Honda Civic Hybrid MPG-Real World Numbers

Karen_S

Please post your acutal MPG here.

"Real World" Fuel Economy vs. EPA Estimates

markdel

On my first tank of gas the overall mileage was 38, on the second tank (about 470 miles on odometer), my mileage went up to 39, now I am on my 5th tank and my odometer is at about 1500 miles and my mileage is about 42.

My driving is 60 highway/40 town and includes two tall ridge lines to cross each way.

I figure at this rate by the time the engine is loosened up my mileage should be somewhere about 46.

I do note that on the straight flat sections my indicated MPG hovers around the 50 to 55 MPG bar.

mauto

Engine "loosened up"? Maybe that was true back in the 70s/80s, but not today. If you could do a lab test on a Civic by holding all the other variables constant, such as temperature, traffic conditions, wind conditions, fuel pump cut-off variations when refueling, etc., you would probably find that a "loose" engine would contribute a few tenths of an MPG to your fuel economy.

misterme

Winter 2004: 55-60MPG
Last summer: 58-65
Last winter: 58-62
Last couple of months 62-65MPG

41K miles driven and 17months have been consistent.
Drive from rural N. Georgia into the City of Atlanta and back for work, ~96miles round trip. Extremely hilly as it is the foothills of the foothills of the Blue Ridge Mountains.
I'm currently trying to set my miles per tank record: On this single trip I've driven over 550 miles and have one bar of fuel above the half way mark still lit.
Never had so much fun saving so much fuel (and $)

cablack

The empirical evidence from this and other forums is that after about 5000 miles or so, most folks get better mileage than they did when they first bought the car. This could be a result of:

- learning how to drive more efficiently
- different seasons (spring vs. winter)
- differences in the automobile itself, i.e. the aforementioned "loosening up"

I'm sure that the first two items can contribute to the increase in MPG. I'm not sure that anybody knows for certain what the effect of the third item is, but the good news is that mileage does indeed seem to improve for most folks after the first few thousand miles.

cablack

2005 HCH CVT, currently with 10,000 miles

Winter:
- City, 6 mile commute, 44-46 MPG
- Highway, 50-52 MPG

Spring:
- City, 6 mile commute, 46-48 MPG
- Highway, 50-52 MPG

Driving style: pretty low-key, and I tend to stay close to the speed limits now.

fireking

I'm so sick and tired of various reviews badmouthing hybrids and how the published EPA numbers aren't applicable in the real world. The problem is the drivers/reviewers who have never owned a hybrid and have no idea how to drive one. I used to have an Insight and routinely got 65+ MPG only after I drove it for a few months. And although my Civic hybrid 5 speed can't match what the Insight achieved, my average of 54 MPG (about 50/50 hwy/city) is very nice. I'm glad to see people here that know how to drive a hybrid and realize it's not so much what you drive, but how you drive it.

Brian
Everett, WA

misterme

Yes, I know what you mean.
My tank came out to 886 miles and I put in 13 point something gallons which came out over 66MPG. The last fuel bar had just gone out.
It was a little better than expected.

markdel

Gee, I've tried all the suggestions and now I have to syphon out two to three gallons each day or my fuel tank will leak out on the highway as I drive... NOT.

Either you guys with 50+ MPG are driving on pure plain flat ground or you are in a car that I don't have. I have tried all, and I mean ALL of the the "tricks" mentioned in ALL of the posting sights, and the HCH I own will not get better than 42 MPG. And, it does not seem to be operating abnormally.

larsb

quote markdel - "And, it does not seem to be operating abnormally." -end quote

If what you say is true, meaning you have tried the tricks, then something is WITHOUT A DOUBT wrong with your HCH.

Try this: on your next fillup, clear the "A" trip meter. Choose a station which is about 10 miles from your home, and that can be driven on "city streets" or a non-busy highway. If you drive on city streets, choose a path with the fewest red lights. Find a road and set the cruise on 40 MPH. If you are on the highway, set the cruise at 60 MPH.

Let us know the MPG figure you get when you arrive home. It should be somewhere in the 60s if you did not have to stop and restart very many times.

Karen_S

Save Money on Gas

markdel

I have done just that, many times. I use trip A for fill ups and I have not reset trip B since I bought the car. Trip B has every mile driven on the car and it reads 40.2 MPG, at 2,684 Miles. When filling up I use a gas station about 12 miles away, all freeway. I average 52 MPG one way and 39 MPG the other way (non-stop miles) I figure the difference is due to the fact that I am going uphill in one direction and down hill the otherway, which gives me and average of 44.5 MPG, all on cruise control. When combining this with getting on and off the freeway and doing other things my mileage drops to and average of 38 to 42 from tank to tank, and overall (as indicated by trip I get 40 MPG PERIOD.

I don't go over 3000 RPM, and I defie anyone to accelerate away from a stop light and not go below 10 MPG and if you use any of the IMA function you will not get 40+ MPG until you get to cruising speed. I have tried. And going from stop light to stop sign to stop light in town, you are just not going to get 56 MPG.

107main

The real world facts: I have 2100 miles on my 05 CVT and have a life time average of 38.2 MPG local/hwy 70/30%. I use the AC and drive conservatively with 35psi in tires. You will see inflated figures by some on here, and if these are true, do you really want to buy a car and drive with 50 PSI in tires, not use the AC, and have people blowing horns at you to get out of way or give it the gas? I would like more mileage, but that is what I get in my driving area with worlds worse traffic light system, etc. This MPG is still a whole lot better than my previous vehicle at 17 or so MPG!

markdel

THANK YOU, I agree, 40MPG is great compared to the 18MPG I was getting before I got my Honda.
Some of the posts I have read are a little suspicious. One said to try to keep it to "ONE BAR of assist", well, in my HCH you get 5 bars or more of either assist or charge but nothing less. You cannot get just one bar. Makes me wonder about the rest of the advice from that poster.
And, no, I will not put 50PSI in my tires, and I like AC, too.

fireking

I've found that using cruise control does not result in the best gas mileage in every situation. Feathering the accelerator to just maintain speed is a sure fire way of getting the most MPG for your desired speed. Normal driving for me is about a 50/50 mix of hwy/city, and in an area with lots of rolling hills. My speed fluctuates from 25 to 70 MPH and I consistently get anywhere from 52 to 56 MPG. I don't drive in the granny lane, I don't always use the AC (unless it's hot), and my tire pressure is not maxed out. As far as markdel's mpg numbers, I can only say that of course if you accelerate from a stop with a fully depressed accelerator, your MPG will go to 10 and your IMA will be pegged out. That is what the IMA is for. Getting one bar of assist is probably beyond your foot's ability to move in small amounts, but it can be done, although I don't see the advantage of doing so. The IMA is supposed to take the place of that extra little bit of gas used by regular engines when accelerating. Some suggest that is the best way to improve your mileage, by quickly accelerating to cruising speed then maintaining it with the minimum amount of throttle. I think the habits we all developed before we got hybrids has a negative effect on the true potential of these machines. It's hard to unlearn bad habits, but with practice, we can all do it.

richard26

I bought a 2005 Civic Hybrid last month and after 2 fill ups my mileage is 561.7 and my mileage per gallon is only 30.393. The mileage has been 80% city & 20% highway. The dealer tells me that there is a break in time & that I should wait until the car has 2,000 miles on it. Is there something I'm doing wrong or is the dealer correct.

107main

You should be getting 38 or better based on what I have experienced driving about a half dozen or so of these cars other than my own HCH. Do you have the AC switches both on auto and the econ button on? Does your engine stop running when you stop at a light or stop sign? If this is happening, you must have a lead foot as your mileage is in the tank so to speak. I think there is a part in manuall on how to drive and improve your mileage. I know I have slowed down and anticipate lights so I dont have to stop and go so much.
My experience having 2800 miles on my CVT model is that the mileage has not increased. I started out with an average between 38-39 and it has stayed there. I think the mileage is probably in the range of 38-45 for these cars. There are those who make claims of way over 50 mpg. They may well be doing that, but I would have to see it personally to believe it. Apparently they drive with overinflated tires and no AC. I wont do that!

misterme

Want to see it personally?
I made a video of one of my commutes just for you doubting Thomas's and for others who may like to improve their numbers. The camcorder was strapped to the rear of the front seats and at the same time a webcam was recording the FCD.
Since it would be difficult to see uphill-flat-down hill grades I added an indicator for that as well. You also see the live rearview shot as well as an IMA indicator. Posted speed limits and actual speed, and tips are also shown.

The file is 117MB MPEG.
It is posted on another hybrid site, and if I post a link here the good and wise Edmund moderators will understandably delete this entire post and shred my membership for breach of rules.
"Today I brought my camcorder" is a good hint if you want to find it, if I may.

Despite a constant 10-15MPH head wind and traffic jams I still got 63 point something MPG on my 46 mile drive which was a little short of my goal. Extremely hilly, about half is single lane highway, about half is freeway into Atlanta onto about 4 miles of 5:30PM terrible rush hour traffic.
Over 43K miles and 19months of driving with 55-67MPG tanks I've never had anyone blow horns or appear even slightly irritated. Not even one.
We applied the same driving technique laid out in my video while driving our 2001 Grand Caravan and the MPG per tank also went up from about 17 to around 26. Not bad.

So download the video if you can and see how.

hybrid_bri

On the cars first tank of fuel I went 497miles, filled it with 10.5 gallons which equates to 47+mpg. It was driven daily up and down hills. Minimun use of the IMA with an average shift point of 2,400 RPM. So far I am very pleased.
I can't wait to see the milage improve once the engine breaks in.

misterme

Markdel, in post #14 you mentioned:
One said to try to keep it to "ONE BAR of assist"
"You cannot get just one bar. Makes me wonder about the rest of the advice from that poster."

Can you point out where anyone says one bar of assist?

If you are referring to me, read again:
Post #4
"On this single trip I've driven over 550 miles and have one bar of fuel above the half way mark still lit."
Post #9
"The last fuel bar had just gone out."

I'm sure it was just careless reading but wanted to set it straight.

aero_eng

I commute 17 miles each way to work, about 15 on the highway. If I keep my speed below about 60 mph (hard to do around Boston, but you can) I can average 49-49.5 mpg. This goes down to 39-40 mpg if I keep up with traffic, driving 70-75 mph.

For those interested in the technical details, here are some rough numbers. Aerodynamic drag accounts for about 50% of the drive power at these speeds. Drag increases as speed squared, so increasing from 60 to 75 mph causes drag to go up by 56%, increasing the required drive energy by about 20-25%. This accounts for the 20% reduction in mileage when I drive faster.

cablack

Thanks aero_eng for the great description. For me, it seems like the effect on mileage only kicks in above a certain speed, somewhere above 60 or 65 mph. In other words, at 55 mph on the freeway I get about 54 mpg; at 65 mph on the freeway, I get roughly the same thing: 54 mpg. However, at 75 mph on the freeway, my mpg goes down to the mid-40s.

Do you know why this is? Are all cars effected at these speeds, or are cars with more powerful engines effected less?

Thanks!

aero_eng

Power is required by losses in the drivetrain, engine, etc, as well as the force required to deform the tires as they roll. These types of loads generally go up with the speed, while aerodynamic drag goes up with the square of the speed. So, at some speed, the aero overtakes everything else. That is when you start to see the more dramatic mileage reductions.

To some degree, the effect is less with bigger engines. This is due to the "overhead" power necessary to keep the engine running. That is, they waste quite of bit of power even at low speeds, so the effect on mileage when you go faster seems smaller.

Also, this all assumes constant-speed operation. When you are accelerating, more power is required because you are increasing the kinetic energy (energy of motion) of the car. You normally throw away this energy when you brake. The advantage of the hybrid is that it recovers this energy and puts in in the battery, using it the next time you accelerate.

John

markdel

I just read the message and want to correct a missaprehension, I do not floor the accelerator, I press it down untill, and just until, the assist is at max.

lamu9

Hello,

I have been keeping very close track of my mileage since the purchase of my 2005 Honda Civic Hybrid. I have had the car since mid April 2005. I have already had my first oil change. The mileage (regardless of freeway or street/stop-and-go) remains between 30 mpg and 33 mpg. The REGULAR civic claims it has mileage of 38 mpg! I have done some extensive research on mileage and how one might increase it. I have changed my driving habits to anticipate traffic changes, drive freeways more than streets, coast more and for longer durations than accelerate, use air conditioning moderately (open window more often), keep tire pressure up. I do all these things and yet I'm still getting worse mileage than my 1998 Honda Civic did! However, now I have the added bonus of a monthly car payment for the next 5 years. That is false advertising. I've been hearing more frequently that this is a common complaint of 2005 Civic Hybrid owners. I wonder if a class action suit might be considered and if so, how to join. I paid well over $6,000 than if I had just bought a regular 2005 Civic. I think they cheated me out of the $6,000.

duddy

Hi -- I purchased a Honda Civic Hybrid at exactly the same time as you (April 15, 2005) and have, over the past 5,000 miles, averaged 53.3 miles per gallon according to the dashboard computer readout. I would say close to 60 percent of my mileage has been on the Interstate, but I average about 48 mpg on city streets and 57 on the highway.

I do tend to drive a little under the 75-mph speed limits in my home state and drive with a light touch on the accelerator, so I suppose I'm squeezing every ounce of mileage I can out of the fuel tank. I also do not employ the air conditioning often. When I do, I've found it reduces mileage about 20 percent. That is significant, but it still yields approximately 43 mpg on average when it is running.

If you are getting just 30 to 33 mpg and doing all you mentioned, i.e., coasting, anticipating traffic conditions, reducing air conditioning usage, something appears to be radically wrong with your vehicle. The current recall of Honda Civic Hybrids might be an opportunity for you to have the problem examined and corrected. I wish you better gas mileage.

cablack

The average mileage for the honda civic hybrid seems to be somewhere between 42 and 46, based on real people's mileage in databases elsewhere and at www.fueleconomy.gov. City driving is the most sensitive to particular conditions, and your mileage can even dip below 40. On the highway, however, at a constant rate of 65 MPH, most people seem to get over 50 without trouble.

The HCH seems to be particularly sensitive to inefficient driving styles, due to its small engine and non-aerodynamic shape. If you are getting 30 MPG in your HCH, either:

- your driving style is such that you would be getting in the low 20s in a regular civic, or
- something is seriously wrong with your car.

Since your dealer is probably just going to say it's not a problem with the car, you might try having a friend who is notorious for getting good mileage (e.g. another HCH or Prius owner), and let them drive your car. It should only take them a mile or two in order to determine if the problem is your car, or your driving style.

hybridhater

We have had our HCH for about 7 months and 6000 miles. Our highest tank to date was 37.2 mpg. We normally average about 34. Lately in the heat, we have been getting 32 to 34. Doesn't really seem to matter what we do differently, the mileage always averages about the same. We drive about 80% city and 20% freeway. We are not lead foots and are constantly keeping an eye on our current mile per gallon indicator. We always have the auto stop on. We have never averaged over 40 mpg like others post. Has any of the advice you've received helped your mileage? We are very discoraged and feel like we have tried everything. We just received a recall for the car running too lean. I'm afraid this repair will only make the mpg lower.

kmh3

Getting 43mpg avg so far on the first tank with a 13 (each way) mile commute, 3 miles city, 10 miles highway. I have to use air-conditioning one way.

The highway part is one long hill (uphill to work and downhill coming back), I am having trouble maintaining 60+mph without mashing the gas pedal. If I mash it my mileage goes down into the mid 30's. So as a neophyte who doesn't know how to drive this car yet I am stuck at about 58 mph when climbing the long hill to maintain 40+ mpg. I still pass the semi's anyway. :-)
Hoping things will improve in time.

I have tried several tricks mentioned in these forums and they all seem to work. Using moderate accelleration up to speed and coasting (clutch down) to the next stoplight is my favorite trick so far since my stoplights are just about the right distance from each other for that to work well. Coasting seems to drain the battery quicker however, even though I downshift during braking it isn't enough to keep up, but my city leg is short enough this is not a problem. I pumped up my tires too (44PSI). I like the improved road feel too.

Overall this car is fun to drive.
It is like having a dog, the pet trains the owner. :-)

Kurt

lamu9

I read many discussion boards online prior to buying my hybrid. I spent the first 2 months re-learning how to drive and be mindful of things that can reduce mileage: air conditioning use, heavy load, tire pressure, stop and go, alot of acceleration and excessively high speeds. I have made concerted efforts to use the econ button when using air conditioning, not using A/C when open window is sufficient, keeping my tires at 35-40 psi, not carrying much of anything in the trunk when not necessary, driving in such a way as to anticipate changes in traffic to utilize the coasting feature (in which I see I'm supposedly getting over 60 mpg), and not driving over 60 or 65 unless I make a trip to Bakersfield (I've done this twice to visit family). I have tracked my mileage and gallons purchased and gallons consumed. I'm averaging 33 mpg. When I first got the car it was 23 mpg and then I even saw a couple of refills yielded 36 mpg but nonetheless I'm getting 30-33 mpg. I did indeed get the recall letter and promptly (2 weeks ago) got the service to the software. I have refueled since then and saw another 33 mpg tank gone by. I'm so frustrated and disappointed. I really love the concept of contributing to our environment in a positive way and for that reason I paid the extra cost to get this instead of regular civic. Yet, I felt that the payoff would be in miles per gallon savings. My old 1998 civic was getting almost this much in mileage and it worked great! I really am starting to wonder why I did this. Can anyone add that they saw significant changes in mileage with more time after the recall software is done? I drive 80% freeways on average...

kernick

wants to get in a car and drive, just as they do today. If they're motivated they'll check the air pressure in the tires once a month. They are going to have kids and extra stuff in the vehicle. They are going to drive with traffic on freeways. They are not going to be anticipating traffic and avoiding lights and traffic jams as if many could avoid them. People are going to drive at -10F on snow tires. This is real world.

I had an '88 Honda CRX w/auto that got 40mpg in those conditions. I would expect a hybrid version could get 50 mpg with no special attention to nursing the vehicle. If you can't just hop in an HCH and get 45-50mpg, why bother, and spend the extra money. Hopefully the new HCH will perform better in real-world as their marketing states.

hybridhater

We had the post just above yours. Your story and ours are almost exactly the same. Our car always gets between 32 and 34 on a tank. We are just as mad about the whole thing. The mileage is the reason we bought the hybrid. We meet people whe own regular Civics and they say they get in the 30's. We took our car in to the dealer and they told us everything is working just fine. We dont know what to do. We would join you on the class action suit.

stevedebi

Be happy, my wife's 2002 Civic EX AT gets 26 MPG in the city.

misterme

with low MPG.
The average on the HCH is upper 40's, I have no idea why yours in paticular is so low.

Myself, if I depend on cruise control set at posted speed limits the car does upper 40's to low 50's.
My wife cares nothing about driving for efficiency and is a "hop in, gas and go" person and gets mid-upper 40's. (I have the CVT, MT should do a little better)

Good luck on your lawsuit, YMMV.
Some hypermilers are currently doing a marathon between them in this vehicle and exceeding 70MPH.

misterme

I need to correct myself about the marathon-
They are 4-5 hypermilers driving a single Prius 2 in over an extremely hilly course with about 7 stoplights. Still in progress, they are exceeding 100MPG using their techniques.

One of them drives a HCH MT and routinely gets over 90MPG in his daily commute.
THIS is amazing stuff!

blane

misterme,

Amazing stuff, but totally unrealistic for the folks in the real world.

falconone

Probably is something wrong with the car. Maybe you can sell it and get a decent amount for it. A nice alternative would be a used HX which gets excellent mileage. They don't sell ytoo many of them,so it may be hard to find. On numerous websites lots of HCH owners are very happy with their mileage.

falconone

WOW...that's it? I guess the Lexus SUV gets better mileage than a Civic. That doesn't make any sense!!

stevedebi

"WOW...that's it? I guess the Lexus SUV gets better mileage than a Civic. That doesn't make any sense!!"

YMMV, and in the case of our car, it does vary. But it does get 37 MPG on the highway. I should also mention that my wife has a lead foot. I haven't yet driven the Civic through a full tank. But the car simply begs to be driven hard; it has so much zip and revs so easily.

BTW, your Lexus SUV also costs about 3 times what my Civic set me back. (OK, maybe 2.5 times). Anyone care to figure out how long you'd have to drive that Lexus SUV to break even?

tdrexler

I don't understand how gas mileage could vary so much. We have an '03 manual Civic Hybrid that now has over 50K. We've driven it from Chicago to Miami, New York, and Oklahoma and average about 50mpg on the highway. We drive with the A/C and average about 70-75 mph. We also get about 46 in city driving. On our last trip to Oklahoma we averaged about 52mpg. I could have driven to Tulsa on a single tank. We are of course, delighted. How can these cars be so different?

stevedebi

" How can these cars be so different?"

I don't know if you missed my original post, I own a 2002 ICE Civic, not an HCH. I was just illustrating the fact that sometimes the entire Civic line gets poor mileage, in my case only 26 MPG in town. HCH owners have reported as low as 32 in town, which is really hard to understand.

motherweary

It's not that hard to understand. I average 48mpg on my '02 HCH (currently over 68k miles). When I let my husband or one of the kids drive it, the mpg plummets. It all comes down to driving style, I think. The Hybrid has trained me out of jackrabbit starts and sudden stops; I try to maintain a smooth and steady speed, and just generally drive to keep my blood-pressure down. On the other hand, there are a couple of stretches of highway during my commute where I and the rest of the traffic go about 80 -- but I try for a steady and smooth 80.

The rest of the family drives my car as though they were driving their cars. You can't do that in a Hybrid -- you need to be patient and pay attention to the mpg bar meter, and let the car train you.

stevedebi

"The rest of the family drives my car as though they were driving their cars. You can't do that in a Hybrid -- you need to be patient and pay attention to the mpg bar meter, and let the car train you."

You can't do that in a regular car either. I used to get 18-19 in my CR-V (admittedly it was FUN); now I get 21-22 (in town - road has stayed at about 26-27 MPG). The difference is my driving style. I took a look at the RPMs and speeds and started driving more intelligently.

hybridhater

You guys are like a bunch of broken records. I understand its all about driving style, What YOU are not understanding is that I HAVE changed my driving style. I will never receive another speeding ticket because at 28 years old I have learned to drive like a grandma. When accelerating from a light I keep the little "mileageometer" at 20 until I get up to speed (while the rest of the world passes me by), once up to speed I do my best to keep it above 40 without slowing down. If I try to keep it any higher than that I slowly lose speed, unless I'm going downhill (which isn't very often out here in flat Arizona). I coast when there's a red light up ahead, I anticipate changes in traffic, My middle name should be "smooth and steady". There has got to be something wrong with my car but all I get is the runaround. Actually, they sound alot like you people. Apparently, It's all my fault. I'm really tired of hearing that and I'm really tired of driving like a senior citizen and still getting crappy mileage. What I would like is some kind of help or advice on how to figure out and prove to the dealership that my car is some kind of lemon or something. I am not an angry or confrontational person so I can't go in and rip somebody's head off or throw a tantrum until somebody listens to me. Does anyone have any ideas without telling me your glowing story about your 80 mpg wonder car? gag.

markdel

Hi,
Just a personal note, I have a HCH also, and I also get lousy mileage. If you want good advise here you are not going to get it. All the folks here that get good mileage either have one of those rare cars built on a wednesday, where nobody at the factory has a hangover, or is distracted by their weekend plans, or (and I think it very likely) they lie. And, in any case they are too busy patting their own back to care about you.
By the way, the recall reprograming gave me a 2 mpg boost in mileage, so if you haven't had that done, do so soonest.
One other thing, don't trust the mileage meter too much. Start keeping track of your fueling and record the gallons used and do the math. I found that I was doing better than I thought.

Good luck,
Mark

rjmatthews

Do not have any ideas but am equally as frustrated. Car is actually my fiancee's, and so far has approx 5K miles and the "Trip A" odometer where we have recorded all miles shows 38.2 MPG average. That includes several trips to the desert out here where we have seen 40-44 MPG average, so you can see what the rest of the driving looks like. She is 80/20 city/highway, and may have a bit of a lead foot, but for example, the most recent tank (after the recall "fix") has shown 31 MPG. Yikes. We received the "wait until 5K miles" story from the dealer when we complained after a thousand miles. We understand the "actual miles may vary" and that we are not expert hybrid drivers, and never will be, but being in the mid-30s on most tanks doesn't sit well with 47-48MPG advertised. I would be happy with 40MPG given other factors. Let me know if you find people to pursue action, although I think we're out of luck. Let me also say that we are happy to help the environment, but could have accomplished almost the same thing with a Civic LX for $4K cheaper!!

kmh3

38 mpg? 80/20 city/highway? and a leadfoot? and I am assuming with the air on since you mention desert.

I am sorry to say it but I think you are getting reasonable mileage for an HCH under those conditions. My own numbers closely match yours, but I rarely do pure city driving and rarely run the air conditioner. Short trips of mine where I operated under conditions similar to yours yielded similar results.

EPA numbers tend to vastly overinflate city mileage compared to real stop-and-go traffic. I have never achieved EPA city numbers without driving gently enough to annoy people around me and even then it is nigh impossible unless the stop lights are far enough apart to get some coasting in.

Matching EPA highway numbers is another story, on flat highways at 65 mph I have exceeded EPA numbers with every car I have owned. Again in the HCH this is no different unless I run with the air on, then it drops quite a bit but is still close to the EPA number. If you are getting mid 40's with air on and a leadfoot style in the HCH you are in the ballpark of what to expect.

My take is that for sky-high pure city mileage the prius is the best choice. If you have a highway centric mix then the HCH will do fine. Let me say that again in this honda civic forum, if you do mostly city driving you will want a prius not the HCH.

For what it is worth, if you are getting upper 30's you are still getting better mileage than any other car (except prius) would get under your conditions.

I highly doubt you would get similar mileage with the LX. It is rated 32 mpg city, given your circumstances you would get around 25 (or 27 with the 5spd) mpg in an LX (assuming the ration of EPA to actual (38/48) remains the same for you).

It might be worth talking to prius owners (in one of the forums here) to see if they can break 40 mpg under mostly city conditions with the air on and a leadfoot driving style. My bet is it that it will be better but may not be enough better to be worth making the switch.

Consider how much money you would save in five years (say with gas at $3.00 per gallon) if you had a prius that got 45 mpg under your conditions, but you had to pay $1,000 more for it. Chances are you would not save any money, my bet is that unless you keep the priusfor a long time you have little to gain by making a switch. And you would have to talk the dealer into buying back your car.

And lastly, the claim of false advertising has been made. It should be pointed out that car manufacturers have no say in what the government mandated EPA stickers have on them. The car manufacturers already lobbied the EPA to reduce the figures by a fudge factor to make the numbers more realistic. Increasing that fudge factor would make sense.

misterme

Mark you wrote in post #46:

"If you want good advise here you are not going to get it"

----Here we can agree. Personally I avoid posting tips on this particular site for the trolls allowed here who distort even the most basic benign suggestions.

"All the folks here that get good mileage either have one of those rare cars or (and I think it very likely) they lie."

----My last tank came to 941 miles and 69.2 calculated MPG. The dash said 66.8.
Judging from many other HCH CVT owners my car is operating normally, not a super car.
So you're saying I'm lying?
Do a google search on "today I brought my camcorder", download it and view it.
63 point something MPG from my 46 mile commute. The road ahead, rearview from behind, FCD and more are clearly shown driving highway, freeway and terrible 5:30PM rush hour Atlanta traffic and shows how I do it, even with a strong head-cross wind.

"in any case they are too busy patting their own back to care about you."

Where did this come from?
I've been among the most vocal about the HCH's potential....but not only potential but as helpful as can be with encouraging others for great things.
My Hot_Georgia_2004 tips are posted many places around the net and several times every week people are thanking me for helping their MPG climb from upper 30's or 40's way up to 50's and 60's. I'm helping people get more from their gas $$ not only from hybrid cars but regular ones as well.

How many people have you helped?
It's one thing to be disappointed with poor MPG but another to create a post trashing those who are most helpful.
Are you here to stir trouble? Help people?

kmh3

After all the claims and counter claims of high vs. low mileage I tried driving my old commute yesterday with my old driving style, meaning leadfoot and no attempt to save gas. I got 45 mpg overall, with the air on I am guessing it would have been around 40-42 or perhaps even in the high 30's. I tried it again today using my best skills (which are still not that good) and got 50 mpg. My best on that route is still 52, with air I am not so sure but guess it would top out around 45ish. It is 17 miles one-way with hills and about 30/70 city/hwy.

I really do believe that high 30's is not unexpected with air on and still being an untrained driver in this car with lots of city driving. I started at 42 (no air), and am up to about 47ish now still on my first tank (it has been over two weeks now and it is still going). I have also been trying really hard, I am not saying this happened automatically or anything.

For someone getting an initial 38 mpg, it seems reasonable you could get it up to low 40's if you really wanted to. I guess you have to ask yourself it you really want to go to the trouble of learning how to do it. I would advise against assuming that it is just plain impossible or that your car is faulty, as that will guarantee you will not achieve improvement and needlessly make you angry and bitter. I see nothing wrong per se about not bothering to retrain yourself, but attempting to assign blame, and lashing out against those who have gone to the trouble is counterproductive in many ways, it hurts you and it disincents them to try to help others.

If I got 60 mpg on a tankful after a few years of hard work developing my driving technique, I would be really excited about it, and I would hope people would be kind enough to congratulate me instead of casting insults. So on that note, congrats to all the hyper-milers out there, you are an inspiration to the rest of us. :-)

play

I just dropped in to lurk and see how things were going among the green set. i feel like I parachuted into the Gaza strip.

And lastly, the claim of false advertising has been made. It should be pointed out that car manufacturers have no say in what the government mandated EPA stickers have on them. The car manufacturers already lobbied the EPA to reduce the figures by a fudge factor to make the numbers more realistic. Increasing that fudge factor would make sense.

A very timely point. Not Honda, nor any manufacturer, is involved in these EPA numbers. If some people were a little more curious, they might realize that hybrids are not for everyone. If the majority of your driving is on the highway, why would you buy a hybrid? At that point, the batteries represent dead weight, not often used.

I will never receive another speeding ticket because at 28 years old I have learned to drive like a grandma. When accelerating from a light I keep the little "mileageometer" at 20 until I get up to speed (while the rest of the world passes me by), once up to speed I do my best to keep it above 40 without slowing down. If I try to keep it any higher than that I slowly lose speed, unless I'm going downhill (which isn't very often out here in flat Arizona). I coast when there's a red light up ahead, I anticipate changes in traffic, My middle name should be "smooth and steady".

The stereotype of grandma is someone who drives not only slowly but also one dimensional. It sounds like you are a very involved in your driving. I am too. I think it keeps things interesting. Its fun. I anticipate the reds and glide, glide , glide. i had a 2001.5 VW Passat and it had the trip computer. I thought I knew alot about MPG but i didn't know enough. On my 65 mile trip to work, at average 80 MPH, by gliding the last half mile as i got off the expressway, I was able to raise the total trip MPG from 31.5 to 32 MPG.

BTW, with the exception of the above mentioned VW, i have been almost totally Honda loyal (incl ACURA) for 30+ years. My experience with the more recent Hondas is that they do not reach peak mileage until at least 15,000 miles. I find the 4 cyl loses from one half to three quarters of a mile per gallon with A/C. I am for the moment driving a Civic Coupe VP. I average 80 MPH (moving with traffic)on my highway commute. The last 5 tank average I had was 38.3 MPG. 25% A/C usage. Am also losing efficiency due to no cruise on the VP (bad idea), its been years since i was without one, and can't seem to hold a truely steady speed as before.

Best of luck to everyone.

misterme

For the record, I haven't always done so well in the MPG department.
My prior car was a Dodge 4cy and I don't believe it ever did better than 16-1`7MPG for my poor, aggressive driving style. I drove about 28 years that way.

I bought my HCH CVT in Jan'04 and my first tank came in the low 40's.
I knew nothing about driving for efficiency. It was frustrating back then because the only site with any tips at all was for Honda Insight specific, and many of those tips didn't work well in my own car.
This is the reason I've posted tips in so many places around the net. Others have posted great tips as well. Now the suggestions are plentiful and easy to find.
By the 3rd month I was in the upper 50's, and by years end low 60's.
I remained in the low 60's way too long thinking it was all I could do then I broke into the upper 60's. I've driven it almost 50K miles and over 20 months.

Our Grand Caravan 6cyl went from 16 to 25MPG using most of those same tips.

I make no bones to say that I work hard for my achievements and my commute is not typical, and few people will get such extreme results. But I get what I get and have a great time doing it.
40MPG in an HCH is pretty low for a typical commute and I'm not in a place to say you are.......or are not doing all you can -
But personally speaking I can't just settle for how it is. I can improve.