exactly what you want and how much you are willing to pay, what so you need a sales person for?
In many dealerships, the sales manager will assign the deal to a reliable sales rep to handle the paperwork and delivery. The sales manager has many other duties to perform.
I do realize that the sales manager will hand off my deal to a salesperson, but if someone is gonna get a chunk of my money as a commission, I will pick that person myself.
MODERATOR /ADMINISTRATOR
Find me at kirstie_h@edmunds.com - or send a private message by clicking on my name.
2015 Kia Soul, 2021 Subaru Forester (kirstie_h), 2024 GMC Sierra 1500 (mr. kirstie_h)
Review your vehicle
Since I was busted, I went with it and asked a few questions. He pulls this rolled up piece of paper out of his back pocket and starts reading off the prices. I thought that was a bit odd. I then agreed to go inside with him and listen to what the specials were and everything. After we sat down and he was giving me quotes, that's when I noticed it. His wedding band was on the wrong hand. There was still a mark on his finger where it should've been. lol. He couldn't have taken it off too long before he approached me.
I guess I was supposed to buy a car from him because he looked single. :confuse:
He was a nice guy, but like most men, just can't take a hint or NO for an answer. I had no intentions of buying a car that day, I told him that from the beginning and said I didn't want to waste his time. But he kept insisting and insisting, probably because there was a storm so he knew he wasn't getting any other potential customers anyway. Everytime he knew I was trying to leave, he'd start a whole new subject. What was supposed to be a 10 minute stop lasted for about 2hours.
The quotes he gave me were pretty average from my research. But I wonder if one of the reasons he was afraid of me leaving was because he knew I could probably get something cheaper at the other place. Hmm. I think his ego was mostly hurt. But I do give the guy credit for not resorting to flirting.
Here is a thought. You visit the car dealer to get information, not to give information to the dealer. Therefore, you do not have to respond to any of their questions. If they ask you a question, ignore it.
If they don't like you behavior (as has happened to me), they will leave you alone.
Don't let them control your actions either. If they ask you to follow them, refuse to do it.
If they start talking and you are not interested in what they have to say, then ignore them. It is OK to walk away when they are talking to you.
Remember, they want your money much more than you want their car, so you are in control of the car shopping experience.
I guess I was supposed to buy a car from him because he looked single. "
I do this all the time. I have skinny, bony fingers, and the ring digs into my pinkie. So I shift it between the left and right hand. And I don't even sell cars...
Not everything that goes on at a car dealership is sinister. Sometimes it's just strange.
-Mathias
(i) I had a suspicion that any topic that included gender in the title was going to be trouble.
(ii) Why are we "egotistical"? We're here sharing, same as you. And while we don't know what it's like, we can try -- as I did -- to come up with an explanation why some salespeople react to women the way they do.
We all stereotype to some extent, some of us are just smarter or more subtle about it...
Some people, I'm sure, live every day as if it was their first. But that'd get old...
-Mathias
Other duties? Like what - trying to figure out ways to milk another thousand from customers? :P