Did you recently take on (or consider) a loan of 84 months or longer on a car purchase?
A reporter would like to speak with you about your experience; please reach out to PR@Edmunds.com by 7/22 for details.
Options

Crossover SUV Comparison

1117118120122123142

Comments

  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    A "base" Outlook sells for about $32K in Canada before tax.

    My bad. I though you were talking about American pricing. The US sounds pretty good right about now.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    SHOCKER * SHOCKER * SHOCKER!

    you really want me to pick, $48k for a gussied up pilot, its a no brainer the enclave with the money saved for track days with the alfa...

    I have to say I agree (gasp!) and not even necessarily abou the Enclave part (gasp!gasp!). While being a fan of the MDX, I know in my right mind I wouldn't spend almost 50k for one- especially knowing it's only a good looking Pilot with more toys. It will get even harder to think about when Honda releases the new Pilot this spring (?) as the two will share even more features and refinements.

    It's a stereotype mindset, but if I'm spending more than 45k, it's a Benz or Bimmer (possibly a Caddy or Audi).
  • nxs138nxs138 Member Posts: 481
    My friend who lives in Montreal says that a couple of his friends have only paid $200 in duty when bringing a car in from the US. Daytime lights can be done at Canadian Tire for cheap. Nothing else had to be modified.

    At least prices are starting to come down in Canada. I found dealers to be very arrogant about pricing when I lived there, as if they're doing you a huge favor by giving you 50 bucks off. It's about time reality bit them in the rear...
  • baggs32baggs32 Member Posts: 3,229
    It's a stereotype mindset, but if I'm spending more than 45k, it's a Benz or Bimmer (possibly a Caddy or Audi).

    I'm with you there but you can keep your Benz and Bimmer. I'll take a Volvo or a Cayenne.
  • hoser0ehhoser0eh Member Posts: 46
    I know that it's a small sample, but my neighbour's German suvs (Benz, BMW, VW Tourag) have all been in the shop way more than they should be, especially for the $ you pay for them. If I had the money, I'd probably go for the MDX instead of something German. But I don't have that much $. That's why I bought the Enclave. I just hope it's reliable.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Owner of performace cars is more showing their wealth, than any thing else.

    Maybe. But BMW is considered performance, and some buy this brand for the luxury part of it.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    I'll take a Volvo or a Cayenne.

    Cayenne- okay (but it's more truck truck to me as it can tow). But Volvo? That's boring. I know everyone may not share that view, but I also know I'm not alone in thinking that Volvo isn't quite at the MB world class level either. You can tell by their somewhat bland interiors. A Volvo is something I would consider if I was buying a Honda.

    But I've digressed. To try to keep it on topic, I think I'd choose an M-class over and XC90 any day of the week. One could bring up Volvo's sterling safety and reliability, but MB has come up in reliability terms, too.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    If I had more money I will go with Audi Q7 or Enclave. I will not buy an Acura. I had Acura 3.2 TL and I was not impressed with this car as a luxury, performance or as sedan. It’s still feeling a lot Honda. I was expecting much more; also it was not reliable as advertised. I had check engine all the time, with no fault code found.
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    You may be interested in the Importing Car into Canada from US discussion. Your comments there would be helpful.

    tidester, host
    SUVs and Smart Shopper
  • aviboy97aviboy97 Member Posts: 3,159
    The Acuras made before 2004 did have more of a regular Honda feel to them. I have to agree. My friend had a 2000 CL, and it was just like an Accord. They also did have a big problem with the tranny's in the RL and TL. I do believe the 2004+ ones are pretty good. Lets just hope Acura does not place Hondas VCM in the MDX, or any Acura, until they fix it. I have read a lot about some very very very unhappy Honda Accord / Odyssey owners that have it in their vehicles.

    BTY, the new MDX is an improvement over the previous gen, however, I personally don't think it has as nice of a feel as Lexus / BMW or MB.
  • jimmy2xjimmy2x Member Posts: 124
    BTY, the new MDX is an improvement over the previous gen, however, I personally don't think it has as nice of a feel as Lexus / BMW or MB.

    It doesn't have the price of a BMW or MB either and for what you would pay for the Tech package it is probably considerably less than a comparable RX.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    That's really not totally true, as people who look at CUVs don't really want minivans (yes, yes atiexera, I know).

    Well, I know the Pilot lost a sale when my aunt looked at the then-new 2005 Odyssey. She was gung-ho about the Pilot, but the van offered more for less, even though the Pilot looked a lot better to her. This, coming from a previous CR-V (read: CUV) owner.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Well, I know the Pilot lost a sale when my aunt looked at the then-new 2005 Odyssey. She was gung-ho about the Pilot, but the van offered more for less, even though the Pilot looked a lot better to her. This, coming from a previous CR-V (read: CUV) owner.

    Totally reasonable. I just don't think that happens much. If I want a minivan, I'm getting a van. The CUVs don't even get a second look. For now. (Though I wonder if the gap will be bridged with the next gen lambdas? As they are the closest CUVs on the market to minivan comfort, we'll have to see)
  • endodocendodoc Member Posts: 15
    i had an AudiS4 which i turned in and got an infinity g35x because the new s4 won't be out for two years (from last summer) its a great car but i miss the audi. i love the nav,bluetooth,keyless entry, ipod stuff,ect, plus it's fast and great in the snow. my wife's touareg lease was up and we drove everything twice. what i think she really would like is a Q5 loaded with all my infinity has . this will be another two years . no suv under 60k has all the stuff or drives very well . the mdx was the best all around but no keyless start or power tailgate without dvd. x5 was heavy and expensive .volvo no bluetooth and drove like a refrigerator.. porsche drove well but no features . anyway i leased a nissan murano for 24 months loaded . i think it's nice looking but has no prestige which is what your saying. it's a fabulous small suv. list 40k -leased at 37.5 k . it wasn't about the money.
  • acdiiacdii Member Posts: 753
    With 3 kids, two in car seats, my Prius was too small. At the 08 CSA we shopped by comparing all 6+ passenger vehicles. CX9 has a lot of bells and whistles and I can see why MT would make it CUV of the year, but, the drivers seating is cramped, my right leg hits the console, while my left knee hits the door. Not much bigger than the Prius. Outlook/Enclave/Acadia, basically all the same vehicle with different skin. Nice, roomy, overpriced when you start to add options. Road test on it, noisy, not very comfortable, the head rest is too far back, and the climate and radio controls are overly complicated, and the buttons are too small. The radio controls on the steering wheel are poorly designed, the volume controls are under the wheel so you have to reach for them. The rear climate system is loud when the overhead vents are going, but access to the third row is the easiest of all models. The Taurus X feels cheap, and looks cheap and basically overpriced when you compare it to the other models. The Honda and Toyota were priced out of our league for what they have so it all came down to the Hyundai Veracruz. The Limited has so many standard features that makes it hard to compare $ 2 $ to the other makes. It seats 7 adults comfortably and seats 3 adults, a 13 YO and two car seats very well, although to get into the rear seat, you need to enter from the tailgate when car seats are installed. Thats what the Outlook had over the Veracruz, and that is about all it had. When price shopping with a budget of no more than $37K it is hard to find something that has everything the Veracruz has for that price. The model we chose has the rear seat DVD system which puts it at $36k and change, a comparable Outlook, which was the other make we were considering, with the same features would have been nearly $39K or more, but would be lacking on a few features that only the Veracruz has, like rain sensing wipers, and auto dimming on all the mirrors, the Outlook only had the drivers side and rear. The Initial quality on the model we chose is superb, I can find nothing wrong with it, with the exception of the dealer not detailing it due to the time we bought it. I have to make arrangements to drop it off for a day during the week so they can properly detail it and remove some scratches I found on a door. Comfort, Ride, Handling, and performance have all been very good, much better than I expected with a vehicle like this, it is not SUVish in any way, nor minivanish, it reminds me somewhat of a 1977 Country Squire Wagon, just a little taller and not as long.
  • mattandimattandi Member Posts: 588
    Sorry for delay. Been busy the last few days.

    We only have 2 kids. Girls 3 and 5. The third is a ride along every day after school. The 3 year old is still in a full carseat. The other 2 are in booster type seats. All three just fit. We have a 2000 Saturn LW2. The back seat has 54" hip room.

    When we went on some test drives we simply checked to see if all three seats would fit in the second row. Some times they didn't so that car would get crossed of the list. The Rondo was the smallest that fit all three seats in the second row. Surprised me. My wife is quite taken with it. Yeah, fully loaded can be had at an attractive price point. It really is quite a buggy. Like Rodney Dangerfield it just gets no respect.

    Usually if we need to carry more than five it is just more kids. I come from a big family with lots of younger kids running around. Lots of seats to carry to the movies or what not are very handy. Sometimes have another kid or two that want to tag along after church as well. Longer road trips are usually just the four of us with my Mom along occasionally. More than five seats would let us spread out a little more for comfort. (if my Mom is along my wife gets relegated to the back seat between the girls, not very comfortable)

    We both like the TX and the VC. The Pilot is a dark horse, I like the traditional SUV styling, and the deals are decent on them now. We'll make a decision sometime within the next couple of months.

    Even though my wife doesn't really like vans so much, our favorites were the Sedona and the Sienna.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    I have just read today in newspaper huge recall by Acura a late models, something overheating there, so power steering pipe get cracked.
    The Enclave and new coming Cadillac CUV's are good choices in the lux segment.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    They took out a loaded model with Navi, power tailgate, etc today. The first words out of my dad's mouth were "it was amazing and high-quality, like a Lexus."

    They were getting their Civic (currently their only car) serviced at the Honda dealer next door, which only had cars loaded with useless extras (several CR-Vs OVER $30k). The Hyundai dealer told mom and dad (under no pressure) that they would be able to get a fully loaded and optioned VeraCruz for under $33k.

    I was impressed with how highly my folks spoke of the VeraCruz. Of course, they really liked the Entourage as well (mom's last vehicle was a 2000 Honda Odyssey EX), and a model with the features they liked was $23k (not sticker of course). They said that they really liked it, and that it made them realize that a Hyundai was worth considering, but that they couldn't see themselves paying over $30k for a Hyundai.

    Dad didn't like the Acadia or Outlook he saw at the car show; he felt they cost too much for what you got in return. He also felt that GM hadn't overcome the "plastification" of its interiors, even though they were better overall than they have been in past years.

    He does plan to test drive a new Malibu LTZ V6 though - they're looking for just about anything for their new vehicle. Key features? Highway comfort, power, and the most comfortable front seats. COMFORT being key here. ;)
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    new coming Cadillac CUV's are good choices in the lux segment.

    Oh yeah? How well did your test drive go? What aspect of the driving experience did you like best?

    :lemon:

    Geez, man, does the word objectivity mean anything to ya?
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    "Road test on it, noisy, not very comfortable, the head rest is too far back, and the climate and radio controls are overly complicated, and the buttons are too small. The radio controls on the steering wheel are poorly designed, the volume controls are under the wheel so you have to reach for them."

    I have to disagree with noisy, not very comfortable. The noisy compare to what vehicle? Prius? What I know the lambdas has most quite and comfortable ride compare to any CUV. Even more Enclave is most quite one from CUV's.
    I agree the GM volume controls are hard to reach on all vehicle, that the including sedans and SUVs.
    AC/climate/ radio is easiest to use on any GM vehicle.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    That's the joy of steering-wheel stereo controls. No eyes-off-the-road or hands-off-the-wheel.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    They will use same platform - Lambdas. I said NEW COMING.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    If you had this car for some time, you will not have any complains. It's good and simple design, accept volume control on wheel., like I said it before.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    "The Hyundai dealer told mom and dad (under no pressure) that they would be able to get a fully loaded and optioned VeraCruz for under $33k. "

    Should it something tell you, that something wrong with this picture? No one wants to buy Huyndai for 38K. Of course "no pressure", it's not my money to spend.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    Because GM never discounts its own vehicles... riiiiiight.
  • steverstever Guest Posts: 52,454
    Recalls happen. Ford just had a bunch too (even more than the Acura one). 19,000 Cayenne SUVs worldwide (none in NA afaik). Similar numbers of Muranos and EX35s. 82,000 Volvo S40s and V50s. 181,000 GM HHR wagons.

    And those recalls were just in the last month. It's important to fix them, but recalls barely make the news anymore. Pick a make and I bet there's a recall on it sometime, somewhere.
  • cjsbcjsb Member Posts: 71
    Should it something tell you, that something wrong with this picture? No one wants to buy Huyndai for 38K. Of course "no pressure", it's not my money to spend.

    I do!

    Sorry...I mean...I did!

    Vad...no disrespect intended, but the fact you and I went different directions with our vehicle purchase after what we both claim was fairly exhaustive research, only serves to leave me feeling validated with my final choice. Language barrier aside, your pathological myopia gives me the impression you entered into your pursuit of a vehicle wearing blinders the size of football fields - CFL size.

    On another note, I believe Acura Canada just followed the pack...did I see a $4500 price break on the MDX in the papers this weekend? I think I posted earlier that Acura hadn't applied incentives...yet...but to watch for them. Looks like they are here. I still think there are better options for buyers in this segment (just my opinion) but the price break helps. There isn't any question the MDX is a great car - I really do like it.
  • cjsbcjsb Member Posts: 71
    It seats 7 adults comfortably and seats 3 adults, a 13 YO and two car seats very well, although to get into the rear seat, you need to enter from the tailgate when car seats are installed. Thats what the Outlook had over the Veracruz, and that is about all it had. When price shopping with a budget of no more than $37K it is hard to find something that has everything the Veracruz has for that price.

    Congrats! I hope you end up us as happy with it as we are. We were at a small party last night and a group of four of the husbands wanted to have a look through the VC after one of them, a friend who has previously driven it with me, couldn't stop talking about it. I didn't say a word. They were all very impressed and simply astounded at the price.

    As for your comment re access to the third row when car seats are in place...we have car seats in both outer positions in the second row and were pleased to find we could slide the second row forward and tilt it fore just enough - with car seats in place - that teenage nieces and nephews can get in and out of the back without too much effort.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    They said that they really liked it, and that it made them realize that a Hyundai was worth considering, but that they couldn't see themselves paying over $30k for a Hyundai.

    Don't be hard on them. I think it's a common mindset. I couldn't really see doing it either (maybe the Genesis will change that). I couldn't see spending more than 40k for a Chevy (besides the Vette) or GMC(maybe Yukon Denali), or Honda. I wouldn't consider a Buick wither unitl I drove the Enclave. I wouldn't pay over 30k for anything Ford Moco, save the the Mustang GT500. Funny thing about the Mustang and the Vette is neither wears the traditional brand badge.

    Oh- and you said your dad didn't like the poorer lambda siblings. Did he like the Enclave?
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    They will use same platform - Lambdas. I said NEW COMING.

    Caddy's getting a Lambda, too? I'm guessing it will be the SRX replacement and will be sized down considerably? HMMM, that is interesting to think about. I bet it would compete well with the likes of X5 and ML and MDX.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    He actually likes the exterior look of the Enclave (a LOT), but the interior quality just left him cold for $40k; not nearly as solid as his 2007 Civic (half the price of the Enclave he saw).
  • aviboy97aviboy97 Member Posts: 3,159
    The front end on the Enclave is really nice.,The rear I could care less about. I have heard that the interior of the Enclave is put together really well. Is that not the case?

    Since I sell the CX-9, I get numerous people comparing it to the Enclave / Acadia etc etc....I have heard nice things from those people. The not so nice commenting people wave "good bye" to me as they are driving away in their new CX-9.
  • zman3zman3 Member Posts: 857
    Car and Driver has a one paragraph blurb on the replacement SRX and they stated that it will be built on a different platform than the Lambda. I don't know my GM platforms very well so I do not recall the platform but it was not Lambda based. Would Epsilon make sense? I'll have to look it up tonight when I get home.
  • ateixeiraateixeira Member Posts: 72,587
    maybe the Genesis will change that

    I was going to say the same thing.

    Also, around me, after discounts, you can get a Veracruz starting at $26k. OK, that's FWD with cloth, but you can still get AWD and leather on a mid-line model for that $30k psychological limit and lot of people might put on the brand.

    Top it off with 2 of Consumer Reports top 10 picks, and they might be on a roll.

    People here may not agree with CR but they certainly do influence a lot of shoppers, perhaps more of those folks will be willing to break the $30k barrier in a Hyundai.
  • vad1819vad1819 Member Posts: 309
    ''He actually likes the exterior look of the Enclave (a LOT), but the interior quality just left him cold for $40k; not nearly as solid as his 2007 Civic"
    That's what amazed me, that a lot people think honda or toyota has better interior then GM vehicle. They're using same cheap plastic as american maker, also i had Acura and I tell you the interior far away from BMW, Lexus or Mercedes. It's may be design make you think that, but if you look close to details it's cheap with big gaps between panel, where in time will be a lot dirt. The Enclave interior is the way better then any Honda or Toyota.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    That's what amazed me, that a lot people think honda or toyota has better interior then GM vehicle. They're using same cheap plastic as american maker, also i had Acura and I tell you the interior far away from BMW, Lexus or Mercedes. It's may be design make you think that, but if you look close to details it's cheap with big gaps between panel, where in time will be a lot dirt. The Enclave interior is the way better then any Honda or Toyota.

    Oh, I get it. You can have your opinion, and it is right. My opinion (or in this case, my dad's) is bogus, and wrong.

    Man, you've got to be kidding me with this crap. Quit telling us that we're all wrong if we don't agree with you, because we don't do it to you. It's getting REALLY old, REALLY fast. Get over yourself.
  • tidestertidester Member Posts: 10,059
    Get over yourself.

    I recommend scrolling past messages you don't care to read.

    tidester, host
    SUVs and Smart Shopper
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    It's hard to do when someone is basically saying "you and your dad are wrong" in a reply to your own post, especially when I wasn't posting factual information.

    Two things that are severely lacking these days? Common sense, and common courtesy.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Oh, I get it. You can have your opinion, and it is right. My opinion (or in this case, my dad's) is bogus, and wrong.

    You've really got to learn to ignore him. We all get some from him,but it seems to get to you the most. If you don't like someone's oppinion, don't reply to it. It simply means you don't have enough respect for it to respond.

    Not to say that you (or your dad) are wrong, but I do kind of have to agree with him. Honda interiors don't really impress me that much. I don't think they are better than anyone else. But I was very impressed with the Enclave interior. I thought it was well made and a huge departure from Buicks of not so long ago.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Car and Driver has a one paragraph blurb on the replacement SRX and they stated that it will be built on a different platform than the Lambda. I don't know my GM platforms very well so I do not recall the platform but it was not Lambda based. Would Epsilon make sense? I'll have to look it up tonight when I get home

    One thing I will say: If Caddy can improve upon a good thing by making the styling even more attractive the driving experience more refined, and the third row more comfortable- basically making it a better competitor in the midsize lux CUV segment- the I'll make space in my garage.
  • zman3zman3 Member Posts: 857
    From the April C&D:

    The BRX, a replacement for the CTS-based sport utility SRX, should debut late in 2009. Styling is almost identical to that of the Provoq concept. Underpinning the BRX will be a new version of GM's Theta sport utility platform.
  • thegraduatethegraduate Member Posts: 9,731
    It is well made, and much better than Buicks of the past. He felt it lacked the tactile feel of the Honda though. Thanks for the response though. :)
  • joe97joe97 Member Posts: 2,248
    Should it something tell you, that something wrong with this picture? No one wants to buy Huyndai for 38K. Of course "no pressure", it's not my money to spend.

    Really? Then you might like to ask the nice owners of those having purchased Veracruz Limited (and optioned out) for 38K to return their keys and car. Hyundai has been able to sell the Veracruz without much incentives; the avg. transaction price is around 36K IIRC.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    The BRX, a replacement for the CTS-based sport utility SRX, should debut late in 2009. Styling is almost identical to that of the Provoq concept. Underpinning the BRX will be a new version of GM's Theta sport utility platform.

    Yeah- I heard that in MT about two years ago. BUt it doesn't make any sense. The BRX will be X3/GLK sized. The SRX was sized to compete with the MDX and X5.i will be dissapointed if they remove themselves from the midsize lux market. And I'm not totally sold by that Provoq. I can tell it's a Vue.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Hyundai has been able to sell the Veracruz without much incentives; the avg. transaction price is around 36K IIRC.

    Where? In Canada? If I'm paying that much, I ,ight as well pay 1500 more and get an MDX!
  • joe97joe97 Member Posts: 2,248
    In the US. Good luck getting a comparable MDX for 37,500, wait, you can't. In Canada, isn't the MDX around 50K base or something?
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    In the US. Good luck getting a comparable MDX for 37,500, wait, you can't. In Canada, isn't the MDX around 50K base or something?

    My bad- I meant 3500. I've heard of people getting MDX's for 38500. But I see incentitives on VCs all the time. It seems others around here do too.
  • joe97joe97 Member Posts: 2,248
    Except the MDX you are talking about is the base version, and the Veracruz I am talking about is pretty much optioned out.

    My point being, people are buying 30K+ Hyundais, as evident, the stigma is slowly fading away. As they say, good products sell themselves.

    Right now the only national incentive I am aware of on the Veracruz is the $299 24 month lease special on the GLS trim, which is the base version. Actually, that one has expired as of yesterday. I would imagine the rest of the incentives come from regional and local dealer support.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Just got my April MT yesterday, and they compared the Sequoia to other full size SUVs (why wasn't the Durango included). The Sequoia won. Looking at the numbers, the Acadia seemed to fare well interior and performance wise. I'd like to see MT compare a Full size SUV to this lambda. It had more cargo space than every SUV but the Sequoia (even the huge Expedition). It had more third row leg space than the Tahoe and Armada. It had more second row leg room than the Sequoia. I know form experience the interior is more comfortable than all but the Expedition. 0-60 times were right in the middle (though running it aqainst the Sequoia's huge 5.7L V8 would have left it gasping for air. It tows a small 4500lbs- but that's not too far away from the Tahoe's 6000lbs base rating. This test really proves that if you don't need to tow, you need to get a CUV. And you can save over half a foot in length.
  • albookalbook Member Posts: 1,282
    Except the MDX you are talking about is the base version, and the Veracruz I am talking about is pretty much optioned out.

    I'm not sure, but I'm guessing the only features you would lose on the Acura are sunroof, and DVD. And you gain bluetooth.

    What I'm sayong is that yes, the stigma is fading, but common sense isn't. 30k for a Hyundai isn't ridicoulous, but 40k is. 40k is ridiculous for a Honda, or a Chevy (unless it's a Suburban or Corvette). 40k is like a luxury marking line. For that close to 40, you can get an Acura or Mercedes or Lexus, and while MT said the VC was better than the Lexus (because it was cheaper), there are luxuries and features you are going to get in an Acura or Lexus that yyou just won't in a Hyundai. But that's fine. Hyundai doesn't compete with Lexus. And it's a mistake trying to market them that way.

    You're right, the rest must be comming from local dealers, as i've seen dealers take over 2000 off of VCs.
Sign In or Register to comment.