Options

What is "wrong" with these new subcompacts?

1133134136138139195

Comments

  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    My minivan reaches 60mph in 7.8 seconds, and that's in the hands of the slowest publication on earth - Consumer Reports.

    C&D got 7.2s, and Autos.com quotes 6.7s to 60mph in the Toyota Sienna.

    So 7.8s is "kinda slow" today. :D

    For tiny cars, 10 seconds or so is about the acceptable limit for acceleration. Any higher is glacial-paced.
  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    You and ateixeira make a valid point but it simply shows what is important to the consumer. Small light weight is replaced with safe quick vehicles at the cost of fuel mileage. Still 20 years and we are still having a hard beating the mileage of Rabbits and Metros. Even if we are doing things with more comfort and security.
  • Mr_ShiftrightMr_Shiftright Member Posts: 64,481
    That's why I call the Prius the Grand Marshall's Car, because they are always at the head of a parade! :P
  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    I have thought about a Civic Hybrid but to this day I haven't warmed up to the Prius. It seems like there must be a law that the Prius just has to have an element of strangeness to it.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    It does, but that has actually worked in Toyota's favor.

    Honda is re-thinking it's strategy, and future hybrids will likely stand out from conventional cars.

    The Civic Hybrid is fine, but it's anonymous. The Prius is the hybrid poster boy. Toyota gets all the good PR from hybrids.
  • texasestexases Member Posts: 11,125
    A low profile choice from Toyota would be the Camry hybrid. Wish they did a Rav4!
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Prius sells better by a long shot, though.
  • podredpodred Member Posts: 127
    You are absolutely right! Toyota is indeed that calculating, never put anything past them.... :)
  • hudsonthedoghudsonthedog Member Posts: 552
    For tiny cars, 10 seconds or so is about the acceptable limit for acceleration. Any higher is glacial-paced.

    If you check out Car & Driver's "Ten Best" issue, the WORST car they tested (acceleration) in 2007 was the Chevrolet Aveo, with a 0-60 time of 10.8 seconds! It wasn't too long ago that an 11 second 0-60 time was reasonable, if not average.
  • texasestexases Member Posts: 11,125
    It wasn't too long ago that an 11 second 0-60 time was reasonable, if not average.

    My 'hot hatch' '83 GTI did 0-60 in a scorching 10.6 sec :blush:

    Sure seemed faster!
  • podredpodred Member Posts: 127
    I simply can't see why they aren't getting 50 to 60 MPG in the new sub compacts when they were getting close to 50 Highway 20 years ago. Unless it is simply that the consumer doesn't care all that much.

    First of all, thanks for the great post, I enjoyed reading it and agree with your points.

    I too have had some of the cars you noted, and raced a Lotus Formula Ford for a few seasons. So the only point, is my how things have changed....

    As far as the question above, my take on it is the oil companies like Exxon, Chevron, etc are so incredibly powerful and influential that they are the reason that we still do not have any small cars with super the high fuel economy that we are capable of obtaining with the technology of today.

    Toyota is a very clever & smart car company. The very reason the Prius has both an electric motor and a gas engine is that they knew that building an all electric car would cause protests, and push back from the oil companies. Toyota learned early on, when selling in the US that they had to be very careful with their success and rate at which they began to overtake other mfgs.

    This is in my opinion why they chose to wait this long before releasing a full size pickup truck. Even though it's content is nearly 100% American, built here, and assembled here, there was still that argument and conflict that it's a vehicle built by a Japanese company. Interesting, very interesting indeed.
  • texasestexases Member Posts: 11,125
    my take on it is the oil companies like Exxon, Chevron, etc are so incredibly powerful and influential that they are the reason that we still do not have any small cars with super the high fuel economy that we are capable of obtaining with the technology of today

    hmmm...OK, can you supply one piece of evidence that shows the oil companies are controlling the design process of all (not just US) car companies? This is an amazing claim, facts are needed!
  • podredpodred Member Posts: 127
    hmmm...OK, can you supply one piece of evidence that shows the oil companies are controlling the design process of all (not just US) car companies? This is an amazing claim, facts are needed!

    Perhaps you've forgotten that this is a public forum and what's it's purpose is. Here is the definition for you:

    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source - Share This
    fo·rum /ˈfɔrəm, ˈfoʊrəm/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[fawr-uhm, fohr-uhm] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
    –noun, plural fo·rums, fo·ra /ˈfɔrə, ˈfoʊrə/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[fawr-uh, fohr-uh] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation.
    1. the marketplace or public square of an ancient Roman city, the center of judicial and business affairs and a place of assembly for the people.
    2. a court or tribunal: the forum of public opinion.
    3. an assembly, meeting place, television program, etc., for the discussion of questions of public interest.
    4. the Forum, the forum in the ancient city of Rome.
    [Origin: 1425&#150;75; late ME < L: marketplace, public place, akin to forīs, forās outside, foris door]
    Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1)
    Based on the Random House Unabridged Dictionary, © Random House, Inc. 2006.

    source: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/forum

    Cheers!
  • texasestexases Member Posts: 11,125
    Okey dokey... :confuse:
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    It wasn't too long ago that an 11 second 0-60 time was reasonable, if not average.

    If you time traffic starting from stop light I doubt that it accelerates that fast. We did that once and found traffic tends to get to 40 in 10-15 seconds.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    This is an amazing claim, facts are needed!

    What? This is a conspiracy theory you don't need facts.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • jlawrence01jlawrence01 Member Posts: 1,757
    When the guy cites the dictionary, you know there is much of an argument there.

    Maybe a red herring would have been better ... you know, like citing Hitler.
  • texasestexases Member Posts: 11,125
    No need to explain how a forum works. You made an assertion regarding collusion between two major industries, an assertion of fact, not an expression of opinion. I was wondering if you might cite your sources, that's all.
  • dromedariusdromedarius Member Posts: 307
    podred also claimed Honda was withholding certain models in order to sell other models based on who he knows.

    :confuse:

    It's fine to state what you think but when you present something as fact you better be willing to back it up w/a source. I didn't need to go to grad school to learn that concept!

    :blush:
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    I simply can't see why they aren't getting 50 to 60 MPG in the new sub compacts when they were getting close to 50 Highway 20 years ago. Unless it is simply that the consumer doesn't care all that much.

    I will say it, the consumer doesn't give a rats #$%^ about it. Even here on Edmunds there are many that don't care. Its all about power and the like. A while back on another thread I mention something about that a midsized sedan doesn't really need 250+ HP and you should have seen the people jump down my neck for that. Most cars out there can easily get away with less powerful more efficient engines and most drivers wouldn't notice in their daily driving. But you can't tell them that.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    " Most cars out there can easily get away with less powerful more efficient engines and most drivers wouldn't notice in their daily driving. But you can't tell them that. "

    I have to assume some guilt on that behalf myself. But I put it at 130HP for a Focus sized car and 175 HP for a mid sized car. After all the 108 HP sub compacts are not the fuel mileage leaders in many cases. They often do pretty well in city mileage but fall short on the highway. It is just hard for me to justify giving up the comfort of a mid sized car or even a compact for a sub compact when the mileage difference is so little. Now if we were talking 50 - 60 MPG and 11K my ears would perk up. But the Smart isn't talking those numbers nor is the Fit.
  • sailorman4sailorman4 Member Posts: 10
    I thought this site was about the Smart automobile. Not a philosophical discussion about the oil industry or individual's opinions as to what's wrong with the American economy. Can you boobs go the Election website and voice your opinions there please. I want to hear from people about the the Smart car. Sailorman
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    This is not a site about the smart car. This discussion is to compare subcompact cars and to discuss their shortcomings. The Smart happens to be one of them, but other vehicles belonging in this thread are the Nissan Versa, Honda Fit, Hyundai Accent, Kia Rio, Toyota Yaris, Chevrolet Aveo, etc.

    It's hard to talk about the Smart since hardly anyone has even laid eyes on one yet.
  • lilengineerboylilengineerboy Member Posts: 4,116
    I thought this site was about the Smart automobile.

    Actually, I have no earthly idea why or how you came to that conclusion since it isn't in the title of this discussion, or listed on the sidebar as vehicles of interest to the discussion. Sorry if you were misinformed.
  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    I believe if he wanted to know how many people felt about the Smart Car he would have seen quite a few posts dealing with that issue. As a Sub Compact it hardly has any advantages over some of the vehicles you listed.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    The smart car is listed in one of the categories ("What is this discussion about?") and thus this discussion will show up in a smart car search.

    There is a Smart Car board here as well that dials in on the smart and its pros and cons.

    Many of the topics here are a bit far removed from the original post that was more of a comparison post. But after almost 7,000 posts, you'd expect quite a bit of topic drift.
  • lilengineerboylilengineerboy Member Posts: 4,116
    ...And there is a Smart Car off on the right now too.
  • sailorman4sailorman4 Member Posts: 10
    I didn't mean to offend anyone regarding the small car discussion. IMO, buying a smart, and I'm a $99.00 deposit holder, is not so much about comparisons with other small vehicles. After all the Nissan Versa or the Fit and others are probably a lot more car for the buck and better value. I redcently drove a new Carolla and was blown away at how solid, well made and quick the car was. For me, the smart is about panache and something totally different. Back in 1962 (as you can see I'm old), I bought a Jaguar XKE when no one could get one in the US. Every time I parked that car, I had a swarm of people around the car asking me questions and fawning over it. I paid $6200 for that car but it did my ego about ten million dollars of good. I currently drive a 2008 Prius and don't know in the final analysis whether I will take delivery of my Cabrio or not. I just received an e-mail informing me that my car will be in Florida and ready for delivery in February. Like everybody on these sites, I love cars and just might go ahead with it for kicks. Sailorman
  • lilengineerboylilengineerboy Member Posts: 4,116
    Back in 1962 (as you can see I'm old), I bought a Jaguar XKE when no one could get one in the US. Every time I parked that car, I had a swarm of people around the car asking me questions and fawning over it.

    I definitely think the Smart will do that, but I think if you still had the XKE, it would do that too :P

    Like everybody on these sites, I love cars and just might go ahead with it for kicks

    There is absolutely nothing wrong at all with buying a car because you like it, based on what ever criteria you have. I think its cool that you still look for new driving experiences and vehicle types after a lot of years of driving.

    If you do get the Cabrio, get a good cap or something with a brim, especially in Florida. The breeze through your hair is a great feeling, but the feeling of skin peeling of a sunburned scalp is sub-optimal (I found out about that on a trip to HI this summer..).

    Happy motoring.
  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    After all the Nissan Versa or the Fit and others are probably a lot more car for the buck and better value.

    While I will agree they are a lot more car the practical side of me asks to I need more car? As a daily commute I cannot even remember when I needed the extra utility that a Versa or a Fit has over a Smart. So with a lower price tag and better mileage a Smart would be better for me as the daily commute.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • iluvmysephia1iluvmysephia1 Member Posts: 7,709
    have you fallen for the SmartForTwo? Are you gonna buy one?

    It was funny to watch Russell Crowe drive a Smart Car in France in the movie 'A Good Day'. It is hilarious! It's a rental car for him and he looks at the car with the most annoyed grinnish-smirshish look. And then the camera follows him as he motors to town and back, etc. I didn't know I was gonna get a look at the Smart Car in this movie so it was a cool surprise. Definitely a different rig, gentlemen. And sub-subcompact, too.

    What's wrong with the car? Humm...lack of storage? That's not a good enough reason. Unsafe in an accident? Dunno yet about that. I'll stick with the extra room and what I feel to be good gas mileage of my '08 Mitsubishi Lancer GTS while Ford works on the new Verve subcompact for 2010 and Chery/Dodge work on the new Dodge Hornet subcompact. It's all about compacts(the Lancer) and subcompacts, but I'm not so sold on the sub-subcompacts like Smart. Or the ZENN-mobile...but I am gonna investigate EV's as the years in the Lancer GTS roll by.

    2021 Kia Soul LX 6-speed stick

  • snakeweaselsnakeweasel Member Posts: 19,592
    have you fallen for the SmartForTwo? Are you gonna buy one?

    Not sure if you can say I have fallen for it but it is on my list as possible replacement for my daily drive. A few things that will affect my decision are how the car feels when I sit in it, when I drive it, how the mileage stacks up, what she who must be obeyed thinks (most influential variable). But I can easily see it as my daily drive commuter car.

    The next two cars we will be buying most likely will be a midsized sedan for the wife for her to use as a daily drive commuter and us to use as a family/vacation car and a small inexpensive high mileage economy car for me as a daily drive commuter car and for me to do some small stuff in. The Smart may fit that very well.

    2011 Hyundai Sonata, 2014 BMW 428i convertible, 2015 Honda CTX700D

  • hudsonthedoghudsonthedog Member Posts: 552
    If you time traffic starting from stop light I doubt that it accelerates that fast. We did that once and found traffic tends to get to 40 in 10-15 seconds.

    I agree, while there are those people who insist on testing their vehicle's capabilities at every light, most intelligent (and semi-intellingent) people accelerate much more cautiously.

    But their vehicles are capable of 0-60 times well under 10 seconds, for the most part.
  • nippononlynippononly Member Posts: 12,555
    Interesting, iluv, that you mention the upcoming Verve from Ford. I was trying to get a handle recently on just how big it will be. Is it going to be like the Versa, calling itself a subcompact but in actuality big enough to be verging on compact territory? Or will it be genuinely small?

    As for the Hornet, and per recent announcements, the upcoming Demon that will compete with the Miata, I think Chrysler made a mistake in farming out the mechanical development and manufacture to Chery. That's not a collaborative arrangement, that's just an arrangement to buy cars from Chery and sell them in the U.S. with Chrysler Group badges on them.

    If that was what they had in mind, I think it would have been better for them to expand the new deal they are going to have with Nissan: they are currently getting set to buy Versas from Nissan (Versa is called Tiida in other countries, so they will be getting rebadged Tiidas) and sell them with Chrysler Group badges in other parts of the world (not the U.S., at least not yet). I think they would be buying into better engineering and better manufacturing standards by going with Nissan.

    Edit...it is intriguing to me that sailorman4 is buying the ForTwo (if he goes ahead) just for its differentness and panache. As I recall, Smart was counting on 25% of the sales going to customers just like him, and it appears that they may have had something there...

    2014 Mini Cooper (stick shift of course), 2016 Camry hybrid, 2009 Outback Sport 5-spd (keeping the stick alive)

  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    With all of the talk about the impending release of a batch of new small diesels from Honda and others I simply can't see getting a sub compact produced today. It seems as if we are on the brink of some truly fuel efficient small cars in the very near future and the cars we are offered today aren't that much better than what we have had for the last 15 years. But if we can get some that can get 50 MPG or better in the next three years cars like the Smart simply will be a blip on the radar screen.
  • nippononlynippononly Member Posts: 12,555
    Weeelll, I will agree with you that the subs we have today are for the most part a relic of the SUV-crazy 90s, and as such the upcoming batch in about two years should be major advances over the current crop. I think the '09 Fit, coming this fall, will be the first of this new wave. Toyota is not in the game with as much heart as it used to be, so I am hoping other automakers will pick up the slack.

    I do NOT think we will see any of the smallest cars with diesels for quite a while. You mention Honda, and Honda has no plans for a diesel for the Civic or Fit. They do have plans to produce the CRZ (the next-gen CRX, after a little 15-year break! ;-)) with a hybrid powertrain, and I bet that car will have fantastic gas mileage and superlative handling as well. 50 mpg and top-speed slaloms, here we come.

    Honda's diesels will be first for Pilot, Ridgeline, and Accord, and then perhaps for CRV and Element etc. According to their announcement, anyway.

    I wish VW would sell the Polo here with a small diesel from Europe. And that Ford would get into the game and bring along one of its own European diesels. Alas, for now, we have no announcements from either...

    I wonder if Mini will ever decide to sell the American Cooper with the European diesel. We have the ULSD now, after all. The base Cooper makes good mileage with the gas engine, but it's not great, just good. The diesel could easily exceed it by quite a bit.

    2014 Mini Cooper (stick shift of course), 2016 Camry hybrid, 2009 Outback Sport 5-spd (keeping the stick alive)

  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    Probably true, but keep in mind you get diminishing returns.

    When you go from 20mpg to 30mpg you get huge savings.

    Going from 30mpg to 40mpg doesn't net nearly the same savings.
  • tiff_ctiff_c Member Posts: 531
    Actually, the XD's gas mileage is pretty dog gone impressive. 36 mpg in mixed driving is what the Yaris gets. That XD's styling is getting better too. Hmmm. Yaris or XD. Oh man I can't decide.

    Actually my wife and I both drove a Scion xD and she was really gung ho about it until she drove it. She said it was the worst car she has ever driven and she had so much trouble with the manual that she had me drive it back from the test drive. I had a few complaints but nothing severe, rubbery vague shifter, awful steering but smooth riding on the highway. The Fit while underpowered was miles better at everything it just needed more power for the highway.
    So we ended up buying a Civic instead. :D
    She loves it even tho it cost me a bundle more.
    I hope the new Fit has a few more ponies for the highway because we are all rural roads and highways here.
  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    "The Fit while underpowered was miles better at everything it just needed more power for the highway.
    So we ended up buying a Civic instead."


    With the roads and distances we drive in the US that has been a big question I have asked about these new sub compacts from the beginning. The Civic just about had the consumers power requirement nailed so knowing that one would have thought a few more ponies would have been a big help for the Fit.
  • tiff_ctiff_c Member Posts: 531
    With the roads and distances we drive in the US that has been a big question I have asked about these new sub compacts from the beginning. The Civic just about had the consumers power requirement nailed so knowing that one would have thought a few more ponies would have been a big help for the Fit.

    She wanted a fun car so she cheated and got and Si which I got for $21K OTD with only a $400 dealer fee included in that. I could have whined about the price but they were really good to us.
    The Fit was great but just wasn't comfortable enough the power was ok in town but on the highway it fell flat.
    The other cars we drove like the Scion xD were just too awful to consider seriously. Prius was too gutless as well. It was great on the highway but no power to get onto the highway and it's similar enough in shape to the gas swilling Si that my wife fell in love with.
    I like sub com[pacts but up here they need more power and snow tires.
  • boaz47boaz47 Member Posts: 2,747
    of Southern California and we do get some snow. Not a lot considering how much some people get but a few weeks a year and about 6 to 10 inches at a time. Once the snow comes most of the sub compacts are left at home and the Subarus, Jeeps and 4X4s come out and stay out till the snow melts.
  • iluvmysephia1iluvmysephia1 Member Posts: 7,709
    the new Ford Verve appears to be Nissan Versa subcompact-size. They are looking at offering a 4-door sedan and a crossover/hatch. It is a European-designed Ford. I thought the bodystyle was kind of interesting looking.

    As for Dodge I was under the impression that they are working closely with Chery Motors on the development of the Hornet. It will take them a while to get to U.S.specs for emissions and safety, too. Chery is really emphasizing the fact that they want to do it right and take the time that's necessary to do the car right. A lot of the Chinese manufacturers are saying that right now.

    2021 Kia Soul LX 6-speed stick

  • hudsonthedoghudsonthedog Member Posts: 552
    I wonder if Mini will ever decide to sell the American Cooper with the European diesel. We have the ULSD now, after all. The base Cooper makes good mileage with the gas engine, but it's not great, just good. The diesel could easily exceed it by quite a bit.

    I believe BMW announced something along those lines the other day at the Detroit show.
  • nippononlynippononly Member Posts: 12,555
    Really? Did they give a timeline?

    iluv: I think Chrysler is on very shaky ground. We may yet see them sold again, or enter some other kind of crisis, before these Chinese cars ever make it to Chrysler/Dodge showrooms.

    As for Verve, I thought Ford announced that it would sell the next-gen Fiesta here in 2010, and I am wondering how both models would fit in the line-up.

    BTW everyone: I believe it was made official this week or last that subcompacts were far and away the fastest-growing segment of auto sales in 2007. :-)

    2014 Mini Cooper (stick shift of course), 2016 Camry hybrid, 2009 Outback Sport 5-spd (keeping the stick alive)

  • iluvmysephia1iluvmysephia1 Member Posts: 7,709
    they mentioned that subcompacts may soon make up about 43% of new vehicle sales. I think the domestic makers are now getting it. I am always in this ballpark as small cars are my favorites always. My 2008 Mitsubishi Lancer GTS is as big a rig as I like to drive and it is classified as a compact car, so there ya go.

    2021 Kia Soul LX 6-speed stick

  • dtownfbdtownfb Member Posts: 2,918
    Check some of the recent news iluv. Initially, chrysler was hoping to have the cars built by Chery in production by 2009. The recent developments or lack of development in the areas of safety and emissions has pushed it back to 2012. Chrysler is talking to other manufactures to fill this niche. I think Nissan is the likely candidate using the Versa platform.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    I take most of these with a grain of salt. Intros seem to be cancelled or at least delayed more often than not.

    Seemed like people started talking diesel 2 years ago, where are they? Two more years? In two year we'll still be saying two more years.
  • grbeckgrbeck Member Posts: 2,358
    nippononly: As for Verve, I thought Ford announced that it would sell the next-gen Fiesta here in 2010, and I am wondering how both models would fit in the line-up.

    The Verve is the next-generation Fiesta. This car will also be sold in Europe - either under the Fiesta nameplate, or a new one. I've heard that it will be called either the Verve or the Fiesta here in the U.S.

    Personally, I think "Verve" is a little too close to "Versa" for comfort.

    It will not, however, be built in the U.S. Alan Mullaly has said that Ford cannot build this car in the U.S. (it will be priced below the Focus) and make a profit on it.

    What we all saw at the Detroit Auto Show is "90 percent of what the production car will be," according to insiders. I really like the Verve, but the 10 percent that changes for the production version concerns me...
  • lilengineerboylilengineerboy Member Posts: 4,116
    What we all saw at the Detroit Auto Show is "90 percent of what the production car will be," according to insiders. I really like the Verve, but the 10 percent that changes for the production version concerns me...

    I concur, and I can't get anyone to confirm if the US gets the hatch or not.
  • iluvmysephia1iluvmysephia1 Member Posts: 7,709
    the only thing I read about Chrysler teaming with Nissan and it's Versa was for cars to sell in South America. I do know that I have not heard much lately from the China front with Chrysler regarding the new Hornet subcompact. I had not heard that the two carmakers had thrown in the towel on collaborating to build the Dodge Hornet.

    Need the info.

    2021 Kia Soul LX 6-speed stick

Sign In or Register to comment.