Jaguar SIII XJ / XJS - a much maligned classic?
andy_jordan
Member Posts: 764
In recently shopping for a car from the 'old
country' my attention turned to Jaguars, and in
particular the amazingly low prices of the Series
III sedans and the XJS. I couldn't help feeling
sorry for these cars that I grew up with, and the
fact that they are now virtually worthless. I am
in the process of negotiating a price for a low
mileage 88 XJS Coupe that will probably end up
around $10,000 Canadian.
Much of the market discounts these for reliability
reasons, but I genuinely think that these are over
emphasized - don't get me wrong I know Jags have
had problems historically, but cars that are still
around now have been looked after - and that is
half the battle.
So what do you think - is the Series III / XJS
going to be the next Jaguar classic, or is it
destined to be yet another pile of metal?
country' my attention turned to Jaguars, and in
particular the amazingly low prices of the Series
III sedans and the XJS. I couldn't help feeling
sorry for these cars that I grew up with, and the
fact that they are now virtually worthless. I am
in the process of negotiating a price for a low
mileage 88 XJS Coupe that will probably end up
around $10,000 Canadian.
Much of the market discounts these for reliability
reasons, but I genuinely think that these are over
emphasized - don't get me wrong I know Jags have
had problems historically, but cars that are still
around now have been looked after - and that is
half the battle.
So what do you think - is the Series III / XJS
going to be the next Jaguar classic, or is it
destined to be yet another pile of metal?
Tagged:
0
This discussion has been closed.
Comments
The V12 is a good case in point for my argument though - prices are less than for the V6 because reliability is seen as a problem. I just don't buy it. Now that is easy for me to say because I know a tame factory trained Jaguar mechanic, but even so, they are not that complicated - although they can be awkward to service. I think that the good V12s are going to appreciate noticeably because they are becoming rarer and rarer - the result of so many people ripping out the 12 and putting in a small block Chevy 350.
Prices are dictated by supply and demand, and the demand is low because people are, justifiably, scared off by the likelihood of having repair bills matching the price of the car itself in a short time.
I would agree that the straight 6 is a better bet than the V-12, but both are historically troublesome cars, and I'd expect you'll come to a certain amount of grief with them. Of course, like you say, the odds are much better with a car that's been cared for.
Sooner or later, these cars will bust you, it's just a matter of luck and time. If you think you're going to be luckier than all the people running away from them, well...welcome to Las Vegas, and I genuinely hope you ARE lucky!
Buy a Benz 420 SEL and be happy, that's my two cents, or save and get a mid 90s Jaguar if you must have one.
I do not delude myself into thinking that a Jag is an investment, I will buy for the driving pleasure, as a throw back to my youth and as a comfortable means of high speed, luxury transportation. It won't ever be my only vehicle.
All that said, I really believe that, if looked after, it will cost me less than many other cars as it will depreciate less than a more modern car of the same value, and may even appreciate if not driven much (not that that will happen). I need to offset the increased costs of maintaining it, but in my case that is reduced through work that I can do myself or have help with from my factory trained friend.
In my case I believe that the cost in terms of time and money that a Jaguar will inevitably involve is more than offset by the pleasure of ownership.
And a 420SEL vs. an XJS, that is a no contest for me.
So in essence I agree with your logic. I would myself not be at all hopeful for any strong appreciation in value of the XJS either; however, it is not dropping into the basement like the sedans, and seems stronger than the XJ6C, so there is some hope there. Naturally, the ragtops are always the best bet for appreciation.
My main complaint about the XJS, aside from its size and fuel mileage (which is just MY problem), is the headroom issue, which for a person over 5' 10" is quite annoying and not easily solvable. But you can't beat the ride and the smoothness, the only two things IMO that are really noticeably better than the Benz. It's a pleasant way to eat up miles, no question!
Gas mileage is pretty horrible, but no worse than the truck I drive.
Incidentally, if you want to have a look at the car I am considering it can be found at
http://www.themechanics.on.ca/sales/british/jagxjs.htm
The only faults I could find were a need to replace / rechrome the left headlight surround and a tiny amount of bubbling under the paint at the bottom right of the windscreen and the bottom left of the rear window - common rust points. Both are no big deal to attend to.
The original steering wheel has been replaced with the later one that has the little thumb buttons for the horn, but I am sure I can pick up an 88 steering wheel fairly easily.
The answer to a is no, definitely not.
To b...well, you're dad did get 90K out of it, and I presume it wasn't too burdensome financially to keep it going...on the other hand, 90K is just about the mileage when all kinds of things are ready to wear out. So if the car hasn't had its steering box worked on, its power steering replaced, and suspension work done, all these things could come up for you.
I do feel, though, that if the car is really nice, you should be able to get more for it than $2,600 US, unless it's dinged up and needing work.
If I were looking for an older hobby car, this is not the one I would pick myself...had you considered selling it and perhaps buying an MGB or Midget to fix up?
I had not considered selling the car (the terms of my father's will do not allow this). You're right - 90K is about the time when all sorts of fun things start to happen, and I can well believe that I will probably spend a great deal of money getting things fixed.
I will say, however, that the car is in really good shape for its age. It does need some very minimal body work (minor rust spots in about 5 places) and I know the engine needs more work than I can afford to give it right now. My main goal right now is to do what I can as I can afford to, and I do try to drive it every day (for some inexplicable reason it does run better when I do). Other than that, I must say:
IT IS SUCH A BEAUTIFUL CAR!!!!!
I still am amazed, after 2 years of ownership. It still turns heads when I drive down the street. The best part is pulling up next to a newer (read: Ford) model Jaguar and watching them stare. It really is an amazing car.
Do you know, or have you heard, of problems with the engine cutting out suddenly while driving? IT seems to do this when I am driving, and all of a sudden the engine will simply die. This is, needless to say, not a pleasant situation at 65mph.
thanks
Like with all high-maintenance, exotic cars, you need to look at each one individually. If the car has excellent service records and you know its entire history, you have a much better chance of a successful ownership. But if it's been cobbled together or neglected, it's going to be hell. These cars are EXPENSIVE to repair, so you don't want to have to restore any major componentry, or overlook the smallest problem when you buy one. Don't assume that "it just needs a tune-up" or that "brake squeek is nothing". Have the car carefully checked out nose to tail and take it for a long test drive. Buy the best car you can afford, not the cheaper one you think you're going to fix...it'll end up fixing you, but good!
Of course, there are plenty of shops that LOOK good but aren't, so don't be fooled by a smooth line of talk and snappy little uniforms.
There is only one resume for a good mechanic, and that resides on the end of his wrench. All else is just puffery and of dubious value.
My 105,000 mile 1995 Vanden Plas is testament to that. The 95+ Sedans are really quite something!
As far as the 90 Sovereign goes.. could be good.. could be bad. At the risk of self-promotion.. I have a technical webpage for those cars. Avoid 88s and 89s tho!
http://www.jag-lovers.org/modern
Also join the e-mail list.. worth it's weight in gold!
Bill
Who has had a 1991 Sovereign and it was a great car!
I don't think we are in disagreement...as you suggest, it's a hit and miss thing with 90s Jags.
Also, you are (like me) a knowledgable person about cars, and this no doubt has contributed to both our success with all types of cars. But giving a Jaguar to someone who knows nothing about cars may not be a good idea. I would contend that if a person drove and maintained a 95 Jaguar as if it were a Toyota Camry (as many try to do), it wouldn't be so likely to work out as well for them as for you.
Also, if I may say in a lighthearted way, these days 105,000 miles isn't exactly grounds for bragging like it used to be. It would be shameful if an expensive car couldn't go that distance without major expense.
Just my .02$
The newer Jags will hold resale value better I think, at least through their warranty, but until the new cars demonstrate 150,000+ mile durability, the stain of the past is going to take some time to wear off. But Audi beat the rap, Saab is trying to beat it, so there's a chance Jaguar will some day have a good reputation again. But still, this won't much help 4-door values. The low resale is not due so much to reputation as to the body style in general. Even the high resale of say a '91 Bmemz 300E 3.0 4-door (cost about the same as your Sovereign in 1991) is about $16K.
Storage can also damage cars if not done properly.
I know that no owner likes to see the resale value of their car plummet. My Alfas are great cars, but ridiculously undervalued--can you imagine that my nearly pristine, bright red '88 Spyder convertible might struggle to bring $5,000? It's too bad that owners have to pay for years in the future for the sins of the factory in the past, but we do. The buying public doesn't easily forget when it's been tormented by an automaker's products.
The risk is that you can't evaluate what has happened to the engine until you take it apart. Let's say the head is warped from overheating...now then, are you going to put a brand new rebuilt head on an engine with almost 100,000 miles on bearings, rods and pistons? Not a great idea, and probably $3500 worth of work right there, if not more. You may get lucky or you may blow out the bottom end in 10,000 miles, or burn oil like crazy from worn piston rings.
The Jaguar 6 is a good engine and very strong; nonetheless I would pay no more for this car than a wrecker would. Why go through all the expense and risk when you could buy a perfect car for not all that much money? (probably under $10,000).
How much of a gambling man are you? My feeling is that you pay a little, and if the diagnosis is bad, just button the car up and bail out for what you can. Otherwise, I'd pass. This is neither a rare or particularly valuable car, so there's no real reason to run a high risk to have it.
Also, Jaguar dealers were advised by the factory to use a product called Barrs Leaks in the cooling system when servicing it. This stuff was supposed to plug any pinholes in the system, and it did - but it also built up in the rad causing a severe tendency to overheat with fairly dire results - an overheated bi-metal engine isn't fun.
Unless of course you like spending large amounts of time & money fixing old cars :-)
I like old luxury 4-doors just because they are cheap. You can buy a great ride for peanuts, what could be better?
Thanks in advance for your comment.:-)
The only time I'd consider advising someone to install a V-8 is if they wanted to make a street rod out of a Jag just for a wild thing to do. This way you transform it into something else and such things as noise or smoothness or resale value become irrelevant. But I think you'd find a V-8 installation very disappointing unless you want your Jaguar to feel like a Buick...in that case, just go buy a Buick, it's cheaper and easier.
What does tend to happen is that the engine suffers failures because of less than wonderful design / implementation / engineering elsewhere in the car. For instance a popular complaint with the V12s was that the valve seat dropped, yes it did, but not because it was faulty, just that the radiator wasn't up to the job and the car overheated - the valve seat would have dropped in any bi-metal engine in the same situation.
That said, as others have stated, an older Jag is definitely a labor of love.
The V-8 conversions aren't all that cheap of course unless you do the work yourself. It's a "way out", but not an easy way out.
a bad reputation that has dogged them it seems forever. Between the Lucas electronics and the lack of reliable over the counter parts at the local parts store(other than the Jag dealer), keeping the things on the road is a labor of love. My question for anyone out there is this, Does anyone manufacture a replacement for the Marrelli ignition systems that is more reliable and not prone to starting the whole car on fire due to a breakdown of the ignition system? If so what is the cost and where do you get it??
I too have the overheating problem - fortunately I didn't have a blocked rad, my auxiliary fan failed - new fan, new rad hoses - yes all 22 of them!! (3 had holes, they were all wearing) and a few more minor bits.
make the Jag a different type of auto. I think I'll check out the local club and get more info about the clubs activities and network with local owners. Seems to be a lot of folks that have had some similar troubles with their cars. I did get a name of a company that has something that might work but an e-mail to them got no response.
Keeping a Jag on the road is something many of my neighbors seem to think is a waste cuz' of the cost. I have been tinkering with it since I got it and have enjoyed every minute of my labors. I do most of the work myself when I have the equipment to do so. Other than electrical foibles that pop up with the Lucas nightmares, it has been a very nice and fun car to own. I did find out that the Jag dealer is the last place to get parts due to the cost and overhead involved. With a little shopping on the net and telephone to places outside of my local area, there seems to be a large contingent of loyal Jag followers and replacement parts available. I have gone as far a California to get parts that could not be repaired. I repair most things myself, electrical and mechanical and it seems to have worked out for the better. I don't have access to a garage to do major work as I used to have before I moved East but I have managed to convince my wife that is what a basement is for. I think I am in need of some work on the bottom end and that will have to go to a shop for repairs. Does anyone have any experience with replacement of oil bypass valve and main bearing replacement. I think I have a problem in that the engine hase a discernible lack of oil pressure for the first 5 seconds after it has sat for a couple of hours? It carries good oil pressure after the initial start up but it bothers me when I start it up in the morning and it grumbles for that first five seconds. The oil pressure comes up slow but remains steady after that. I think it is the bearings or bypass valve
that is the problem. It makes no noise after that and runs smoothly. Any advise is appreciated. Like I said before it is a love/hate relationship. In response to your hose replacement thanks, I will check them all out before I take it on my vacation. The fan problem is one that is inherent to the Jag. It develops small hairline cracks that grow larger over time. If you take a close look you will see them starting at the center and radiating out from the mounting flange on the fan clutch. It is one thing that could spell disaster to your hood, radiator and other nearby items.
Best way to find out if your Jaguar V12 is leaking - walk to the back of the car, bend down and look for 'V12'. If you see it you have an oil leak!!!
More seriously, V12 oil pressure is low anyway - I have never seen above 5, mostly around 3 and when idling your oil pressure will be well down - the advice I was given was that if the warning light isn't on then you don't have a problem. Still you seem to know what you are doing so good luck with the checks.
Is a Jag hard work - yes, is it worth it, whenever I wonder I just lower the right foot - oh my!!
Essentially an index of Jag clubs, websites, and parts suppliers for Jaguars, and prices better than the dealer. (Most dealers only know about X300, S-Type, and XK8's anyway). I myself have been bitted by the bug, and as soon as finance allow, I'll probably be looking for an 85 or 86 XJ6. That'll be a couple of years yet, but til then I can dream, right?
BTW...Jag XK and V-12 engines are supposed to leak oil...It's Jaguar's anti-corrosion system.
Dependability should have been more of a concern in the beginning and not image. The XJS will break you financially if you don't have a clue as to how to take care of them. I had mine in the shop when I first got it and it took them a week to get parts at the dealer. After I got it back I had to redo everything but the initial oil change myself. I haven't been back to them since. I'll state again that I do love the car and will keep it for a very long time. Maybe I'll spend some money later and redo the interior in a different color. I'm getting tired of the brown leather interior. How is this for an expensive repair! The Jag dealer wanted $5,600.00 to replace the top! That was only the cost of the parts! No labor or taxes were included. Looks like I'll live with the discolored headliner for a while. That's what I mean about gouging the customer. How many convertible were made from 1989 thru the end of the production of the XJS convertibles? Does anybody out there know? I've gotten various number from 14,000 to 26,000.